- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
K.C Sinha v. Union Of India And Another
1. The petitioner joined military service of the Central Government on 21-12-1969 and, presently, he is in the rank of major. However, on account of long service rendered by him he is presently posted as Lt. Colonel at Bareilly. He has not yet been promoted as Lt. Colonel. Presumably, this is so, since he was awarded adverse remarks for the year 1983-84. He made a representation in September, 1987 for setting aside the adverse remarks and also for considering case afresh for selection to the rank of Lt. Colonel but the same was rejected vide order dated 24-4-1990. By this writ petition, the petitioner has claimed a mandamus for quashing government order dated 24-4-1990 and also for quashing annual confidential remarks for the year 1983-84 and also for commanding respondent No. 1 to consider him for selection as Lt. Colonel with effect from the date his batch mates were promoted with consequential benefits and privileges attached to the post of Lt. Colonel.
2. The learned counsel for the respondents has taken a preliminary objection that this Court does not have the territorial jurisdiction in respect of the subject matter of this petition.
3. We have heard Sri Ashok Kumar, learned counsel, for the petitioner, and Sri Sushil Harkauli for the respondents on the point of jurisdiction.
4. There are only two respondents in this case. First respondent is Union of India whose office is located at New Delhi. Other respondent is Brigadier H.S Sandhu whose office is located in Maharashtra.
5. Therefore, none of the respondents is located in the territories in relation to which this Court exercises its jurisdiction. As regards the cause of action, the petitioner has alleged in paragraph 14 of the petition that initiating officer as regards the impugned adverse entry was sitting at Jodhpur. Admittedly, respondent No. 2 who was reviewing officer, was also not sitting in Uttar Pradesh.
6. The learned counsel for the petitioner has made three submissions in an attempt to show that this Court has territorial jurisdiction over the subject mat ter of this petition. The first submission is that since the petitioner is posted presently at Bareilly i.e within the territorial jurisdictioin of this Court, he has been denied promotion at Bareilly and, as such, the conse quence of the adverse entry has been felt at Bareilly and, therefore, this Court should entertain the petition. The second submission is that Section 124 of the Army Act, 1950 provides that any person subject to this Act who commits any offence against it may be tried and punished for such offence in any place whatever. The learned counsel submits that since under Section 124 of the Army Act an army officer can be punished at any place whatsoever in respect of an offence irrespective of the fact where the offence was committed, on the same analogy, the question where cause of action arose is not material in respect of an army of ficer and the petition would lie even if the cause of action arose outside the jurisdiction of this Court. The other submission is that the Chief of Army Staff has issued Army Order No. 72/81 according to which an office has been established at Delhi to represent the Chief of the Army Staff in relation to cases of army personnel in the High Court.
7. After anxious consideration of the rival contentions made by the learned counsel for the parties, we do not see any merit in the submissions made on behalf of the petitioner. The fact that an office has been opened by the Chief of the Army Staff at Allahabad to deal with the cases in the High Court relating to Army Personnel is not at all relevant to the question whether the cause of action arose within the jurisdiction of this Court. The adverse entry was made beyond the jurisdiction of this Court. If there was an unjustified denial of promotion, that denial was also outside the jurisdiction of this Court. The allegation that the effect of denial of promotion was felt at Bareilly is also without substance. The place where the effect of an action or inaction is felt is no part of the cause of action. The fact that the petitioner is at present posted at Bareilly and, therefore, he made representation from Bareilly and the communication about the rejection of his representation was also received at Bareilly are irrelevant, since neither the posting nor despatch of the representation nor the receipt of the communication regarding rejection of the representation forms essential part of the cause of action. We see also no merit in the submission that since the petitioner can be tried and punished for an offence under the Army Act at any place, he can file a writ petition anywhere, without limiting himself to the provisions of Article 226 of the Constitution. The provisions of the Army Act are not relevant to determine the question as to territorial jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 226. Furthermore, the question where a person can be tried and punished for any offence under the Army Act has no nexus with the question whether cause of action arose in respect of the subject matter of the Petition within the jurisdiction of this Court as contemplated in Article 226 of the Constitution.
8. In the result, we hold that this Court does not have territorial jurisdiction to deal with the subject matter of this petition. The petition is, therefore, dismissed in limine.
9. Petition dismissed.
Alert