Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Chandan Mishra And O... v. Convenor, M.B.B.S/B....

Orissa High Court
Dec 16, 1993
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Court Opinion (Pasayat, J. and R.K. Patra, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The State of Orissa conducted the M.B.B.S./B.D.S. entrance examination for the year 1993-94 under a prospectus approved by the State (G.O. No. 18686.H dated 19-5-1993). The examination consisted of 150 multiple-choice objective-type questions with four alternatives, of which only one was to be the most appropriately correct answer. The Selection Board evaluated candidates on the basis of 145 questions after excluding five questions which the Board itself considered defective; the Board also treated 12 questions as having more than one correct answer.

A large number of unsuccessful candidates challenged the validity of the examination by filing writ petitions, alleging widespread defects: printing and spelling errors, questions beyond prescribed +2 syllabus, unauthorized retention/handling of question papers and answer keys by the ex-Director (Dr. N.K. Satpathy) after his retirement, manual corrections and pastings on question papers, and at least one instance of a candidate being found in possession of a paper with answers. The Selection Board, the State and successful candidates defended the examination, arguing any irregularities affected all candidates equally and did not unduly prejudice any candidate.

The Court appointed four subject experts (by consent) to examine disputed questions and directed that their views would be binding on the parties. The experts produced reports identifying particular questions as defective, ambiguous, or having multiple correct answers. The Court considered these expert reports, evidence and the parties' submissions, and disposed of the writ petitions with directions (see Holding and Implications).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the manner of handling and custody of question papers and key answers (notably, possession by the ex-Director after retirement) and alleged possession of answer papers by a candidate vitiates the examination or warrants its cancellation.
  2. Whether printing errors, manual corrections/pasting, and alleged setting of questions beyond the prescribed +2 Science syllabus rendered the examination invalid or prejudiced candidates.
  3. How to treat questions that the Selection Board or experts have found to be defective, ambiguous, without any correct answer, or to have more than one correct answer—specifically, whether to exclude such questions or to award marks to candidates who chose alternative answers found correct by experts.
  4. Whether departures from prospectus stipulations (procedural breaches) automatically invalidate the examination or require a case-by-case assessment of prejudice and mandatory nature of the stipulations.
  5. Procedural question of remedy: whether re-evaluation/recalculation of marks and consequential modification of the selection list is appropriate and, if so, the manner and timeline for doing so.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The examination was rendered legally void or vitiated because a large number of questions were defective: some had no correct answer, some had more than one correct answer, and many contained printing/wording errors causing confusion and prejudice.
  • The ex-Director (Dr. N.K. Satpathy) retained question papers and key answers after retirement, handed papers to his successor only a day before the exam, and thus created a risk (or evidential basis) of leakage; this handling vitiated the secrecy and integrity of the examination.
  • Manual corrections and pasted strips on question papers show lack of secrecy and inadequate printing processes, which prejudiced candidates who had less than a minute per question and could be materially misled.
  • Some questions were alleged to be beyond the +2 Science syllabus prescribed in the prospectus, thereby unfairly disadvantaging certain candidates.
  • Where errors existed, candidates who answered according to the correct solutions (as determined by experts/textbooks) should be awarded marks; in the extreme, the petitioners sought annulment or other appropriate relief to protect merit and fairness.

Opposite Parties' and Intervenors' Arguments

  • Although the manner of conduct, printing defects and inaccuracies left much to be desired, the irregularities were common to all candidates and therefore did not place any candidate in a relatively better or worse position; prejudice was not specific to particular candidates.
  • Successful candidates should not suffer for administrative lapses of the examining body; the examination results should remain alive except to the extent accurate correction or limited remedial measures are necessary.
  • The Selection Board undertook moderation, sought second opinions and eventually fixed key answers; where some questions were found defective the Board itself excluded certain questions or indicated more than one correct answer for others.
  • It was argued that not every departure from prospectus stipulations automatically invalidates the process because many prospectus provisions are guidelines rather than peremptory (mandatory) conditions.
  • Some intervenors attempted to rely on textbook authorities to challenge experts' conclusions, and urged that the Court should not give overriding primacy to the Court-appointed experts' views.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
R v. Hodge, 1838, 2 Lewis C.C. 227 The caution against replacing proof by suspicion or conjecture; jurisprudential warning on inferring guilt from circumstances. The Court invoked the authority to emphasise that strong suspicion or circumstantial inferences cannot substitute for proof of leakage; the Court declined to invalidate the examination on suspicion alone.
Barindra v. R., 14 C.N. 1114 Similar approach as R v. Hodge regarding caution in drawing inferences from circumstances. The Court relied on the same cautionary principle to reject conclusions of leakage based merely on circumstantial facts without solid proof.
Kanpur University v. Samir Gupta, (1983) 4 SCC 309; A.I.R. 1983 S.C. 1280 Guidance on the character of multiple-choice objective questions and principle that when an examining body is alerted to a defect or ambiguity, prompt exclusion of the suspect question is appropriate; Court may grant relief where another answer is proved correct despite the official key. The Court used this authority to (a) delineate what constitutes a multiple-choice objective question and insist that only one correct answer is permissible in principle, and (b) to explain how defective questions should be treated (exclusion or awarding marks where alternative answers are shown correct).
Priyadarshini Acharya v. State of Orissa, 1991 (1) O.L.R. 514 Prior decision of this Court finding several questions incorrect and excluding them from evaluation; guidance that minor errors do not necessarily invalidate an exam and that exclusion of defective questions must be prompt and considered. The Court followed the approach in Priyadarshini to assess whether errors affected validity; it also relied on the case for recommendations (e.g., compilation of a test book) and procedural guidance on reserved categories.
Raghunath Pradhan v. State of Orissa, 1992 (11) O.L.R. 317 Earlier decision of this Court declaring certain questions not to satisfy the test of multiple-choice objective type questions and considering alternate answers supported by texts/experts. The Court cited Raghunath Pradhan to support the view that where authorities or experts demonstrate alternate answers are correct, those answers may be accepted and candidates given credit accordingly.
O.J.C. No. 8396 of 1992 & 18 others (Miss Uma Patnaik etc. v. Convenor, M.B.B.S/B.D.S. Selection Board) — disposed 10-5-1993 Procedural observations by this Court on reserved-category selections and on avoiding the post-examination practice of seeking different views after results; guidance on dealing with departures from prescribed procedure. The Court directed that the Selection Board consider reserved-category procedures in the revaluation and selection process in light of observations made in Miss Uma Patnaik's case, and criticized the practice of seeking post-hoc opinions after results are out.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in several interconnected steps, each rooted in findings of fact and established legal principles cited in the record:

  1. Custody and secrecy of question papers:
    • The facts established that Dr. N.K. Satpathy (ex-Director) retained the question manuscripts and key answers beyond his retirement date, handed question paper bundles to the new Director on 21-8-1993 (one day before the exam) and handed keys on 24-8-1993; manuscripts were later produced to the Court in sealed cover (30-11-1993).
    • The Court concluded that Dr. Satpathy's conduct was "unusual" and irregular; he should not have handled the material post-retirement. However, the Court found no definite material proving he leaked questions or key answers and held that suspicion, however strong, cannot replace proof. The Court invoked classic authorities (R v. Hodge and Barindra v. R.) to stress that inference without solid foundation is insufficient.
  2. Alleged leakage and possession of answer paper by a candidate:
    • One candidate was seized with a piece of paper containing answers to questions 81–140. Comparison showed 22 answers did not match the published key, leading to the conclusion that the seized paper did not constitute the key answers; nevertheless, the authorities erred by valuing that candidate's answer sheet instead of expelling him under Clause 8.8.4 of the prospectus. The Court condemned the authorities for that breach.
    • The Court reiterated that malpractices must be addressed according to prospectus rules but that the existence of malpractice alone (in the absence of proof of systemic leakage) did not automatically vitiate the entire examination.
  3. Printing errors, manual corrections and pasting:
    • The Court accepted that printing mistakes, manual corrections and pasted strips on question papers were widespread and indicative of unsatisfactory printing practice. The Court found these to demonstrate lack of adequate care but held that such defects did not ipso facto invalidate the examination unless shown to have caused serious prejudice.
    • Experts (appointed by the Court) reported that many printing errors were of a negligent character and that an average student could deduce the intended correct wording; in past related cases, similar errors had not been held to affect validity where no serious prejudice was shown.
  4. Nature of multiple-choice objective questions:
    • Relying on Kanpur University and related decisions, the Court emphasised the conceptual distinction: multiple-choice questions should have one correct answer (the rest being distractors). The Court held that the Selection Board failed to provide 150 clear objective-type questions per the prospectus.
    • The Court rejected the submission that multiple choice implies multiple correct answers; instead, it clarified the Board's acceptance of more-than-one-key answer in certain questions was contrary to the principle of single-correct-answer MCQs, although where the Board itself accepted multiple answers that factored into the Court's remedial approach.
  5. Assessment of prejudice and remedy:
    • The Court balanced two considerations: whether defective questions prejudiced particular candidates and whether the defects conferred advantage or disadvantage. The Court noted the narrow margin between success and failure (46 candidates had 123 marks; clause 9.3 of prospectus was used to select few), which raised the possibility that awarding or withholding a single mark could alter selection.
    • The Court appointed four experts by consensus to determine which disputed questions were defective, ambiguous, had multiple correct answers, or were beyond the +2 syllabus. The experts' reports (with reasons) were considered binding on the parties because their names were jointly proposed and accepted and they were eminent in their fields.
    • The Court accepted the experts' findings on particular questions and ordered revaluation of answer scripts so that candidates who had given answers indicated by the experts as correct would receive marks if not already granted (specific questions and dispositions are identified in the judgment). The Court applied the logic that where the Board itself had accepted multiple answers or where moderators disagreed, the experts' views could not be ignored.
  6. Treatment of prospectus stipulations and procedural breaches:
    • The Court differentiated between mandatory/peremptory provisions and guideline-like stipulations in the prospectus. It held that mere non-observance of guideline provisions does not automatically invalidate the examination; only breaches of mandatory stipulations leading to demonstrable prejudice would corrode the action.
    • The Court nevertheless criticised recurrent laxity and directed remedial administrative steps (including enquiry) to prevent recurring defects.
  7. Practical directions and timeline:
    • The Court directed revaluation of answer scripts in respect of eight questions (as identified by the experts and the Court) and ordered that marks be awarded where appropriate; after revaluation the Board was to publish a fresh selection list applying clause 9.3 of the prospectus to select candidates who are similarly or better placed than the last candidate selected.
    • The Court directed the revaluation to be completed and a fresh list published within two weeks, with admissions to follow immediately; if required, seats were to be increased and the State was to take steps with the Medical Council/Union of India to facilitate that.
    • The Court ordered the Chief Secretary of the State to enquire into systemic failures of the examining body and file a report within three months.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The writ applications were disposed of by the Court with specific remedial directions.

Principal operative consequences for the parties:

  • The Court ordered revaluation of answer scripts in respect of questions identified by the Court and the experts. Candidates who had given the answers the experts determined to be correct shall be awarded marks if not already given.
  • Following revaluation, the Selection Board must publish a fresh list of selected candidates within two weeks and admissions shall proceed immediately thereafter.
  • The selection after revaluation is to include candidates who are similarly or better placed than the last candidate selected by application of clause 9.3 of the prospectus; if necessary, the State and appropriate authorities (including the Medical Council/Union of India) shall take steps to increase seats or reallocate from central pools so that the judgment can be given effect to forthwith.
  • The Court directed the Chief Secretary to enquire into systemic defects in examination preparation/conduct and submit a report within three months so that administrative remedies may be explored going forward.
  • The Court required that the selection board take reserved-category procedures into account as per observations made in Miss Uma Patnaik's case when implementing revaluation results.

The judgment emphasises that (a) not every administrative lapse or printing defect automatically invalidates an examination; (b) suspicion of leakage without solid proof is insufficient to annul an exam; and (c) where specific errors/ambiguities are shown (and particularly where experts demonstrate alternative correct answers), limited remedies such as revaluation and awarding of marks may be appropriate rather than wholesale annulment. The Court also expressed strong administrative criticism of recurrent careless practices, recommended institutional reforms (e.g., State-compiled test book and expert modulation of objective questions) and required an inquiry into the examining body's functioning. The Court's directions are remedial and case-specific; the opinion does not purport to set a new general precedent beyond applying and following the principles and prior authorities cited.

Disposition: Writ applications disposed of in accordance with the directions recorded in the opinion.

Show all summary ...

A. Pasayat, J.:— Shakespeare in Othello has written “Chaos is come again”. This Court has witnessed chaos almost annually when time for admission to M.B.B.S/B.D.S courses came. Large number of candidates who appeared at the annual entrance examination for selection of candidates for admission to M.B.B.S/B.D.S courses 1993-94 allege that they are victims of “examination malady and chaos” and pray for a declaration that the entrance examination is legally dead. The State of Orissa, Convenor of the examination and many of the candidates who Were declared to have come out successful in the entrance examination submit that notwithstanding the deficiency in questions/answers the results should be declared to be alive. Such post-examination scrutiny has become almost a ritualistic feature. Winston Churchil has said; “......it would be wrong not to lay the lessons of the past before the future” (The Second World War The Gathering Storm). But the examining body does not appear to have done so.

