- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Surajpal Singh v. State Of U.P And Others
1. This writ petition has been filed against an appellate order passed by the Second Civil Judge, Aligarh in an appeal arising out of an order of the Prescribed Authority under the U.P Imposition of Ceiling on Land Holdings Act determining certain lands possessed by the petitioner as surplus.
2. In this writ petition only one question has been argued before me. It has been submitted that plot No. 235 has been treated as irrigated land both by the Prescribed Authority as also the appellate Authority. It is submitted that these two authorities have committed a manifest error of law in holding that the aforesaid plot is irrigated land. According to the petitioner the plot was unirrigated. The Appellate Authority found that the petitioner's son Rameshwar Dayal who appeared as a witness before the Prescribed Authority had admitted that there was a tube-well in plot No. 235 belonging to the petitioner and so it is established that there is a source of irrigation on the plot. According to Rameshwar Dayal, there is a tila in the plot measuring about thirty kacha bighas and water does not reach a further sixty kacha bighas of the plot. In this way about 90 Kacha bighas is not capable of irrigation. The Appellate Authority dealt with the objection of the petitioner in the following words:
“The area of plot No. 235 is 49 bighas 12 biswas. In 1378 Fasli the appellant had sown kharif crop in 37 bighas and Rabi crop in 30 bighas 13 biswas. In 1379 Fasli the appellant had sown kharif crop in 25 bighas 14 biswas area and Rabi crop in 42 bighas 15 biswas. In 1380 Fasli the appellant had sown Kharif crop in 35 Bighas 9 Biswas area. From a perusal of the extract khasras it is clear that the appellant had sown crop in 42 bighas 15 biswas area of this plot. The contention of the appellant that there is no facility of irrigation for 90 Kuchha bighas area of plot No. 235 does not appear to be correct. The land of plot No. 235 is capable of growing 2 crops in an agricultural year and the appellant has an assured source of irrigation. The learned Prescribed Authority, therefore correctly held the entire area of plot No. 235 to be irrigated.”
3. The learned Standing Counsel appearing on behalf of the State submitted that the order of the Appellate Authority can be justified in view of the provisions of S. 4-A, thirdly. He points out that there is a private irrigation work situate in plot No. 235 itself. He further submits that it has been found that two crops were grown on the land. He further points out that for purposes of Explanation I to clause thirdly defines “effective command area” as one covered in the manner prescribed, from either a lift irrigation work, canal or State tube-well, or a private irrigation work. The principal difficulty in accepting this argument is that no finding has been recorded either by the Prescribed Authority or by the Appellate Authority that the class and composition of the soil is such as it is capable of growing at least two crops in an agricultural year. Before Cl. (3) can be applied, both the conditions (a) and (b) prescribed therein have to be satisfied. In this case in the absence of a finding that Cl. (b) of S. 4-A thirdly has been complied with, the order cannot be sustained. The order, if it is assumed to be one under S. 4-A, thirdly of the Act, cannot be sustained and will have to be quashed.
4. Alternatively, the learned Standing Counsel argued that the case would be covered by S. 4-A, firstly, as plot No. 235 contains a tube-well which is a private irrigation work as mentioned in S. 4-A, thirdly. However, before this clause can be applied, it must be found that two crops were grown over the land in any of the years 1378F, 1379F and 1380F.
5. The Appellate Authority has mentioned the entires in the khasras which mention the crops grown both in kharif and rabi seasons during the three years. Before a whole plot can be described as irrigated, within the meaning of S. 4-A, firstly, it has to be found that the entire land had been under a crop in each of the two seasons kharif and rabi in any of the three years, 1378, 1379 and 1380F. It is not enough that a portion of the land was cultivated in one crop. The expression “at least two crops were grown on such land in any one of the aforesaid years”, by its very force requires that crops should have been grown over the whole period of the relevant year. In this case the finding shows that the entire area was not covered with a crop in both rabi and kharif in any of the years 1378F, 1379F and 1380F.
6. The maximum land that can be declared as surplus under this clause would be that much area which was sown both with kharif and rabi crops in any of these years. Only that land can be treated as irrigated land.
7. The learned standing counsel has also urged that the finding recorded by the Appellate Authority that the entire area of plot No. 235 is irrigated land is a finding based on a consideration of relevant evidence and is binding on me under Art. 226 of the Constitution. I cannot accept this argument.
8. As I have already found, the Appellate Authority has completely misdirected itself in law in determining the whole area of plot No. 235 as irrigated land.
9. It must be emphasised once again that merely because a portion of a plot is irrigated, even in two crops, the whole of it cannot be declared as irrigated land, unless the whole of it was cultivated in both the crops.
10. In the result, the writ petition is allowed; the impugned order of the Appellate Authority, in so far as it has determined the entire area of plot No. 235 as irrigated, is quashed. The Appellate Authority will again determine whether, and if so, which portion of plot No. 235 is irrigated, in accordance with law and in the light of the observations made in this judgment. The Appellate Authority is further directed to ascertain whether the State proposes to apply S. 4-A, firstly or S. 4-A, thirdly in this case. The petitioner is entitled to his costs.
11. Petition allowed.
Alert