Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

T.R Krishnan () v. State Of Kerala And Others (S).

Kerala High Court
Dec 18, 1979

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

Gopalan Nambiyar, C.J:— Those appeals are from the common judgment of a learned Judge In O.P No. 2139 of 1977 and O.P 3514 of 1977; W.A No. 162 being by the petitioner in the earlier O.P in whose favor a qualified relief had been granted by the learned Judge and W.A No. 197 of 1979 being by the State. W.A 201 of 1970 Is by the State against O.P 3514 of 1977. The case disclosed represents one of the freaks of service integration after the re-organization of States which continues to cause heartburn and suffering to some of the employees in this State.

2. The appellant in W??? No. 162 of 1979 was a provisional appointee under rule 10(a)(i) of the Madras State and Subordinate Services Rules appointed by Ext. P. 1 Order dated 25-9-1956 In the State of Madras-a date perilously near to the re-organization of States on 1-1-1956, Ext. P. 1 order was by the Chief Engineer, P.W.D Hopeful, Madras and directed the Superintending Engineer to issue posting orders The appellant was posted as Supervisor, which was the designation for Junior Engineer This was in accordance with Ext. P. 2 notification inviting applications for the post of Supervisors. 495 appointments were to be made by direct recruitment 25% of the appointments for the post of Supervisors was reserved to be filled by candidates possessing the Upper subordinate of L.C.B Diploma of the College of Engineering, Gu???ndy. One of the conditions for appointment was stated thus:—

“A person appointed on or after the 15th March, 1953 by direct recruitment to a service, class or category thereof in a department or office, the re-organisation of which has not been ordered by Government before 23rd August, 1955, shall not be regarded as a probationer in such service, class or category or be entitled by reason only of such appointment to any preferential claim to future appointment to such service, class or category.”

3. The petitioner is a diploma holder He has alleged in paragraph 2 of the petition that the practice in Madras State was to select Supervisors (Junior Engineers) under Rule 10(a)(1) of the Madras State and Subordinate Services Rules (corresponding practically to Rule 9(a)(i) the K.S.S??? and to regularise such appointments through the Public Service Commission Such regularisation used to be done within one or two years; and only direct appointments of Supervisors was within the purview of the Commission Posts lower to that of Supervisors such as Overseers, Draftsman, etc. were outside the purview of the Public Serves Commision. For such posts the regularization was done by the Superintending Engineers and Chief Engineer. After the petitioner's allotment to the Kerala State he repeatedly requested that steps for regularization of his service as Junior Engineer from the date of his appointment be talon. Ext. P. 3 dated 27-3-1958 is a copy of his representation to the Chief Engineer. P.W.D, Trivandrum and Ext P 4 is a copy of the representation dated 2???-10-1960 to the Chairman of the Committee for integration of the Public Works Department. This letter referred to G.O No. 339 dated 2-3-1939, according to which those who have put in six months of continuous service prior to 1-11-1956 art only eligible for regularizations in the same post. As the petitioner was not entitled to regularizations under the said G.O as he did not have requisite six months continuous service, he requested that his case may be favorably considered and regularizations recommended. Ext. P. 4 stated that as the Kerala Public Service Commission selects diploma holders only at Overseers, it would be an injustice to ask the petitioner to apply and get selected for a tower post, than what he was holding, after four years of continuous service in the higher post.

