Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Hakim Soban Ali v. Kanai Lal Sarma And Ors. Opposite Parties.

Calcutta High Court
Apr 26, 1956
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a petition under Article 227 of the Constitution arising out of an election petition concerning the Municipal election of Ward No. 3 of Garulia Municipality. Ward No. 3 is a plural general constituency with two seats and three candidates contested the election. Vote totals recorded in the opinion are: Badri Narayan Bidyarthi (opposite party No. 2) 147 votes; Hakim Soban Ali (opposite party No. 1) 123 votes; Md. Salim (opposite party No. 3) 109 votes.

The election of Hakim Soban Ali was challenged in the election petition; the learned Subordinate Judge set aside his election. The Subordinate Judge also declared Md. Salim to have been duly elected (along with Badri Narayan). The present opinion reviews that decision and addresses whether Hakim Soban Ali was disqualified u/s 22(1)(g) of the Bengal Municipal Act and whether the Subordinate Judge had jurisdiction to declare Md. Salim elected.

Relevant transactional and chronological facts relating to Hakim Soban Ali's ownership and municipal rates, as recited in the opinion, include:

  • Hakim Soban Ali purchased holding No. 160 in Ward No. 3 on 8 June 1954.
  • By application dated 25 June 1954 his name was mutated on 27 June 1954 and he was informed of the mutation on 18 July 1954.
  • Municipal rates are payable quarterly; the first-quarter 1954–55 rates fell due on 1 April 1954 and the second-quarter rates on 1 July 1954.
  • Nomination papers for the election were submitted on or about 26 October 1954 (the last date for filing nominations).
  • Hakim Soban Ali paid the municipal rates for the holding on 6 November 1954.
  • The election and declaration of results occurred on 5 December 1954.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Hakim Soban Ali was disqualified under section 22(1)(g) of the Bengal Municipal Act by being "in arrears for more than 3 months in payment of any rate or tax" as of the relevant date for eligibility.
  2. What is the relevant date for determining eligibility under section 22(1) — in particular, whether the date of nomination (as opposed to the date of polling) is the relevant date for disqualification?
  3. Whether the learned Subordinate Judge had jurisdiction in an election petition under section 36 of the Bengal Municipal Act to declare a defeated candidate (Md. Salim) "duly elected" when the winning candidate was declared disqualified.
  4. Whether an alleged Government memorandum (No. 1279.M 3P-18/55(13)) alters the operation of section 22(1)(g) by requiring further delay after service of demand notice before disqualification arises.
  5. Whether the successful challenge to one candidate in a plural-member constituency requires setting aside the entire election for that constituency.

Arguments of the Parties

Counsel identified in the opinion (Mr. Dutt) — reliance on Government memorandum

  • Reliance was placed before the learned Judge on an alleged memorandum (No. 1279.M 3P-18/55(13)) of the Local Self-Government Department of the West Bengal Government. The memorandum was said to provide that the disability in section 22(1)(g) would arise only if a rate or tax remained unpaid for more than three months after the expiry of 15 days from the date of service of a demand notice under section 155 of the Bengal Municipal Act, 1932.
  • When pressed, Mr. Dutt (appearing at one point described as "on behalf of the petitioner") admitted he could not trace the memorandum and could not contend that, if it existed, it had been sanctioned by the rule-making power under section 505 of the Bengal Municipal Act, 1932.

Argument on behalf of Hakim Soban Ali (as recorded in the opinion)

