Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Gulabrao Vithoba v. Shamrao Jagoba

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Dec 12, 1947

JUDGMENT

1. On 23rd June 1921 the plaintiff Shamrao and his four brothers executed two mortgages, Ex. D-1 in favour of Ghudulal for Rs. 2256 and Ex. D-2 in favour of Sheoratan for Rs. 2500. In each deed the mortgaged property consisted of a two-anna village share and two absolute occupancy fields, survey Nos. 20 and 65, in mauza Mogra in the Chhindwara district. Sheoratan brought Civil Suit No. 137 of 1925 to enforce his mortgage (Ex. D-2), and a preliminary decree was passed on 20th October 1925 declaring that the property would before closed in default of payment of Rs. 6351-13-0 by 20th April 1926. As a result of a family partition between Ghudulal and Sheoratan some time in 1925—the exact date is unknown—the mortgagee rights in Ex. D-1 were assigned to Sheoratan. In the meantime on 28th April 1925 Shamrao and his brothers executed an agreement (Ex. D-4) to sell Survey No. 20 to Gadiram, who has since died and is now represented by his sons, the first four defendants, for Rs. 13,500, and admitted the receipt of Rs. 5000 paid as earnest money. Notice of this proposed sale was given to Sheoratan, who was the lambardar of the village, and he applied to a revenue officer to fix the value of the field. The Deputy Commissioner fixed the value at Rs. 11,088 on 8th April 1926 and an appeal by Sheoratan to the Commissioner failed Sheoratan then abandoned his claim to pre-empt.

2. On 1st July 1926 Shamrao and his brothers executed a sale-deed (Ex. D-3) by which they sold Survey No. 20 to Gadiram for Rs. 18,500 which according to the recitals in the deed, was made up of Rs. 7351 which was retained by Gadiram, Rs. 4853–4813-0 which the vendors said that they had already received, and three items of Rs. 475, Rs. 616-9-0 and Rs. 303-10-0, totalling Rs. 1295-3-0, which were admittedly paid by Gadiram some time in 1925 in settlement of three decrees that had been passed against the vendors. The main question in dispute in this case is whether this sum of Rs. 7351 was retained by Gadiram in order to pay off both the mortgages, as Shamrao contends, or only the debt due on Ex. D-2 for which the preliminary decree for Rs. 6251-13-0 had been passed; as the sons of Gadiram contend. The recital in the deed is as follows:

‘This field is subject to mortgage along with other property and a foreclosure decree of Sheoratan … has been passed against us, and it is also subject to one more mortgage. It is necessary to make payment thereof. The amount of the decree No. 137 of 1925 … is Rs. 6251–6213-0, and the amount due under the mortgage deed, in respect of which no suit has been brought, comes to Rs. 5,000 including interest. If we do not pay this debt there is apprehension of getting the entire ancestral property under mortgage dated 23-6-1921 ruined. Hence in order to save other property, we hereby, after Belling the above-mentioned field to the said Gadiram, keep Rs. 7,351 with the purchaser by way of amanat (deposit). The purchaser may pay that amount directly to Sheoratan … or may deposit the same in the Court.”

3. On 24-4-1926 Sheoratan applied for a final decree in civil Suit No. 137 of 1925: vide Ex. D-9. On 20-4-1926 Shamrao and his brothers had applied for an extension of time for payment, and on 25-9-1916 one month's time was given to them to find security for payment of interest. On 20-10-1926 they produced Gadiram as a surety, and he undertook to give security for the value of the crops which it was agreed was Rs. 1000. The Court directed as follows:

“I allow interest at Re. 1 p.c p.m till the date that now will be fixed for payment, i.e 20-3-1926. The total amount comes to Rs. 1,000 plus Rs. 687-8-0 interest from 23-4-1926 to 20-3-1927, total Rs. 1,687-8-0.’