2. Thumb nail description of the scenario is as follows:—

A prospectus approved by the Government of Orissa, Health and Family Welfare Department in G.O No. 18686.H. dated 19th May, 1993 was issued wherein it was stipulated that the candidates taking the examination are to answer 150 multiple choice objective type questions. Four alternative answers were indicated against each question. According to the examining body only one of them is the most appropriately correct answer. In the question paper at instruction No. 5, it was indicated that the set containing multiple choice type of questions has one correct or one most appropriately correct answer to each question out of the four suggested answers given. Instruction No. 8 stipulated that in the answer sheet against each question numbered, the candidate was required to cross the alphabet box, which he/she thought to be correct or most appropriately correct answer. The body selects the correct answer or most appropriately correct answer which is normally called the ‘key answer’. The undisputed position, is that marking has been done out of 145. The basis for exclusion of 5 marks is stated to be the view of the selection body that five of the questions did not have any correct answer and/or, because of inaccuracy. Question No. 40 was to be excluded from consideration. In addition 11 questions were indicated to have more than one correct answer.

3. There is unanimity amongst the petitioners, the opposite parties and the intervenors that the manner in which the examination has been conducted, questions have been set and key answers indicated leaves much to be desired. The effect thereof, however, does not have concurrence of all concerned, while the petitioners maintain that the examination was vitiated, the opposite parties and the intervenors submit that the prejudice emanating from such irregularity was common to all concerned and not a single candidate was unduly and/or unequally prejudiced on account of such irregularity. According to them the successful candidate have not derived any undue benefit because of it, and the unsuccessful on the other hand have not been affected unduly in the manner. Additionally they submit that the successful candidates have no role to play in the chaos, and they should not be made to suffer for the laches, if any, of the examining body. We shall deal about correctness of questions and answers in detail infra. The grievance of the unsuccessful Candidates can be categorised in to following broad heads:—

(i) Because of large number of questions which have been accepted by examining body to be either wrong or having more than one correct answer, the examination lost its vitality and there was no scope for evaluation of merit.

(ii) Many questions do not have any correct answer, or have more than one correct answer or the questions are themselves not correct, in addition to those accepted to be so by the examining body.

(iii) The examination has become a mockery because the Director who relinquished office with effect from the close of 31st July, 1993, continued to be in possession of the question papers and key answers. It is accepted that the question papers were handed over by the ex-Director to the present incumbent on 21-8-1993, i.e, a day before the entrance examination. The ex Director continued to be in possession of the key answers till 24-8-1993.

(iv) In a large number of cases manual corrections were made in the question papers, and in some strips of papers were pasted. This clearly shows that secrecy of the examination was not maintained, and that vitiated the examination. There was leakage of the questions/answers because one of the candidates was in possession of the key answers written on a piece of paper, which was seized by the invigilator and a report was lodged against the erring candidate the Nuabazar High School Centre. Specific allegations in this regard have been made in O.J.C No. 8593 of 1993 (Santoshi Sahoo v. State of Orissa).

(v) There are large number of errors in the questions/answers, which though claimed to be printing errors, affect the process of selection. It is relevant to mention here that the factual aspects are undisputed.

4. It is not in dispute that the ex-Director continued to possess the question papers till 21-8-1993 and the key answers till 24-8-1993. The manuscripts were produced before us in a sealed cover on 30-11-1993. It is not in dispute that strips of papers had been posted on the question papers and/or manual corrections were made. It is stated in the counter affidavit of the State and its functionaries that the corrections might have been made in the press where the question papers were printed and there was no scope for making such corrections elsewhere. It is further stated that on receipt of complaints about inaccuracies in the questions/answers the matter was referred to two sets of moderators, and this was done to wipe out any doubt about corrections of the questions and/or key answers and after elaborate consideration of the question setters, and the two sets of moderators, the key answers were finally settled and declaration of the results was made. Five questions were kept out of consideration because they were not either intrinsically correct and in one case pasting was done over the answers in only some question papers. The questions which have been kept out of consideration are 29, 71, 73, 77 and 40. The last one relates to pasting of strip of paper. In respect of questions 2, 10, 34, 49, 51, 75, 80, 81, 84, 85, 101 and 127 it has been accepted that there were more than one key answer.

5. We shall first deal with the question whether necessary measures were taken to ensure the secrecy of question papers. The undisputed factual position is that Dr. N.K Satpathy had retired on 31-7-1993. He handed over the question papers on 21-8-1993 to the present Director and the Convenor. The examination was held on 22-8-1993 and the key answers were banded over by Dr. Satpathy to the present Director on 24-8-1993 and the manuscript continued to be with Dr. Satpathy till they were handed over in sealed cover in this Court on 30-11-1993. It needs no microscopic examination to come to a conclusion that the course adopted by Dr. Satpathy is unusual. It is submitted by the learned counsel for State in that in the past also the Director who bad initiated the process of examination continued to be in charge till the examination was over. We find no substance in this plea. The composition of the Selection Board has been prescribed in the prospectus itself on the basis of Government orders. The Director nominated is by virtue of office held by him or her, and not by name. The stress was on the persons designate holding office by virtue of office held, as is evident from the prescription in the prospectus in Note (i) to Clause 1.1 to the effect that in the case of change in the composition, a notification in official gazette and in the notice board of there Medical Colleges is necessary. Dr. Satpathy, therefore, should not have handled the matter, which is a sensitive one relating to examination for selection of candidates for adminission to M.B.B.S/B.D.S courses, where the fate of a large number of “students is involved. No scope should have been given to make a grievance that an unauthorised person handled question papers and/or key answers. We are, therefore, in agreement with the submission of the learned counsel for petitioners that Dr. Satpathy should not have handled the question papers and/or key answers after his retirement. That leaves us with the question whether the examination was vitiated on that score. Dr. Satpathy, the ex-Director was authorised and competent to handle the question papers and key answers for the year 1993-94 till the date of retirement. Nobody could have possibly questioned his competence and authority till that day. Even though he handled the question papers after that date it cannot be said that it led to the leakage of question papers. Had he intended to leak out the question and/or the key answers, he had the opportunity to do so before his date of retirement and would not have waited to do so after his retirement. His credibility has not been questioned till the date of retirement. Can it be said that it was affected by vulnerability after his retirement “? Did he suddenly suffer from as ailment which can be diagnosed as urge to leak out questions and/or answers? That conclusion would not be proper, though he acted with apparent irregularity in handling the question papers and/or key answers after his retirement.

