- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Lakshmipati Hazra & Ors. v. Rajendra Nath Pyne.
Structured Summary of the Legal Opinion (P.N. Mookerjee, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
These seven appeals were filed by tenants against decrees in seven ejectment suits relating to six shop rooms and one wall-shop at Premises No. 11, Nirmal Chandra Street (formerly Wellington Street), Calcutta. The landlord had initiated the suits in September 1961 after serving the usual notice of ejectment. Alongside these seven suits there was an eighth suit (not appealed) relating to residential rooms at the same premises, which was decreed on grounds of default in payment of rent and reasonable requirement.
In the seven suits that generated the present appeals, the landlord's pleaded grounds included default in payment of rent and reasonable requirement for building and re-building; however, the landlord pressed only the ground of reasonable requirement in these seven suits. The trial court decreed these suits on the ground of the landlord's reasonable requirement, granting tenants two months to vacate. The tenants appealed.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the landlord had established a bona fide and reasonable requirement of the disputed premises for the purpose of building and re-building within the meaning of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1956 (specifically the relevant part of Section 13(1)).
- Whether the condition of the disputed front portion of the building was such that it was "beyond repairs" in the sense that it would be uneconomic and imprudent to undertake repairs (i.e., whether demolition and rebuilding was justified).
- Whether the landlord had established (a) municipal sanction for rebuilding and (b) sufficient funds to carry out the rebuilding, supporting the bona fides of the claimed reasonable requirement.
- What relief and timetable (if any) should be ordered, taking into account the condition of the building and prevailing accommodation needs in the city.
Arguments of the Parties
Landlord's Arguments
- The landlord pleaded, among other grounds, default in rent and reasonable requirement for building and re-building; in these seven suits he relied on the ground of reasonable requirement.
- The landlord's specific case was that the front portion of Premises No. 11 (abutting Nirmal Chandra Street) was extremely old and dilapidated, insecure, beyond repairs and that repairing it would be uneconomic and serve no useful purpose.
- The landlord produced expert evidence: two engineers inspected the premises, one being a former City Architect who produced an exhibited report; the other (T.K. Ghose) supported that report. Their evidence described the building as over 100 years old with the front portion extremely dilapidated and liable to fall.
- The landlord obtained a commissioner’s inspection and report (appointed by the court), which substantially supported the plaintiff's experts. The landlord also obtained sanction from the Corporation of Calcutta for raising a new structure (demolition being a condition for rebuilding) and established that he had sufficient funds for the task.
Tenant Defendants' Arguments
- The tenants contended that, although some repairs were necessary, the building was not in such condition as to require pulling down; major repairs had already been made by the plaintiff and the disputed premises were not in dangerous or dilapidated condition.
- The tenants objected to the experts' report and to the examination of experts who had inspected the premises ex parte; they took objections to the commissioner's report, alleged issues concerning the commissioner, and sought further inspection by the court.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Neta Ram v. Jiwal Lal, A.I.R. 1963 S.C. 499 | Tests laid down by the Supreme Court under a sister statute for proving a landlord's reasonable requirement of premises for building and re-building. | The court held that the facts of these cases sufficiently met the tests in Neta Ram for establishing reasonable requirement and accordingly satisfied the requisites under the relevant part of Section 13(1) of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1956. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court reviewed the evidence, including the plaintiff's expert reports and the commissioner's inspection report, and considered the objections and criticisms raised by the defendants. The court's reasoning proceeded in the following steps, as expressly stated in the opinion:
- Evidence appraisal: The court noted that the plaintiff produced two engineers' evidence (one with an exhibited report and the other corroborating it) and that the judge-appointed Pleader-commissioner submitted a report substantially supporting those expert opinions.
- Credibility and sufficiency: Although the court accepted that the plaintiff's extreme contention (that the building required immediate pulling down) might not be fully supported, it found sufficient materials to conclude that the front portion was "beyond repairs" in the relevant legal sense — meaning that it would be uneconomic and unreasonable for a prudent man to expend money on repairs.
- Relevant factual findings relied upon: the building was admitted to be over 100 years old; construction materials (thin bricks and mud mortar) had lost most of their utility; the rear portion had already been pulled down and rebuilt, and the northern wall of the front portion had received some benefit from that reconstruction. Taken together, these facts supported the conclusion that substantial repair was not appropriate.
- Bona fide intention to rebuild: The court accepted the trial judge's finding that the plaintiff had a bona fide desire to rebuild because the plaintiff had secured municipal sanction (which made demolition a condition for reconstruction) and had shown the requisite means to carry out the work.
- Legal standard and precedent: Applying the tests from Neta Ram v. Jiwal Lal (a Supreme Court decision under a sister statute), the court concluded that the case met the criteria for establishing reasonable requirement for rebuilding under the relevant part of Section 13(1) of the local Act.
- Relief tailoring: Recognising that the evidence did not fully support the plaintiff's more extreme claims and having regard to the acute accommodation shortage in the city, the court modified the relief by allowing extended time and conditional grace periods for the tenants, subject to undertakings and specified conditions of rent deposit and arrears payment. The court established a regime under which failure to comply (including default in two monthly deposits or failure to clear arrears by the specified date) would cause the grace period to lapse and the decrees to become executable immediately.
