- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mamta Sharma v. Hari Shankar Srivastava And Others
Summary of Judicial Opinion — N.N. Mithal, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
Suit No. 32 of 1981 was instituted by Respondent No. 1 against the appellant and others (heirs of Sri Bishambhar Manav) seeking reliefs after serving notice terminating a tenancy under Section 106 of the Transfer of Property Act. The suit was filed before the District Judge (valuation above Rs. 5,000) and was ultimately decreed on 17-8-1982. The appellant did not file a written statement; she was served by substituted service (beat of drum and by affixation), which the trial Court deemed sufficient by an order referred to in the opinion (the text contains references to an order dated 19-1-1981 and elsewhere to 19-9-1981).
Civil Revision No. 647 of 1982 (filed by contesting defendants under Section 25 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act) was dismissed on 8-12-1982. Execution proceedings followed. The appellant and her brother Prabhat Sharma moved two applications before the trial Court: (i) an application under Order IX Rule 13 CPC read with Section 151 CPC (registered as Misc. Case No. 2 of 1983) and (ii) an objection under Order XXXII Rule 5 read with Section 47 CPC (registered as Misc. Case No. 3 of 1983). Both applications were dismissed by order dated 25-11-1987.
Civil Revision No. 1004 of 1987 (challenging the decision in Misc. Case No. 3 of 1983) filed by Prabhat Sharma and Mamta Sharma was dismissed by this Court on 4-2-1988 (reported as Prabhat Sharma v. Hari Shanker Srivastava, 1988 (1) ARC 285). Thereafter the present appeal (FAFO) was filed by the appellant alone. The respondent appeared, and by consent the appeal was taken up for admission and final disposal. The parties filed counter and rejoinder affidavits and supplementary pleadings.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether an appeal (as instituted before this Court) was maintainable where the subject suit was of the nature cognizable by a Court of Small Causes (i.e., whether only a revision under Section 25 lay instead of an appeal).
- Whether the application under Order IX Rule 13 CPC (to set aside an ex parte decree) was maintainable without compliance with Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act (specifically, the requirement to deposit the decretal amount or give security at the time of presenting the application).
- Whether substituted service effected by beat of drum and affixation could be treated as sufficient in the absence of specific averments by the applicant denying that such substituted service took place.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The appellant contended that she was not served with notice of the suit and that the proceedings against her were therefore a nullity and without jurisdiction. She stated she became aware of the existence of the decree only on 18-1-1983 and filed the application on 2-2-1983.
- It was also urged on the appellant's behalf (implicitly) that because the trial Court did not indicate it was exercising the powers of a Court of Small Causes, the suit was tried on the regular side and thus an appeal should be maintainable.
Respondent's Arguments
- The respondent (Sri A.K. Sand appearing for Respondent No. 1) raised a preliminary objection to maintainability: that the suit was tried by the Court below exercising powers of a Judge of Small Cause Courts and, therefore, only a revision under Section 25 would lie and an appeal was not maintainable.
- It was also contended that the present appeal was barred because Civil Revision No. 1004 of 1987 (on almost the same grounds) had been filed and finally disposed of.
- The respondent further argued that the application under Order IX Rule 13 CPC was not maintainable because the appellant had not complied with the requirement of Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act (i.e., deposit of the decretal amount or providing security when seeking to set aside an ex parte decree).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Bisheshwar Prasad Gautam v. Dr. R.K. Agarwal, AIR 1977 Alld. 103 | Where a suit for ejectment and recovery of arrears of rent is brought as an ordinary suit, it nevertheless retains its nature as a small cause suit if it is inherently of that nature; the substance of the suit, not merely the procedure adopted, determines its character. | The Court relied on this precedent to hold that the nature of the suit (lessor-lessee eviction/arrears) determined that it was of small cause nature even though the trial Court did not expressly state it was deciding the suit as a Court of Small Causes. |
| Trilok Singh v. Smt. Jamuna Devi, AIR 1978 Alld. 129 | The pecuniary limit in the proviso to Section 15(3) of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act (as amended) does not apply to District Judges and Additional District Judges when jurisdiction is conferred on them under Section 25(2) of the Bengal, Agra and Assam Civil Courts Act; they may try lessor-lessee suits irrespective of value. | The Court invoked this decision to support the proposition that District Judges/Additional District Judges, having been conferred jurisdiction under Section 25(2), can try lessor-lessee suits of small cause nature irrespective of pecuniary limits, reinforcing that the suit before the Court was of small cause nature. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court disposed of the appeal on the preliminary question of maintainability and therefore did not decide other raised questions. The analysis proceeded in the following steps:
- Statutory framework and jurisdiction: The Court reviewed the legislative changes effected by U.P. Act 37 of 1972 and the notifications by which the State Government delegated powers under the amended Section 25 of the Bengal, Agra and Assam Civil Courts Act (1887) to the High Court, and thence the High Court conferred, by notification, the jurisdiction of a Judge of a Court of Small Causes on all District Judges and Additional District Judges. The Court reproduced Section 25(2) (as introduced by amendment) to show that lessor-lessee suits for eviction and recovery of rent fall within the jurisdiction conferred.