6. The learned counsel for petitioners have submitted that inferentially conclusions can be arrived at about leakage of question papers and/or key answers. Inference can be drawn from facts, presumptions can be made if a solid foundation is laid. There is no definite material placed before us to show that there was any leakage as alleged. Suspicion however strong cannot take the place of proof. It is true, direct evidence would be hard to comeby in almost all cases involving leakage. In such cases, probabilities and tell-tale circumstances can be considered. “Some circumstantial evidence is very strong, as when you find a trout in the milk”. (Thoreau, Journal, November, 1850). But before those can be acted upon, it has to be held that they lean heavily in favour of the view “must be”, and not “may be”. The mind is apt to take a pleasure in adopting circumstances to one another, and even in straining them a little, if need be, to force them to form parts of one connected whole; and the more ingenious the mind of the individual, the more likely is it, considering such matters, to overreach and mislead itself, to supply same little link that is wanting, to take for granted some fact consistant with its previous theories and necessary to render them complete. The aforesaid warning was addressed by Baron Elderson to the jury in R v. Hodge; 1838 2 Lewis C.C 227. The same approach was adopted by Jenkins C.J in Barindra v. R., 14 C.N 1114. When one is at the outset strongly impressed with the truth of a case as a whole, it is obviously all, the more necessary to be on one's guard against approaching with prejudice or unconscious bins the respective cases of the individuals concerned and one must be very careful not to allow conjecture or suspicion to take the place of legal proof. Suspicion though a ground for scrutiny of evidence cannot be made the foundation of a judicial decision. We however, feel tempted to quote, Ambrose Bierse (in the Devil's Dictionary): “Don't steal thou It never thus compete; Successfully in business Cheat”. A faint attempt was made by Mr. Sanjit Mohanty, learned counsel appearing for some of the petitioners to show that the very fact that a candidate secured 135 marks out of the marks of 145 itself is a circumstance to prove leakage. The plea is plainly untenable. In the past days a candidate securing top position in the High School Certificate Examination, was securing 72% to 73% of the total marks. These days candidates securing more than 80% marks are even not getting admission in certain streams in reputed institutions of the State. Merely because a candidate has secured high percentage of marks, that cannot be basis for a conclusion of leakage of question papers/key answers. A candidate may be extremely brilliant. Without any other material to establish the allegation of leakage it would be undesirable to attribute unfairness as the basis for securing high marks.

7. So far as allegations as regards possession of key answers during examination as made in O.J.C No. 8593 of 1993 are concerned, from the counter affidavit we find that in fact the candidate was in possession of a piece of paper where certain answers were indicated against question Nos. 81 to 140. The same was seized. On comparison of the answers indicated therein vis-a-vis the published key answers, it is seen that they do not tally in respect of 22 questions. It therefore, follows that the candidate was not in possession of key answers during examination. But the manner in which the erring candidate has been dealt with shows the scant regard authorities have for guidelines and instructions. Clause 8.8.4 of the prospectus clearly stipulates that a candidate resorting to unfair means shall be expelled from the examination and his candidature shall be rejected. Instead of acting in terms of Clause 8.8.4, the authorities have valued the answer sheet of the candidate. The authorities deserve condemnation for their irresponsible act, and we do so. Since we are considering non-observance of stipulations, it would be proper to deal with a plea of the petitioners relating to effect thereof. It is emphasised that many stipulations were followed more in breach than observance. That according to them, vitiates the selection. It cannot be gainsaid that procedures are prescribed to be followed. But in all cases, departure would not render the action vulnerable. Only when the procedures have mandatory character, breach would corrode the action, otherwise not. Stipulations in the prospectus appear to be in the nature of guidelines, without being mandatory in nature. Sufficient care and caution should have been taken to follow the stipulations. That unfortunately has not been done.

8. Before proceeding further, we shall deal with the plea of petitioners about absolutely unsatisfactory manner in which the question papers were handled. It is undisputed that in large number of questions pasting was made on the key answers in respect of question No. 40, and manual corrections were made in respect of several other questions and/or key answers. From the - affidavits filed by opp. parties, we find that a plea has been taken that the corrections may have been made at the press because after the question papers were received in sealed packets and were distributed, it could be noticed that there were manual corrections. From this it is inferred by the opp. parties that the corrections had been made at the press. Though a submission was made by the learned counsel for petitioners that we should direct the management of the press to file affidavits as to who carried out the corrections, at what stage, and/or the necessity for making such corrections, we do not think it to be appropriate as the same would expose the name of the printer. The manual corrections cannot per se lead to an irresistible conclusion about leakage of question papers, thereby affecting its secrecy. But in the absence of definite material about leakage of answer papers, we do not propose to probe into the matter as to who made the corrections, at what stage and what precautions were taken to ensure secrecy. But it goes without saying that the manner in which the question papers had been printed is certainly unsatisfactory. The fact that pastings had been made, and manual corrections had been carried out goes to show that adequate care was not taken to make the questions defect-free. The printing should have been done in a more careful “manner to avoid any sort of controversy.

9. Added to that the printing errors are very large in number. The petitioners with reference to large number of errors in the questions and key answers have asserted that they were led to confusions, were materially prejudiced. According to them, the time available for answering each question is less than a minute. In such a situation there should not be scope for any confusion because of wrong printing of the questions and/or key answers. We are in agreement with the submission that there should not be any printing error. But the question is whether the candidates were confused and/or prejudiced. As rightly observed by some of the experts appointed by our order dated 12-11-1993, the errors were of such negligence character that any average student can know what the correct word was and would not be confused. As observed by a Bench of this Court to which one of us (Pasayat, J. was a member) in O.J.C No. 8396 of 1992 and 18 others (Miss Uma Patnaik etc. etc. v. Convenor, M.B.B.S/B.D.S Selection Board) disposed of on 10-5-1993 relating to admission of candidates to M.B.B.S/B.D.S courses for the year 1992-93, such errors though unfortunate did not affect the validity of examination, and did not cause any serious prejudice. It was submitted by the learned counsel for petitioners that question No. 71 has been kept out of consideration on account of a printing error in the question itself. We find that mistake was substantial, even though it was in relation to a particular letter. Printing errors in the question led to a situation, where none of the answers would be correct, and therefore, the Board has decided to keep that question out of consideration altogether.

10. After dealing with unsatisfactory manner in which the examination has been conducted which we have held is of no consequence so far as validity of examination is concerned, the nodal problem which was highlighted before us by the petitioners merits careful consideration. The candidates were required to answer 150 multiple choise objective questions. At this stage it is desirable to delineate what a multiple question is. The position was illuminatingly stated by the apex Court in Kanpur University v. Samir Gupta, (1983) 4 SCC 309 : A.I.R 1983 S.C 1280, and followed by this Court in Priyadarshini Ackarya etc. etc. v. State of Orissa represented by the Secretary, Departmet of Health, 1991(1) O.L.R 514, and Raghanath Pradhanv. State of Orissa, represented by the Secretary to Government, Health and Famil Welfare Department, Bhubaneswar, 1992(11) O.L.R 317.

