Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Union Of India v. Corporation Of Calcutta .

Calcutta High Court
Sep 9, 1952
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Mookerjee, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

Premises No. 4, Dum Dum Road were originally assessed by the Corporation of Calcutta under clause (b) of section 127 of the Calcutta Municipal Act, 1923, effective from the first quarter of 1938–39. The Central Government, as owner, objected and this Court in 1947 (The Governor-General in Council v. The Corporation of Calcutta) held that the premises should be assessed under clause (a) of section 127. Although the assessment period in dispute had expired in 1944, the Corporation issued a notice on 6 July 1948 under section 136 for the assessee to submit a return; the return was submitted on 3 January 1949.

The property comprises a large area with 43 distinct quarters (including a hostel with multiple smaller units), a club-house, playground and other common open areas. Quarters were let primarily to employees of the Gun and Shell Factory (a Union of India undertaking); occupiers were charged 10% of pay or standard rent whichever is lower, and occupiers were not required to pay municipal rates (the Government paid owner's and occupier's shares).

In the return the Central Government claimed total annual rent of Rs. 65,400 (based on standard rents and Rs. 500 per month for common facilities) and sought deductions of “the usual three 10 per cents” to arrive at taxable annual value. The Corporation's Assessment Department proposed a 50% increase on the Government's standard rent to reach a gross annual value under section 127(a), allowed two 10% deductions (one statutory 10% and one because owner paid occupier's share of taxes), and issued a new assessment. The Deputy Executive Officer reduced the proposed gross annual rental figure and allowed two 10% deductions; the assessee appealed under section 141. The principal contested point was whether a further (third) 10% deduction should be allowed to account for probable vacancies among many tenements.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, when determining net annual value under clause (a) of section 127 of the Calcutta Municipal Act, the assessee is entitled to an additional deduction (a third 10% or any other deduction) from gross annual rental to account for probable vacancies among multiple tenements.
  2. Whether the Assessment and Collection Manual or past practice of the Corporation can require or compel allowance of such additional deductions when fixing annual value under section 127(a).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant / Union of India (assessee) — arguments

  • Claimed that from the gross annual rent (aggregate of standard rents and facilities) deductions of “the usual three 10 per cents” should be allowed to arrive at taxable annual value.
  • Specifically sought a third 10% deduction to allow for the contingency of vacancies in a premises composed of a large number of separate tenements occupied by different tenants.
  • Relied on the Corporation's Assessment and Collection Manual (1917), notably an entry (Article 71) permitting a deduction where a premises contains a large number of huts to provide for eventual vacancies, and argued the Manual shows a general practice of allowing such deductions for buildings with many separate tenements.
  • Filed examples (Ex. 3 to 3(c)) of other Corporation orders showing three 10% deductions had been allowed in other cases, to demonstrate general practice.

Respondent / Corporation of Calcutta — arguments and position

  • The Corporation allowed two 10% deductions: one statutory 10% for cost of repairs and maintenance; a second 10% where it was shown the owner (not occupier) paid the occupier's share of rates. The second deduction was explained as granted when the owner bore occupiers' share of taxes.
  • The Corporation did not adduce evidence to explain circumstances under which three 10% deductions had been allowed in prior instances or to justify refusing the additional deduction in this case.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
The Governor-General in Council v. The Corporation of Calcutta (51 C.W.N 517) Determination that the premises at issue should be assessed under clause (a) of section 127 of the Calcutta Municipal Act. The Court relied on this earlier determination as establishing that the premises in question fall to be assessed under clause (a) of section 127.
Corporation of Calcutta v. Moti-chand Chowdhury (40 C.W.N 818) Held that rules contained in the Assessment Manual have no statutory force and may be ignored if inconsistent with the Act. The Court cited this authority to reject the contention that the 1917 Manual could override or bind interpretation of the 1923 Act; the Manual cannot be treated as having the force of law if inconsistent with the statute.
Durham County Council v. Tan-field Overseers [(1933) L.R. 2 Q.B. 333] Practice of long-standing administrative procedure is not of itself binding; the true question is the actual assessable value—what a tenant would pay. The Court relied on this to emphasize that an established practice (even if convenient) does not create a legal obligation; the statutory test remains what gross rent might reasonably be expected year to year.
Mersey Docks & Harbour Board v. Birkenhead Overseers (1873) 8 Q.B. 445 In English law, a hereditament capable of separate letting may be separately rated. The Court cited this to contrast English law (where separate letting can lead to separate rating) with the Calcutta Municipal Act, which contains different provisions and limited subdivision rules.
R. v. St. George Union (1871) 7 Q.B. 90 Authority indicating that flats (modern sense) may be separately rateable under English law. Used as part of the comparative discussion showing English authorities allow separate rating of distinct lettable portions, unlike the Calcutta Act framework.
St. Marylebone Association Committee v. Consolidated London Properties Ltd. (1914) A.C. 870 Further authority that separate lettable units (e.g., flats) are ratable in England. Referenced to illustrate the English position of separate rating, reinforcing the Court's view that English law differs from the Calcutta Municipal Act on subdivision and separate rating.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by identifying the statutory framework and then applying it to the facts:

  1. Statutory framework: Clause (a) of section 127 requires determination of the gross annual rent at which the land or building might reasonably be expected to let from year to year. From that gross amount an assessee is entitled to a statutory allowance of 10% for repairs and other expenses necessary to maintain the building in a state to command such gross rent.
  2. The Court accepted that a second 10% deduction had been allowed by the Corporation where the owner pays the occupier's share of municipal rates (the owner bears the occupier's usual obligation). The Corporation did not produce evidence explaining prior instances of triple deductions.
  3. The assessee's claim for a third 10% deduction rested on (a) the Assessment and Collection Manual (1917) provision (Article 71) that allowed deductions for premises with many huts to provide for vacancies, and (b) examples of past Corporation orders where three 10% deductions were allowed. The Court noted the Manual predates the 1923 Act, and earlier authority (Corporation of Calcutta v. Moti-chand Chowdhury) holds the Manual has no statutory force if inconsistent with the Act.
  4. The Court emphasized that administrative practice, however longstanding, does not have the force of law (citing Durham County Council v. Tan-field Overseers) and that the controlling question under section 127(a) is the true assessable gross rent—what a tenant would give from year to year.
  5. The Court contrasted English law (where separate lettable hereditaments may be separately rated) with the Calcutta Municipal Act's specific provisions. Under the Calcutta Act:
    • Sections 151 and 152 provide for refund/remission of occupier's share if the entire premises remain unoccupied for 60 consecutive days with proper notice; partial vacancy does not entitle to such refund.
    • Section 132 requires separate valuation for bustees and huts; other properties may be subdivided only under specified conditions (e.g., separate ownership or physical separation as in section 133).
    Consequently, a premises like 4, Dum Dum Road must be assessed as one unit unless statutory subdivision conditions are met.
  6. The Court held that while the Act does not expressly require anticipated vacancies to be taken into account in clause (a), the fact that some portions ordinarily remain vacant is a relevant consideration in determining the gross annual rent a tenant would reasonably be expected to pay for the entire premises from year to year.
  7. On evidence: the Corporation gave no explanatory evidence about its prior practices. The assessee produced a statement showing some tenements of the premises had remained vacant for about ten years; this was not challenged, and the Court accepted it as indicative for assessing reasonable gross rent from year to year.
  8. The Court rejected the proposition that proving many separate tenements automatically entitles the assessee to a fixed extra 10% deduction for vacancies. Each case must be considered on its facts: number of tenements, past vacancy experience, and other considerations.
  9. Applying these considerations to the present facts, the Court concluded that, in addition to the two 10% deductions already allowed by the Corporation, a further deduction of 7½% should be allowed to reflect probable vacancies and arrive at a reasonable annual rent for the whole premises.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: Appeals allowed in part; the annual value fixed by the Corporation is to be further reduced by 7½ per cent.

Consequences and immediate effects:

  • The annual value (net annual rent) as fixed by the Corporation is to be reduced by an additional 7½% beyond the two 10% deductions already allowed, and rates shall be assessed on that reduced net annual value.
  • The appellant (Union of India) is entitled to half the costs of this Court. There will be one hearing fee for the two appeals.

The opinion does not set out any declaration that it establishes a new general legal rule; it applies statutory interpretation and existing authorities to the facts and adjusts the annual value for this specific premises. No broader novel precedent is announced beyond the application to these appeals.

