- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sirsilk Limited v. Government Of Andhra Pradesh
Factual and Procedural Background
This writ petition challenges the power of the State Government to levy a duty of 0.20 paise per bulk litre on rectified spirit and industrial alcohol under the provisions of the A.P. Excise Act 17 of 1968. The petitioners, two companies—The Sirsilk Limited and Andhra Sugars Limited—contend that the State Government lacks authority to impose such a duty on alcohol used for industrial purposes. They argue that, in light of the Parliament's declaration under the Industries (Development and Regulation) Act, 65 of 1951, no duty can be levied on industrial alcohol. The core dispute centers on whether alcohol not used for human consumption is subject to state excise duty.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the State Government has the power under the A.P. Excise Act 17 of 1968 to levy duty on rectified spirit and industrial alcohol used for non-consumable (industrial) purposes.
- Whether the Parliament's regulatory provisions under the Industries (Development and Regulation) Act, 65 of 1951, exclude the State Government from levying such duty on industrial alcohol.
- The interpretation of the term "liquor" or "alcohol" in the context of excise duties—whether it includes industrial alcohol or is limited to alcohol for human consumption.
- The appropriate interest rate applicable to arrears of excise duty under the relevant statutory and rule provisions.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The State Government has no power under the A.P. Excise Act 17 of 1968 to levy duty on alcohol used for industrial purposes.
- Parliament's declaration under the Industries (Development and Regulation) Act, 65 of 1951, places alcohol regulation under Central Government control, precluding state duties on industrial alcohol.
- Alcohol not used for human consumption should not be subject to excise duty by the State.
State Government's Arguments
- The State Government holds a monopoly over liquor regulation and can prohibit or regulate liquor use, including industrial alcohol.
- This regulatory monopoly includes the power to levy duties on industrial alcohol.
- The power to levy duty is distinct from the monopoly over liquor regulation.
- The interest rate on arrears of duty should be 15% per annum as per the Andhra Pradesh Excise (Levy of Interest on Government Dues) Rules, 1982, not 12% as previously directed by a single Judge.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| State of Bombay v. F.N Balsara, AIR 1951 SC 318 | Definition of "liquor" includes liquor used for industrial purposes, not limited to human consumption. | Established that "liquor" in statutes includes industrial alcohol, which supports the State's power to levy duty on such alcohol. |
| State of U.P v. Synthetics and Chemicals Limited, AIR 1980 SC 614, (1980) 2 SCC 441 | Reiterated that liquor includes alcoholic liquids used for beverage purposes and also rectified or denatured spirits. | Supported the view that the definition of liquor encompasses industrial alcohol, reinforcing the State's levy power. |
| Tika Ramji v. State of A.P, AIR 1956 SC 676 | Section 18-G of the Industries (Development and Regulation) Act, 65 of 1951, operates only when Central Government issues a notification levying duty. | Clarified that State's power to levy duty is not ousted unless Central Government notification exists; confirmed State Act's presidential assent affirms State competence. |
| Har Shankar v. Dy. Excise and Taxation Commissioner, AIR 1975 SC 1121, (1975) 1 SCC 737 | State's monopoly in regulating liquor, including prohibition and control over use and storage. | Supported the State's broad regulatory powers over liquor but distinguished monopoly from power to levy duty. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by distinguishing alcohol used for human consumption from industrial alcohol, explaining the chemical and legal definitions relevant under the Excise Act. It relied heavily on authoritative Supreme Court decisions which held that the term "liquor" in statutory contexts includes alcohol used for industrial purposes, not just for human consumption. Consequently, the State Government's power to levy duty on such alcohol stands affirmed.
Regarding the Parliament's regulatory role under the Industries (Development and Regulation) Act, 65 of 1951, the court noted that the State's power to levy duty is not negated unless the Central Government issues a notification under Section 18-G of that Act. Since no such notification was shown, the State Act (which has presidential assent) remains valid and operative.
The court also addressed the State Government's argument about its monopoly over liquor regulation, recognizing its broad powers but emphasizing that the issue in the case was the power to levy duty, which is distinct and upheld.
Finally, on the question of interest rates for arrears of duty, the court corrected a prior order that fixed interest at 12%, holding that the applicable rate under the Andhra Pradesh Excise (Levy of Interest on Government Dues) Rules, 1982 is 15% per annum.
Holding and Implications
The writ petition is dismissed with costs.