11. An objective type question is one where alternative answers are given and the candidates have to indicate the correct answer by some signs (in the instant case by putting X mark). Objective-based and objective type questions are often confused with each other. In the former, a question is framed with deliberate attention to the objective which is to be measured. In the latter, the question is designed to gauge the depth of the candidates' knowledge of the subject. Prof. Dr. B.K Behura (one of the experts chosen by this Court) has observed that for effective selection, the following pattern should be adopted while formulating questions:

“40% based on knowledge', 30% based on understanding of the subject; and 30% on application.”

12. Objective type questions can be classified into (a) true-false type, (b) matching type, (c) sentence completion type, and (d) multiple choice type. The last category is one where the question is composed in the form of a statement or a question followed by four alternative choices. The correct choice may be only correct answer or only wrong answer type. The incorrect choices in a multiple choice question are normally called distractors. Externally the correct answer and distractors should appear similar.

13. The stand of the opposite parties and the intervenors is that in the cases of Priyadarshini Acharya and Raghunatk Pradhan (supra) this Court has accepted that there can be more than one correct answers in respect of one question, and had granted relief, and therefore, there is nothing wrong in the selection board indicating more than one correct answers in respect of certain questions. According to them, in an objective type question the possibility of there being more than one correct answers is not completely ruled out. The plea is clearly untenable. It was nowhere observed in the aforesaid two cases that an objective type question can have more than one correct answers. In these cases, correctness of alternative answers which were proved to be correct, notwithstanding the stand of the examining body that the concerned question had only one correct or most appropriately correct answer. In Kanpur University's case (supra) the appex Court had observed that even though one answer was indicated to be the correct answer, yet when it is proved that another answer was correct and/or the key answer is incorrect the Court can grant appropriate relief. It was nowhere held that in an objective multiple choice question, there can be more than one correct answer. Emphasis is laid on the expression “multiple choice” by the learned Government Advocate to submit that the choice is more than one. It is not in doubt that the choice is more than one, but the correct answer has to be one. Four different choices are given, out of which a candidate is required to pick up one which, according to him is the correct or most appropriately correct one. To test merit of the candidate and his knowledge of the subject, different choices are placed before him. Each one of them appears to be correct, but only one of them has to be indicated to be correct. As indicated above, except the correct one, others are distractors, and are redherrings introduced by the examiner in order to find out whether a candidate is actually well equipped, to be selected or is just taking a chance. The object and purpose for which the objective questions are set are to find out the depth of a candidate's knowledge, and the ability to pick up a correct answer. There may be cases where per chance a candidate may pick up a correct answer. This is inevitable. But by and large, a really meritorious student can pick up the correct answers on the basis of his knowledge of the subject. Therefore, the examining body has indubitably failed to indicate 150 objective type questions, notwithstanding clear stipulation in the prospectus.

14. (sic) Here again question arises how it has prejudiced the candidates. According to the petitioners, there was bound to be confusion. The plea revolves round (i) the five questions which the examining body itself blocked out, and awarded marks out of 145, and (ii) questions for which more than one correct answers have been indicated. Here distinction between vulnerability and non-vulnerability is razor edge. We notice that the last candidate who has been declared selected has secured 123 marks. It is apparent from the affidavit filed by the opposite parties that forty-six candidates secured 123 marks but on the basis of clause 9.3 of the prospectus only six have been selected for admission to M.B.B.S course and thirteen to B.D.S course. That show the thinness between success and failure. While some candidates with identical marks have been selected, some others are left out. It is pleaded by the learned counsel far petitioners that if five more correct questions could have been given by those left out and less than that by those selected it is not known what would have been the position. Surfacially the argument appears to be on terra firma. But here again there is a question of “ifs and buts”. Each candidates was equally confronted with the wrong question. The selected candidates were not placed in better position because of that.

15. In Kanpur University's case (supra) the Apex Court observed that if the attention of the examining body is drawn to any defect in a key answer or any ambiguity in a question set in the examination, prompt and timely decision must be taken to declare that the suspect question will be excluded from the paper and no marks assigned to it. Similar view was expressed in Priyadarshni's case (supra). But can such elimination be carried out to point of no return? Merely because, such act is permissible, it cannot be done as a matter of course. The learned Government Advocate fairly stated that when the number is unusually large, the selection becomes vulnerable, but submitted that the case at hand is not that alarming. Without probing into the question as to at what stage the resistance limit of nonvulnerability would be exceeded being of the view that all the candidates were equally situated on account of these five questions, we do not think it appropriate to nullify the examination on that score.

16. (sic) So far as questions where more than one correct answers were indicated are concerned, as discussed above, the questions were certainly not objective type questions. The Board itself accepted that there were more than one correct answers. It is an advantageous position for the candidates where more than one correct answers are indicated, as answering any one of them to be correct answer would have fetched a mark. Here again it is highlighted by the learned counsel for petitioners that the candidates were confused. But since there was advantage and not disadvantage because of more than One correct answers, it also cannot be a ground for holding that the examination was invalid.

17. (sic) Large number of questions were attacked by the petitioners on the ground that they are either incorrect questions and/or carry correct answers, in addition to those indicated by the examining body. The learned Advocate General suggested that in respect of such disputed questions opinion of experts may be sought for. On the consent of learned counsel for petitioners opposite parties and intervenors, four persons were selected. The parties were asked to give their choice before such selection. They all agreed to the selection of Dr. Harihar Misra for Physics, Dr. Phanibhusan Das for Chemistry, Dr. Harihar Patnaik fox Botany and Dr. Basant Kumar Behura for Zoology. The learned counsel for parties agreed that the views of these Experts shall be binding on each one of them. The Experts were asked to indicate, whether the key answers were correct or were not, whether any question had more than one correct answers and whether they were within the prescribed courses of studies. It is urged that the questions were required to be set from courses of studies/syllabus meant for +2 Science classes as prescribed by the Council of Higher Secondary Education, Orissa. The relevant clause in the prospectus on which reliance was placed reads as follows:—

“4.1 Must have passed the qualifying examination: Note — Qualifying examination means the +2 stage/I.Sc with English, Physics, Chemistry, and Biology (Botany and Zoology) from the Council of Higher Secondary Education, Orissa/any University of Orissa or any other examination recognised as equivalent thereto by the Council of Higher Secondary Education, Orissa, Universities of Orissa to which the Medical Colleges are affiliated.”