4. On 30-10-1926 Shamrao and his brothers paid Rs. 3900, which was admittedly received from Gadiram, and were granted an extension of four months. Interest apparently was to be paid as already agreed. Subsequently Gadiram paid further sums of Rs. 2445-14-0 on 1-3-1927, rupees 326-11-0 on 7-3-1927, and finally Rs. 115 and Rs. 23-8-0 costs on 2-7-1927 in full satisfaction of the claim: vide Exs. D-9, D-10, and D-11. Subsequently Sheoratan brought Civil Suit No. 4 of 1929 to 13-4-1929 to enforce the other mortgage, Ex. D-1, in which suit Gadiram also was impleaded is a defendant. On 25-1-1930 Sheoratan obtained a preliminary decree directing foreclosure in default of payment of apparently Rs. 11,416-11-6, but an appeal by Gadiram to the Judicial Commissioner's Court was allowed on 12-1-1933, as reported in 30 N.L.R 2651 vide Ex. D-15. It was held that as Gadiram had paid off the mortgage, Ex. D-2, he was entitled to use that mortgage (Ex. D-2) as a shield against the mortgage in the suit (Ex. D-1), though both mortgages were in fact executed and registered on the same day, and that he was therefore entitled to retain survey No. 20 without redeeming the mortgage Ex. D-1. A final decree for foreclosure against Shamrao and his brothers, Ex. P-10, was passed on 20-7-1934, and on 17-9-1934, and on 17-9-1934 possession of the other mortgaged property was delivered to Punamchand, son of Sheoratan, Sheoratan having died meanwhile: vide Ex. P-3. Gadiram thus retained possession of survey No. 20 without paying off the mortgage Ex. D-1, and Shamrao and his brothers lost the entire mortgaged property in spite of their attempts to save some of it by the sale of survey No. 20.

5. Gadiram died on 29-2-1936. On 17-7-1937 Shamrao sent a telegraphic notice (Ex. D-17) to Vithoba, son of Gadiram, defendant 1, demanding the return of Rs. 7351 within 24 hours, and on 19-7-1937 he filed an application to sue in forma pauperis for the recovery of this amount from the sons of Gadiram, defendants 1, 2, 3, 4. As Shamrao's brothers had refused to join him in bringing the suit he impleaded his three surviving brothers as defendants 5, 6, 7. The result of his failure to implead the legal representative of his other brother, Narayan, will be considered later. The application to sue in forma pauperis was eventually allowed, and an amended plaint was filed on 11-3-1940. There were further amendments on 15-6-1940.

6. The lower Court held that out of the money retained by Gadiram Rs. 2351 was retained to pay off the balance due on the preliminary decree after the payment of Rs. 3900 on 30-10-1926 and Rs. 6000 to pay off the other mortgage (Ex. D-1), and that the plaintiff was entitled to a refund of Rs. 6000 with interest at 3 pee cent, per annum from 1-7-1926. Against that decision the sons of Gadiram have preferred, this appeal.

7. The sale deed, Ex. D-3, was registered on 1-11-1926. When it was executed on 1-7-1926 no application had been made for a final decree, and there v?as no agreement in existence to pay interest on the preliminary decree for rupees 6251-13-0. It is therefore difficult to see why the purchaser should have been allowed to retain Rs. 7351 if he were to pay off only the preliminary decree for Rs. 6251-13-0. The appellants' explanation of this is that it was intended to apply for an extension of time, that it was expected that there would be no difficulty in obtaining an extension on an agreement to pay interest, and that this sum of Rs. 7351 included Rs. 1100 interest at the contract rate of Rs. 1-8-0 per cent, per mensem for one year from 20-4-1926, by which time it was hoped that the question of pre-emption would be settled. The exact amount would be Rs. 1125-5-0, but it is said that Rs. 1100 was taken as a round figure.

8. Shamrao, the plaintiff-respondent, on the other hand, contends that the figures in the sale deed were altered after the payment of Rs. 3900 on 30-10-1926, which was two days before the registration. This left Rs. 2351-13-0 payable on the preliminary decree, and this combined with Rs. 5000 calculated as due on the other mortgage, Ex. D-1, made up the sum of Rs. 7351. There have been a considerable number of alterations in Ex. D-3, not all apparently at the same time. It appears to us from a scrutiny of that document that, apart from the figure of Rs. 13,500, which was throughout fixed as the consideration, the other figures were not filled in at the time of writing. As first written the deed showed that Rs. 12,204-13-0 was to be retained by the purchaser and Rs. 7351 was admitted as having been received. There could never have been any admission that Rs. 7351 had been received, and there obviously was some mistake because this would make the total consideration over rupees 20,000 and the stamp that was actually purchased, Rs. 210, was a stamp for such an amount.

