Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Lakshmi Chandra Agarwal v. State Of U.P And Others Opposite Parties.

Allahabad High Court
Oct 14, 1957
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner was appointed Executive Officer of the Municipal Board, Hapur, in December 1931. A new Board was elected in October 1953 and Shri Tara Chand Modi (opposite party no. 3) was elected President. On 7 November (year given as 1956 in the opinion), a vote of no-confidence was passed against him; those proceedings were challenged by Shri Tara Chand Modi by writ petition and this Court stayed operation of the order initially. On 19 February 1957 the Additional District Magistrate, Meerut, wrote that the President should be deemed incapacitated and that the Vice President should look after Board affairs. The Senior Vice President, Shri Abdul Rashid, began functioning but later resigned on 24 March 1957. The State Government, by letter dated 27 April 1957 exercising powers under Sec. 47-A(2) of the Municipalities Act, removed Shri Tara Chand Modi effective 29 April 1957. Shri Tara Chand Modi challenged that removal by writ; he lost earlier challenges to the 7 November resolution in this Court but later proceedings (special appeal) set aside the State Government's removal order on 18 September 1957.

On 4 May 1957 Shri Mahesh Chandra (opposite party no. 4) was elected Vice President by the Board. The petitioner asserts that Sub-sections (2) and (3) of Sec. 54A were not complied with in that election. On 9 June 1957 the petitioner applied for leave effective 10 June 1957, and the Medical Officer of Health was to officiate as Executive Officer. On 11 June 1957 opposite party no. 4 cancelled that order and directed the Head Clerk to officiate. After other administrative directions and disputes, opposite party no. 4 on 18 June 1957 framed charges against the petitioner under Sec. 69-A(1) of the Municipalities Act and suspended him; service of that order occurred on 21 June 1957.

The petitioner filed the present writ petition under Article 226 on 16 July 1957 challenging the suspension order dated 18 June 1957. Notices were issued. The Court records that there were competing proceedings: a writ by Shri Tara Chand Modi challenging his removal (with interim orders from the Supreme Court at various stages) and a separate petition challenging the election/authority of the Vice President.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, in view of the Supreme Court's stay of the State Government's removal order, Shri Tara Chand Modi continued to be President such that the Vice President (opposite party no. 4) had no authority under Sec. 69A to suspend the petitioner.
  2. Whether the resignation of the Senior Vice President (Shri Abdul Rashid) was properly accepted and, relatedly, whether the election of Shri Mahesh Chandra as Vice President complied with the procedure of Sec. 54A (and thus whether the Vice President had authority to act).
  3. Whether the order of suspension passed by the Vice President under Sec. 69-A(1) of the Municipalities Act was illegal and mala fide (i.e., whether the Vice President had jurisdiction to pass that order and whether it was motivated by improper partisan considerations).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Because the Supreme Court had stayed operation of the State Government's removal order, Shri Tara Chand Modi remained the President and the Vice President had no power under Sec. 69A to suspend the petitioner.
  • The resignation of the Senior Vice President (Abdul Rashid) was not properly accepted (only the President could accept it), making the election of Shri Mahesh Chandra defective. Even if Sec. 54A applied, its procedures were not followed.
  • The Vice President had no right to pass an order under Sec. 69A and the suspension order was mala fide; therefore it was illegal and liable to be quashed.
  • After the Special Appeal setting aside the removal order, counsel for the petitioner indicated he would not press the point based solely on that Special Appeal decision in these proceedings.

