Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Santosh Tewari And Others v. State Of U.P And Another

Allahabad High Court
Jul 8, 1996
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition under Section 482, Cr.P.C. was filed to quash a criminal complaint and the summoning order dated 3 February 1994. The complainant (respondent No. 2), Nirbhai Mehrotra, had been an Accountant and later Deputy Director (Finance) at Kamla Nehru Hospital, Allahabad. A news item headlined "BUNDLING IN KAMLA NEHRU HOSPITAL" was published in the English daily "Our Leader" on 13 October 1994; the petitioners are the publisher (Santosh Tewari), editor (Anupam Mishra) and working editor (H.P. Srivastava).

Aggrieved by the publication, Mehrotra filed a criminal complaint on 15 January 1994 seeking prosecution under Section 500 IPC for defamation. The learned Magistrate recorded the complainant's statement under Section 200 Cr.P.C. and statements of two witnesses under Section 202 Cr.P.C., and on 3 February 1994 issued an order summoning the applicants to face trial under Section 500 IPC. The present petition challenges the complaint and the summoning order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the complaint and the order summoning the petitioners under Section 500, IPC can be quashed in exercise of the High Court's inherent jurisdiction under Section 482, Cr.P.C.
  2. Whether the published news item falls within the First Exception (and/or Second Exception where relevant) to Section 499, IPC — i.e., whether it is substantially true and published for the public good — so as to render criminal prosecution for defamation unjustified.
  3. Whether criminal prosecution for alleged defamatory publication in a newspaper is appropriate when the matter concerns public institutions and the alleged reporting is substantially accurate, or whether civil remedies should be preferred.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' (Applicants') Arguments

  • The petitioners sought quashing of the complaint and the summoning order under Section 482, Cr.P.C.
  • They produced affidavits and documentary material showing that the news item was essentially correct: a shortage of Rs. 20,000 from the hospital cash chest; an inquiry was instituted; the complainant had been suspended and subsequently dismissed following the inquiry.
  • They relied on the proposition that if a news item is substantially true and published for the public good, criminal prosecution for defamation is unjustified (invoking the First Exception to Section 499, IPC and supporting authorities).
  • They contended there was no allegation of malice in the publication and that the article primarily concerned the affairs of a public hospital (public interest), not an intent to target the complainant personally.

Complainant's (Respondent No. 2) Arguments

  • The complainant initiated prosecution under Section 500, IPC alleging the news item defamed him.
  • Learned counsel for the complainant referred to precedents (Amar Singh v. K.S. Badalia and Sahib Singh Mehra v. State of U.P.) in support of the submission that the news item was defamatory and that the proceedings could not be quashed under Section 482, Cr.P.C.
  • Separate from argument, the complainant's counsel fairly accepted (as recorded in the opinion) that the complainant had been placed under suspension and later dismissed from service on account of the shortage found by the inquiry.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Radha Govind v. Saila Kumar, (1950) 51 Cri LJ 1293 : AIR 1950 Cal 343 Authority that for the First Exception to Section 499 IPC it is sufficient if the accused can show the statements are substantially true as to the material portion of the allegation. The court relied on this authority to support the view that substantial truth of the material portions of the news item defeats criminal defamation liability even if minor parts are incorrect.
Shivage Gowda v. T. Narayana, 1968 Cri LJ 836 (Mysore) Same proposition as Radha Govind: substantial truth of the material portion suffices for First Exception to Section 499 IPC. The court applied this principle together with Radha Govind to hold that substantially correct reporting of the hospital affairs fell within the First Exception and weighed against criminal prosecution.
Amar Singh v. K.S. Badalia, 1965 (2) Cri LJ 693 (Pat) Cited by complainant's counsel to support the submission that the news item was defamatory and that prosecution should not be quashed. The court found this authority distinguishable on the facts and held it had no application to the present case where the news item was substantially true and published for public good.
Sahib Singh Mehra v. State of Uttar Pradesh, 1965 (2) Cri LJ 434 : AIR 1965 SC 1451 Cited by complainant's counsel to argue the news item was defamatory and proceedings could not be quashed. The court considered this precedent distinguishable as well and did not treat it as applicable given the factual findings of substantial truth and public interest here.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court conducted a textual and factual analysis of the published news item as a whole, applying constitutional and statutory considerations (Article 19(1)(a) and its reasonable restrictions under Clause (2); Sections 499 and 500 IPC; exceptions to Section 499).

