- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Public Prosecutor v. Satyanarayana And Another
Facts:
The respondents were accused of selling three bottles that were alleged to contain honey, specifically labeled as "honeyrex." The prosecution argued that the sale of these bottles constituted a violation of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act. However, the respondents contended that they did not sell the bottles as honey but rather as honeyrex, a different product.
Issue:
Did the respondents commit an offense under the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act by selling honeyrex instead of honey, and is the order of acquittal by the learned Magistrate justified?
Holding:
The Supreme Court upheld the acquittal of the respondents, confirming that they did not commit an offense under the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act.
Reasoning:
The Supreme Court referenced a precedent that establishes that a vendor of food articles is not liable under the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act if they can demonstrate that the food article was purchased with a written warranty from a manufacturer, distributor, or dealer. In this case, the evidence presented by the defense witness (D.W. I) and the documentation provided (invoice Ex. D-1 and bill Ex. D-2) indicated that the respondents sold the honeyrex in the same condition as received from the manufacturer.
Given these facts, the learned Magistrate's order of acquittal was not found to be erroneous. The court confirmed that the respondents acted within the legal framework provided by the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act, as they were able to prove the legitimacy of their product through proper documentation.
Conclusion:
The appeal against the order of acquittal was dismissed, and the decision of the learned Magistrate was affirmed, thus reinforcing the legal protection afforded to vendors who comply with the statutory requirements of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act.
Disposition:
Appeal dismissed; order of acquittal confirmed.
Madhusudan Rao, J.:— This appeal by the State is directed against an order of acquittal passed by the learned 2nd Addl. District Munsif Magistrate, Kovvur in C.C 109/73 on the file of his Court. The two respondents are the two accused in the case. The 1st accused-1st respondent is the owner and proprietor of a general store shop at Nidadavole. The second respondent second accused is a salesrran in the shop.
2. The case of the prosecution is:
3. The Food Inspector, Nidadavole Municipality (P.W 1) visited the shop of the respondents on 17-11-72 at about 9.45 a.m and purchased from the 2nd respondent 3 bottles of 1 one rex for sampling purposes. The purchase was made in the presence of the Sanitary Maistry (P.W 2) and a mediator (P.W 3). After complying with the necessary forrralities of sampling, the Food Inspector sent one bottle of honeyrex to the Public Analyst for analysis. The Public Analyst reported under Ex. P. 7 that the honey in the sample bottle is adulterated.
4. The plea of the respondents was that they did not sell honey but sold honeyres supplied to them by Bell & Co. which gave a warranty and the warranty was printed on every bill given to a purchaser.
5. In so far as the respondents did not sell the three bottles to P.W 1 as honey but sold them only honeyrex, the learned Magistrate acquitted the respondents.
6. In this appeal, the learned Addl. Public Prosecutor contends that even if the respondents are not to be convicted for an offence of selling adulterated honey they have to be convicted for violating Rule 45 of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Rules. Rule 45 provides that:
“No person shall use the word “honey” or any word, mark, illustration, or device that suggests honey on the label, or any package of, or in any advertisement fcr, any food that resembles honey but is not pure honey.”
7. Fri Padmanabha Reddy the learned counsel appearing fcr the respondents states that by selling the product as honeyrex the respondents are not suggesting that the prcduct contains any honey and that they have not wilfully violated Rule 45. He further says that honeyrex is marketed as a balanced food product and that it is not considered by any of the customers as a food ccntaining honey.
8. He brings to the notice of the Court letter No. 4165/70 dated 13-8-70 of the Government Analyst, Institute of Preventive Medicine, Andhra Pradesh, whereunder the Analyst has advised withdrawal of the prosecution against a vendor of honeyrex stating in the letter that honeyrex is a balanced food product and that the same should not be treated as honey under the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act.
9. In a recent case, the Supreme Court has held that a vendor of food articles shall not be deemed to have committed any offence under the provi sions of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act if he proves that the article of food sold by him was purchased by him from any manufacturer, distribu tor or dealer with a written warranty in the prescribed from. The evidence of D.W I and the recitals in the invoice Ex. D-1 and the bill Ex. D-2 show that the respondents were selling the bottles of the honeyrex in the very con dition in which they were supplied to them by the manufacturers.
10. Under the circumstances the order of acquittal passed by the learned Magistrate cannot be said to be erroneous. The order is therefore confirmed and the appeal is dismissed.
11. Appeal dismissed.
Alert