Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Bhagwati Devi v. District Judge

Allahabad High Court
Jan 1, 1980

K.C Agrawal, J.:— By this petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution, Smt. Bhagvati Devi, the landlady challenges the validity of an order of District Judge Bulandshahr dated 21.3.1978 dismissing a revision filed by her under section 18 of U.P Act 13 of 1972.

2. The disputed house belonged to the petitioner of which one Prem Prakash Agrawal was a tenant. Prem Prakash Agrawal purchased his own house in 1976, thereupon a vacancy of the disputed house occurred. Jagdish Singh Rathi respondent no. 3 filed an application for its allotment. Before the application of allotment had been filed by Jagdish Singh Rathi, the petitioner also filed an application for its release on the ground that the disputed house was required by her for the purpose of her mother-in-law Smt. Savitri Devi.

3. The petitioner gave two reasons for release of the premises in her favour. One of them was that the relations between her and her mother-in law Smt. Savitri Devi were not cordial; the second reason was that the accomodation in her posession was insufficient and, as such, the premises be released in her favour.

4. The Prescribed Authority held that the need of the petitioner was not bona fide. He found that the two grounds given for the release were not made out. In his opinion a case of relations being strained with the mother-in-law had been set up by the petitioner only for the purpose of getting the premises released in her favour. He also held that the accommodation in possession of the petitioner was not insufficient and, as such, since the promises was not bona fide required, the application was liable to be rejected. The revision preferred by the petitioner was also dismissed, hence the writ petition.

5. Counsel for the petitioner contended that the courts below committed an error in holding that since Smt. Savitri Devi was not a member of the family of the petitioner, the release application filed by the petitioner was not maintainable. The word ‘family’ has been defined in section 3(g) of U.P Act no. 13 of 1972. The definition given in the said Act does not take within itself a mother-in-law. The definition has been given in the Act itself. The same has to be treated exhaustive and it is not open to a court to bring in a person other than those mentioned in the definition.

6. Counsel further contended that the courts below wrongly thought that the release of the premises for tbs need of the mother-in-law Smt. Savitri Devi could not be treated so be that of the petitioner. Be that as it may, the fact is that two courts concurrenly found that the need of the petitioner was not bona fide. The petitioner was found to have sufficient accommodation in her possession and that she could accommodate her-mother-in-law also with herself. Accordingly, even if the application filed by the petitioner for the need of the mother-in-law could be treated to be for the requirement of the petitioner herself, the application was rightly rejected; the reason being that the finding was that the need of the petitioner was not bona fide. A finding on the question that the need of the petitioner was not bona fide is one of fact.

7. Counsel attempted to assail the judgment on the ground that the need of the brother-in-law and herself had not been considered and, as such, the orders are Illegal and cannot succeed. A reading of the judgment of the first court would show that it was aware of the number of the members of the petitioner's family and found that the requirement of the petitioner was not bona fide. Admittedly, the petitioner had three rooms and one bed-room in her possession whereas the members of the family consisted only of her husband, her widowed daughter-in-law, son of the widowed daughter-in-law and the mother-in-law. Taking into account the totality of the circumstances, the judgment of the courts below holding that the need of the petitioner was not bona fide cannot be said to be erroneous.

8. Counsel also invited my attention to the supplementary affidavit filed in the writ petition wherein the allegations were that respondent no. 3 was an accused in a case under section 307 of the Indian Penal Code for having attempted to kill the husband of the petitioner and the allotment order ought to be set aside. A counter-affidavit has been filed in reply denying the charge that respondent no. 3 attempted to kill the husband of the petitioner. Admittedly, respondent no. 3 has not been convicted of the offence. The matter is still under investigation. It will not be proper to set aside the allotment order on this ground.

9. In the result the writ petition fails. The parties are directed to bear their own costs.