- Procedural propriety: The court considered the defendants' allegations against the Commissioner and found the defendants had not justified the course they took; if they were serious, they should have taken proper legal steps in time, and the court could not hold that their attempts satisfied the requisite test on the record.
Holding and Implications
APPEALS DISMISSED. The court upheld the decrees of the trial judge dismissing the tenants' defences and decreeing ejectment on the ground of the landlord's reasonable requirement for building and re-building, subject to the conditional and time-limited relief described below.
Direct consequences for the parties
- The trial court decrees in favour of the landlord are affirmed.
- The defendants (tenants) were given a conditional grace period in recognition of the accommodation shortage: initially till the end of December 1964, with a longer conditional extension until the end of June 1965 if the defendants file an undertaking in this Court by 30th November agreeing to vacate by June 1965.
- Conditions for availing the grace period include: monthly deposits of rent to the credit of the landlord in the trial court (month by month, deposited by the 15th of the next succeeding month according to the English calendar). Default in any two such deposits will cause the grace period (longer or shorter) to lapse and the decrees to become executable immediately.
- Tenants must also pay arrears, if any, within December; default on that obligation has similar consequences.
- Any amounts deposited under these provisions are withdrawable by the plaintiff (landlord).
- The defendants are given liberty to apply for further extension on satisfying the court as to the then condition of the premises and the necessity for such extension; the landlord has liberty to ask for modification of the time provisions if immediate demolition becomes necessary due to the building's condition.
- There is no order as to costs in this Court or the court below.
Broader legal implication
The court applied the Supreme Court's tests (Neta Ram v. Jiwal Lal) under a sister statute to the local Act's Section 13(1) requirements and found them satisfied on the particular facts. The opinion does not announce a new principle of law beyond applying that precedent and the statutory test to the established facts; the decision's significance is its application of established tests to find a landlord's reasonable requirement for rebuilding where the structure was over 100 years old and repair would be uneconomic.
Additional Observations Recorded by the Court
- The court emphasised that it was not satisfied with the defendants' approach in making allegations against the court-appointed Commissioner and noted that such allegations, if genuine, should have been pursued by appropriate legal steps in time.
- Concurring opinion: A.C. Sen, J. agreed with P.N. Mookerjee, J.
This summary is drawn exclusively from the provided opinion and does not introduce information not present in the source text.
P.N Mookerjee, J.:— These seven appeals are by the tenants. They arise out of as many ejectment suits in respect of six shop rooms and one Wall-shop at Premises No. 11, Nirmal Chandra Street, formerly Wellington Street, Calcutta. The suits were brought in September, 1961 after service of the usual notice of ejectment in each case. Along with these seven suits, there was another suit against another tenant in respect of certain residential rooms, occupied in the same Premises.
1. In all the suits, the landlord's grounds for ejectment under the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1956, included default in payment of rent on the part of the defendants tenants and also the landlord's reasonable requirement of the disputed premises for building and re-building. The eighth suit, relating to the residential rooms, in which the tenant was one Sati Bhusan Sen Gupta, was decreed on both the above grounds and the tenant concerned has not preferred any appeal. The remaining seven suits, out of which the present appeals arise, were decreed only on the ground of the landlord's reasonable requirement of the disputed premises for building and re-building, the ground of default in the payment of rent not having been pressed in these cases by the landlord plaintiff. On the question of the above requirement, the landlord's specific case was that the shops or shop rooms in question were situate in the front portion of the above Municipal Premises No. 11 Nirmal Chunder Street, abutting on the said street, and the said front portion was extremely old and dilapidated, so that it was insecure and it would be unsafe to allow the said portion to stand. It was his further specific case that the said front portion was beyond repairs and it would be uneconomic and imprudent to effect any repairs in the said front portion and such repairs, if made, would serve no useful purpose.
2. The suits were resisted by the tenant defendants and their contention was that, although the building might be old, it was not in such a condition as to require its being pulled down for the purpose of building and re-building. Their specific case was that certain repairs were undoubtedly necessary but major repairs had already been made by the plaintiff and the disputed premises were not in any dangerous or dilapidated condition.
3. In support of his case, the plaintiff examined two experts, engineers, who, at his instance, inspected the disputed premises and one of whom, who was a former City Architect of the Corporation of Calcutta, had submitted a report, which was exhibited in the instant suits. The other engineer Mr. T.K Ghose was also a qualified engineer in the panel of this Court, and, although he did not submit any report, he supported the report of the other engineer, according to which the building in question was over 100 years old and the disputed front portion was in an extremely dilapidated condition and might fall down at any moment.
4. Objections having been taken by the defendants, in the course of the suits, to the above report and the examination of the above experts, who inspected the premises ex parte, the court appointed a qualified Pleader commissioner for inspection and report on the condition of the disputed building. The Commissioner submitted his report, which substantially supported the evidence and the report of the other experts, examined by the plaintiff.