Key elements of the court's step-by-step reasoning:

  1. Interpretive approach: The court emphasised that allegedly defamatory statements must be read in their entirety and assigned their plain, natural and popular meaning, taking the expression as a whole (drawing on cited jurisprudence and treatises regarding construction of allegedly defamatory language).
  2. Factual determination: On the affidavits and materials before it, the court found that the central factual allegations in the news item — shortage of Rs. 20,000 in the hospital cash chest, institution of an inquiry, suspension and eventual dismissal of the complainant — were correct and not controverted by the complainant. Certain peripheral allegations (e.g., an alleged 1992 police seizure of a truck with teak furniture) were not proved and had to be treated as defamatory for present purposes.
  3. Public interest and exceptions to defamation law: The court analysed the First Exception to Section 499 IPC (truth published for the public good) and held that when a news item is substantially true in respect of the material allegations and published for public good (here, alleged bungling of funds in a publicly important hospital), criminal prosecution for defamation is inappropriate. The court relied on authorities holding that substantial truth as to material parts suffices for the First Exception.
  4. Balance with freedom of speech and press: The court reviewed constitutional guarantees of free speech and the role of the press in a democracy, noting that press reporting of corruption and maladministration serves public interest and that criminal prosecutions will have a chilling effect on reporting important public matters.
  5. Comparative and policy considerations: The court referenced legal developments and practices in the U.K. and U.S.A., including statutory restrictions on initiating prosecutions for newspaper publications in the U.K. (Law of Libel Amendment Act, 1888) and the modern preference in the U.S. for civil remedies rather than criminal libel prosecutions. The court used these comparative observations to inform its view on when criminal prosecution should be resorted to.
  6. Application to the case: Given the material accuracy of the news item, the public interest involved (Kamla Nehru Hospital being an important public institution), and the absence of an allegation of malice, the court concluded that the prosecution under Section 500 IPC was wholly unjustified and illegal.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

PETITION ALLOWED; the criminal proceedings in Criminal Case No. 301 of 1994 (Nirbhai Mehrotra v. Santosh Tewari) pending before the 1st A.C.J.M., Allahabad are quashed.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The criminal prosecution of the petitioners under Section 500 IPC is terminated by quashing of the proceedings; the petitioners will not proceed to trial on the impugned complaint as a result of this order.
  • Doctrinal and policy observations: The court articulated that substantially true reporting on matters of public concern is protected against criminal prosecution under the First Exception to Section 499 IPC, absent malice; it expressed policy concerns about the chilling effect of criminal prosecutions on the press and recommended legislative consideration of protections similar to those in the U.K. statutes (e.g., Law of Libel Amendment Act, 1888 and Defamation Act, 1952) — but the court did not purport to introduce a new statutory rule or claim to set binding legislative policy beyond its reasoning in this case.
  • On precedent: The court applied existing case law (as cited) to the facts and emphasised that certain authorities relied on by the complainant were distinguishable and therefore not applicable on the facts before it.

This summary is derived exclusively from the provided opinion text. No additional facts or outside information have been added.

Show all summary ...

1. This petition under Section 482, Cr. P.C has been filed for quashing the complaint and the summoning order dated February 3, 1994.

2. The complaint-respondent No. 2 Nirbhai Mehrotra was initially appointed as Accountant in the Kamla Nehru Hospital, Allahabad and was subse quently designated as Deputy Director (Finance). A news item was published in “Our Leader” a English daily on October 13, 1994 of which applicant No. 1 Santosh Tewari is the publisher, applicant No. 2 Anupam Mishra is the editor and applicant No. 3 H.P Srivastava is the working editor. The respondent No. 2 Nirbhai Mehrotra felt that the news item de famed him and accordingly he filed a criminal com plaint for prosecuting the applicants under Section 500, I.P.C in the Court of C.J.M 1st, Allahabad on January 15, 1994. The learned Magistrate after re cording the statement of the complainant under Section 200, Cr. P.C and that of two witnesses under Section 202, Cr. P.C passed an order on February 3, 1994 summoning the applicants to face trial under Section 500, I.P.C Before adverting to the facts of the case it is necessary to bear in mind the constitutional and statutory provision which have a bearing on the controversy raised. Article 19(1)(a) the Constitutional of India guarantee freedom of speech and expression to every citizen. Clause (2) of the same Article however lays down that nothing in sub-clause (a) of Clause (1) shall affect the operation of any existing law, or prevent the State of any existing law, or prevent the State from making any law, in so far as such law imposes reasonable restrictions on the exer cises of the right conferred by the said sub-clause in relation to contempt of Court, defamation or incite ment to an offence. Section 499, I.P.C defines demation which is made punishable under Section 500, I.P.C The first exception to Section 499 lays down that it is not defamation to impute anything which is true concerning any person, if it be for the public good that the imputation should be made or should be published. Vifhether or not it is for the public good is a question of fact. Second exception lays down that it is not defamation to express in good faith any opinion whatsoever respecting the conduct of a public servant in the discharge of his public functions or respecting his character, so far as his character appears in that conduct, and no further. First exception to Section 499 thus shows that if the imputation made against a person is true and if it is for public good that the imputation should be made or published then even if the imputation is defamatory in character it will not amount to a criminal offence. Similarly the second exception shows that if any opinion is expressed regarding conduct of a public servant in the discharge of his public function or respecting his character so far as his character appears in that conduct and if the opinion is expressed in good faith, it will not be a criminal offence even if the opinion is defamatory in character. The legal position in U.K appears to be almost similar. In Halsbury's Laws of England (Fourth Edition) Vol. 28 Notes 284 the law on the point has been stated as under:

“284. Justification and public benefit

On the trial of any indictment for a defamatory libel, in addition to the regular plea of not guilty, the defendant may enter a special plea that the alleged defamatory matter is true, and that its publication is for the public benefit. The plea of truth follows the style and manner of a plea of justification in a civil action for defamation. However, in addion to the place of truth, without which the truth of the matter charged may not be inquired into, the defendant must further allege that it was for the public benefit that the defamatory matter charged should be published, and must State that particular fact or facts by reason of which he maintains that the publication of the matter charged was for the public benefit. Thus, truth alone is no answer to the charge.”

3. There can be no doubt that freedom of speech or freedom of Press does not extend to publishing any imputation concerning any person intending to harm or, any one having reason to believe that such imputation will harm the reputation of such person, unless the case is covered by one of the exceptions to Section 499, I.P.C There is often a conflict between the right guaranteed to a citizen under Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution and the provions of Chapter XXI of the Indian Penal Code which deals with defamation. Such conflict has also frequently arisen before the Courts in U.S.A The framers of our Constitutional have borrowed Article 19(1)(a) from the American Constitution. The First Amendment of American Constitution, which came into force as far back as November 3, 1791, provides that Congress shall make no law abridging the freedom of speech or of the Press. It will therefore be used to notice the legal position on this question in U.S.A In 50 American Jurisprudence 2nd Articles 1 (Page 513) it has been stated as under:

‘The law relationship to defamation is a limitation upon the constitutioinal guaranty of freedom of speech and of the press, and the vagarious and complex structure of such law, as it exists today, is to a large extent a direct result of the friction between it, as a restriction on untrammeled freedom of expression, and the highly cherished rights of freedom of speech and of the press. On the one hand, the constitutional guaranty does not condone unjustifiable defamation, but on the other hand, Court decisions and State statutes relating to libel and slander should not be violative of a proper exercise of the constitutional privilege. Needless to say, a State statute relating to defamation should conform to other applicable con-stitutibnal requirements.”

4. Freedom of speech and expression is one of the most cherished right of a citizen in a free society. It will be appropriate to recall the famous words of Voltaire:

“I disapprove of what you say, but will defend to the death your right to say it.,”.

and that of Benjamin Franklin:

‘They that give up essential liberty to obtain little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.”

5. The Press has an important role to play in a democratic society like ours and the fundamental rights guaranteed under the Constitution depend a good deal upon freedom of Press. It will not be out of place here fo reproduce the words of a few great persons regarding freedom of Press:

‘Our liberty depends on the freedom of the Press, and that cannot be limited without being lost.”

THOMAS JEFFERSN

“The free press is the mother of all our liberties and of our progress under liberty.”

ADLAIE. STEVENSON.

‘The press is not only free, it is powerful. That power is ours. It is the proudest that man can enjoy.”

BENJAMIN DISRAELI

“Let it be impressed upon your minds, let it be instilled into your children, that the liberty of the press is the pall adium of all the civil, political, and religious rights.”

