Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Tomy Mathew v. State Of Kerala

Kerala High Court
Dec 2, 2016
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is the first accused in Criminal Case No. 139 of 2015 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-III, Kozhikode, facing charges under Sections 406, 420 read with 34 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). The second respondent is the complainant, and the third and fourth respondents are the other accused. The complainant, proprietor of Mayan Consultants, entered into an agreement with the petitioner’s company for advisory services to launch and market products in Kerala for a sum of Rs. 5,00,000, of which Rs. 1,50,000 was paid. The petitioner allegedly reneged on the contract and failed to pay the remaining amount despite a legal notice. The complainant filed a police complaint leading to an FIR and subsequent investigation. The final report submitted by the police is challenged in this petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the allegations in the final report prima facie constitute offences under Sections 406 (criminal breach of trust) and 420 (cheating) read with Section 34 of the IPC.
  2. Whether the petitioner had a dishonest or fraudulent intention at the inception of the contract to attract penal provisions.
  3. Whether the continuation of the criminal prosecution amounts to abuse of process of law in a matter that is essentially a civil dispute.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The allegations, even if accepted in entirety, only amount to a breach of contract and do not constitute any criminal offence.
  • The petitioner had informed the complainant of contract termination and the complainant has a pending civil suit for damages, indicating a civil remedy is available.
  • There is no evidence of dishonest or fraudulent intention (mens rea) at the time of entering the contract.
  • The prosecution relies solely on the complainant’s testimony without corroboration.
  • Continued proceedings would amount to an abuse of law.
  • Relied on precedents including Ajay Mitra v. State of M.P, G. Sagar Suri v. State of U.P, Maksud Saiyed v. State of Gujarat, Dalip Kaur v. Jagnar Singh, and S.W Palanikar v. State of Bihar.

Complainant’s Arguments

  • The petitioner’s fraudulent intention was present at the inception, intending to obtain ideas and execute them through others without retaining the complainant’s services.
  • Criminal remedy is available alongside civil remedy in commercial disputes involving criminal offences.
  • Relied on Indian Oil Corporation v. NEPC India Ltd. and other Supreme Court decisions (Kurukshetra University v. State of Haryana, Rupan Deol Bajaj v. Kanwar Pal Singh Gill, State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal) to argue that inherent powers to quash prosecution should be exercised sparingly.
  • Contended that the offences under Sections 406 and 420 IPC are clearly made out.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ajay Mitra v. State of M.P [(2003) 3 SCC 11] Principle that breach of contract does not necessarily amount to criminal offence. Supported the petitioner’s contention that the allegations amounted only to civil breach.
G. Sagar Suri v. State of U.P [(2000) 2 SCC 636] Warning against converting civil disputes into criminal prosecutions. Used to emphasize that criminal prosecution should not be used to pressure settlement of civil claims.
Maksud Saiyed v. State of Gujarat [(2008) 5 SCC 668] Clarification on mens rea and ingredients of criminal offence in commercial disputes. Supported the requirement of fraudulent intention for criminal liability.
Dalip Kaur v. Jagnar Singh [(2009) 14 SCC 696] Principle regarding the necessity of proving dishonest intention for cheating offences. Reinforced the petitioner’s argument on absence of guilty intent.
S.W Palanikar v. State of Bihar [(2002) 1 SCC 241] Standards for quashing criminal proceedings in cases involving civil disputes. Supported quashing where criminal prosecution is an abuse of process.
Indian Oil Corporation v. NEPC India Ltd. [(2006) 6 SCC 736] Criminal remedy is available besides civil remedy in cases involving criminal offences in commercial transactions. Considered by complainant to argue that criminal prosecution is maintainable.
Kurukshetra University v. State of Haryana [AIR 1977 SC 229] Use of inherent powers to quash criminal proceedings sparingly. Referenced to emphasize caution in quashing legitimate prosecutions.
Rupan Deol Bajaj v. Kanwar Pal Singh Gill [AIR 1996 (SC) 309] Criteria for exercise of inherent powers under Section 482 CrPC. Used to support complainant’s stance on maintaining prosecution.
State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal [1992 AIR SCW 237] Guidelines for quashing criminal proceedings to prevent abuse of process. Considered for the principle of sparing exercise of quashing powers.
Onkar Nath Mishra v. State (NCT of Delhi) [(2008) 2 SCC 561] Definition and requirements of criminal breach of trust under Section 405 IPC. Applied to analyze the absence of misappropriation or dishonest dealing in the case.
Madhavrao Jiwajirao Scindia [AIR 1988 SC 709] Test for quashing prosecution at initial stage based on prima facie establishment of offence. Applied to conclude that continuation of prosecution would serve no useful purpose.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the facts and the final report, focusing on the essential ingredients of offences under Sections 406 and 420 IPC. It noted that criminal breach of trust requires entrustment of property and dishonest misappropriation or conversion, which was not established here. The agreement was terminated, and the petitioner paid part of the consideration before termination due to dissatisfaction with the complainant’s services. The Court emphasized that whether the termination was justified or damages are payable is a civil matter to be decided by the Civil Court after evidence is recorded.