  • It was contended that because Ward No. 3 was a plural constituency, the successful challenge to one candidate should lead to setting aside the entire election for the ward (relying upon Md. Anisul Islam v. Kali Kumar Mukherjee (59 C.W.N 127)).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mathuraprasad v. The Corporation of Calcutta (48 C.W.N 336) That service of a bill is not a condition precedent to the right of recovery of municipal rates by suit (despite a provision requiring service of the bill). The court relied on this case to hold that non-presentation of a bill or notice of demand under section 155 did not prevent rates being due and recoverable and did not prevent a person from being a "defaulter" for the purposes of disqualification.
Harford v. Linskey (1899) 1 Q.B. 852 Authority for the proposition that the relevant date for determining eligibility in an election is the date of nomination (nomination being an essential part of the election). Used to support the conclusion that the date of nomination (26 October 1954 in the facts) is the relevant date to decide disqualification under section 22(1).
Satyendra Kumar Das v. The Chairman of the Municipal Commissioners of Dacca (34 C.W.N 972) Supports the position that nomination date is relevant for election eligibility questions. Relied upon along with other authorities to establish that the candidate's eligibility must be assessed as of the date of nomination.
Sheikh Ahmed Hossain v. Aswini Kumar Paul (57 C.W.N 421) Also cited for the proposition that nomination is the relevant date for assessing eligibility; used in contrast with Md. Anisul Islam on the question of when an election may be set aside. Relied upon to contrast and distinguish the scope of Md. Anisul Islam; supports the narrower view that remedies under section 38 address the election of the candidate brought in question.
Md. Anisul Islam v. Kali Kumar Mukherjee (59 C.W.N 127) Held (Division Bench) that an election may be set aside not only for corrupt practice by the candidate or agent but also for want of fairness of election proceedings for which others (not the candidate) may be responsible; a headnote paragraph suggested that in a plural-member constituency successful challenge to one candidate requires refreeing the whole election. The court reviewed and distinguished this case: it considered that a portion of the headnote was too widely expressed and that the case was decided on the footing that the election of the candidate concerned had been brought in question under section 36 (which was not the situation in the instant case vis-à-vis the other successful candidate).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeds in two main strands: (A) whether Hakim Soban Ali was disqualified under section 22(1)(g) of the Bengal Municipal Act; and (B) whether the Subordinate Judge had jurisdiction to declare Md. Salim to be duly elected.

(A) Disqualification of Hakim Soban Ali under section 22(1)(g)

  1. Statutory dates and liability for rates: By section 153 of the Bengal Municipal Act, rates are payable in quarterly instalments and each instalment is deemed due on the first day of the quarter. Accordingly, the rates for the first and second quarters of 1954–55 fell due on 1 April 1954 and 1 July 1954 respectively.
  2. Effect of purchase: Under section 166 the purchaser of a holding becomes liable for rates due at the time of purchase. Hakim Soban Ali purchased the holding on 8 June 1954; the opinion notes he therefore became liable for the first-quarter rates (which had fallen due on 1 April) at that date and in any event was plainly liable for the second-quarter rates as from 1 July 1954.
  3. Unpaid rates and the three-month period: The second-quarter rates (due 1 July 1954) remained unpaid until 6 November 1954. Thus, on 26 October 1954 (the date nominations were filed) those rates had been due and unpaid for more than three months.
  4. Role of bill/notice under section 155: The court examined whether non-presentation of a bill or notice of demand under section 155 prevented the rates from being regarded as due for the purpose of disqualification. The court concluded that even if no bill/notice had been presented (and it was satisfied none was), the rates were nevertheless due from 1 July 1954. The absence of bill/notice only affected the municipality's ability to employ the special distress procedure (sections 156–164), not the existence of the liability itself.
  5. Reliance on precedent (Mathuraprasad): The court relied on Mathuraprasad v. The Corporation of Calcutta to support the proposition that service of the bill is not a condition precedent to recovery of rates by suit and that a person under obligation who has not paid is a "defaulter" even if no bill has been presented.
  6. Meaning of "arrears": The court observed that "arrears" is not a technical term of art; because the rates were due and unpaid for more than three months as of the nomination date, Hakim Soban Ali was "in arrears for more than 3 months" within the meaning of section 22(1)(g).
  7. Relevant date for disqualification: The court reiterated authorities (Harford v. Linskey; Satyendra Kumar Das; Sheikh Ahmed Hossain; Parker's Election Agent) that the relevant date for eligibility is the date of nomination. Because Hakim Soban Ali was disqualified on that date, his election was rightly set aside.