Opposite Parties' (Respondents') Arguments

  • The effect of Sec. 47A(2) was that on expiry of three days from communication the President became incapacitated to function; that legal consequence would not be affected by the Supreme Court's stay of the operation of the removal order.
  • The petitioner suppressed material facts (an allegation the Court found unproven); specifically, respondents argued the petitioner was wrong to claim Sec. 54A/B had not been followed, and that the petitioner ought not to be granted relief under Article 226 if facts were suppressed.
  • There was an apparent conflict between decisions (this Court's earlier observations and the later Special Appeal), and respondents suggested the matter might appropriately be referred to a larger Bench to resolve whether the President was incapacitated under Sec. 47A(2).
  • Opposite parties contended that the petitioner did not make out mala fides and that no clear facts demonstrated mala fide conduct by the acting Vice President when passing the suspension order.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court limited its decision to questions that could be resolved without deciding the controversial points about (a) the precise effect of the Supreme Court's stay order (i.e., whether it merely stayed the operation of the removal order or restored full status quo) and (b) the detailed legality of the Vice President's election. The judge stated that those questions were doubtful or involved conflict between decisions and therefore chose not to base the decision on them.

The Court then examined the statutory scheme in the Municipalities Act, relying on the text of its provisions as follows:

  • Sec. 50: Certain powers, duties and functions are to be exercised by the President alone—examples include powers to appoint, punish or dismiss servants of the board and determining questions of service, transfer, leave, pay and allowances.
  • Sec. 55(b): A Vice President may, during vacancy or incapacity of the President, perform any duty and, when occasion arises, exercise any other power of the President; Sec. 55 also permits the Vice President to preside at meetings and exercise certain powers when so presiding.
  • Sec. 69A(1): Confers a special power on the President to frame charges against officers (including the Executive Officer) and, if satisfied it is necessary, to suspend an officer pending inquiry, for reasons to be recorded.

Applying these provisions, the Court concluded that Sec. 69A grants a special, emergency power of suspension specifically vested in the President. Although Sec. 55(b) allows the Vice President to perform duties of the President when the President is incapacitated, that provision was interpreted as covering the ordinary duties of the President (not the special emergency power under Sec. 69A). Consequently, the Vice President did not have authority to exercise the President's power to suspend under Sec. 69A.

The Court analyzed the facts and temporal sequence surrounding the suspension: a non-confidence resolution (7 November 1956), ADM communication (19 February 1957), resignation of the Senior Vice President (24 March 1957), State Government removal of the President (27 April 1957), election of Shri Mahesh Chandra as Vice President (4 May 1957), the petitioner's leave application (9 June 1957), and the suspension (18 June 1957). The judge found the timing and context significant.

The Court addressed the allegation of suppression of facts by the petitioner and rejected it: the only specific contention by respondents was that the petitioner wrongly argued Sec. 54A/54B had not been followed, but the Court held that it could not be said the petitioner suppressed material facts so as to disentitle him to relief.

On mala fides, the Court considered the content of the charges and the surrounding circumstances. The suspension was principally predicated on an asserted association between the petitioner and Shri Tara Chand Modi (the President). The Court treated the averments in the respondents' counter-affidavit (paragraph 20) as reflecting that the Vice President's view was that the petitioner had been associated with Shri Modi. The Court concluded that association or party-linkage, even if true, was not by itself a ground to infer misconduct warranting suspension, and that the facts supported an inference that the suspension was motivated by partisan considerations rather than bona fide administrative concern. The Court therefore found the suspension order to be mala fide and without jurisdiction because the Vice President lacked the statutory authority to make such an order under Sec. 69A.

The Court explicitly refrained from deciding the disputed and potentially determinative questions about (i) the legal effect of the Supreme Court's stay on the President's status and (ii) the validity of the Vice President's election, noting that those matters were either doubtful or the subject of separate proceedings.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition was allowed and the Court quashed the suspension order passed by opposite party no. 4 on 18 June 1957.

Implications and direct consequences:

  • The immediate legal effect is that the suspension of the petitioner dated 18 June 1957 was declared void and quashed by the Court.
  • The Court directed that the parties bear their own costs.
  • The Court did not decide or pronounce a general precedent on the contested points concerning the effect of a Supreme Court stay on statutory consequences under Sec. 47A(2) or on the precise validity of the Vice President's election; those broader, potentially precedent-setting questions were left undecided or were the subject of separate proceedings.

No broader doctrinal rule beyond the application of the Municipalities Act to the facts before the Court was declared as a binding new precedent in this opinion.