Show all summary ...

Mookerjee, J.:— Premises No. 4, Dum Dum Road was assessed by the Corporation of Calcutta under clause (b) of section 127 of the Calcutta Municipal Act, 1923, with effect from the first quarter of 1938–39. Objection was raised on behalf of the Central Government as the owner of the property and ultimately this Court decided in 1947 [The Governor-General in Council v. The Corporation of Calcutta (1) (51 C.W.N 517)] that these premises should be assessed under clause (a) of section 127 of the said Act. Although the period for which the assessment had been made which was the subject-matter of the appeal to this Court had expired in 1944 a notice was issued by the Corporation on the 6th July, 1948, purporting to be one under section 136 of the Act on the assessee to submit a return. The return was submitted (Ex. 1) on the 3rd January, 1949.

2. The premises in question covers a large area and includes 43 different units of quarters. They have been classified by the Union of India into different classes of quarters dependant upon the rent which is payable by the officers or other occupiers who are allowed to reside therein. One of the structures is a hostel wherein are included a number of smaller units of quarters. In addition to the above, there is one club-house, play-ground and certain other open areas which are used by the occupants jointly. The quarters are let out mainly to the employees of the Gun and Shell Factory, an undertaking run by the Union of India. The occupants are charged at 10 per cent, of their pay or the standard rent whichever is lower. The occupiers are not required to pay any share of the municipal rates for the premises. The Government pays both the owner's as also the occupier's shares of taxes. In the return Ex. 1. It was claimed on behalf of the Central Government that taking the standard rent fixed for each of the quarters, being the maximum amount leviable for the quarters, and a lump sum of Its. 500 per month as the rent of the club-house, playground, etc., the total annual rent was Rs. 65,400. On behalf of the assessee Government it was claimed that deductions therefrom should be made of “the usual three 10 per cents.” for arriving at the taxable annual value.

3. From the certified copy of the inspection book maintained by the Assessment Department of the Corporation (Ex. B) it appears that the department proposed a 50 per cent, increase of the standard rent as charged by the; Central Government to be “the gross] annual value at which the building may at the time of the assessment reasonably be expected to let from year to year” as under section 127(a) of the Calcutta Municipal Act. The rental for the Club-house, play-ground and other open spaces, etc., was accepted at the same rate as proposed on behalf of the assessee. From the gross amount a deduction of two 10 per cents, was proposed by the Assessor of the Corporation. Notice was thereupon issued of the new assessment as proposed. Objections were filed and the Deputy Executive Officer reduced Rs. 7,925, as proposed by the Department to be the gross annual rental, to Rs. 6,500. From that amount deductions of two 10 per cents, were allowed. Against the decision of the Deputy Executive Officer an appeal was taken on behalf of the assessee under section 141 of the Calcutta Municipal Act. The only substantial point raised in the appeal was that in determining the net annual value under clause (a) of section 127 of the Calcutta Municipal Act the Corporation ought to allow a deduction of three 10 per cents from the gross amount of rent determined. The learned Judge has overruled this objection and affirmed the valuation as fixed by the Deputy Executive Officer.

4. The only point for consideration in these two anneals is whether the assessee is entitled to a further deduction of 10 per cent, or any other deduction from the annual rental over and above what has been allowed by the Deputy Executive Officer.

5. In clause (a) of section 127 of the Act the Corporation has to determine the gross annual rent at which the land or building might at the time of assessment reasonably be expected to let from year to year.

6. From the gross amount so determined the assessee is entitled to a statutory “allowance of 10 per cent for the cost of repairs and for all other expenses necessary to maintain the building in a state to command such gross rent”.

7. An assessee is thus entitled to an allowance of 10 per cent, under the statutory provisions to cover cost of repairs, etc. No evidence was adduced in the present case to explain why the second ten per cent, deduction had been allowed by the Corporation. It is explained before us both on behalf of the Corporation as also the assessee that a second ten per cent, allowance is allowed by the Corporation when it is shown that the occupier's share of taxes is paid by the owner and not by the occupier. A moiety share of the rates for a premises being the owner's share is payable by the owner and the other moiety share is ordinarily payable by the occupiers. On the basis of the agreed statement of facts as aforesaid we accept the same and proceed on that footing.