(B) Jurisdiction to declare Md. Salim duly elected

  1. Statutory framework: The court reviewed the remedies available in an election petition filed under section 36 of the Bengal Municipal Act and emphasized that the reliefs are specified in sections 38, 39 and 39A.
  2. Limits of sections 38, 39 and 39A: Section 38 empowers the Judge to set aside the election of the candidate whose election is brought in question; section 39 deals with scrutiny and computation of votes; section 39A permits confirmation of an election. The court held that none of these provisions empowered the Judge to declare a defeated candidate to be duly elected in the circumstances of this case.
  3. On the facts: In the present election petition only the election of Hakim Soban Ali had been brought into question; the election of Badri Narayan Bidyarthi was not challenged within the statutory limitation (section 36 requires a petition within ten days of the declaration). Because the petition did not bring in question the election of the other successful candidate, the Judge could not invoke section 38 to set aside that other candidate’s election nor declare the defeated candidate (Md. Salim) to be duly elected.
  4. Treatment of Md. Anisul Islam precedent: The court considered Md. Anisul Islam v. Kali Kumar Mukherjee but distinguished it: that decision proceeded on the footing that the election of the candidate concerned was brought in question under section 36. The court regarded a portion of the headnote in Md. Anisul Islam (to the effect that a successful challenge to one candidate in a plural constituency requires fresh election of the whole constituency) as too widely expressed and in any event not applicable to the present facts.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The court ordered that the portion of the Subordinate Judge's order dated 24 August 1955 which declared Md. Salim to have been duly elected is set aside. The remainder of the Subordinate Judge's order is affirmed. The Rule is disposed of and there will be no order as to costs.

In brief, the court determined:

  • Hakim Soban Ali was disqualified under section 22(1)(g) of the Bengal Municipal Act because municipal rates due for more than three months were unpaid as of the date of nomination; thus the setting aside of his election was correct.
  • The Subordinate Judge acted without jurisdiction in declaring Md. Salim duly elected because the statutory remedies available in an election petition under section 36 (sections 38, 39, 39A) do not authorise declaring a defeated candidate elected when the petition only challenged the election of another candidate.
  • The court affirmed the remainder of the Subordinate Judge's order (i.e., the setting aside of Hakim Soban Ali's election) and set aside only the part declaring Md. Salim elected.
  • There will be no order as to costs; the Rule is disposed of accordingly.

The opinion does not purport to create broader binding precedent beyond its application to the statutory provisions and facts before it; the court explicitly distinguished Md. Anisul Islam and confined its ruling to the statutory limits of reliefs available under the Bengal Municipal Act.

Show all summary ...

1. This is a petition under Article 227 of the Constitution arising out of an election-petition. The dispute relates to the Municipal election of Ward No. 3 of Garulia Municipality. Ward No. 3 is a plural general constituency consisting of two seats. There were three candidates for the election. All the three candidates are opposite parties to the election petition. Badri Narayan Bidyarthi, opposite party no. 2 to the election petition secured 147 votes, Hakim Soban Ali, opposite party No. 1 secured 123 votes, Md. Salim. opposite party No. 8 secured 109 votes. The election of Hakim Soban Ali was challenged in the election petition. The learned Judge has set aside his election.

2. In my opinion Hakim Soban Ali was disqualified u/s 22(1) (g) of the Bengal Municipal Act and as such was not eligible for election and therefore, his election was rightly set aside.

3. Hakim Soban Ali is the owner of holding No. 160 in Ward No. 3 of Garulia Municipality. Municipal rates for the first quarter of 1954-55 of this holding fell due on the 4th April, 1954. On the 8th June, 1954, Hakim Soban Ali purchased this] holding. On his application on the 25th June, 1954 his name was mutated on the 27th June, 1954, and he was informed of the mutation on the 18th July, 1954 The Municipal rates for the holding No. 160 for the 2nd quarter, 1954-55 fell due on the 1st July, 1954. Nomination papers were submitted on or about the 26th October, 1954 which was the last date for filing nomination. The rates were paid by Hakim Soban Ali on the 6th of November, 1954. The election was held on the 5th of December, 1954 and on the same date the result of the election was declared and Badri Narayan and Hakim Soban Ali were declared to have been duly elected.