Regarding cheating, the Court reiterated that fraudulent or dishonest intention at the time of making the promise is essential. Mere failure to fulfill a promise without mens rea does not constitute cheating. The Court referred to authoritative precedents warning against the conversion of civil disputes into criminal cases and noted the complainant’s civil suit seeking damages.

Applying the test from Madhavrao Jiwajirao Scindia, the Court found that the allegations do not prima facie establish the offences charged. The Court concluded that allowing the prosecution to continue would amount to an abuse of process, as the criminal charges are essentially a disguised civil dispute.

Holding and Implications

The petition is allowed and the final report is quashed. All further proceedings against the petitioner in C.C. No. 139 of 2015 before the Judicial Magistrate of the First Class-III, Kozhikode, are quashed.

The decision directly terminates the criminal proceedings against the petitioner on the basis that the allegations do not disclose a criminal offence but a civil dispute. No new legal precedent is established; the ruling reinforces established principles restricting the use of criminal law to resolve purely civil contractual disputes and prevents abuse of judicial process.

Show all summary ...

Raja Vijayaraghavan V., J.:— The petitioner herein is the first accused in C.C No. 139 of 2015 on the file of the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-III, Kozhikode. In the aforesaid case, he faces indictment under Sections 406, 420 r/w 34 of IPC. The 2nd respondent is the de facto complainant and the respondents 3 and 4 are the accused Nos. 2 and 3 in the final report.

2. For the sake of convenience, the parties shall henceforth be described as “complainant” and “accused”, as per their status in the final report.

3. Facts in brief:—

(a) The complainant is the sole proprietor of Mayan Consultants, a full service advertising agency providing advertising and consultant services. The 1st accused is the Managing Director of M/s. Elements Homestead Products Pvt. Ltd., having its business at Kozhikode. The 1 accused deals with products such as coconut oil, cashew nut, Coffee powder.

(b) The 1 accused entered into an agreement with the complainant at the behest of accused Nos. 2 and 3. As per the terms of the agreement entered into between the parties, the complainant had agreed to provide necessary advice and inputs to launch and market the various products of the 1 accused in the State of Kerala and the 1 accused agreed to compensate him by a sum of Rs. 5,00,000/-. A sum of Rs. 1,50,000/-, being the 1 installment, was paid by the 1 accused to the complainant. In total violation of the terms of the agreement, the 1 accused reneged from the contract. Annexure-5 legal notice was issued to the accused calling upon the 1 accused to make immediate payment of Rs. 3,00,000/- towards settlement of the claims. However, no payment was effected.

(c) In the said circumstances, the complainant approached the Superintendent of Police and submitted a complaint which was forwarded to the Assistant Commissioner of Police, Kozhikkode for inquiry and report.

(d) On the basis of his report, Annexure-1 FIR was registered alleging offences punishable under sections 406 and 420 read with section 34 of the IPC. Later, investigation was concluded and Annexure-2 final report was laid before the jurisdictional Court. The same is under challenge.

4. I have heard Sri. Manjeri Sunder Raj, the learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner, Sri. Vinod Natesan, the 2 respondent who argued as party-in-person and also the learned Public Prosecutor. I have also gone through the notes of argument submitted by the contesting parties.

