- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sehhadat Khan v. The State .
Case Summary — Excerpted Opinion concerning Sehhadat Khan (Bail Application)
Factual and Procedural Background
On 31-1-63 at about 7:30 A.M., the petitioner, Sehhadat Khan, was arrested at Agartala Airport by the Sub‑Inspector (S.I.) of the Security Unit on suspicion that he was a foreigner without passport or visa. A search revealed Rs. 1,431 in cash and four gold tabijes (weighing approximately seven tolas and odd) on his person, plus various other items (wearing apparel, fountain pen, knife, plane ticket and papers). The petitioner gave differing addresses and identified different persons as the owners of the gold ornaments, which led the Police Officer to suspect the articles might be stolen; the articles were therefore seized.
The petitioner was produced before the O.C., Kotwali Police Station and was re-arrested there under Section 54 Cr.P.C. He was produced before the S.D.M., Agartala on 1-2-63; the Police sought remand for investigation. The Magistrate remanded the petitioner and refused bail, directing the Police to submit a report by 6-2-63. The Police did not file that report; the Magistrate extended remand to 15-2-63. On 15-2-63 the petitioner applied to the Sessions Court for bail; the Sessions Judge dismissed the bail application on 16-2-63, stating that proper investigation into the petitioner's nationality and the circumstances was necessary. The petitioner then moved the High Court seeking bail.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the continued remand and detention of the petitioner beyond the initial period was lawful when the Police failed to submit the report ordered by the Magistrate and had not collected evidence to raise a suspicion of an offence.
- Whether a Magistrate may remand an accused beyond the 15‑day limit in Section 167 Cr.P.C. without taking cognizance under Section 190 Cr.P.C., or otherwise without satisfying the requirements for remand under Section 344 Cr.P.C.
- Whether, in the circumstances (lack of investigation and absence of evidence), the petitioner should be released on bail.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Contentions
- It was submitted (for the petitioner) that an order of remand under Section 344 Cr.P.C. can be made only after the Magistrate has taken cognizance under Section 190 Cr.P.C.; therefore, where no cognizance had been taken, the Magistrate could not detain the petitioner beyond 15-2-63 (the expiry of the Section 167 period).
- A related contention (relied upon before the Court) invoked a decision of the Orissa High Court (Artatran Mahasuara v. State of Orissa, AIR 1956 Orissa 129) in support of the proposition that remand under Section 344 requires prior cognizance under Section 190.
State / Government Advocate's Position
- The Government Advocate stated that letters had been written to the Karimganj Police (because the petitioner had given an address in Karimganj) and that reminders had been sent, but that no reply had been received so far.
- No further evidence had been collected or produced to satisfy the Court that there was evidence raising a suspicion that the petitioner had committed an offence (this was admitted).
Sessions Judge's Observations (as recorded in the opinion)
- The Sessions Judge refused bail and remarked that the Police should be able to complete investigation regarding the petitioner's citizenship at an early date and should do so expeditiously so that the petitioner would not be detained unnecessarily if there was no case against him.
- The High Court notes that the Sessions Judge did not appreciate that there was no question of the petitioner having entered India from abroad without a passport — the petitioner had travelled from Calcutta to Agartala by plane on the day of arrest.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Artatran Mahasuara v. State of Orissa, AIR 1956 Orissa 129 | Relied upon for the proposition (as advanced by the petitioner) that remand under Section 344 Cr.P.C. can be made only after the Magistrate has taken cognizance under Section 190 Cr.P.C. | The decision was relied upon in argument. The Court observed that it was not necessary to decide the point finally in this case; instead the Court explained the principle that remand under Section 344 requires sufficient evidence to raise a suspicion that the accused may have committed an offence and that further evidence may be obtained by remand. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the statutory framework and the factual record and proceeded step‑by‑step:
- Statutory safeguards and magistrates' duty: The Court emphasised that Section 167 Cr.P.C. permits magistrates to authorise detention for investigation only when there are grounds for believing the accusation or information is well‑founded, and that magistrates must not remand arrested persons as a matter of routine. Magistrates should ensure remand is genuinely necessary and should rely on the diary/entries sent by the Police.
- Sequence of suspicion and arrest: The Court noted that in this case the S.I.'s suspicion that the petitioner was connected with a cognizable offence arose only after the arrest and after seizure of the ornaments (i.e., suspicion arose post‑search). This made the case one where particular watchfulness was required because Section 54 empowers arrest without warrant on suspicion.