18. As directed by us, the experts have furnished their reports. From their reports, it is noticed that they expressed the following views:

Subject Question I. PHYSICS: No. Correct answer As per As per Expert Key answer Remarks of the Expert. 1 (b) (d). Not properly worded 2 (b) (b), (c) 10(d) Wrongly worded by use of word ‘produced’-Board (c), (d) 28 (d) (c) 29 All answers Excluded by - wrong due to examining omission of ‘mole’ body. 34 (d) is the most appropriately correct answer According to Board (c), (d) 40 II. CHEMISTRY: Has a correct answer as given in the pasted paper. Excluded by examining body. 41 (a) (b) 49 (c) (b)/(c) Two answers given are ambiguous. 51 (b), (c), (d) (b), (c), (d) Ambiguous 55 None is correct (b) Ambiguous 71 Printing mistake Excluded by examining body. 73 None of the four answers is correct Excluded by examining body. 75 (b) (a), (b) (d) Three answers are given which are not correct (ambiguous). 77 Question is defective. Cancelled by Board. III. BOTANY: 81 All the four correct. 83 (c) (b) Printing mistake in correct answer. 85 (d) (a), (d) 99 (b) (i) There is a printing mistake which may create confusion. (ii) Symbol of omega has been wrongly printed.

19. They have also indicated that various questions are beyond the courses of studies for +2 Science classes, as prescribed by the Council of Higher Secondary Education, Orissa. An objection was raised when the matter was taken up on 2nd and 3rd December, 1993 that the Experts have not given any reason for their coming to the conclusion in respect of various questions. Though all the parties agreed that the reports of the Experts would be binding on all concerned, in order to give a finality we asked the Experts to give reasons for their conclusions. Further reports have been submitted by them. With reference to various text books, the learned counsel for intervenors have tried to support the conclusion of the Boad that the correct answers as indicated by the Board are correct. They have prayed for discarding the views of the Experts. We express our displeasure for such submission. We hold such plea as fence sitter's plea. It was agreed by all the parties that the views of the Experts would be binding on them. Each of the Experts selected is a man of eminance in the field of his respective subject and almost is a household name in the State. They are widely respected persons and are considered to be the last words in concerned subjects. Two of them are retired Vice-Chancellors, one of them is the President of Board of Secondary Education, Orissa. It was submitted that the Experts may be “Dronas” but the authors on whose books intervenors rely are “Arjunas”. Almost a pathetic plea was taken that some of them have retired from office, and might have lost touch over the subject. The plea according to us is frivolous and ridiculous. While their names were suggested by the parties, almost in one voice, each of the learned counsel stated that no one can question their depth of knowledge and mastery over the subject, and, therefore, their names were so suggested. Now that their views have gone against the views of the Board, it is not proper for the intervenors to say that views of the Experts should not be accepted. It would be showing disrespect to those honoured scholars. It is unfortunate that a plea has been taken that they have lost touch of the subjects. A master never forgets his subject. They belong to the old school of learning. Notwithstanding the advancement in the field of education for various subjects. It is unthinkable that they even have no grip over questions and answers which were required to be dealt with by students of +2 Science level. A plea was taken that ultimately the Court being experts of Expert should express its own view uninfluenced by the view expressed by Experts. It is true that ultimate decision is ours, but we cannot claim any specialised knowledge over various subjects. Therefore, we had sought for views of Experts. The choice of Experts was with consent of all concerned, and we find no reason to keep the reports of Experts out of consideration. They have given reasons. The question is what would be the effect of Experts' reports. At this juncture the intimatble words of Bertrant Russel in “The Sceptical Essays” come to mind-Even when the experts all agree, they may well be mistaken”. In lighter vein Nicholas M. Butler in his commencement address had said “An expert is one who knows more and more about less and less”. Here we have four persons who have spent almost half a century each in libraries, laboratories and class-rooms, shaping the future of thousand of students. Some of those fortunate ones are those whose views are pressed before us to be given preference ever their revered Gurus. By accepting the prayer for rejection of their views, we may set an unhealthy precedent. The intellectual masters may feel shy in future to give their views, lest intellectual pigmies may question their view, and thereby their wisdom may be doubted. As observed by the apex Court in Kanpur University's case (supra), where it is shown by a candidate that another answer is correct, and is backed by views of authors, experts, and text hooks, credit has to be given. This Court in Raghunath Pradhan's case (supra) had referred to various text books and had observed that in addition to the key answers indicated by the Board, other answers can be taken as correct. We are, therefore, of the view that those candidates who have given the same answer as indicated by the Experts to be correct answers, are entitled to marks. It is to be noticed here that the question setters were required to indicate the key answers which they provided. The Board sought for the views of the persons whom they called moderators, as regards correctness of the answers given. Since in respect of some questions they indicated answers different from those indicated by the question setters, views of other persons (stated by the opposite parties to be second set of moderators) were sought for. They interestingly gave different answers in respect of some questions. It appears from the counter affidavit of the selection Board that after taking note of all the views in respect of certain questions, more than one correct answers were indicated to be correct and this is how in twelve questions, more than one correct answers were indicated. If that be so, we find no reason as to why the views of the Experts nominated by this Court can be ignored. Since the Board has accepted the views of different persons whom it called as moderators and on the basis of their views, has indicated more than one correct answers in respect of certain questions, we find that to be an additional reason for which the candidates who have indicated the same answer as indicated by the Experts nominated by this Court, deserve marks in respect of such questions. The questions and corresponding answers are as follows:—

Question No. Answer 1 (b) 28 (d) 41 (a) 83 (c)

20. In respect of question No. 10, we find that the word “produced” has been used. It is not disputed that the word is inappropriate and with the same, no sense is conveyed by the question, and is utterly confusing. Each candidate who has not been awarded a mark in respect of that question shall be awarded a mark. In respect of question No. 75 the Expert has opined the Question to be ambiguous, while the key answers have been indicated to be (a), (b), (d). Every candidate who has not got a mark in respect of that question shall be awarded a mark. In respect of question No. 55, the Expert has opined that there is no correct answer and there is ambiguity in the question. The correct answer has been indicated to be [Fe(NO)] SO4. In that view of the matter, every candidate who has not got a mark in respect of that question shall be awarded a mark. In respect of question No. 99, the Expert has indicated (b) to be the correct answer which is also the answer given by the examining body. But the Expert has opined that there is a printing mistake which may create confusion since the symbol of Omega has been wrongly printed. This being the position, every candidate who has not been awarded a mark in respect of that question shall be awarded a mark.