Show all summary ...

Mehrotra, J.:— The petitioner was appointed Executive Officer, Municipal Board, Hapur, in December 1931. In October 1953 the new Board was elected and Shri Tara Chand Modi, opposite party no. 3, was elected President of the Board. On 7th November a vote of no confidence was passed against him. Under the orders of this Court the operation of the order was stayed as the proceedings of the meeting were challenged by means of a writ petition by Shri Tara Chand Modi. On 19th February, 1957 a letter was sent by the Additional District Magistrate, Meerut, to the petitioner that the President should be deemed to be incapaciated from functioning as a President and under Sec. 47A of the Municipalities Act the Vice President should look after the affairs of the Board. The Senior vice President, Shri Abdul Rashid started functioning though Shri Tara Chand Modi, opposite party no. 3, continued to assert his right to function as the President of the Board. On the 24th March, 1957 Shri Abdul Rashid, the Senior Vice President resigned from his office. The State Government by letter dated 27th April, 1957 in the exercise of its powers under Sec. 47-A(2) of the Municipalities Act removed Shri Tara Chand Modi from the office of the President of the Municipal Board with effect from 29th April, 1957. On the 3rd May, 1957 Shri Tara Chand Modi filed a writ petition challenging the validity of the order of the State Government removing him from the office of the President. It should also be pointed out that the petition filed by Shri Tara Chand Modi challenging the validity of the resolution of the 7th November, 1956 was ultimately dismissed by this Court and the order of Hon'ble Single Judge was confirmed in Special Appeal by a Bench. The prayer for the interim relief in the second writ petition filed by Shri Tara Chand Modi challenging the order of the removal by the State Government was rejected on the 8th May, 1957. On the 4th May, 1957 Shri Mahesh Chandra, Opposite party no. 4, was, however, elected Vice President by the Board by a Special resolution and according to the petitioner, provisions of Sub-secs. (2) and (3) of Sec. 54A were not complied with in the election of Shri Mahesh Chandra. On the 24th May, 1957 an application was made by Shri Tara Chand Modi for special leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against the order of this Court refusing interim relief to him. On the 3rd June, 1957 the application for interim relief in the application for special leave was heard and operation of the removal order of the State Government dated the 27th April, 1957 was stayed. After the stay order had been granted by the Supreme Court Shri Tara Chand Modi asserted his right to function as president of the Board. On the 9th June, 57 the petitioner applied for a week's leave with effect from 10th June, 1957 which was granted. The Medical Officer of Health was asked to officiate as Executive Officer during his absence. On the 11th June Shri Mahesh Chandra, however, cancelled the order regarding the Medical Officer of Health to Officiate in the absence of the petitioner and directed the Head Clerk of the Board, Shri Rameshwar Prasad Goel who, according to the petitioner, was related to the opposite party no. 4, to officiate the absence of the petitioner. On a representation made by the Health Officer the District Magistrate directed the Vice Chairman to remove the Head clerk and entrust the work of the Executive Officer to some other responsible officer. Thereupon opposite party no. 4 asked the Tax Superintendent, suspended by Shri Tara Chand Modi, to officiate in place of the petitioner. On the 18th June, 1957 the petitioner applied for a week's leave on the ground of health and on the same date opposite party no. 4 passed an order framing charges against the petitioner under Sec. 69-A(1) of the Municipalities Act and placing him under suspension. The said order was served on the petitioner on 21st June, 1957. On the 19th June, 1957 the telephonic connection sanctioned by the Board at the official residence of the petitioner was disconnected under the orders of opposite party no. 4. The petitioner was threatened to vacate the official residence forthwith. On 22nd June, 1957 the District Magistrate sent a letter to the opposite party no. 4 asking him to place the matter of suspension of the petitioner before the Board and further holding that the order of suspension of the petitioner was without jurisdiction. The petitioner thereupon assumed his duties and started functioning as Executive Officer of the Board. On the 28th June, 1957 opposite party no. 4 passed an order appointing opposite party no. 5 Shri Brij Basi Lal as Executive Officer of the Board with effect from the same date. On the 1st July, 1957 the petition for special leave to appeal by Shri Tara Chand Modi came up for hearing before the Supreme Court and by the agreement of the parties the interim stay order was directed to be continued till the disposal of the writ petition which was pending in this Court. On 2nd July, 1957 the petitioner thereafter sent a letter to the opposite party no. 4 explaining his position and praying for time till 4th August, 1957 for furnishing his explanation. On the 4th July opposite party no. 3, Shri Tara Chand Modi passed an order reinstating the petitioner from the date of his suspension with full pay and allowances holding him not guilty and quite innocent and by the same order the services of opposite party no. 5 were dispensed with. On the 10th July, 1957 opposite party no. 4 sent a telegram to the petitioner intimating that the State Government had upheld his order suspending the petitioner and directing him to hand over the official files etc. to the officiating Executive Officer. On the 11th July, 1957 a telegraphic reply was sent by the petitioner to the opposite party no. 4. On 12th July, 1957 the petitioner received a copy of the letter dated 4th July, 1957 sent by the Secretary to the State Government addressed, to the Commissioner, Meerut Division, stating therein that the State Government did not propose to interfere with the order of suspension passed by the acting President. On these facts the present petition: was filed in this Court on the 16th July, 1957 under Art. 226 of the Constitution challenging the order of suspension of the petitioner passed by opposite party no. 4 on the 18th June, 1957. It was also pointed out in the affidavit filed in support of the petition that the function of the opposite party no. 4 as Vice President has also been challenged by means of another writ petition filed by a member of the Board. After filing of this petition notice was issued. The writ petition filed by Sri Tara Chand Modi challenging the order of the State Government removing him from the presidentship of the Board was rejected by me. In special Appeal, however, the order of the State Government dated the 27th April, 1957 removing him from the presidentship has been set aside by the order of the Court dated the 18th September, 1957.