- Substance over form: The Court applied precedent (Bisheshwar Prasad Gautam and Trilok Singh) to conclude that the intrinsic nature of the suit — i.e., a lessor-lessee suit for eviction/recovery of rent — determines that it was a small cause suit irrespective of the procedure adopted or whether the trial court expressly stated it was exercising Small Cause Court powers. Thus, the suit before the Court was properly characterized as small cause in nature and cognizable by a Judge of a Court of Small Causes.
- Consequence for remedies available: Because the suit was of a small cause nature and the Court below was exercising small cause jurisdiction, the appropriate remedy against interlocutory/post-judgment orders lies by way of revision under Section 25 rather than by an ordinary appeal. Hence the appeal's maintainability was put into question.
- Application under Order IX Rule 13 CPC and Section 17 (Provincial Small Cause Courts Act): The Court examined Section 17 which incorporates the Code of Civil Procedure subject to exceptions and contains a proviso requiring that an applicant seeking to set aside an ex parte decree (or for review) must, at the time of presenting the application, either deposit the amount due under the decree or give security for performance as directed. The Court treated this as a statutory modification of the ordinary Order IX Rule 13 CPC procedure in the context of Small Cause Court matters.
- Non-compliance with deposit/security requirement: The appellant had not complied with the deposit/security requirement of Section 17 when presenting the Order IX Rule 13 application. The Court held that this non-compliance rendered the Order IX Rule 13 application non-maintainable and therefore liable to dismissal on that ground alone.
- Service contention: On the appellant's contention that she had not been served, the Court noted that substituted service by beat of drum and affixation had been recorded and that the trial Court by order (date recorded in different places in the text) had deemed such service sufficient. The Court explained that the appellant's application merely denied service generally and did not specifically aver that no affixation or no beat of drum had taken place or otherwise explain why substituted service could not be deemed sufficient. Given the prior order deeming substituted service sufficient and the absence of specific factual pleadings to the contrary, the Court held service must be deemed sufficient in the absence of particularized grounds to set it aside.
- Conclusion of reasoning: Because (a) the suit was of small cause nature (making an appeal improper) and (b) the Order IX Rule 13 application was not maintainable due to non-compliance with Section 17, the Court found no need to consider other points and concluded that the appeal could not succeed.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Court's final decision was that the appeal fails. The Court rendered the following disposition: APPEAL DISMISSED, and the dismissal was ordered with costs.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The appellant's appeal was dismissed and the earlier decrees and orders (including the dismissal of her applications and the ex parte decree) remain in force; costs were awarded against the appellant.
- Scope and precedent: The opinion treats the matter as one of statutory application of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act (Section 17) and of the nature-of-suit principle (substance determining that a suit is of small cause nature). The Court did not purport to lay down any novel broader principle beyond applying existing statutory provisions and precedents; the decision resolves the present matter on maintainability grounds rather than establishing a new legal doctrine.
Note: This summary is prepared exclusively from the contents of the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond those contained in the opinion text.
N.N Mithal, J.:— One of the defendants against whom an ex-parte decree had been passed by the Court below and whose application under Order IX Rule 13 CPC had been dismissed by the impugned order, has come up in appeal. The facts, in brief, in so far as they are relevant for the purposes of disposing of this appeal, may be set out below.