5. The learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner submitted that the allegations in the final report, even if they are taken at their face value and accepted in its entirety, do not prima facie constitute any offence or make out a case against the accused. According to the learned counsel, even if the allegations raised by the complainant is accepted as such it would amount only to a breach of contract and the same cannot be the basis of a criminal prosecution. Referring to the transaction entered into between the parties, it is pointed out that the service of the complainant was availed by the company for launch of its products in the State of Kerala. The parties fell apart and the accused had immediately informed the complainant that the contract was being terminated and that the service was no longer required. This fact was communicated to the 2 respondent on 21.04.2014 itself. Stating his version of the incident and claiming damages and compensation, the 2 respondent has preferred a Civil suit in the City Civil Court, Mumbai, which is pending. It is submitted that the continuance of proceedings is nothing but an abuse of law as there is nothing in the final report to conclude that the petitioner had guilty intent when the transaction was entered into. A dishonest intention, according to the learned counsel, cannot be inferred from the mere fact that the contract entered into was terminated for valid reasons. Referring to the final report, it is submitted that the only person who has been cited by the prosecution to prove the offence under sections 420 and 406 of the IPC is the 2 respondent himself and none else. In support of the aforesaid contention, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner would rely upon the decisions rendered in Ajay Mitra v. State of M.P [(2003) 3 SCC 11]; G. Sagar Suri v. State of U.P [(2000) 2 SCC 636]; Maksud Saiyed v. State of Gujarat [(2008) 5 SCC 668]; Dalip Kaur v. Jagnar Singh [(2009) 14 SCC 696] and S.W Palanikar v. State of Bihar [(2002) 1 SCC 241].

6. Per contra, the 2 respondent, who himself argued the matter, took this Court extensively through the materials and submitted that the fact that the intention of the petitioner was fraudulent at the very inception is blatantly obvious. According to the 2 respondent, the intention was not to retain the 2 respondent for three months, but to obtain ideas from him within a month and to execute it through some one else. It is admitted that a Civil Suit was instituted seeking damages and compensation but referring to the decision of the Apex Court in Indian Oil Corporation v. NEPC India Ltd. [(2006) 6 SCC 736] it is contended that a commercial transaction or a commercial dispute apart from furnishing a cause of action for seeking remedy in Criminal Law, may also involve a criminal offence. According to the 2 respondent, the offenses alleged are clearly made out. Referring to a catena of decisions of the Apex Court in Indian Oil Corporation (supra), Kurukshetra University v. State of Haryana [AIR 1977 SC 229], Rupan Deol Bajaj v. Kanwar Pal Singh Gill [AIR 1996 (SC) 309] and State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal [1992 AIR SCW 237] it is submitted that the inherent powers of this Court is not to be exercised to stifle a legitimate prosecution, unless it finds that the allegations in the FIR is absurd or inherently improbable. The powers are to be used sparingly and with caution and it is submitted that the instant case is not a case where this Court can justifiably invoke powers under section 482 to quash the proceeding.

7. The 2 respondent would also highlight various other aspects in his argument note which for the purpose of adjudicating this matter has no significance. It appears that quite a bit of bad blood exists between the parties.

8. I have considered the submissions.

9. Essentially, the matter involves an agreement entered into between the parties with regard to availing of intellectual services of the 2 respondent for marketing the products of the petitioner. Admittedly, an agreement was entered into between the parties and a sum of Rs. 1,50,000/- was transferred to the 2 respondent. A sum of Rs. 1,00,000/- was also transferred in the name of Mr. Viren Kamdar, who was assigned with incidental tasks. It appears that the petitioner had terminated the services and informed the said fact to the 2 respondent on 21.04.2014

10. In so far as the instant final report is concerned, the allegation is that the complainant had entered into an advertisement contract with M/s. Elements Products Pvt. Ltd., owned by the accused No. 1 and signed an agreement agreeing to pay a sum of Rs. 5,00,000/- for his services. However, only a sum of Rs. 1,50,000/- was paid and by failing to pay the balance amount of Rs. 3,50,000/- the accused have committed offence under sections 406, 420 read with section 34 of the IPC.

11. The question is whether the above allegations would would attract the penal provisions as alleged.

12. For the purpose of constituting an offence for criminal breach of trust and/or cheating, the ingredients thereof as contained in Sections 405 and 415 respectively must be borne out from the records.

13. The punishment for criminal breach of trust as defined in section 405 of the IPC is provided in Section 406 of the IPC. Punishment for aggravated forms of criminal breach of trust is provided in Section 407 to Section 409 of the IPC.

14. The terms of the section are very wide. It applies to one who is in any manner entrusted with property or dominion over property. The section provides inter alia, that if such a person dishonestly misappropriates or converts to his own use property entrusted to him, he commits criminal breach of trust. There are separate offences by which criminal breach of trust may be committed. This section requires:

1) Entrusting any person with property or with dominion over property.

2) That person entrusted (a) dishonestly misappropriates or converting to his own use that property; or (b) dishonestly using or disposing of that property or wilfully suffering any other person so to do in violation—

(i) of any direction of law prescribing the mode in which such trust is to be discharged, or

(ii) of any legal contract made touching the discharge of such trust.