21. It may be noted here that in respect of questions 2, 34, 49 and 85, the Experts have indicated specific answers, but according to the Selection Board, the question carry more than one correct answers. Since the answers indicated by the Experts are covered by the Board's key answers, no further mark can be awarded in respect of those questions. Accordingly we direct that the answer scripts be revalued, and if a candidate has answered any question by indicating the answer as indicated by the Experts to be the correct, the shall be given a mark in respect of that question, if he has not already been given a mark. After the revaluation, the Board shall publish a fresh list of selected candidates. The selection shall be made of those candidates who are either similarly or better placed than the last candidate selected by application of clause 9.3 of the prospectus. Since revaluation is to be made in respect of eight questions, any candidate who has secured less than 115 marks cannot come within the sone of consideration even if he secures full marks in respect of the aforesaid eight questions. The selection shall be made in addition to those who have been selected. The revaluation be done within two weeks from today and the result of selected candidates be published within that time and admissions be made immediately without further loss of time. If necessity arises, requisite number of seats shall be increased. Union of India and Indian Medical Council are parties in some of the writ applications and are represented by counsel. The State Government shall take appropriate steps with the Council in the matter of increase of seats, if necessary, so that our judgment is given effect to forthwith. If necessary steps may be taken for release of available seats from thd Central pool.

22. It is stated by the learned counsel for petitioners that the questions were beyond the prescribed courses of studies. The learned counsel for the opposite parties and the intervenors have submitted that the examination is not limited to only students who have taken +2 Science examination conducted by the Council of Higher Secondary Education. It is also submitted that the questions under challenge are taught in C.B.S.E/I.C.S.E courses. It is porper that the examining body should ensure that questions are set out of those topics which are common in all Boards of Councils. It is so desirable, because a particular topic may be taught in one Council/Board and may not be taught in another. The students who have not been taught the topics are certainly to be affected. The Experts were asked to give opinion whether questions were covered by the courses of studies of+2 Science examination level as conducted by the Council of Higher Secondary Education, Orissa. They have given their opinion in the negative. The language used in clause 8, 7 of the prospectus is that questions relate to various subjects taught at the qualifying examination level. We asked the learned counsel for petitioner to show that the questions are out of topics which were meant for higher level than+2 Science courses. No definite material was placed by them in that regard. The learned counsel for intervenors have produced certain books before us to show that those topics are taught at lower level, i.e, in clauses IX and X. We are, therefore, of the view that the questions cannot be said to be above +2 Science level. The questions would have become vulnerable and would have affected the candidates, if they are of a higher level. If any question is set below than the leval, then the candidates cannot be said to have been prejudiced. We, therefore, do not accept the submission made by the learned counsel for petitioners that the questions set were not within the +2 Science syllabus as prescribed by the Council of Higher Secondary Education, Orissa, and therefore, the examination was vitiated.

23. To avoid unnecessary controversy and to maintain parity and uniformity, the State Government should compile a test book under its auspices, which can be prescribed for students desirous of appearing at the entrance examinations. This recommendation in Kanpur University's case and Priyadarshini's case (supra) does not appear to have been taken note of by the State which is unfortunate. Year after year large number of applications have been filed for varifying correctness of evaluation made by the examining body which involves future of thousand of students. This year we find 12, 521 students took the test. In other words, the future of thousands of aspirants for admission to professional course was at stake. The disease continues year after year without any visible effort for finding out the remedy. Henceforth the questions should be modulated by a body of Experts chosen by the State Government and objective type questions should be set in such a manner that questions having ambiguous import are not set. Answers should contain one correct answer and the rest should be distractors leaving no scope for reasoning or argument except merely involving tick-marking the correct answer. The questions, therefore, should be clear and unequivocal. We are of the view that the reason for which the examining body has failed to perform its duties properly leading to numerous controversies needs to be investigated. We direct the Chief Secretary of the State to enquire into the matter and submit a report to this Court within three months from today so that the matter can be further looked into to find out the remedy. This, however, shall not stand on the way of the opposite parties in carrying out our directions contained hereinbefore.

24. In cartain writ applications it is asserted that due procedure has not been followed in the matter of selection for reserved categories. The procedure to be adopted relating to reserved categories has been indicated by this Court in Miss Uma Patnaik's case (supra). Since we are directing revaluation, the procedure to be adopted in respect of seats relating to reserved categories shall also be considered by the Selection Board keeping in view the observations made by this Court in Miss. Uma Patnaik's case (supra)

25. After the writ applications were filed by order 11-10-1993, we bad stayed admissions in the medical colleges. Pursuant to our direction notices were inserted in the largest circulating local daily, the Samaj indicating that if any of the candidates whose names appeared in the selection list wants to appear in this Court and participate in the case, he may do so. On the basis of notice large number of candidates who were selected prayed for being impleaded as parties and by order passed to that effect they have been impleaded as parties and they have been heard in the matter.

26. The writ applications are accordingly disposed of.

27. Before parting with the case we may indicate certain aspects which year after year have been highlighted by this Court to improve the health situation of the examining body. But the “error virus” still continues to attack the examination and suffering is almost annual. It baffles us as to how year after year the health of the examination continues to deteriorate instead of showing and improvement. It is brought to our notice that many similar entrance examinations conducted for Admission into the Engineering Colleges have not yet suffered any attack in its credibility. It seems no attempt is being made to diagnose the cause of this almost permanent illness. Life saving measures are being taken by the Courts for the last three years, and this year we are almost called upon to prevent legal death of the examination. But time may come, when no amount of judicial oxygen can save the examination. It is said that prevention is better than cure. Why not take effective steps for prevention? Time alone can say whether this Court shall be called upon to annual check up in the future years. The choice of the question setters and the so called moderators does not appear to be appropriate. Large number of questions in Physics, Chemistry and Botany are year after year being assailed to be incorrect. While the case of Priyadarshini Acharya (supra) was under consideration of this Court, the candicates had furnished the views of a person in respect of a queition in Botany. The State in its counter affidavit filed indicated that the person who supported submission of the petitioners lacked fundamental so far as Botany is concerned. But to our utter surprise we find that the same person, who, according to the State lacked fundamentals in Botany, was selected to be an Expert and her views were pressed into service. It is baffling that a person in course of one year had a miraculous transition from a person looking fundamentals to be an Expert. So far as Physics is concerned, in Raghunath Pradhan's case (supra), we had the occasion to express displeasure in respect of a question which the examining body in its counter affidavit had accepted to be incorrect, was stated to be correct by the Expert of the examining body. This shows the careless manner in which the matter is being handled. If the examining body is interested to conduct the examination by setting objective type questions all possible care and caution should be taken before examination. In case of ambiguity such a question should not be set in the examination. It appears that year after year the views of different persons are taken after the examination is over. We had deprecated that practice in Miss. Uma Patnaik's case (supra).

R.K Patra, J.:— I am in respectful agreement with the conclusions reached and the reasons expressly recorded for them in the judgment delivered by my learned brother. The theme ‘examination of examination’ has persuaded me to append a separate opinion.