- First remand vs. subsequent remands: The Court accepted that the initial remand (on 1‑2‑63) may not be seriously objectionable, but the Magistrate expressly directed the Police to file a report by 6‑2‑63 because he was not satisfied that a longer remand was necessary. When the Police disobeyed that direction and failed to submit the report or explain the failure, there was no justification for further remand beyond the date ordered. The further order of detention passed on 6‑2‑63 was therefore held to be clearly wrong.
- Sessions Court treatment: The Court criticised the Sessions Judge for treating the question as one requiring further inquiry into nationality when the record showed the petitioner had arrived from Calcutta that same morning; the detention related to suspicion arising from the seized ornaments, not to illegal entry from abroad.
- Obligation on Police to investigate promptly: The Court underscored the duty under Section 173 Cr.P.C. to carry out prompt investigation and collect evidence to satisfy the Court that there is sufficient evidence to raise a suspicion of an offence. The Court observed that money and ornaments in a passenger's possession are not uncommon and, by themselves, do not necessarily ground a suspicion of an offence. Verification of the petitioner's Karimganj address would have been comparatively easy, but the Police had only corresponded with Karimganj and received no reply; no further evidence had been collected.
- Legal limit on remand and criteria for remand under Section 344: The Court noted that the 15‑day limit under Section 167 Cr.P.C. expired on 15‑2‑63. Any further detention would have to be under Section 344 Cr.P.C., which (the Court explained) can be invoked only if sufficient evidence has been obtained to raise a suspicion that the accused may have committed an offence and it appears likely that further evidence may be obtained by remand. Because the Police failed to submit the report called for by the Magistrate and had not collected evidence, the Court treated that as an indication that the Police had not obtained sufficient evidence to justify a remand.
- Practical consideration and condemnation of slack investigation: The Court deplored the apparent slackness of the local Police in not making reasonable efforts (for example, personal enquiries to Karimganj by air or train) and emphasised that such indifferent investigation, coupled with disobedience of court directions, could not justify continued deprivation of liberty.
- Exercise of discretionary remedy: On this basis — lack of evidence, failure to obey the magistrate's direction, and expired Section 167 period — the Court exercised its supervisory jurisdiction under Section 498 Cr.P.C. to prevent further remand and to grant bail.
- Return of seized articles: The Court held that the question of return of the seized articles (including cash and gold tabijes) is for the Magistrate to deal with under Section 523 Cr.P.C. and that the High Court could not order return at the investigative stage. The Court warned that if the Police continued to disobey the magistrate's directions, the magistrate would have to deliver the property to the person entitled under Section 523.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
PETITION ALLOWED. The Court ordered that the petitioner be released on his personal bond for Rs. 2,000/‑ supported by two sureties, each for a like amount, to the satisfaction of the S.D.M., Sadar.
Immediate consequences and practical effects:
- The petitioner was to be released on bail on the specified bond and surety terms.
- The Police were criticised for failing to comply with the Magistrate's direction to file a report; the Court found no sufficient evidence had been collected to justify further remand after expiry of the Section 167 period.
- The question of return of the seized property was left to the Magistrate under Section 523 Cr.P.C.; the High Court did not direct immediate return while investigation remained pending, but warned that continued non‑compliance by the Police would oblige the Magistrate to deliver property to the person entitled.
Broader implications: The Court emphasised magistrates' duty to prevent routine remands and to ensure that remand is justified by evidence. However, the opinion did not purport to lay down a novel binding precedent beyond application of the statutory provisions cited (Sections 54, 167, 173, 190, 344, 498 and 523 Cr.P.C.) and the principles articulated; the decision here affects the parties directly by granting bail and directing the Magistrate's attention to the proper procedure for handling seized property and Police compliance.
End of summary — prepared exclusively from the text of the provided opinion.