8. On behalf of the assessee it is claimed that as the premises in question consist of a large number of tenements occupied by different tenants, a third 10 per cent, should be allowed as a further allowance from the gross annual rent and that for the purpose of meeting the possible contingency of vacancies of particular tenement or tenements.

9. In the first place reliance has been placed on certain provisions contained in the Assessment Manual issued by the Corporation. A copy of the Assessment and Collection Manual published in 1917 was placed before us. Article 71 which relates to huts provides that if a premises contains a large number of huts deduction from the gross annual rent is to be allowed to provide for eventual vacancies of some of the huts. Under section 2(7) of the Calcutta Municipal Act a “building” includes a hut. On the strength of this entry in the Manual it is contended that the Corporation has been allowing the same allowance in the case of all kinds of buildings. A ten per cent, deduction is generally allowed by the Corporation if the premises contain a large number of separate tenements occupied by different tenants.

10. To prove that the Corporation generally allows three ten per cent, deductions from the gross annual rental copies of orders issued by the Corporation in respect of different premises were filed. Ex. 3 to 3(c).

11. As already stated the Corporation of Calcutta chose not to adduce any evidence. No attempt was made by the Corporation to explain under what circumstances deductions of three 10 per cents, had been allowed in the case of the premises referred to in Ex. 3 series. On the evidence therefore all that we can find is that in the case of certain premises the Corporation had allowed three 10 per cent, deductions without any materials to explain the circumstances under which such deductions had been allowed.

12. On behalf of the Union of India reliance is placed on the provisions contained in the Assessment and Collection Manual as indicating the general practice followed. We may, however, point out immediately that no materials were placed before us to show to what extent the directions contained in the Manual made were under the Statutory Rule-making powers under the Act. Moreover, the Manual placed before us was of 1917 and the Calcutta Municipal Act which we have to interpret was passed in 1923. An attempt which had been made on a previous occasion to use the rules contained in the Manual was repelled by this Court in the Corporation of Calcutta v. Moti-chand Chowdhury (2) (40 C.W.N 818) and it was held that the rules contained in the Manual had not the force of Law and might be ignored if they were inconsistent with the provisions of that Act.

13. It is, however, contended on behalf of the appellant that though the rules in the Manual have no Statutory force yet they show unmistakably the practice and procedure which the Executive is called upon to follow uniformity in practice is not only expected from the Corporation, but all the ratepayers should be treated in the same manner as no differential treatment should be meted out to any particular assessee.

14. In Durham County Council v. Tan-field Overseers (3) [(1933) L.R 2 Q.B 333], an Assessment Committee acting in accordance with a practice which had always existed in the Union assessed certain collieries by ascertaining their net annual value upon the basis of the actual out put of coal during the previous 12 months. Owing to a strike there had been no output of coal during four of the previous twelve months. The County Council for the purposes of the County rate basis and of the rate made thereon, refused to follow the prevailing practice and assessed the collieries at a larger sum. On appeal against the County rate basis the Quarter Sessions held that the practice of taking the actual output for the previous 12 months should have been followed but on an appeal the case was remitted to the Quarter Sessions for ascertaining the true assessable value of the collieries. It was held that there was no obligation of law requiring that the existing practice should be followed, the only question being what in fact and law was the true assessable value of the collieries—the test was what would a tenant give in the coming year.

15. Lord Hewart, C.J, observed that there is no law which requires that a practice, however convenient it may be and however fairly it may work out over a period of years, must be observed. The question is, apart altogether from any suggestion that there is a sanction of law behind that practice, what in fact was the true assessable value in that case.

16. We have, therefore, to ascertain in the present case whether in determining the annual value under clause (a) of section 127 of the Calcutta Municipal Act it is incumbent on the part of the Corporation Authorities to take into consideration the circumstance that a particular holding consists of a number of smaller tenements let out to different tenants with the possibility of someone or more of these tenements remaining vacant for some period or other during a year.

17. What is required to be determined under clause (a) of section 127 of the Calcutta Municipal Act is the gross annual rent at which the entire premises may be reasonably expected to let out from year to year, an allowance for the cost of repairs etc. In determining what reasonable rent may be expected for the entire premises if let out to one person may or may not be the aggregate rent what each one of the tenements taken separately yields per month. In particular cases no doubt the aggregate amount of rent reasonably expected from each one of the tenements may be the rent for the entire premises also.