28. The present bunch of writ petitions bears eloquent testimony that all is not well with the Government in the Health and Family Welfare Department with regard to holding of entrance examination to M.B.B.S/B.D.S courses in the three medical colleges of the State. Since 1990 candidates have been challenging in succession the validity of the multiple choice objective type questions set for the entrance examinations. First of such cases came up before this Court in Priyadarshini Acharya v. State of Orissa, 1991 (I) O.L.R 514. This Court found 8 of the questions to be incorrect and was constrained to exclude them from evaluation. In the succeeding year in Raghunath Pradhan v. State of Orissa, 1992 (II) O.L.R 317, this Court declared 9 questions to have not satisfied the test of ‘multiple choice objective type questions’. This year (1993-94) the position is monstrous in view of the admitted position that before they were impugned in any legal proceeding, the Selection Board deleted 5 questions from evaluation as they were found to be defective and directed evaluation for 145 questions out of the total number of 150. Out of 145 questions, the Board further found 12 questions to have contained two correct answers. The experts appointed by us found 8 more questions to have contained more than one correct answers. This being the position, there is no other alternative than to pass the direction contained in the judgment of my learned brother for revluation.

29. Besides the aforesaid serious defect in setting of questions with key answers, the question papers admittedly contained a number of spelling and printing mistakes. The printing mistakes are seemed to have been rectified by manual corrections and pasting with strips of papers. This kind of patchwork solutions should not have been adopted giving scope for criticism. A finer sense and sensibility is expected from the Selection Board which was supposed to hold unstained and irreproachable examination when the career of large number of young and prospecting candidates is at stake.

30. Counsel for the petitioners submitted that the authorities committed breach of different provisions of the prospectus for which results of the examination are vitiated. Provisions contained in the prospectus are guidelines to be observed/compiled with by the concerned persons. Mere nonobservance/non-compliance of any of the provisions of the prospectus does not ipso facto invalidate the action taken in the matter in absence of peremptory provision stating that nonobservance/non-compliance lead to a particular consequence. This legal position, however, does not absolve the Selection Board from performing its solemn duty of conducting defect-free examination.

31. To the allegation that there was leakage of question papers, it has been replied in the counter affidavit filed by the opposite parties by saying that “neither the present Chairman nor the Convenor (of the Selection Board) had any knowledge of the contents of the question papers”. It is apposite to refer here clause 1.1 of the prospectus which states that selection to the first M.B.B.S/B.D.S courses will be conducted by the Selection Board, whose Chairman shall be the Dirertor of Medical Education and Training, Orissa (in short, ‘D.M.E.T ‘). The stand taken by the opposite parties in their counter affidavit is that Dr. N.K Satpathy was the D.M.E.T and in that capacity was the Chairman of the Selection Board who had initiated the process of question paper setting, printing etc. and continued to remain in charge of the aforesaid assignment even after his retirement from government service on 31-7-1993. He delivered the question paper bundles to the present D.M.E.T on 21-8-1993, a day prior to the entrance examination which was held on 22-8-1993. He had even in his retention the original manuscript of the question papers and the key answers which he submitted to the Court on 30-11-1993 in sealed cover. Admittedly Prof. Dr. K.K Mishra, assumed the office of D.M.E.T on 1-8-1993. After retirement, Dr. Satpathy should not have dealt with the matter further, it being without authority. It is equally irregular on the part of Prof. Dr. K.K Mishra to allow his predecessor to deal with the matter. An affidavit has been filed on 20-11-1993 by the Ex-D.M.E.T stating that his predecessor during previous year did not hand over any paper pertaining to the examination although he had also retired from service prior to the examination. In support of this statement, a copy of the letter No. 43 dated 30-9-1992 has been enclosed to the affidavit which indicates that Dr. Satpathy agreed in writing that the confidential matters pertaining to the examination should be handed over to the Convenor after they were received from the press by his predecessor. In the affidavit, it has been claimed that keeping the earlier practice, he did not handover any papers pertaining to the examination to his successor. One such instance cannot be dubbed as practice. In any event, the aforesaid letter shows that Dr. Satpathy agreed that the matter relating to the examination to be dealt with by his predecessor. This year there is no such authorisation by the present D.M.E.T. The method adopted in the matter is highly irregular, not sanctioned by law. In the name of keeping confidentiality, this kind of dealings are not conducive for holding fair and unblameworthy entrance examination. This has given scope for making allegation that leaking of question papers at the hands of the Ex-D.M.E.T cannot be ruled out.

32. In course of hearing of the cases, it was brought to our notice by way of affidavit that in the examination centre at Nuabazar High School one invigilator in room No. 1 of the Centre seized a sheet of paper from a candidate called Sibasis Acharya which contained question numbers and respective answer numbers serially arranged. It is stated in the said affidavit that the incriminating material was seized before 11.30 a.m from which it follows “that the said material was prepared prior to the starting of the examination and not after the question papers were distributed”. In the reply affidavit filed by the opposite party No. 3 seizure of such incriminating material from the concerned candidate has been admitted. Learned Government Advocate submitted that the fact that he secured only 94 marks and could not be selected for admission is the proof that it was not a case of leakage of question paper but a ease of mal-practice only. This is an argument of elusion. Since it is a case of mal-practice the candidate should have been dealt with under clause 8.8.4 of the prospectus. The Selection Board for the reasons best known to it conveniently forget the aforesaid provision and got his answer paper valued. This is an instance from which it can be said that the provisions of the prospectus were freely breached than strictly followed. A note of caution I As to what should be the multiple choice objective type questions, there should not be any second opinion in view of the pronouncement of this Court in Priyadarshini Acharya and Raghunath Pradhan (supra) on the topic. NCERT. has also indicated the guide-line on this subject. Relevant portion of the Chapter dealing with ‘multiple choice type questions’ appearing in the book published by N.C.E.R.T is as follows:—

“Multiple choice type questions can again be classified as follows:—

(1) Only correct answer type, and (2) Only wrong answer type.

33. Following points should be kept in mind while structuing a good Multiple Choice question:

1. Be sure that only one choice out of four is correct and the choices do not overlap each other.

2. The alternative should not contain anything which could have been put in the stem.

3. Give 4 or at most 5 choices, but not more than 5′ etc.

34. It may be relevant to mention here that to explain the Objective Type MCQ the teacher-pupils in different Orientation Courses conducted throughout the country by different experts, the following example is being given—

“In the epic story of Nala and Damayanti, Damayanti was put to test by the Gods, who assuming the forms of three Nalas presented themselves along with the true Nala before Damayanti, who was asked to identify the only true Nala present among the four persons looking alike”.

35. While expressing my anguish of the manner in which the question papers were set and the examination was conducted, I say that further time may not be lost in given a fresh and fundamental look at the problem so that this sort of limitative history may not repeat itself.

36. Ordered accordingly.