2. Three points were raised by the petitioner in support of the present petition. Firstly, it was urged by him that as by the order of the Supreme Court the operation of the order of his removal was stayed Shri Tara Chand Modi continued to be the president of the Board and the opposite party no. 4 had no power to suspend the petitioner under Sec. 69-A of the Municipalities Act. Secondly, it was contended by him that the resignation which was tendered by the Senior Vice President Sri Abdul Rashid on the 24th March, 1957 was not properly accepted inasmuch as the Presiden alone had a right to accept that resignation. Consequently, the election of Sri Mahesh Prasad as Vice President was itself defective. Even if it be accepted under Sec. 54A of the Municipalities Act Senior Vice Chairman could be elected the procedure provided under that section was not followed. It was contended that the order passed by opposite party no. 4 suspending the petitioner was illegal inasmuch as the Vice President had no right to pass an order under Sec. 69A of the Act and that the order was mala fide. It has also been urged by the petitioner that in view of the decision of this Court in the Special Appeal by which the order of the removal of Shri Tara Chand Modi has been set aside on the date when the order was passed by opposite party no. 4 Shri Tara Chand Modi was the President and the Opposite party no. 4 had no power to pass the order under Sec. 69-A of the Municipalities Act. It is neither necessary nor proper for me to decide the validity of the election of opposite party no. 4 as a Senior Vice President in this petition. The election of opposite party no. 9 has been challenged by means of a separate petition and the proper proceedings in which the question of the validity of the election of me opposite party no. 4 can be examined the said writ petition filed by the member. Moreover, at any rate, he was doubtful as to how far Shri Tara Chand Modi was competent to function as the Chairman at the time when the resignation by Shri Abdul Rashid was tendered. In this view of the matter and as I am deciding the petition on other points raised by the petition it is not necessary to deal with this matter any further, and examine the validity of the election of opposite party no. 4 as the Vice Chairman. As regards the question raised by the petitioner that Shri Tara Chand Modi in view of the stay order passed by the Supreme Court was functioning as the Chairman on the date when the order was passed by opposite party no. 4 it is not necessary to base my decision on that question. There is some controversy between the parties as to what was the actual order of stay passed by the Supreme Court; whether the effect of the Supreme Court order was to maintain the status quo or the only effect of the order was that the operation of the order of the removal was stayed. The contention raised by the opposite party is that under Sec. 47A, sub-sec. (2) on the expiry of three days from the date of communication the President was in-capaciated to function. That legal consequence which followed from the failure of the president to resign within a certain period will not be affected by the stay order passed by the Supreme Court staying the operation of the removal order passed by the State Government under Sec. 47A(2). The question is a very doubtful one. As there is a controversy between the parties with regard to the actual order of stay passed by the Supreme Court, I would therefore not base my opinion on this controversial question.