4. There appears to have been seven officers In the same predicament as the petitioner Bit. P. 3 is a copy of the representation of the Kerala Engineers' Association in respect of the petitioner and others similarly recruited. These elicited Ext. P. 4 order from the Government dated 2-3-1959. It was ordered that ??? like the petitioner recruited under the emergency provisions If the ???s rules would ha eligible for regularization two ??? (1) that they satisfy the age and educational qualification at the time of their first appointment and (2) that they should have been selected for the post after a due process of selection. A list of such persons was shown In the annexure the Ext. P 6 and was to be sent to the Public Service Commission not later than 1-6-1939 The Commission was to attest their suitability for regularized appointment. Tested selected by the Commission were to be regularly appointed to the post with effect from the date if continuous service In that post. They were to take rank below these, if any, who lave already been regularly appointed before the coming into force of the Kerala State and Subordinate Service Rules, the list directed to be prepared by the Commission together with the recommendations of the Commission were to reach the Government not later than 1-6-1959. By Ext. P7 memo of the Chief Engineer (General and Irrigation), Trivandrum to the Superintending Engineer, dated 28-6-1961, it was informed that the petitioner and seven others are not eligible for regularization at Supervisors. It was stated that their cases could not be distinguished from those of persons was may not be eligible for regularization under Ext. P6 G.O (Toe Superintending Engineers were therefore requested to direct at once that those Junior Engineers got themselves regularly selected at the Fearless by the Public Service Commission as Draftsman First Grade as and when vacancies are advertised. Two things may here itself be noted in connection with the above GO First, that it marked a departure from Ext. P6 G.O and second, that it directed the petitioner and others to apply for, and go themselves selected to, a lower post than what they were actually holding. It was not a pleasant prospect for the petitioner and the others concerned, having gone forward to for with their temporary appointment, to travel, so to say. In reverie gear, and start from allowed post. Naturally, this provoked Ext. ???8 representation the Minister. It was pointed out in that representation that under the Madras practice both graduates and diploma holders were being appointed as Junior Engineers and thereafter regularized by (he Public Service Commission. After the selection of the petitioner on 23-10-1956, there could be no regularization by the Public Service Com-mision as the reorganization of States supervened on 1-11-1956 and the petitioner was allotted to Kerala. Under the Rules prevailing in the Travascore-Cochin Stale as on 1-11-1935 only graduates were selected as Junior Engineers, and diploma holders could get to that post only on promotion from the port of Overseers, for which, the diploma holders wore eligible. There was thus a qualification bar which prevented the Kerala Public Service Commission from selecting the petitioner for the post of Junior Engineer. By Ext. P10 order dated 14-3-1963 it, was observed that the petitioner and others appointed as Junior' Engineers under Rule 10(a)(I) of the Madras Rules were still holding the post without regularization, whereas, the services of diploma holders holding emergency appointments as Draftsman in the Malabar area had already been regularized In consultation with the Public Service Commission. It was pointed out that the cases of the petitioner and seven others were not covered by the provisions of Ext. P6 G.O as they had not put in six months continuous service on 1-11-1956 and were not possessed of all the necessary qualifications (degree in Engineering), at the time of their first appointment as Supervisors. The Chief Engineer pointed out that it would be hard if they are called upon to get themselves recruited as First Grade Overseers. The Chief Engineer recommended that their services be regularized from 26-9-1957, that Is, the date when they would have become eligible for promotion as Junior Engineers had their first appointment been as Overseers First Grade. The Government directed that the services of the eight persons be counted as service put In as First Grade Overseers and their appointment regularized on that basis The petitioner was naturally dissatisfied with Ext. P10 G.O, and made Ext. P11 representation dated 8-2-1945. The petitioner would rely on the Kerala Government's G.O.M.S 290 dated 16-3-1962 (copy Ext. P12). The Government at India had directed that the provisional or emergency appointments of the Travancore-Cochln or Madras personnel prior to 1-11-1956 before regularization of their appointment should be taken into account for the purpose of deciding inter State seniority, only if such service is either regularized or if It is In a time-scale of pay and Is rec???oned for the grant of increment in the time scale and is continuous. This was accepted by the Kerala Government. The Government of Kerala pasted Ext P 13 G.O in which they held that the regularization by Ext. P10 was not in order. It was therefore ordered that the service of the eight allotted Supervisors (including the petitioner be regularized as First Grade Overseers with effect from 2-3-1959. Ext. P10 G.O was modified to that effect. Ext. P14 is the petitioner's representation pointing out the differences in qualifications and recruitment to the post of Junior Engineers as between Madras and Kerala. The petitioner set out in Ext. P14 all his grievances against modification of Ext. P10 G.O by Ext. P13, But by Ext. P 15, the petitioner's request was rejected and the position In Ext. P 13 was reaffirmed Ext. P16 is the consequential older and Ext. P16(a) is the seniority list of Junior Engineer appointed during the period from 2-12-1958 to 16-10-1965, prepared as per the direction of the High Court in O.P Nos. 3361 of 1968 and 4493 of 1972. The petitioner's counsel stated that even First Grade Overseers appointed in Kerala after.-11-1956 became seniors to the petitioner in till list.

5. It was objected that the petitioner cannot be directed to apply for a lower post each as Overseer First Grade and be regularized in the said post. Reliance was placed for this position on the decision of the Mysore High Court in P.R Kulkarni v. State of Mysore (A.I 1967 Mysore 825), affirmed on appeal by the Supreme Court in State of Mysore v. P.R Kulkarni ((1973) 3 SCC 597 : A.I.R 1972 S.C 2170). It was observed by the Supreme Court:

“9. We are unable to accept the submission of the learned counsel for the Mysore State that the subsequent orders passed in Bombay State appointing others, who were clearly junior to and lost meritorious than the respondents, must be held to be irrelevant in deciding whether the impugned reversion orders had resulted in violation of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution in the case of the respondents. If, at a consequence of reversion orders, the respondents were denied the opportunities which their juniors in service, who were also below them In order of merit, secured in their stead, we think that these consequences could be taken into account In deciding whether discriminatory treatment was acted out to the respondents. We think that the conclusions reached by the Mysore High Court, on the strength of relevant date before it were unassailable.