1. The petitioner Sehhadat Khan was arrested on 31-1-63 at about 7-30 A.M by the S.I of Police of the Security Unit at the Agartala Airport suspecting him to be a foreigner without a Passport and Visa. Then he was searched and Rupees 1,431 in cash and 4 gold Tabijes weighing 7 tolas and odd were found on his person. He appears to have given different addresses and also mentioned different persons as the owners of the gold ornaments. Thus as the Police Officer found that the petitioner could not give a satisfactory account of the articles and suspected them to be stolen, he seized the articles. There were also various other articles like wearing apparel, fountain pen, knife, plane ticket and other papers as seen to the seizure list. The petitioner was produced with the seized articles before the O/C Kotwali Police station with a report that the petitioner was detected as a stranger and was strongly suspected to be connected with a cognizable offence. At the Police station, he was re-arrested by the S.I under Sec. 54 Criminal Procedure Code. He was produced before the S.D.M, Agartala on 1-2-63 and the Police prayed for his remand pending investigation. A bail application was moved for him. But the magistrate remanded him to custody and disallowed bail as the matter was under investigation and asked for a report from the Police by 6-2-63. On 6-2-63, bail was again moved for the petitioner and it was found that the Police toad not submitted any report as directed by the magistrate. The Police were then asked to submit the report by 15-2-63 and the petitioner was further remanded till then. Then he moved the Sessions Court on 15-2-63 for bail. The learned Sessions Judge, however, dismissed the bail application on 16-2-1863 and in doing so stated that there should be a proper investigation regarding the question of the nationality of the petitioner, who had made contradictory statements to evoke suspicion as regards not only his nationality but also his possession of the gold Tabijes and hence, the prayer for bail cannot be considered at that stage. Hence, the petitioner has come up to this Court for bail.
2. It may be mentioned that on 15-2-63 the Police did not file the report called for by the magistrate and still the magistrate has further remanded the petitioner to jail custody and even till this date the Police have not filed the report before the Magistrate. To my question to the learned Government Advocate whether any evidence has been collected so far to raise a suspicion that the petitioner may have committed an offence, he replied that as the petitioner mentioned that he belonged to Karimganj in Assam, letters have been written to the Police at Karimganj for information but that no reply has been received so far from Karimganj in spite of reminders. Thus the petitioner who was arrested under Sec. 54 Cr. P.C on suspicion continues in jail custody, even though no attempt has been made by the Police so far to the course of investigation to secure any evidence against him excepting writing letters to the Karimganj Police.
3. I am afraid that the learned Magistrate has not acted in accordance with the provisions of Secs. 167 and 344 Cr. P.C in ordering the remand of the petitioner. Section 167 provides that where there are grounds for believing that the accusation or information against an arrested person is Well-founded, the Police officer concerned shall forward the accused to the nearest Magistrate along with a copy of the entries in the diary relating to the case and the magistrate may authorise the detention of the accused in such custody as he thinks fit for a term not exceeding 15 days on the whole. But this does not permit the magistrate merely as a matter of routine to remand the arrested person to custody. Such routine remands; must be deprecated. I have seen such routine remands in many instances and I have given directions to the magistrates to satisfy themselves that a remand is really necessary before they commit the arrested person to jail custody. It is to satisfy themselves on this matter that a copy of the entries relating to the case is sent to the Magistrate. Particularly in the case of a person arrested on mere suspicion under Sec. 54, Cr. P.C, the magistrate has to be watchful, as the power to arrest without warrant on suspicion under Sec. 54 Cr. P.C is liable to be abused. In the present case, the suspicion of the S.I (who arrested) that the petitioner was concerned in a cognisable offence arose after the arrest and after the seizure of the gold ornaments from his person. This is clear from his report to the O.C perhaps that was why there was a second arrest under Sec. 54 in the Police station.
4. However, there may not be any serious objection to the first remand on 1-2-63. But the Magistrate directed the Police to submit a report by 6-2-63 evidently as he was not satisfied regarding the necessity for a long remand. When the Police disobeyed the direction of the magistrate and did not submit any report and did not give any reasons for their failure to submit the report, there, was no reason for further remand, and the Magistrate should never have made an order for the further detention of the arrested person. The further order of detention passed on 6-2-63 was, therefore, clearly wrong. It is such orders by a Magistrate that make the Police disregard the directions of the Court and make them feel that they can take their own time for investigation.