4. By section 153 of the Bengal Municipal Act, 1932 the rates are payable in quarterly instalments and every such instalment is deemed to be due on the first clay of the quarter in respect of which it is payable. The rates for the first and second quarters of 1954-1955, therefore, fell due respectively on the 1st April, 1954 and the 1st July, 1954 U/s 166 the purchaser of a holding is liable for all rates due in respect of the holding at the time of the purchase. Hakim Soban Ali, therefore, became liable for the rates for the first quarter, 1954-55 for the first time on the 8th of June, 1954. Even ignoring the liability of Hakim Soban Ali in respect of the rates for the first quarter 1954-55 there can he no possible doubt that he was liable for payment of the rates for the second quarter, 1954-55 as from the 1st July, 1954. By section 153 the rates for the 2nd quarter 1954-55 fell due on the 1st July, 1954 and remained unpaid until the 6th of November, 1954. On the 26th of October, 1954 these rates were due and had not been paid for more than 3 months.

5. I am satisfied that no bill nor notice of demand was presented to Hakim Soban Ali as contemplated by section 155 of the Bengal Municipal Act. In my opinion notwithstanding the non-presentation of any bill or notice of demand the rates for the 2nd quarter 1954-55 were due from Hakim Soban Ali on and from the 1st July, 1954. The effect of the non-presentation of the bill and the notice of demand was that the Municipality could not take recourse to the special procedure of levy by distress provided by sections 156 to 164. But section 155 itself shows that the rate is due before the bill and the notice of demand are presented The rate due is a charge on the holding under section 167 of the Bengal Municipal Act and service of the bill and the notice of demand is not condition precedent to the right of the Municipality to recover the amount due for the rate by suit under section 162. See in this connection Mathuraprasad v. The Corporation of Calcutta (1) (48 C.W.N 336) where it was held that inspite of section 189 of the Calcutta Municipal Act 1923 requiring service of the bill, such service was not condition precedent to the right of recovery of the rates by suit under section 204 of the Calcutta Municipal Act 1923 and that the person who was under an obligation to pay and had not paid the rate due was a defaulter within the meaning of that section though no bill had been presented to him.

6. The word “arrears” is not a term of art. The rates being due and not being paid for three months. Hakim Soban Ali must be said to have been on the 26th October, 1954 “in arrears for more than 3 months in payments of any rate or tax” within the meaning of section 22(1)(g) of the Bengal Municipal Act; (see Burrows Words & Phrases and Wharton's Law Lexicon under title “arrears”).

7. Before the learned Judge reliance was placed upon an alleged memorandum No. 1279.M 3P-18/55(13) of the Local Self-Government Department of West Bengal Government which is said to have provided inter alia that “the disability imposed by the aforesaid section, namely 22(1)(g) would arise only if any rate or taxes remained unpaid for more than three months after the expiry of the period of 15days from the date of service of demand notice u/S. 155 of the Bengal Municipal Act, 1932”.

8. Mr Dutt appearing on behalf of the petitioner frankly confessed that he is unable to trace the memorandum. He further admitted that he is unable to contend that the memorandum, if any, was sanctioned by the rule-making power of the State Government conferred by section 505 of the Bengal Municipal Act, 1932.

9. The relevant date for deciding the question of eligibility for election u/s. 22(1) of the Bengal Municipal Act is the date of the nomination and not the date of the actual polling. The nomination is for this purpose an essential part of the election: [see Harford v. Linskey (2) (1899) 1, Q.B, 852]. Parker's Election Agent and Returning Officer, 5th edition, page 52; Satyendra Kumar Das v. The Chairman of the Municipal Commissioners of Dacca (3) (34 C.W.N 972); Sheikh Ahmed Hossain v. Aswini Kumar Paul (4) (57 C.W.N 421). Hakim Soban Ali being disqualified on the date of nomination was not eligible for election.

10. The learned Judge not only set aside the election of Hakim Soban Ali but also declared Md. Salim to have been duly elected. His order in this behalf is as follows: “the opposite parties Nos. 2 & 3 who were the only remaining candidates from this ward No. 3 of the Municipality of Garulia and whose nomination papers were? accepted as valid, there being two seats only for this ward No. 3 and declared to be duly elected Commissioners of the Municipality from this Ward No. 3”.

11. In my opinion, the learned Subordinate Judge had no jurisdiction to declare opposite party No. 3 Md. Salim to have been duly elected.