3. As regards the point now raised by the petitioner that in view of the order passed in the Special Appeal setting aside the removal order passed by the State Government, it was urged by the counsel for the petition that he would not in the circumstances of the present case press that point. The objection with regard to this contention raised by the opposite parties was that the judgment in the Special Appeal related to the order of removal passed by the State Government; it left undecided the question as to whether under Sec. 47A(2) the Chairman was incapaciated to function or not. If the reasoning on which the Bench has held that the order of removal was illegal is accepted it may follow that the president was not incapaciated to function but if the observations made by the Bench in the earlier writ petition filed by Shri Tara Chand Modi are accepted as correct law it can be held that the president was incapaciated to function. In this view of the matter there appears to be a conflict between these two decisions and opposite parties contended that the proper course for me is to refer the matter to a larger Bench. Realising this position the learned counsel for the petition has contended that he does not want to base his present petition on that ground alone. I do not therefore decide this question.

4. Coming to the main point urged by the petitioner it is necessary to refer to the provisions of the Municipalities Act. Sec. 50 of the Act provides:

“Following powers, duties and functions of a board may be exercised, and shall be performed or discharged, by the President of the Board and not otherwise, namely—

(a) the powers vested in the President by Secs. 70 and 74 and the provision to Secs. 75 and 76 to appoint, punish or dismiss servants of the board;

(b) the determination, in accordance with any regulation in this behalf, of questions arising in respect of the service, transfer, leave, pay, privileges and allowances of servants of the board.”

5. Sec. 55 provides:—

“A Vice President shall, in the absence of the President from a meeting of the board and unless prevented by reasonable cause, preside, regulate the conduct of business, and maintain and enforce order, at the meeting and when so presiding may exercise the powers specified in Sec. 91.

(b) shall during the vacancy in the office on President or the incapacity or temporary absence of the President, perform any other duty and, when occasion arises, exercise any other power of the President.

(c) shall at any time perform any duty and exercise, when occasion arises, any power delegated to him by the President under Sec. 53.”

6. Sec. 69A reads as follows:—

“If the president has reasons to believe that the executive officer or the secretary or any of the other officers of the board appointed under Sec. 68, is corrupt or has persistently failed in the discharge of his duties or is otherwise guilty of misconduct, be may frame charges against him and where he is satisfied that it is so necessary, he may for reasons to be recorded, suspend him pending the completion of the enquiry.”