JUNIUS

6. The right of liberty, though fundamental tohuman nature, is neither absolute in exercise nor is itan act of charity by the ruler of the day. It is inherentin the complexion of any civilised society. At the same time no liberty in a civilised society is as absolute as to become licence, which in turn may change into anarchy or the rule of jungle. When a majority of us refuse to interfere with the Jiberty of others and voluntarily submit to a curtailment of our private liberty, we do so to enjoy a social order which makes our liberty a reality. The question of putting legitimate limits to the exercise of liberty becomes inevitable when such liberty becomes a social nuisance or smacks of bullying tactics or feudal fads. The question of defamation is primarily linked up with one's reputation that one commands among one's fellow beings and it is infringement of this right to have one's reputation preserved in tact that gives the cause of action. Thus there is paramount public interest that a person be permitted to speak or write freely without fear of civil or criminal liability and individual should be free toenjoy his reputation unimpaired by false and defamatory attacks.

7. While considering whether a statement js defamatory in character or not a question arises as to how the statement should be read. In 50 American Jurisprudence 2d Article 501 the law on the point has been stated as under:

“As a general rule, the principles of construction applicable in civil cases govern the construction of language claimed to be criminally defamatory. Thus, in the absence of any showing that the words composing the statement complained of were used in a special sense, the Court must assign them their plain, natural and popular meanings, and then, taking the expression as a whole, determine its true meaning and effect, in the same manner as a stranger to the controversy Would do. An alleged libelous article should be considered in its entirety, and not as cut up in sections or paragraphs.”

8. The same view is expressed in 53 Corpus Juris Secundum Para 283(c) where the law has been stated as under:

“In determining whether the offence of criminal libel has been committed, defamatory words are to be construed as a whole, and are to be taken in their plain, natural and ordinary meaning; but it is not necessary that the charge be made directly or that the person defamed be mentioned by name.”

9. It is therefore well settled that the whole of the statement complained of must be read and hot merely part or parts of it.

10. The offending news item bears following caption in bold letters: BUNDLING IN KAMLA NEHRU HOSPITAL. The news item begins as follows:

“A bungling in the hospital funds of the Kamla Nehru hospital came to light recently when Rupees 20,000/- were found missing from the cash chest of the hospital on 1st October last. An inquiry was instituted in the matter and all the documents were sealed on 7th October in the presence of the Administrator, but despite the knowledge the Administrator decides to keep the issue under wraps for reasons best known to him.”

11. Thereafter, it is mentioned that the Administrator had instituted an inquiry by constituting a committee of two doctors to hold an inquiry and submit its report. In the third paragraph, it is mentioned that when the scribe contacted Administrator, he denied that any bungling of cash had taken place but when he was shown the office order regarding initiation of enquiry, he said that he would not give any comments. In the fourth paragraph, it is mentioned that when other members of the committee were contacted, they replied that they had been instructed not to give any comments. In the fifth paragraph, it is mentioned that an accountant Sri Chandra Shekhar Srivastava said that Mr. Mehrotra was the only one to handle the cash chest. In the sixth paragraph, it is mentioned that the General Secretary of the Kamla Nehru Hospital Karmachari Sangh said that the hospital is mired in corruption and recently a jeep of the hospital was stolen but no enquiry was carried out. In the next three paragraphs reference is made to the complainant and it is said that he was an accountant in the hospital in the year 1985 and was made Deputy Director in September, 1993 and on 1st October the cash fell short. He enjoyed clout in the hospital and that in 1992 the police seized a truck with teak furniture of the hospital which he was allegedly carrying. In the last paragraph, it is said that the whole episode of missing Rs. 20,000/- is mired in mystery as every official was keeping mum on the issue thus giving rise to the belief of greater corrupt practices in the hospital

12. In paragraph 9 of the affidavit filed in support of this petition, it is averred that following instructions of the high command namely Kamla Nehru Trust, New Delhi, the complainant Nirbhai Mehrotra had been placed under suspension in view of prima facie evidence regarding bungling of funds by him. A copy of the order dated October 1, 1993 passed by the Administator has been filed which shows that a committee had been constituted consisting of two senior doctors of the hospital to hold an enquiry regarding shortage of Rs. 20,000/- from the cash chest. A second supplementary affidavit has been filed by the applicants wherein it is stated that the complainant was dismissed from service following report of the en-quiry committee. It is further stated therein that the Administrator has written a letter to the Provident Fund Commissioner, Varanasi, on January 28, 1995 requesting that the provident fund of the complainant Nirbhai Mehrotra, who had been dismissed from service due to mishandling of cash, should not be released to him without giving prior intimation to the employer and that money should not be unilaterally paid to him. These facts have not been controverted by respondent No. 2 (complainant) and in fact his counsel Sri Sanjay Goswami fairly accepted that his client, who had been initially placed under suspension, has been dismissed from the services of the hospital on account of shortage of money from the cash chest.