The court held that the State Government has the power under the A.P. Excise Act 17 of 1968 to levy duty on rectified spirit and industrial alcohol. The Parliament's regulatory provisions under the Industries (Development and Regulation) Act, 65 of 1951, do not exclude the State's power to levy such duty in the absence of a Central Government notification. The definition of "liquor" includes industrial alcohol, supporting the State's levy power. The interest rate on arrears of excise duty is fixed at 15% per annum as per the relevant State rules, overruling a prior direction for 12% interest.
No new precedent was established; the decision reaffirms existing Supreme Court rulings and clarifies the applicable interest rate under State rules.
Raghuvir, J.:— In this writ petition, the powers of the State Government to levy duty of 0.20 paise per bulk litre on rectified spirit and industrial alcohol is questioned. The writ petitioners are two companies: The Sirsilk Limited, Sirpur Kaghaznagar, Adilabad and the Andhra Sugars Limited, Venkatarayapuram, Tanuku. The companies assert, the State Government have no power under the provisions of the A.P Excise Act 17 of 1968 to levy duty on alcohol used for industrial purposes, and add, having regard to the Parliament's Declaration under the Industries (Development and Regulation) Act, 65 of 1951, no duty on the industrial alcohol, can be levied. The question, thus, raised, prince pally is on alcohol which is not used for human consumption, no duty can be levied. Even if such a power, exists the writ petitioners state, having regard to the provisions of the Act 65/1951 there is no power left in the State Government to levy duty. In the context of this question and controversy it is necessary to set out the distinction between alcohol used for human consumption and alcohol, not used for human consumption.
2. Alcohol is used in almost all civilisations. In vedic days, in India, it was known as “Soma” some times referred as a deity. “From the hymns addressed to this deity, it is evident that at one time, it was considered right for the Hindus to use intoxicants. Now as a rule, they are forbidden amongst the members of one branch of the worshippers of ‘Kali’ they are commonly indulged in, but with almost this single exemption, the people do not touch them and Soma, in his vedic character has ceased to be worshipped.” In modern days, alcohol beverages are of two types (a) undistilled and (b) Distilled.
3. When alcohol is produced by simple process of fermentation, it is called undistilled; when grape juice, wines etc., are fermented they are called “distilled beverages.” Normally alcohol beverages have more than 50% of alcohol content. Alcohol content is measured by means of hydrometer by determining the specific gravity of the liquid. The determination of the percentage of alcohol goes by the name of alcoholometry.
4. In the Excise Act, the expression, denatured (alcohol) means, “subjected to a process prescribed for the purpose of rendering unfit for human consumption”. The word “rectification” is also defined, “every process whereby spirits are purified or are coloured or flavoured by mixing any material therewith.” “Rectified spirit” is defined as “liquor containing undenatured alcohol of a strength of not less than 50% over proof and includes absolute alcohol in other forms, but does not include arrack issued in varying degrees of concentration for potable purposes”. The expression, “Over-proof” is derived from old customary practices. When it was customary to gauge the alcohol content by pouring the sample of alcohol on gun powder and then setting fire to it. If the liquid contained much alcohol it burnt away leaving the gun powder dry enough to catch fire. On the contrary, if it contained water it damped the gun power from catching fire. A sample of spirit which was just strong enough to fire the powder, was called “proof spirit”. Stronger spirits were called, “over proof” (O.P). The weaker ones “under proof” (UP). Proof spirit is now legally defined as an alcohol-water mixture having specific gravity 0.91976 at 15 degree and contains 57.1 percent alcohol by weight. The strength of liquor thus, in modern times, expressed in degrees of O.P or U.P
5. Alcohol, when used for industrial purposes, is chemically referred as “Ethyl Alcohol”. It contains 96% strength and also known as “rectified spirit”. When used pure, is known as “denatured or specially denatured spirit”, when treated with small quantities of other chemicals to render it unfit for portable purposes. The term, “power alcohol” is applied when it is used as a motor fuel mixed with petroleum factions. Ethyl alcohol should have a strength or composition greater than 99.5% with less 0.5% of water if it is to be mixed with petrol to remain homogenous during its use. In non-petroleum producing countries alcohol is mixed with petrol and benzane for use as motor fuel. The alcohol thus used for the generation of power is popularly known as “power alcohol”. In denatured and rectified spirits, the two are used for production of either. Ethyl chloride. Acetone, D.D.T, Pharmaceutical products and Organic Intermediates, Ethylene Dicholoride, Ethylene Oxide, Glycol & Derivaties, Acetal Dehyde based chemicals Acetate Rayon/Cellulose Acetate and Synthetic rubber.