10. It has also been shown to us, by the learned counsel for the respondents, that, although the respondents were allotted, after illegal reversion, as mere constables to trie newly formed State of Mysore, yet, they had been working throughout the period of their service In Mysore as Wireless Operators, because of their proficiency and experience in this work Assertions made by the respondents that they had been assigned and were doing the work of Wireless Operators In Mysore had not been controverted by the State of Mysore. It is, therefore, only just and proper that they should be treated as Wireless Operators and decemed to nave been all c???t. ed in that capacity to the State of Mysore In fact, the is the result of the orders of the Mysore High Court which and quashed the reversion orders while leave a the allotment in c??? We tee no grounds for interference with the orders of the Mysore High Court”

6. The learned Additional Advocate General p???ced r???ancce in he decision of the Supreme Court in Antony v. Union of India (1977 K.L.T 322), where the scope and effect of Rule 10(a)(1) appointments was examined by the Supreme Court and it was stated that such appointments cannot avail for purposes cf seniority Stress was bid on the preamble to the Kerala Mate and Subordinate Services Rules which stated that it was Issued “in supersession of all rules on the subject”. Therefore, it was stated that rule 10(a)(t) of the Madras Rules was also obliterated, This, we are afraid, la too narrow a view to take. The petitioner's first appointment having been in the Madras State prior to the States Re-organisation Act the Madras Rules continued to apply to him till repealed by a law of the State Legislature (vide Sections 119 and 110 of the States Re-organisaton Act). The Kerala State and Subordinate Service Rules discharged that function of appeal. But the conditions of service of the allotted persons cannot be changed to their prejudice or disadvantage except with the concurrence of the Central Government vide the proviso to section 115(7) of the States' Re-organisation Act the appointments were purely provisional appointments, which conferred no preferential right to promotion and gave no right to the appointee save to the em???luments for the post. But the fact remains that, for from terminating the service, the petitioner has been allowed to remain in the post now for over 23 years. It is not a pleasant or fine prospect for him to be ashed to take his chance of regularlsation by applying for the lewer or the inferior post of Draftsman First Grade. Such a direction, teems, Indeed, illegal as was ruled In P.R kulkarni v. State of Mysore (A.I.R 1967 Mysore 225) confirmed by the Supreme Court in State of Mysore v. Kulkarni, (1973) 3 SCC 597 : A.I.R 1972 S.C 2170). There is also the aspect that it is illegal to retain a person who is junior even in a temporary appointment while sending out the seniors, That was ruled in the recent decision in Govt. Branch Prea v. D.B Balliappa, (1979) 1 SCC 477 : AIR 1979 S.C 429???. It is a sad commentary on the slow neat of the administrative machinery that despite 23 long years, the petitioner, rather, than being given the legl???te promotion to which he might perhaps have a claim, Is to be told to start his career from a post of lower level. Ext. P6 G.O had laid down the two conditions subject to which regulation could be claimed by the allotted personnel. This was given the go by the Chief Engineer by Ext. P7. It was he who directed the petitioner and others to get themselves regularly selected In the lower ??? ost of Draftsman First Grade. That had set the clock back. The Government stepped in to set things right by Ext. P. 10. Again Ext. P. 13, slightly modified the stand in Ext. P. 10, by allowing rcgularisation as First Grade Overseer from 2-3-1959 aad providing for promotion as Junioer Engineers an lhat basis. Ext. P. 13 re-a???d Ext. P. 13 and Ext. P. 10 was only a consequential order. Ext. P. 15(e) is the seniority list and the petitioner would stress that even First Grade Overseen appelated in Kerala after 1-11-1956 became seniors to the petitioner.

7. The records and exhibits produced do not disclose a happy state of affairs, nor perhaps one which is easy of solution. But a way out must be found for the position disclosed. We do not think we will be justified in maintaining the direction of the learned Judge to identify the vacancies that arose In the Malabar area of this State from 1-11-1930 to 2-12-1958 the date when the Special Rules came into force), and consider the question of absorbing the petitioners to these vacancies. There might bo difficulty (although we do not express a final opinion) in implementing this direction in view of the recent decision of a Full Bench Judgment of this Court which has held that the first proviso to Section 27 or the State and Subordinate Services Rules has application even to the post re-organization Kerala State recruits taken into service after 1-11-19???6—vide ???eva Kurup v. Board of Revenue, I.L.R 1979 (1) Kerala 275). it is for the Government to consider its implications, if any, along with the proviso to Section 1???5(7) of the States Re-organisation Act, and whether, and If 10 how far, the same can effect the petitioner. We therefore allow W.A No. 162 of 1979 to a limited extent and modify the judgment of the teamed Judge and merely direct that the case of the petitioner be considered In all its aspects with respect to the Madras Rules and the States Re-organisation Act and their implications, if any, in the light of the observations contained in this judgment. It Is vary necessary that the osders art passed expeditiosly, and as far as possible within three months from today as the matter has dragged on for 23 long years, and the petitioner's retirement from service mast be fairly lambent. Wo male no order as to easts.

8. In view of our above conclusion we allow W.A 197 of 1979 ???ed by the State to a limited extant in the same terms, aad modify the judgment of the learned Judge No costs. W.A No. 201 of 1979

9. The appeal is by tbe State against the judgment in O.P No. 3314 of 1977 disposed of along with O.P No. 2139 of 1977. W.A Mo. 197 of 1979 is the appeal by the State against tbe connected writ petition, namely, C.P No. 2139 of 1977. In view of the judgment la the above appeal, this writ appeal is also allowed as tbe same terms with no order at to costs. Although the writ petitioners have not filed an appeal, against the learned Judge's judgment we trust that the benefit. If any, of the consideration directed In the other appeal, would be extended to these writ petitioners also.

10. Order accordingly.