2. Suit No. 32 of 1981 was filed by the Respondent No. 1 against the appellant and proforma Respondents 2 to 5 and one Prabhat Sharma, all being heirs of Sri Bishambhar Manav, the erst-while tenant of the disputed property. The suit had been filed after serving necessary notice demanding arrears of rent and terminating the tenancy under Section 106 of the Transfer of Property Act. The suit was instituted before the District Judge as the valuation of the suit was above Rs. 5,000. The defendants filed their written statement except the appellant. The appellant was served through beat of drum and by affixation and this substituted service was deemed to be sufficient by the Court vide its order dated 19-1-1981. The suit was contested by the remaining defendants and ultimately it was decreed on 17-8-1982. A revision under Section 25 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act, was filed by the contesting defendants being Civil Revision No. 647 of 1982, but that too was dismissed on 8-12-1982. After the dismissal of the suit, when the execution was moved seeking delivery of possession, the appellant along with her brother Prabhat Sharma moved two applications before the Court below. The first application was under Order IX Rule 13 CPC read with Section 151 CPC which was registered as Miscellaneous Case No. 2 of 1983. The other objection was filed purporting to be one under Order XXXII Rule 5 read with Section 47 CPC. This was registered as Misc. Case No. 3 of 1983. The contents of both the objections were just the same and in both of them the appellant and her brother Prabhat Sharma were the objectors. Both these applications were, however, dismissed by an order dated 25-11-1987. The decision in Misc. Case No. 3 of 1983 because subject of Civil Revision No. 1004 of 1987 which was filed on behalf of both Prabhat Sharma and Mamta Sharma. The revision was heard and finally disposed of by Hon'ble V.K Mehrotra, J. on 4-2-1988 whereby the same was dismissed. (Prabhat Sharma v. Hari Shanker Srivastava) reported in 1988 (1) ARC 285. After the dismissal of the revision, the present FAFO has been filed on behalf of the appellant alone although initially in the memo both were mentioned as the appellants. It is also to be noted that although the name of Prabhat Sharma has been deleted from the array of the appellants, it has not been added in the array of respondents. Before this FAFO was admitted, counsel for the plaintiff-respondent put in appearance and with the consent of the parties, the appeal was taken up for admission as well as final disposal thereof. The parties were, therefore, permitted to file their counter and rejoinder affidavits. Subsequently, the parties have also filed supplementary counter affidavit and supplementary rejoinder affidavit.
3. Although several questions have been raised but a preliminary objection has been taken by the respondent regarding the maintainability of the appeal. It is submitted by Sri A.K Sand appearing for the Respondent No. 1 that the suit was tried by the Court below exercising the powers of a Judge Small Cause Courts and as such only a revision under Section 25 would lie and the appeal was not maintainable. He has also raised an objection that after the dismissal of Civil Revision No. 1004 of 1987, the present appeal is not maintainable inasmuch as on almost the same ground the Civil Revision had been filed and had been finally disposed of. It is lastly urged that the application under Order X Rule 13 CPC was not maintainable as the appellant had not complied with the requirement of Section 17 Provincial Small Cause Courts Act.
4. Since the matter can be disposed of on a preliminary ground, I do not wish to enter into other questions which were argued at length.
5. On the first question that the appeal does not lie, it may be mentioned here that a suit between lessor and lessee is now entertain able by the Court of Small Causes in this State after amendment brought in by U.P Act 37 of 1972. By a notification published in Uttar Pradesh Gazette Part I dated October 9, 1972, at page 5973, the State Government, in exercise of its powers under Sub-section (3) of Section 25 of the Bengal, Agra and Assam Civil Court Act, 1987, as amended by Uttar Pradesh Civil Laws (Amendment) Act, 1972, delegated its powers to the High Court under the said Section. In pursuance of this delegation, the High Court by its Notification No. 526 dated 25-10-1972 conferred upon all the District Judges and Additional District Judges jurisdiction of a Judge of the Court of Small Causes under the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act, 1887, for the trial of all suits (irrespective of their value) of the nature referred to in the said Sub-section (2). Sub-section (2) referred to above was introduced by means of an amendment to Section 25 of the Bengal, Agra and Assam Civil Courts Act, 1887 and is as follows:—
“The State Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette, confer upon any District Judge or any Additional District Judge the Jurisdiction of a Judge of a Court of Small Causes under the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act, 1887, for the trial of all suite (irrespective of their value) by the lessor for the eviction of a lessee from a building after the determination of his lease or for the recovery from him of rent in respect of the period of occupation thereof during the continuance of the lease or of compensation for the use and occupation thereof after such determination of lease, and may withdraw any jurisdiction so conferred.
Explanation.—For the purposes of this sub-section the explanation ‘building’ has the same meaning as in Article 4 in the Second Schedule to the said Act.”
