Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Jai Singh v. State

Allahabad High Court
Mar 23, 1979
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The applicant was convicted under Sections 7(i) and 7(iii) read with Section 16 of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act for selling adulterated milk. He was initially sentenced to six months' rigorous imprisonment (R.I.) and fined Rs. 1000 on each count. The conviction was upheld on appeal, but the sentence was reduced to three months' R.I. and a fine of Rs. 500 on each count, with the substantive imprisonment sentences to run concurrently. Failure to pay the fine would result in two months' additional R.I. The applicant filed this revision against the reduced sentence.

The prosecution case was that the applicant was carrying three cans of milk for sale when a sample was taken by the Food Inspector according to prescribed legal procedures. The sample was analyzed by the Public Analyst and found deficient in fat and non-fatty solids by about 8% each. After obtaining sanction for prosecution from the District Medical Officer of Health, the applicant was prosecuted and convicted.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the sanction for prosecution granted by the District Medical Officer of Health was valid and involved proper application of mind.
  2. Whether the sample of milk was properly packed and sealed in accordance with Rule 16 of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Rules prior to its analysis.
  3. Whether non-compliance with Rule 9(j) concerning sending a copy of the Public Analyst’s report to the accused was mandatory and prejudicial to the applicant.
  4. Whether the sentence imposed on the applicant was appropriate given the facts and circumstances of the case.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • The sanction for prosecution was legally defective as the sanctioning authority did not apply his mind to the facts and merely appended his signature on a typed order.
  • The sample was not packed and sealed in accordance with the directions in Rule 16(a)(b)(c) of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Rules, allowing scope for tampering by the Food Inspector.
  • The sealing of the sample was not done properly as found by the Sessions Judge, raising doubts about the integrity of the sample sent for analysis.
  • The Food Inspector failed to send a copy of the Public Analyst’s report to the accused by registered post as required under Rule 9(j), which was argued to be mandatory.
  • The applicant is a poor milk vendor, the deficiency in fat and solids was minor (8%), he had already undergone about one month’s imprisonment, was fined Rs. 1000, and is not a previous convict, warranting reduction of sentence to the period already undergone.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the sanction order (Ex. Ka. 5) and found that the District Medical Officer of Health had considered the Food Inspector’s report and the papers before granting sanction, concluding that the sanction was valid and not mechanical despite being a typed document with only the signature appended.

Regarding the packing and sealing of the sample, the court held that Rule 16 of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Rules is directory rather than mandatory. The law provided safeguards by requiring the sample to be divided into three parts and giving one to the accused. The accused had the right to have his sample tested at the Central Food Laboratory if he suspected tampering but did not avail this right. Therefore, even if the Sessions Judge’s finding of improper sealing was accepted, it would not affect the merits of the case.

The court further noted that under Rule 17 and Rule 18, the sample was sent in a sealed packet with a memorandum and a specimen impression of the seal was separately sent to the Public Analyst. The Public Analyst’s report confirmed that the seal on the sample matched the specimen impression, negating any suspicion of tampering after dispatch.

On the non-compliance with Rule 9(j), the court reiterated that this rule was held to be directory and not mandatory by prior judicial pronouncements. The applicant failed to show any prejudice caused by the non-compliance. Moreover, since 1977, Rule 9(j) has been deleted. The applicant could have sent his sample for independent analysis if he doubted the sample’s condition, but the Public Analyst’s report indicated the sample was fit for analysis.

Lastly, considering the applicant’s status as a poor milk vendor, the minor deficiency in fat content, the fact that he was not a previous convict, and that he had already undergone about a month’s imprisonment, the court found it appropriate to reduce the sentence of imprisonment to the period already served while maintaining the fine imposed.

Holding and Implications

The court upheld the conviction of the applicant under Sections 7(i) and 7(iii) read with Section 16 of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act.

The sentence of imprisonment was reduced to the period already undergone by the applicant on each count. The fine of Rs. 500 on each count was maintained, payable within three months. In case of default, the applicant would undergo two months' rigorous imprisonment on each count.

This decision directly affected the parties by modifying the sentence but did not establish any new legal precedent.

Show all summary ...

1. The applicant has been convicted under S. 7(i) and S. 7(iii) read with Section 16 of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act and sentenced to 6 months' R.I and a fine Rs. 1000/- on each count. His conviction has been maintained in appeal but the sentence of imprisonment imposed upon him has been reduced to 3 months' R.I and fine to Rs. 500/- on each count. In default of payment of fine, he is to undergo 2 months' R.I, both the substantive sentences of imprisonment to run concurrently, hence this revision.

2. I have heard learned counsel for the applicant and have also perused the impugned orders. According to the prosecution case, the applicant was carrying three cans of milk on his cycle for sale near village Bhojpur when its sample was purchased by the Food Inspector in accordance with the procedure prescribed by law. The milk was kept in three dry clean bottles after adding the necessary preservative. One of these sample-bottles was sent for analysis. The report of the Public Analyst disclosed that the sample was deficient in fat contents as also in non-fatty solids by about 8 per cent each. After obtaining the sanction for prosecution, the applicant has been prosecuted and convicted as above.

3. Counsel for the applicant has argued that the sanction for prosecution is legally defective. The sanctioning Authority has not applied his mind to the facts of the case. I have perused the order, granting sanction (Ex. Ka. 5). The sanction has been granted by the District Medical Officer of Health, Saharanpur. It is mentioned in the said order that the papers along with the Food Inspector's report have been seen by the Sanctioning Authority. After considering the same, he has permitted the prosecution to be instituted against the applicant. I find no reason to disbelieve the contents of Ex. Ka. 5.