9. The question whether Gadiram undertook to pay off both mortgage debts or only one depends largely on whether he paid Rs. 5000 in cash on 28-4-1925. (Their Lordships considered the evidence in this respect and continued.) We, therefore, agree with the lower Court and accept Shamrao's evidence that Rs. 5000 was not paid in cash on 28-4-1925.

10. If Rs. 5000 was not paid in cash in advance, then clearly Rs. 7351 was retained in order to pay off both the mortgages and Gadiram failed to fulfil his obligation. The question then is what the vendors can claim as damages for this failure. The lower Court has held that they are entitled to the refund of Rs. 5000, which was retained by the purchaser to pay off the mortgage Ex. D-1, and interest thereon, but admittedly as a result of the purchaser's failure to fulfil his obligation the vendors lost property worth Rs. 1000. There was no pronaise by Gadiram to pay Rs. 6000 to his purchasers. He under-took, as we have held, to retain that money and use it to pay off the two mortgages, which he failed to do, and as a result of his failure his vendors lost certain property worth Rs. 1000. Gadiram's covenant with his vendors to pay off this encumbrance was nothing more than a con-tract of indemnity, as was held in 31 All. 583,2 and it appears to us that the damages to which his vendors are entitled on a breach of that con-tract must be measured by the loss that they have suffered, and that limitation will run from the date when the loss was Suffered. It may be that it would have been open to the purchasers to sue for breach of contract before they had actually suffered loss, as was held in A.I.R 1931 ALL. 7543 and 34 ALL. 429;4 but where loss has actually been suffered, that, in our opinion, gives rise to a cause of action. In support of this proposition there are the decisions in 26 Cal. 241,5 56 Mad. 724,6 55 ALL. 4907 where the decision in 34 ALL. 429 was not approved, A.I.R 1926 Nag. 4298 and 31 N.L.R 235.9

11. The question, however, remains whether the loss was suffered when the suit on the mortgage was filed or when the final decree for foreclosure was passed or when possession was actually taken in execution of the final decree. In A.I.R 1938 Pat. 27610 it was held that limitation runs from the date of the filing of the suit to enforce the mortgage, but after that date the mortgage debt might have been paid of, and we agree with the view taken in 26 Cal. 241, 55 ALL. 490 and A.I.R 1926 Nag. 429 that limitation in such a case would run from the date of payment. In 56 Mad. 724 it was held that the loss occurred when the property was sold. In the present case it seems to us that the loss clearly occurred either when the final decree for foreclosure was passed by which the plaintiff lost his title in the property or when he actually lost possession, and whichever of these dates is held as the starting point for limitation the present suit is within time. The last question is whether the plaintiff alone is entitled to sue, and if so, whether be is entitled to recover the entire amount of the compensation or only 1/5th share of it. One of his brothers, Narayan, died some time between 25-1-1930 when civil suit No. 4 of 1929 was decided and 12-1-1933 when the appeal in that suit (First Appeal No. 108 of 1930) was decided in the Judicial Commissioner's Court. The plaintiff stated that his surviving brothers had refused to join him in this suit and he therefore impleaded them as defendants. According to his own evidence elicited in cross-examination there was a complete partition between him and his four brothers while Narayan was still alive and thereafter the plaintiff had a 1/5th separate undivided share in the property that was subsequently foreclosed and lost by the failure of Gadiram to pay off the mortgage Ex. D-1. He is, therefore, in our opinion, entitled to compensation for the loss of his separate share, and he is entitled to sue for that compensation without joining his brothers as co-plaintiffs. He is therefore, entitled to 1/5th share of Rs. 1000 i.e as 200 as compensation for the loss that he has suffered, and in order that he may be restored to the position in which he would have been if he had not suffered that loss he must be allowed interest on that amount from the date when he lost possession. In the plaint as originally drafted he claimed interest at 3 per cent, per annum, but subsequently he claimed 10 per cent. We think that be should be allowed interest at 6 per cent, per annum on Rs. 200 from 17-9-1934 up to the date of suit, during the suit, and thereafter till realization. Costs both here and below will be in proportion to success and failure.

12. Order accordingly.