13. Kamla Nehru Hospital was founded by Pt. Jawahar Lal Nehru in the memory of his wife. It is undoubtedly the best maternity hospital in Allahabad and in the neighbourhood. It has also got a Cancer Wingland well equipped Radio diagnosis facilities. The hospital is run by Kamla Nehru Trust and so long as Smt. Indira Gandhi was alive, she used to take keen interest in the management of the hospital. The hos pital is rendering very good service to society at large. The whole public is therefore interested in seeing that the hospital is properly run. Any financial bungling in the hospital is a matter of public concern as it is bound to affect its efficiency.

14. The affidavits exchanged by the parties reveal that the news item relating to shortage of Rupees 20,000/- is correct. Similarly the fact that an enquiry was held against the complainant and subsequently he was dismissed from service on account of shortage of funds, is correct. The applicants have not filed any material here which may show that the part of the news item wherein it is mentioned that in 1992 the police seized a truck with teak furniture of the hospital which Mr. Mehrotra was allegedly carrying is correct and therefore for the purpose of the present petition it has to be taken as defamatory. The news item also mentions that Mr. Mehrotra enjoys clout in the hospi tal as his sister is P.A to the Secretary of Kamla Nehru Trust. In my opinion this part is not defamatory in character. The last part of the news item that sources further alleged that Mr. Mehrotra also runs a loan shark business in the hospital can be held to be defamatory. However if the news item is read as a whole, it will show that basically it is regarding the affairs of Kamla Nehru Hospital. No doubt it also mentions certain things about the complainant Nirbhai Mehrotra but it cannot be said that the object of publishing the news item was to highlight his activi ties.

15. There cannot be even a slightest doubt that there is wide spread corruption in the country and persons holding public positions are adopting most dubious methods to acquire wealth. Mind buggling scams involving astronomical figures are being brought to light almost every day. The Press has an important role to play in exposing the corruption at public places and to inform the people about the misdeed of those who are indulging in such nefarious activities. In fact it is the duty of the Press to highlight the cases of corruption. The Press must publish reports about such incidents immediately after they are brought to light. Investigation into matters relating to financial bungling takes a long time. The Press has to publish the news about such matters forthwith and it cannot wait indefinitely for the investigation to be completed and complete facts to be ascertained as waiting for such a long period would make the news stale. Public good demands that such people, if not actually convicted and sentenced by a Court of law, at least get a bad name in the society by publication of their names and misdeeds in the media. This may act as some sort of check or deterrence on those who have no qualms in misappropriating public funds. If a reporter or editor is under threat or fear of criminal prosecution for an offence of defamation he is not likely to report or publish anything regarding those who have indulged in financial bungling till at least the investigation is over. This may take months or years and by that time the news will become stale and will ceased to be worth reporting. It has been held in Radha Govind v. Saila Kumar, (1950) 51 Cri LJ 1293 : (AIR 1950 Cal 343) and Shivage Gowda v. T. Narayana, 1968 Cri LJ 836 (Mysore) that for application of First Exception to Section 499, I.P.C it is sufficient if the accused can show that the statements are substantially true in regard to the material portion of the allegation or insinuation. Therefore if the news published by the Press is substantially correct, the persons responsible for reporting or publishing the same cannot be held liable for defamation merely because it is not true on some minor matters.

16. As shown earlier the news item was published basically to highlight the affairs of Kamla Nehru Hospital and not particularly for the complainant. The main allegation made against the complainant has been found to be true. Further it is for the public good that the imputation regarding bungling of funds or property of the hospital and misdeeds of its employ ees should be published. The prosecution of the petitioners under Section 500, I.P.C is, therefore, I wholly unjustified and illegal.

