Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Union Of India v. Dhanpal Patni

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Feb 22, 1954

1. The application for revision is referred to a Division Bench apparently under R. 9, sub-r. (1) of Chapter 1 of the Rules of this Court as involving a question of law of difficulty or importance. Obviously, R. 9(2) is inapplicable. There is no decision of this Court or of the late Judicial Commissioner's Court which requires reconsideration in this case. Nor does this case involve any question as regards the interpretation of the Constitution. Two courses were therefore open to the learned referring Judge under sub-r. (3) of R. 9: either to refer a stated question, or to refer the whole case. The latter course is followed but the question of law is not indicated. The counsel who appeared before us also appeared before the learned Judge. They are not able to point out the question of law of difficulty or importance. We are ourselves unable to discover any such question. We are therefore of the view that an order of reference would have been of immense help to us to decide the question or questions of law which appeared to the learned referring Judge to be of difficulty or importance.

2. This application was admitted for hearing parties by one of us (Deo J.) because the decree appeared to be in utter Disregard of the agreement between the parties evidenced by risk note A and because the decision reported in — ‘Janeshwar Lal v. Dominion of India’, AIR 1951 Punj 383 (A) relied on by the trial Court was inapplicable. The facts of the case are very simple and are not disputed. 16 bundles of fresh dates, whose weight as shown in the railway receipt was 23 maunds and 18 seers, were booked from Wadibundar to Parasia in the Chhindwara district under risk note A. On arrival at the destination it was found that three bundles were in broken condition and some contents were missing. These three bundles were separately weighed and were found to weigh 56, 51 and 54 seers. One unbroken bundle was found to weigh 52 seers. Delivery was taken six days later. The total weight of 13 bundles at the time of delivery was 21 maunds and 15 seers. Plaintiffs therefore claimed damages for the short weight of 2 maunds and 3 seers.

3. Subject to the provisions of the Indian Railways Act, the responsibility of a Railway Administration for loss, destruction or deterioration of goods is that of a bailee under Sections 151, 152 and 161 of the Contract Act. If by the default of the bailee the goods are not delivered at the proper time, it is responsible to the bailor for any loss, destruction or deterioration of the goods bailed from that time. The bailment in the Instant case was of 16 bundles. Unexplained failure to return the thing bailed is presumed to be by the bailee's default. An unexplained failure to deliver a complete package would therefore fall within Section 161 of the Contract Act. This is not the case here and the Railway Administration cannot be held liable for the short weight, if any, of the 13 bundles which were delivered in a sound condition.

4. There is no material on record to show that the short weight of 2 maunds and 3 seers was the weight of the contents missing from the three bundles which were found in a broken state. That is not even the plaintiff's case. It is a matter of common knowledge that fresh dates are liable to dry and lose some weight thereby. The extent of this loss depends upon the degree of freshness of the fruit. Plaintiffs cannot therefore succeed because they have failed to prove the weight and value of the missing contents of the three bundles in question. The suit was therefore liable to be dismissed on this short ground.

5. The learned trial Judge seems to hold that the risk note A in the present case is applicable if the dates were delivered in a bad condition but not when they were lost in transit. As stated in the risk note A Exhibit D-2, that form is to be used when articles are tendered for carriage which are either already in bad condition or so defectively packed as to be liable to damage, leakage or wastage in transit. It is also stated in the document that a consignment of 18 bundles tendered for carriage was in bad condition and/or liable to damage, leakage or wastage in transit as the bundles were insecurely sewn and the contents were dropping. The lower Court has therefore taken an erroneous view of the risk note. Its statement “there is no burden on the plaintiff to prove the misconduct and negligence on the part of the Railway Administration” is not borne out by the decision relied on by him and is contrary to the agreement in the risk note.

6. As is evident from issue no. 5 reproduced at page 384 of the decision relied on by the lower Court (‘Janeshwar Lal v. Dominion of India (A)’, cit sup.), it was a case of non-delivery of one complete bag and it was held that such loss was not protected by risk note A. This case is distinguishable.

7. The recitals in the risk note A undoubtedly protected the defendant from liability in the instant case because the articles tendered for carriage were in a bad condition and were liable to leakage in transit as the bundles were insecurely sewn and the contents were dropping. The consignor agreed and undertook to hold the Railway Administration harmless and free from all responsibility for the condition in which the goods would, be delivered to the consignee at the destination and for any loss arising from the same except upon proof that such loss was due to misconduct on the part of the Railway Administration's servants.

8. The case of misconduct was not pleaded, not proved and is not relied on in this Court. The goods were delivered to the consignee apparently after some leakage in transit due to insecure packing of the three bundles. The Railway Administration is therefore absolved from liability for any loss arising from this condition in which the goods were delivered to the consignee. The learned trial Judge seems to have assumed that the Railway Administration is exempt from liability only for the deterioration of goods. He seems to have overlooked the case of damage due to defective packing.

9. Risk note A is to be used when the articles tendered for carriage are already in bad condition or so defectively packed as to be liable to damage, leakage, or wastage in transit. If a consignor fails in his duty to see that his goods are so securely packed as to be protected from the ordinary and inevitable incidents of a journey and the goods are consequently injured, the Administration is not liable.

10. We are therefore satisfied that the defendant is not liable for the plaintiff's claim. Grounds Nos. 1, 2, 3 and 4 of the application for revision were not pressed as the counsel on examination of the record felt satisfied that the notices under Sections 77 and 80 of the Railways Act, were not open to any objection. No question of law is involved in these grounds. The application for revision is therefore allowed and the suit is dismissed with costs. The learned counsel for the non-applicants did not attempt to support the decree of the trial Court and submitted that the firm should not be made liable for the costs, particularly the paper book costs occasioned by this reference. The learned counsel for the applicant submitted that the defendant should not be made liable to pay those costs because it did not seek the reference. It is not necessary to examine these contentions. Costs are in the discretion of the Court, and we direct that the costs in this Court should be borne as incurred.

11. Revision allowed.