15. In Onkar Nath Mishra v. State (NCT of Delhi) [(2008) 2 SCC 561], the Apex Court has held that in the commission of the offence of criminal breach of trust, two distinct parts are involved. The first consists of the creation of an obligation in relation to the property over which dominion or control is acquired by the accused. The second is misappropriation or dealing with the property dishonestly and contrary to the terms of the obligation created.

16. After having perused the final report and the statement of the 2 respondent, I am unable to hold that the petitioner had committed any offence under section 406 of the IPC in the instant case. An agreement was entered into between the parties and the same was terminated for one reason or the other. Whether it was on rightful grounds or whether the 2 respondent is entitled to damages etc., are the concern of the Civil Court, which aspect can be determined only after recording the evidence adduced by the parties.

17. In so far cheating is concerned, the offence cannot be said to be made out unless the following ingredients are satisfied:

i) deception of a person either by making a false or misleading representation or by other action or omission;

(ii) fraudulently or dishonestly inducing any person to deliver any property; or

(iii) To consent that any person shall retain any property and finally intentionally inducing that person to do or omit to do anything which he would not do or omit.

18. For the purpose of constituting an offence of cheating, the complainant is required to show that the accused had fraudulent or dishonest intention at the time of making promise or representation. Even in a case where allegations are made in regard to failure on the part of the accused to keep his promise, in absence of a culpable intention at the time of making initial promise being absent, no offence under section 420 of the Indian Penal Code can be said to have been made out. A guilty intention is an essential ingredient of the offence of cheating. In other words ‘mens rea’ on the part of the accused must be established before he can be convicted of an offence of cheating.

19. In Indian Oil Corpn. (supra), the Supreme Court held that in a dispute arising from breach of contract wherein civil remedy has been availed by a party, the remedy in criminal law is not barred, if the allegation discloses a criminal offence, however, the Supreme Court has held that a purely civil dispute cannot be permitted to be converted into a criminal offence. Referring to G. Sagar Suri (supra) the Supreme Court held thus in para 13:

13. While on this issue, it is necessary to take notice of a growing tendency in business circles to convert purely civil disputes into criminal cases. This is obviously on account of a prevalent impression that civil law remedies are time consuming and do not adequately protect the interests of lenders/creditors. Such a tendency is seen in several family disputes also, leading to irretrievable breakdown of marriages/families. There is also an impression that if a person could somehow be entangled in a criminal prosecution, there is a likelihood of imminent settlement. Any effort to settle civil disputes and claims, which do not involve any criminal offence, by applying pressure through criminal prosecution should be deprecated and discouraged.

20. Testing the facts of the instant case on the basis of the above settled legal position, I am of the view that the ingredients of the offence under section 406 or section 420 is not made out. Even if it is admitted that an agreement was entered into, and that the petitioner had reneged his promise at some stage, in the facts of the instant case, it will be well nigh impossible to hold that the petitioner had guilty intent at the inception. It is specifically alleged that the petitioner was forced to terminate the contract after paying a sum of Rs. 1,50,000/- to the 2 respondent and a sum of Rs. 1,00,000/- to his associate when it was found that the intellectual inputs from the side of the 2 respondent was not to his satisfaction. Allegations and counter allegations are made. According to the 2 respondent, the petitioner was not justified in leaving him midway whereas the specific case of the petitioner is that the services offered by the 2 respondent was below par and did not suit their cause or need. The contract was terminated by the petitioner and even if there is any breach, the remedy is to approach the Civil Court, which has been done by the 2 respondent. There are no materials attracting the ingredients of sections 406 or 420 of the IPC.

21. In Madhavrao Jiwajirao Scindia (AIR 1988 SC 709) the Supreme Court held thus:

The legal position is well settled that when a prosecution at the initial stage is asked to be quashed, the test to be applied by the Court is as to whether the uncontroverted allegations as made prima facie establish the offence. It is also for the Court to take into consideration any special features which appear in a particular case to consider whether it is expedient and in the interest of justice to permit a prosecution to continue. This is so on the basis that the Court cannot be utilised for any oblique purpose and where in the opinion of the Court chances of an ultimate conviction are bleak and, therefore, no useful purpose is likely to be served by allowing a criminal prosecution to continue, the Court may while taking into consideration the special facts of a case also quash the proceeding even though it may be at a preliminary stage.

22. I have no hesitation in my mind that if the prosecution is permitted to continue, it will be a clear case of abuse of powers of the Court. The final report is liable to be quashed for the aforesaid reasons.

23. This petition will stand allowed. All further proceedings against the petitioner in C.C.No 139 of 2015 on the file of the Judicial Magistrate of the First Class-III, Kozhikkode are quashed.