6. Thus, in the light of the above provisions, all the District Judges and Additional District Judges in the State have been conferred with the powers of Judge Small Cause Courts under the Act of 1887 and such Courts have jurisdiction to decide suits between lessor and lessee for eviction etc. It is not disputed that the dispute in the present suit also related to one between lessor and lessee after the termination of the lease and, as such it was a suit which was cognizible by the Court of Small Causes. It is also undisputed that the suit was filed before the District Judge, Allahabad from where it was transferred to the IV Additional District Judge for trial. There is nothing to indicate that during the trial the procedure which is required for deciding small cause suit had been followed or not. Even in the final judgment it is not indicated that the Court had decided the suit while exercising the powers of a Judge Small Cause Courts. On this basis the learned Counsel for the appellant submitted that the suit had been tried on the regular side and as such the appeal was maintainable. In my opinion, this alone is not sufficient to determine whether the suit was a suit of a small cause nature or it was a regular suit. Merely because the Court does not mention that it was deciding a particular suit as a Court of Small Causes can not determine the nature of the suit if inherently the suit was of small cause nature. It is the substance of the suit which is material. In Bisheshwar Prasad Gautam v. Dr. R.K Agarwal, AIR 1977 Alld. 103, it was held that where a suit for ejectment and recovery of arrears of rent was brought as an ordinary suit, although under Section 9 of the U.P Civil Laws (Amendment) Act, 1972, the suit ought to have been transferred and tried on small cause side, it continue to refrain its nature namely, small causes. Almost similar situation arose before this Court in Trilok Singh v. Smt. Jamuna Devi, AIR 1978 Alld. 129, where a learned Single Judge of this Court, after taking notice of all the relevant provisions and the amendments made in U.P came to the conclusion that the pecuniary limit of Rs. 500 laid down by the proviso added to Section 15(3) of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act by U.P Civil Laws (Amendment) Act, 1972 does not apply to the jurisdiction of District Judges and Additional District Judges to try suite by lessor for the eviction of the lessee from a building after determination of his lease or for recovery from him rent etc. Where they have been conferred such jurisdiction in terms of Section 25(2) of the Bengal, Agra and Assam Civil Courts Act. In view of the above, it is quite obvious that it is not the procedure which has been adopted by the Court while disposing of the suit will determine the nature of the suit but it is the nature of jurisdiction exercised by the Court and the allegations made in the plaint which will determine the true nature of the suit.
7. In the present case, even if the Court had not mentioned that it was deciding the suit as a Judge of Small Causes Court, yet the very nature of the suit and the allegations made in the plaint clearly go to show that it was a suit of a Small Cause Court nature and the Court, thus, had the necessary jurisdiction to try the said suit and, therefore, it must be deemed to have been decided as a suit of small cause nature.
8. After reaching the above conclusion the question arises as to whether the above application under Order IX Rule 13 C.P.C was maintainable. It may be recalled that Section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Court Act lays down the procedure and reads as under:
“17. Application of the Code of Civil Procedure—(1) The procedure prescribed in the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 shall save in so far as is otherwise provided by that Code or by this Act, be the procedure followed in a Court of Small Causes in all suite cognizable by it, and in all proceedings arising out of such suits: Provided that as applicant for an order to set aside a decree passed ex-parte or for a review of judgment shall, at the time of presenting his application either deposit in the Court the amount due from him under the decree or in pursuance of judgment, or give such security for the performance, of the decree or compliance with the Judgment as the Court may, on a previous application made by him in this behalf, have directed.
9. Therefore, the ordinary procedure for making application under Order IX, Rule 13 C.P.C stands slightly modified in its application in case of an ex-parte decree passed by Court of Small Causes. An application under Order IX, Rule 13 C.P.C in such cases cannot be moved unless the amount decreed is deposited at the time of presenting the application. Admittedly, in the present case, this condition has not been complied with and, therefore, the application was liable to be dismissed only on this ground.
10. The appellant has also contended that the Trial Court has not given a clear finding as to whether the notice of the suit had in fact been served on the appellant. As mentioned earlier, service on the appellant was affected by beat of drum and by affixation. In the application, only this much has been stated that no service of the suit was ever affected on the applicant. For the same reason it was asserted that the proceedings against the appellant were a nullity and without jurisdiction because there was no service on her and she became aware of the existence of the decree only on 18-1-1983. The application was moved on 2-2-1983. In the application it was no where indicated that no affixation had been made and that no beat of drum had taken place. When the Court had specifically mentioned in its order dated 19-9-1981 that service on the appellant be deemed to be sufficient on account of beat of drum and affixation, it was the duty of the appellant to have set out in the application that there had been no beating of the drum at the time when it is alleged to have been done or there was no affixation of notice and such other facts on the basis of which she could not have been served. In the absence of any such material, it would be difficult for the plaintiff-respondent to lead any evidence to prove service. The Court below has, therefore, rightly mentioned that in view of the order passed by the Court on 19-9-1981, it must be deemed that service on her was sufficient in the absence of any specific ground why the service could not be deemed to be sufficient.
11. Several other points were also urged, but in my opinion they are not relevant at all because neither the application under Order IX Rule 13 C.P.C was maintainable nor the appeal is maintainable. In the result, the appeal fails and accordingly dismissed with costs.
12. Appeal dismissed.
Alert