6. The question whether the definition of alcohol includes industrial alcohol or power alcohol or merely means alcohol used for human consumption, came to be considered by the Supreme Court with reference to item VIII of List II read with Entry 33 of the List III of the Seventh Schedule, in State of Bombay v. F.N Balsara (1) AIR 1951 SC 318. In that case, it was held the word “liquor” includes, not only the liquor that is consumed but includes liquor used for industrial purposes. In this case, no doubt, the question of the power to levy duty was not discussed but it was authoritatively held that the expression, liquor contained in any Statute (otherwise excluded), would not only include liquor used for human consumption and includes liquor used for industrial purposes. Once, it is accepted that the expression “liquor”, covers liquor for industrial purposes, there is very little left to be decided. The duty aspect was considered in State of U.P v. Synthetics and Chemicals Limited (2) (1980) 2 SCC 441 : AIR 1980 S.C 614. In that case, reiterating the contents of the definition of “liquor”, the Supreme Court observed that the liquor generally covers alcoholic liquor for beverage purposes producing intoxication and includes liquids containing alcohol even if the components of alcohol are mixed up with some other liquid to make it rectified or denatured spirit. Having regard to these two decisions, there is hardly anything necessary or left to decide now, in the instant case. However, for long, some of the High Courts, have opined, if “liquor” is not used for human consumption, the power to levy duty was not available, to the State. For example, the judgment of Justice Varadarajan of the Madras High Court in W.P Nos. 3377 and 5172 of 1975. We would have considered this question in all its perspective, but it is unnecessary for the reason, the issue is finally decided by the Supreme Court in the above two cases.
7. The next question that is argued by the companies is with reference to the provisions of the Act 65 of 1951. In that, it is argued, alcohol is one of the subjects which was taken over for regulation by the Parliament. Alcohol, thus, is under the domain of the Parliament, therefore, the State Government cannot levy the duty of 0-20 ps. per bulk litre.
8. The Parliament, under the above Act, empowered the Central Government, if they found it expedient for the purpose of “securing the equitable distribution and availability at fair prices of any article or class of articles, relatable to any scheduled industry, they may…… by notified order provide for regulating the supply and distribution thereof and trade and commerce therein……” It is from the stand point of that Act, it is argued, the State Government has no more left with any power to levy duty on alcohol used for industrial purposes. This question, again, is no more res integra as the powers of the parliament and powers of the State Government, have been authoritatively laid down by the Supreme Court under Act 65 of 1951 in Tika Ramji v. State of A.P (3) AIR 1956 S.C 676 where it was held, Sec. 18-G of the Act 65/1951 to mean in the context of liquor (the case was decided in the context of sugar), operates only when the Central Govt. issues a notification levying duty and not otherwise. It is in this connection, it may also be noted that the State Act 17 of 1968 also has received the assent by the President of India, therefore, the competence of the State Government is no more in doubt.
9. In resisting this writ petition, the State Government have raised the question that the State Government has the monopoly of regulating liquor and they have a right to prohibit the use of liquor, absolutely. The width of the power is so much, it is argued, it can prohibit the use of industrial alcohol, to include storage, export or for, manufacturing purposes. Therefore, it is argued, the companies cannot question the power, having regard to the magnitude of the privileges enjoyed by the State in dealing with liquor, and relied on Har Shankar v. Dy. Excise and Taxation Commissioner (4) (1975) 1 SCC 737 : AIR 1975 S.C 1121. The question, in the instant case, is of the power to levy duty, which cannot be mixed up with monopoly. It is unnecessary to go into the further question as it is, in our view the State Government has the power to levy duty in question.
10. Lastly, it is seen, in another writ petition, a single Judge of this court in W.P No. 6174/78 dated June, 11, 1984, directed the State Government to charge interest at 12%, on arrears of duty payable by a company. The rate of interest, has been fixed, in that case, per incuriam as under Sec. 72 read with sub-section (3) of Sec. 65 of the Act, the Government has promulgated the Rules, known as. The Andhra Pradesh Excise (Levy of Interest on Government Dues) Rules, 1982 which came into force on July, 1, 1981 and under the Rules, it is recited, the arrears of moneys recoverable under Sec. 65 of the Act shall bear interest at the rate of fifteen percent per annum. Therefore, the direction at 12% interest, to the State Government, is not proper. The State Government can collect arrears at the rate of 15% interest payable under the excise duty. The Writ Petition, for all the aforesaid reasons, is dismissed with costs. Advocate's fee Rs. 200/-.
Alert