17. In India defamation may amount to a civil wrong as well as a crime. According to Salmond, the distinction between the crimes and civil wrongs is roughly that crimes are public wrongs and civil wrongs are private wrongs. Wrongs are divisible into two sorts or species, private wrongs and public wrongs. The former are an infringement or privation of the private or civil rights belonging to individuals, considered as individuals, and are thereupon frequently termed civil injuries; the latter are a breach and violation of public rights and duties which affect the whole community considered as a community; and are distinguished by the harsher appellation of crimes and misdemeanours. A crime then is an act deemed by law to be harmful to the society in general, even though its immediate victim is an individual. Those who commit such acts are proceeded against by the State in order that if convicted, they may be punished. Civil wrongs are deemed only to infringe the rights of individual wronged and not to injure society in general and consequently the law leaves it to the victim to sue for compensation in the Courts. (See Salmond on Jurisprudence 1988 Ed. P. 91). According to the theory on Criminal Law of England, the essence of the crime on private libel consists in its tendency to provoke the breach of peace. However under the Indian Penal Code, defamation has been made an offence without any reference to its tendency to cause acts of illegal violence. But the Code was drafted nearly one and a half century ago in the year 1837 by the first Indian Law Commission of which Lord Macaulay was the President and was passed by the Legislative Council on October 6, 1860. Many provisions in the Code were enacted with the object of preventing the voice of dissent or criticism of the administration and for strengthening the British Rule. The position has vastly changed with the enforcement of Constitution and the Society becoming more and more free and open and a demand for transparency in public dealings. There can be no denial that there is rampant corruption in the country and the legal system takes a long time in bringing the guilty to book. In such a situation the Press has an important role to play and in fact it is its duty to expose the corrupt and wrong people. This can be done only if the publisher, reporter or the writer is free from the threat of a criminal prosecution. Sec. 499, I.P.C may be a valid piece of legislation in view of clause (2) of Article 19 but it should be interpreted in a manner which permits clause (1) to have its full amplitude.

18. It is noteworthy that the current thinking in U.S.A is that the person aggrieved should pursue his civil remedy and not by initiating prosecution in a criminal Court. In 50 American Jurisprudence 2d Article 495 the law on the point has been stated as follows:—

‘The United States Supreme Court has made reference to the changing mores, and to the virtual disappearance of criminal libel prosecutions, and it has been said that even though a defamation may be a crime as well as a civil wrong, the injured person generally should content himself with his civil remedy.”

19. In U.K newspapers enjoy a special protection in view of the Law of Libel Amendment Act, 1888 and without the leave of a Judge, which can be granted only if the imputation is very serious or public interest demands prosecution, no prosecution can be launched. The legal position has been stated as under in Halsbury's Laws of England (Fourth Edition) Vol. 28 Note 280:

“280. Leave to prosecute for publication in newspaper

No criminal prosecution may be commenced against any proprietor, publisher, editor or any person responsible for the publication of a newspaper for any libel published in it, without the order of a Judge in chambers. The application for such an order must be made on notice to the person accused, who must have an opportunity of being heard. Leave will only be granted where there is a prima facie case, where the libel is so serious that the criminal law ought to be invoked and where the public interest requires the institution of criminal proceedings. No appeal lies from the Judge's order allowing or refusing leave to prosecute.”

20. It is a legitimate function of all newspapers in a democratic set up to act as a champion of clean administration and sentinels of public interest and as such they are well within their rights to expose and bring to the notice of general public any lapse or malpractise in the administration including that of nepotism and favouritism and by doing so they will be acting for public good. In view of long passage of time which has elapsed since the enactment of Penal Code, change in the pattern of society and instances of corruption, misappropriation of public funds and favouritismetc. being brought to light very frequently, the development of law in the leading democracies like U.K and U.S.A should be taken notice of. It will, therefore, be appropriate to hold that if a substantially true news item is published for public good, no criminal prosecution of the persons responsible for the publication is partly untrue or incorrect unless the report was made or published maliciously. Further more the prosecution should be allowed only if the damage done cannot be met by a civil action and it will be in the public interest to do so.

21. Learned counsel for the complainant has referred to Amar Singh v. K.S Badalia, 1965 (2) Cri LJ 693 (Pat), Sahib Singh Mehra v. State Of Uttar Pradesh, 1965 (2) Cri LJ 434 : (AIR 1965 SC 1451) in support of his submission that the news item is defamatory in character and the proceedings cannot be quashed in exercise of jurisdiction under Section 482, Cr. P.C In my opinion, the authorities cited are clearly distin guishable and can have no application on the facts of the present case as the news item is substantially true and it is for public good that it should be published. There is no allegation that the publication was mali cious. Before parting with the case, I would like to observe that it is high time the Parliament considered the desirability of bringing in a legislation on the pattern of Law of Label Amendment Act, 1888 and also Defamation Act, 1952 of the United Kingdom where publication in a newspaper of matters mentioned in the Schedule to the Act is privileged unless the publication is proved to be made with malice.

22. For the reasons mentioned above, the petition succeeds and is hereby allowed. The proceedings of criminal case No. 301 of 1994 (Nirbhai Mehrotra v. Santosh Tewari) pending in the Court of 1st A.C.J.M Allahabad are quashed.

23. Petition allowed.