5. To the Commissioner's report, certain objections were taken by the defendants and, at one stage, an inspection was prayed for by the court itself and certain allegations were also made against the said Commissioner. The court took also these into consideration, but, eventually, came to the conclusion that the plaintiff had sufficiently made out a case of reasonably requiring the disputed premises for building and rebuilding, he having sufficiently established that the age of the building in question was over 100 years and it was in a dilapidated condition and he having further proved that he had already obtained sanction from the Corporation of Calcutta for raising a new structure according to the sanctioned plan at an estimate of roughly Rs. 50,000/- and had the necessary means to undertake the said task. In this view, the learned trial Judge passed a decree in favour of the plaintiff in each of the instant suits, granting the tenants concerned two months' time for vacating the disputed premises.
6. The appeals have been argued in great detail and we have been taken through the evidence in all its relevant particulars by the learned Counsel and Advocates, appearing on the two sides. The reports of the experts, including the Commissioner, have been scrutinised carefully and their evidence also has been subjected to criticism by the appellants. On a review however, of the entire position, we are satisfied that, although the extreme contention, raised by the plaintiff, that the building is in such a dilapidated condition that it requires to be pulled down at once may not be supported by the materials on record, it is clear that it is beyond repairs in the sense that it would be uneconomic and unreasonable on the part of any prudent man to spend money on its repairs. It is to be observed in this connection that this building has its rear part on the C.I.T Road on the north; the said rear part has already been pulled down and a new construction has been raised in its place and the northern wall of the front portion, also, has, in the course of such re-construction, obtained some benefit of recent repairs. It is abundantly clear, however, from the evidence before us that the condition of the front portion is such that no prudent man should be called upon to spend any money on it for repairs. The building is, admittedly, over 100 years old and this is not and cannot be disputed by the defendants. The thin bricks, which were used for its construction, and the mud mortar, which was used used for the purpose, have, after this long existence, retained only a small part of their usefulness and in that state of things, it would not be proper to compel the plaintiff to spend money for effecting repairs on this front portion for the purpose of keeping up the same.
7. We are also satisfied that the learned trial Judge is right in his finding that the plaintiff has the bona fide desire to rebuild and he has established the same by getting the necessary sanction from the Corporation of Calcutta, under which demolition of the existing structure is a condition for the rebuilding, and also by establishing that he has sufficient funds for the purpose.
8. In our view, on the above findings, the case would sufficiently come inter-alia within the tests laid down by the Supreme Court under a sister statute in the case of (1) Neta Ram v. Jiwal Lal, A.I.R 1963 S.C 499, for proving the plaintiff's reasonable requirement of the disputed premises for building and re-building purpose and would satisfy all the requisites under the relevant part of Sec. 13(1) of our local Act.
9. We would, accordingly, uphold the decision of the learned trial Judge and the decrees under appeal, subject to this that, as, in our view, on the materials before us, the building is not in such a dilapidated condition as was sought to be made out by the plaintiff, we would give the defendants time, having, particularly, in mind the prevailing acute condition in the matter of accommodation in this city, in the first instance, till the end of December 1964, with liberty to the defendants to file an undertaking, in their respective cases, in this Court, within the 30th of November next, to quit and vacate the disputed premises in their respective possession and make over vacant and peaceful possession thereof to the plaintiff landlord within June 1965 and, if such undertaking is filed, the above grace period, in the particular case or cases concerned, will be extended till the end of June, 1965; provided that, in either case, the defendant or the defendants concerned go on depositing, in the trial court, to the credit of the landlord decree-holder, sums equivalent to their respective rentals, month by month, regularly, according to the English calendar, within the 15th of the next succeeding month according to the same calendar, and, in default in the matter of any two of such deposits, the above provision for time, be it the longer or the shorter one, would automatically lapse and these decrees for eviction, so far as the particular case or cases are concerned, would become executable at once. The defendants will also put in the arrears, if any, within December next and, in case of any default in this respect also, similar consequences will follow. If any amount is deposited in pursuance of this order, or, if any amount is in de posit on any of the above accounts, the plaintiff will be entitled to withdraw the same.
10. We would, also, in the circumstances of these cases and having regard to the materials before us, give further liberty to the defendants to apply for further extension of the above extended period on satisfying the court as to the then condition of the disputed premises and of the necessity of such extension, and to the plaintiff, too, to ask for modification of the above provision for time, in case any necessity is felt for immediate demolition of the disputed building on account of its condition.
11. Subject to the above conditions, including the liberties aforesaid, these appeals fail and they are dismissed.
12. There will be no order as to costs either in this Court or in the court below.
13. We need only add that we are not satisfied that, in the matter of making allegations against the Commissioner, the defendants were justified in taking recourse to the course, adopted by them. If they were really serious in that matter and, if there was any real justification for their allegations, they ought to have taken proper steps in accordance with law in proper time. We are unable to hold that the attempts on the part of the defendants in this direction satisfy the requisite test on the materials before us.
A.C Sen, J.:— I agree.
P.N.C
Alert