4. Learned counsel for the applicant has said that since the order granting sanction is a typed document, and the Sanctioning Authority has merely appended his signature thereon, it should be taken that the Medical Officer of Health has not applied his mind before granting sanction. I do not agree with this submission. No particular form of sanction has been prescribed. It is not an unusual feature for a senior officer to dictate an order and for the clerk to type out and to place it before him for his signature. This appears to have been done in the instant case. I am satisfied that the sanction granted by the Medical Officer of Health, Saharanpur was a valid sanction in accordance with law and not a mechanical one.

5. Learned counsel for the applicant has then brought to my notice R. 16(a)(b)(c) framed under the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act, prior to its amendment in 1977. On its basis, he has urged that the sample taken from the applicant was not packed and sealed in accordance with the directions given in these rules. He has argued that after the sample bottle had been securely fastened, it was to be wrapped completely with a fairly strong thick paper. Thereafter, it was to be further secured by strong twine or thread and sealed at least at four distinct places. One of the seals was to be on the top of the packet, one at the bottom and two others on the body of the packet. The knots of twine were to be covered by sealing wax bearing the impression of the seal of the sender.

6. Learned counsel for the applicant has also brought to my notice the findings of the Sessions Judge to show that the sealing of the sample was not done in accordance with these directions. He has thus argued that there was ample scope for the Food Inspector to tamper with the sample bottle before sending it for analysis to the Public Analyst.

7. Rule 16 of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Rules is merely directory. It lays down the method by which the sample is to be packed and sealed. There can be no doubt that these directions are meant to be carried out by the Food Inspector while taking sample, but law also provides ample safeguards to the citizens, in case the directions regarding the packing and sealing of the samples are not strictly followed and a suspicion is raised in the mind of the accused that the sample bottle had been tampered with by the Food Inspector. Under the law, as it existed then, the sample was to be divided into 3 parts and then separately bottled, packed and sealed. One of these sample bottles was given to the accused. This was obviously for his protection. He had a right to get the sample tested by having it sent to the Director, Central Food Laboratory, Calcutta, in case he had the slightest doubt that the specimen sample in the possession of the Food Inspector had been tampered and was not the correct specimen, which has been purchased from him on the date of the incident. In this view of the matter, I am of the opinion that even if the finding of the Sessions Judge is accepted that the sample phial was not properly sealed, that would not have any effect upon the merits of the case. The applicant did not care to have his sample phial sent for analysis to the Director, Central Food Laboratory, Calcutta, and as such it does not lie in his mouth to speculate that, the phial sent by the Food Inspector had been tampered with and changed, prior to its dispatch.

8. Under Rule 17, the container of the sample was to be sent to the Public Analyst by registered post or railway parcel in a sealed packet, enclosed together with a memorandum in Form (7) in an outer cover addressed to the Public Analyst. Under R. 18, a copy of the memorandum and a specimen impression of the seal, used for sealing the packet, should be sent to the Public Analyst separately by registered post or delivered to him in person. In the instant case, the report of the Public Analyst discloses that the seal affixed on the container of the sample tallied with the specimen impression of the seal separately sent by the Food Inspector. Therefore, it would be reasonable to infer that the sample which was sent by the Food Inspector for analysis to the Public Analyst was not in any way tampered with by him. The apprehension of the accused-Applicant on this score is merely conjectural and imaginative.

9. Another argument addressed by the applicant's counsel is that R. 9(j) is mandatory under which it was incumbent duty of the Food Inspector to send by registered post, a copy of the report of the Public Analyst to the accused.

10. It has already been held by our court a number of times that R. 9(j) is merely directory and not mandatory. The applicant has failed to show that any prejudice has been caused to him, as a result of the non-compliance of Rule 9(j). It may be pertinent to remember that since 1977 R. 9(j) has been completely deleted. In any case, even prior to this, it was open to the applicant to have sent his sample for analysis, if, he doubted that the contents of the sample sent by the Food Inspector to the Public Analyst had deteriorated due to lapse of time. The report of the Public Analyst in the instant case, however, indicated that the sample was in a fit condition for analysis. In these circumstances, I do not find any justification for interfering with the impugned order on this ground.

11. Lastly the applicant's counsel has argued that Jai Singh is a poor milk-vendor selling milk as a petty hawker. It has also been argued that the deficiency in the fat contents or in the non-fatty solids was very small viz. 8 per cent. It has further been submitted that the applicant has been in jail for about a month already. It has also been pointed out that the applicant has been fined a total sum of Rs. 1000/- on both counts, for which he has been found guilty. It has also been strenuously urged that the applicant is not a previous convict. In these circumstances, the submission is that the sentence of imprisonment may be reduced to the period already undergone. I am inclined to agree with this submission.

12. Since the incident in question had taken place prior to the amending Act 34 of 1976, the accused can be given the benefit of these circumstances and a lenient view would be permissible.

13. While, therefore, upholding the conviction of the applicant for the offence under S. 7(i) and S. 7(iii) read with Sec. 16 of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act, I hereby reduce the sentence of imprisonment imposed upon him on each count to the period already undergone. The sentence of fine of Rs. 500/- on each of the two counts is however maintained. The fine shall be paid within 3 months from today with the trial court. In the event of default, the applicant shall suffer two months' R.L on each count

14. Order accordingly.