18. No doubt in clause (a) of section 127 of the Calcutta Municipal Act no reference is made to anticipated vacancy of the premises being required to be taken into consideration and that is due to the provisions contained in sections 151 and 152 of the same Act. A ratepayer is entitled to a refund of the occupier's share of the consolidated rate if for a period of 60 consecutive days or more the premises had not been occupied and proper notice of that fact had been delivered to the Corporation under the relevant provisions. The condition precedent to a refund or remission under section 152 or 151 of the Act may be due only if the entire premises remain vacant and not otherwise. If a portion of the premises remains vacant the ratepayer is not, under the provisions of the Calcutta Municipal Act, 1923, entitled to any consideration.

19. It is only in the case of a bustee that under section 132 of the Calcutta Municipal Act the Corporation is bound to cause the land contained within the bustee and of the huts standing on it to be valued separately for purposes of levying the consolidated rate. In the case of other properties, however, subdivision of a particular premises may be allowed only if certain conditions are satisfied each one of the separate portions being either owned by different co-owners as in section 133 of the Act or if each one of the portions be physically separated from the rest.

20. A premises like the one which is now before us for determination of rates cannot be assessed except as one unit; there has been no subdivision and as a matter of fact some portions of the premises being the play ground, Club House etc., are available for the common use of all the occupiers.

21. In England, however, a heriditament which is capable of being separately let out may be separately rated. [Mersey Docks & Harbour Board v. Birkenhead Overseers (4), (1873) 8 Q.B 445]. Even flats in the modern acceptation of the term are separately ratable. [R. v. St. George Union (5), (1871) 7 Q.B 90]; St. Marlybone Association Committee v. Consolidated London Properties Ltd., (1914) A.C 870].

22. In view of the special provisions under the English Law, which are different from those as under the Calcutta Municipal Act, all that we are required to find out is whether the Calcutta Corporation, while fixing the annual value of an entire premises, consisting of a large number of tenements, should take into consideration the fact that if one person had taken the entire premises as a tenant, could it be reasonably expected that he would pay the gross rental per month which the different tenants of the tenements might in their totality have paid. The fact that the assessee will not be entitled to any remission for vacancy, although there is a reasonable likelihood of such vacancies, is a factor which cannot be overlooked altogether. What the authorities are required to do is to determine the annual rent at which the entire premises may be reasonably expected to let year to year. The fact that some portions of the premises ordinarily remain vacant is a consideration which cannot be overlooked in determining the gross annual rent which a tenant would give from year to year for the entire premises.

23. As observed already the Corporation had not adduced any evidence in the present case. The Assessee had produced before the Court a statement in support of the fact that some tenement or other being part of the premises 4, Dum Dum Road, had remain-ed vacant during a period of about 10 years. There was no suggestion even questioning the accuracy of the statements. This gives the Court an idea as to what the gross annual rent which may be reasonably expected for the entire premises from year to year for determining the annual value for fixing the rates.

24. On behalf of the assessee it is claimed that an allowance of 10 per cent, from out of the gross annual rent, expected from all the different tenements added together should be allowed on this account before the fair annual rent as may be reasonably expect-ed is ascertained. We do not think that whenever an assessee proves that within a certain premises there are many tenements let out to different tenants that a deduction of 10 per cent, from the gross rental of the totality of the rent payable by the tenants of all the tenements taken together can be claimed. Each case must be considered on its own fact—how many separate tenements there ore within the premises, the average gross rental for the entire premises which may be expected after allowing probable vacancies from the past experience, if any, and many other considerations.

25. In the present case, we think that in addition to the allowance of two deductions by the Corporation at 10 per cent, each a further deduction of 7½ per cent, should have been allowed.

26. That would give the reasonable amount of annual rent of which the entire premises may be reasonably expected to be let from year to year.

27. These two appeals are accordingly allowed in part and the annual value as was fixed by the Corporation will be further reduced by 7½ per cent, and on such net annual value the rates will be assessed.

28. The appellant will be entitled to half the costs of this Court. There will be one hearing fee for the two appeals.

Renupada Mukherjee, J.:— I agree.

A.K.D.G