12. In an election petition filed u/s. 36 of the Bengal Municipal Act, 1932, the reliefs which the court can give are specified in sections 38, 39 and 39A of the Bengal Municipal Act. The impugned order with regard to Md. Salim is not justified by section 38, which empowers the Judge to set aside the election. Section 39-A empowers the Judge to confirm an election. Hakim Soban Ali was not declared to have been elected and there is therefore, no question of confirming his election u/s. 39-A. In my opinion, section 39 also does not empower the Jearned Subordinate Judge to declare Md. Salim as duly elected. Section 39 provides for scrutiny and computation of votes where there is a dispute between two or more candidates as to who has secured the largest number of votes. Section 39 does not empower the Judge to declare a defeated candidate to have been duly elected on the ground that the rival candidate who has won is disqualified and is not eligible for election. In my opinion, therefore, that part of the order which declares Md. Salim to have been elected is without jurisdiction and must be set aside.

13. Mr. Dutt appearing on behalf of Hakim Soban Ali also contended that as Ward No. 3 was a plural constituency the entire election of the Ward including the election of Badrinarayan Bidyarthi should be set aside. I do not accept this contention. Mr. Dutt relied upon Md. Anisul Islam v. Kali Kumar Mukherjee (5) (59 C.W.N 127) and upon the second paragraph of the head note which reads “accordingly in a plural number constituency if the challenge is successfully made to one of the candidates, the result would be that the entire election of the constituency would have to beheld afresh”. In my opinion this part of the head note in (5) 59 C.W.N 127 is too widely expressed.

14. In the election petition in the instant case the prayer was “for setting aside the election of opposite party No. 1 and for declaring the opposite parties 2 and 3 as duly elected, they being he only two candidates and two seats in Ward No. 3 of the Garulia Municipality”. The election of Badrinarayan Bidyarthi is not challenged in the election petition nor is there any prayer for setting aside his election.

15. Under section 36 of the Bengal Municipal Act a petition bringing in question the validity of any election of a commissioner must be made within ten days after the date of the declaration of the result of the election. An election cannot be challenged after the time presented and an election petition presented thereafter is barred by limitation. No election petition having been filed challenging the validity of the election of Badrinarayan Bidyarthi, his election can no longer be challenged.

16. The question in issue in Md. Anisul Islam v. Kali Kumar Mukherjee (5) (59 C.W.N 127) was whether an election may be set aside not merely upon the grounds of corrupt practice or other misconduct on the part of the candidates concerned or his agent but also on the ground of want of fairness of election proceedings for which persons other than the candidate may be responsible. A Division Bench in that case held that the election of a candidate may be set aside although neither he nor his agent is guilty of any corrupt practice or misconduct. On this point 59 CWN 127 must be contrasted with Sheikh Ahmed Hossain v. Aswini Kumar Paul (4) (57 C.W.N 421). In giving the reasons for the decision of the Division Bench in 59 C.W.N 127 Mr. Justice Debabrata Mookerjee observed that the words such candidate “in section 38 of the Bengal Municipal Act, 1932” can have reference only to the Commissioner whose election is brought in question. What is disputed in an application under section 36 of the Act is the validity of the election of a Commissioner and section 38 merely gives power to the Judge to set aside the election on proof of existence of one or the other four grounds enumerated in Clauses (a) to (d) of that section. He further observed “In the view, therefore. I take it must be held that the words ‘such candidate’ refer to a candidate whose election is brought in question under section 36 of the Act”.

17. In this case the validity of the election of Badrinarayan Bidyarthi has not been brought in question under section 36 of the Act Only the election of Hakim Soban Ali having been challenged the election of Badrinarayan Bidyarthi cannot be set aside under section 38 of the Bengal Municipal Act.

18. The present case with regard to Badrinaravan Bidyarthi is clearly distinguishable from the decision in Md. Anisul Islam v. Kali Kumar Mvkherjee (5) (59 C.W.N 127) which was decided on the footing that the election of the candidate concerned was brought in question under section 36 of the Bengal Municipal Act

19. I, therefore, pass the following order:— I set aside the order of the learned Subordinate Judge dated the 24th August, 1955, in so far as that order declares that Md Salim is duly elected a Commissioner of the Municipality. The rest of the order of the learned Subordinate Judge is affirmed.

20. There will be no order as to costs in this Rule.

21. The Rule is disposed of accordingly.