5. When again, on 15-2-63, no report was filed by the Police to satisfy the Magistrate that further remand was necessary, the Magistrate should not have ordered the further detention of the petitioner. It was brought to the notice of the Sessions Judge that even on 15-2-63 no report was filed. But still the learned Sessions Judge refused to grant bail and merely remarked that it is not difficult Page: 141for the Police to complete investigation with regard to the citizenship of the petitioner at an early date and that they should complete the investigation expeditiously so that the petitioner may not be detained in custody unnecessarily if there was no case against him. The learned Sessions Judge failed to see that no question of citizenship was involved and that the petitioner was not arrested on the ground that he was a Pakistan national and had entered India without a Passport. It is clear from the documents seized from the petitioner that he was in possession of an Air Ticket from Calcutta to Agartala for travel on 31-1-63 and that he had lust reached Agartala by Plane that morning when he was arrested. It is also seen that he had made purchase of cloth at Calcutta on 30-1-63. Thus he was not at the time of arrest seen entering India from outside without a Passport, but had travelled from Calcutta to Agartala. His arrest was made at the Police station on suspicion of his having been concerned in a cognizable offence connected with the ornaments seized from him.
6. When a person is thus arrested on suspicion, it is the duty of the Police to carry out prompt investigation without unnecessary delay as provided finder Sec. 173 Cr. P.C and collect evidence to satisfy the Court that there is sufficient evidence to raise a suspicion that the arrested man may have committed an offence. After all, cash and ornaments are not uncommon things to be seen in a passenger who has come by plane and the possession of the same by itself need no cause suspicion of the commission of an offence. The arrested man had given his address at Karimganj and it was easy for the Police to verify his statements.
7. Under Sec. 167 Cr. P.C no magistrate has got the power to order the detention of an accused in custody for a term exceeding 15 days in the whole. This period expired on 15-2-63. Thus on the date when the bail petition was moved before the Sessions Judge, there could be no further detention under Sec. 167 Cr. P.C Any further order of remand, to custody can be made by a Magistrate only under Sec. 344 Cr. P.C It was pointed out for the petitioner that an order of remand can be made under Sec. 344 Cr. P.C only after the Magistrate had taken cognizance of the offence under Sec. 190 Cr. P.C and that, in this case where no such cognizance had been taken, the Magistrate cannot detain the petitioner beyond 15-2-63. The decision of the Orissa High Court, Artatran Mahasuara v. State of Orissa, AIR 1956 Orissa 129 was also relied upon in that connection.
8. It is not however, necessary to decide this question finally at present. It is enough to say that any further remand under Sec. 344 Cr. P.C jean be made only if sufficient evidence has been obtained to raise a suspicion that the accused may have committed an offence and that it appears likely that further evidence may be obtained by, a remand. Thus in order to remand an accused under Sec. 344 Cr. P.C the Magistrate must satisfy himself that sufficient evidence has been obtained to raise a suspicion that the accused may have committed an offence. In this case, the Police who were called upon to submit a report on that matter failed to obey the direction of the magistrate and did not submit any report to show that suffcient evidence was obtained to raise a suspicion that the accused may have committed an offence. We have, therefore, to take it that the Police have not been able to obtain sufficient evidence. In fact, the learned Government Advocate admitted that no further evidence has been collected till now. Thus without any evidence being collected and without any attempt being made to collect such, evidence, the petitioner has simply been kept in jail on suspicion of his having been concerned in a cognizable offence.
9. As pointed out by the Sessions Judge, Karimganj is not far away and it would not have been difficult for the Police to complete the investigation by this time. If a Police officer wanted to collect information from Karimganj, he could reach Karimganj by Air and Train within a few houri from Agartala. Instead of that the local Police have been merely corresponding with the Karimganj Police and it was admitted that so far no reply has been received from the Karimganj Police. Such slack investigation in spite of the order of the magistrate to submit Police report by 6-2-63 has to be deprecated. No arrested person should be allowed to not in jail when the Police have such little regard for the liberty of the citizen and when they disobey the orders of the Court so flagrantly without giving any proper explanation why there has been practically no investigation in this case between 31-1-63 and this date. This is a fit case where this Court should interfere under Sec. 498 Cr. P.C and direct that the petitioner should not be remanded any further to custody and that he should be granted bail. It is accordingly ordered that the petitioner will be released on his personal bond for Rs. 2000/- supported by two sureties each for a like amount to the satisfaction of the S.D.M, Sadar. The petitioner has made a request for the return of the articles including the cash all in Indian currency and the gold Tabijes seized from him. That is a matter to be dealt with by the Magistrate under Sec. 523 Cr. P.C It goes without saying that if the Police continue to disobey the direction of the magistrate and fail to submit report to him, the magistrate will have to deliver the property to the person entitled to the possession thereof, under Sec. 523. At this stage, when the matter is still under investigation, this Court cannot direct the return of the seized articles to the petitioner.
EG/V.B.B
10. Petition allowed.
Alert