7. The special power of suspension has been given to the President under Sec. 69A pending an enquiry into the charges framed against the executive officer and the contention of the petition is that this order could only be passed by the President and not by the Vice-President when acting in absence of the President. Sec. 55(b) no doubt gives power to the Vice President to perform any duty of the President when he is incapaciated but that to my mind only gives him power to perform the duties of the President given in Sec. 50 and 51 of the Municipalities Act. It does not give him a right to pass on order which the President alone can do under Sec. 69A. As I have said it is power in the nature of emergency power conferred upon the President and that cannot be regarded as one of the normal duties cast upon the President nor can it be said to be an exercise of the power contemplated under Sec. 55(b). Even if it is accepted that the result of the passing of the non-confidence resolution was that the President was incapaciated within the meaning of Sec. 55 in view of the provisions of Sec. 47(2) in my opinion the Vice President had no power to pass an order under Sec. 69A suspending the petitioner pending enquiry into charges framed against him and the order passed therefore was without jurisdiction. It was contended by the opposite party that the petitioner has suppressed certain facts which disentitles him to a relief under Art. 226 of the Constitution. I do not think that there has been any material suppression of facts by the petitioner. The only ground urged by the opposite party is that the petitioner has wrongly stated that the procedure under Sec. 54A was not gone into in this case although it was not a case of Sec. 54A at all. As has been urged by the counsel for the petitioner it may be that in the opinion of this Court Sec. 54B may not apply but it cannot be said that the petitioner was not entitled to urge that Sec. 54B did apply and if it did the procedure under Sec. 54B was not followed: it cannot be said that there was any suppression of material facts by the petitioner so as to disentitle him to a relief. It was then urged by the petitioner that the order under the circumstances of the case is a mala fide order and should be set aside by this Court. It is significant to note that the Vice-President himself was elected on the 4th May, 1957. The resolution of non-confidence was passed on 7th November, 1956. On the 19th February, 1957 the Additional District Magistrate asked the President to cease to function. The Senior Vice President Shri Abdul Rashid started functioning thereafter and on the 24th March, 1957 he tenders his resignation and on the 27th April, 1957 the order of removal of the President is passed by the State Government and on the 4th May, 1957 Shri Mahesh Chandra is elected as a Vice President. On the 9th June, 1957 the petitioner applied for a weeks' leave with effect from the 10th June and before his leave could expire on 18th June, 1957 the opposite party no. 4 passed an order suspending the petitioner. The circumstances in which this order was passed by the opposite party no. 4 legitimately leads to the inference that the order was not a bona fide. There is a controversy going on as to who was entitled to function as the President. The President had further challenged the orders passed by the State Government in this Court. In these circumstances it cannot be said that the Vice-President had any occasion to watch the work of the petitioner. Moreover, from the charges it is also clear that the main ground on which the petitioner was suspended was that he was in league with the President Sri Tara Chand Modi. It is unfortunate that the dispute between the President and other members of the Board and the party friction should recoil on its employees. It affects the efficient working of the Board if the party politics results in the dismissal or appointment of the employees. But the charges themselves clearly prove that the action has been taken not on the ground that the Vice President had occasion to independently apply his mind to the conduct of the petitioner but because he belonged to the party of the president against whom no-confidence resolution had been passed at the instance of the opposite party no. 4 and other members of the Board. It is also clear from the averments in the counter affidavit contained in paragraph 20 that the Vice President acted under Sec. 69A as in his opinion the present petitioner was associated with Sri Tara Chand Modi. Paragraph 20 of the counter affidavit reads as follows:—

“That contents of paragraph 31 of the affidavit under reply are denied. In fact Sri Agarwal had associated himself with Sri Modi and had created great havoc in the municipal Board in conspiracy with Sri Modi. His fear was that now Sri Modi is turned out, all his doings will be exposed and his fear has come true. In fact Sri Agarwal is unnecessarily and without authority trying to harass the Municipal Board itself in the interest of Sri Modi and himself instead of obeying the orders passed by the acting President.”

8. Even if the fact is admitted that Sri Agarwal associated with Shri Modi in the past that by itself can be no ground for assuming that he was not acting in the interest of the Board and that assertion by itself indicates that the order passed by the acting President was not bona-fide. It was strenuously contended by the opposite party that no facts have been set out in clear terms which make out a case of mala fide. The facts have been set out by the petitioner in his affidavit. He has also attacked the order on the ground of mala fide. The question is one of inference to be drawn from certain set of facts given in the affidavit and it is open to this court to examine the facts which have been set out by the parties in their respective affidavits and come to its own conclusion. In view of the circumstances pointed out by me and with regard to which there is no controversy legitimate inference can be drawn that the order passed by the acting President was not bona fide. In the result, therefore, I allow this petition, quash the order of suspension passed by opposite party no. 4 on the 18th June, 1957. In the circumstances of the case I direct the parties to bear their own costs.

9. Petition allowed.