Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Karan Singh And Others v. State Of U.P And Others

Allahabad High Court
Aug 7, 1996
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The applicants filed an application seeking quashing of the Magistrate's order dated 28.1.92, which rejected the Final Report submitted by the police and issued process against the applicants. The applicants challenged the legal validity of the Magistrate’s order on the grounds that it was unclear under which provision of Section 190(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Cr. P.C.) cognizance was taken, and contended that the procedure for complaint cases was not followed after the filing of a Protest Petition and affidavits by the complainant. The matter proceeded to hearing before the court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Magistrate’s order summoning the applicants as accused is legally valid when it does not specify whether cognizance was taken under Section 190(1)(a) or Section 190(1)(b) of the Cr. P.C.?
  2. Whether the Magistrate was required to follow the procedure applicable to complaint cases after the filing of a Protest Petition and affidavits by the complainant following the submission of a police Final Report?
  3. Whether the applicants were entitled to an opportunity of hearing before the Magistrate issued process against them?

Arguments of the Parties

Applicants' Arguments

  • The impugned order is bad in law as it does not clarify under which provision of Section 190(1) cognizance was taken.
  • After the filing of a Final Report, if the complainant files a Protest Petition and affidavits, the Magistrate must take cognizance under Section 190(1)(b) following the procedure for complaint cases, including recording the complainant’s statement under Section 200 Cr. P.C.
  • The Magistrate failed to record the complainant’s statement under Section 200 Cr. P.C. and did not follow the complaint procedure.
  • The impugned order is invalid as no opportunity of hearing was given to the applicants before issuing process against them.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The Magistrate acted within the powers under Section 190(1)(b) Cr. P.C. by taking cognizance based on the police report and the material on record, without following complaint procedure.
  • The applicants have the remedy to appear before the Magistrate after issuance of process and can then contest the case.
  • There is no requirement under the Code or principles of natural justice to afford hearing before issuance of process once the Magistrate takes cognizance under Section 190(1)(b).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bhagwan Das v. State, 1988 25 ACC 571 Procedure to be followed when Magistrate takes cognizance after protest petition filed against Final Report; no need to treat informant as complainant burden. Established that Magistrate is not bound to follow complaint procedure when taking cognizance under Section 190(1)(b) after protest petition; the Magistrate was deemed to be considering only police report here.
Bhagwant Singh v. States, 1986 A.W.C 26 Requirement of notice to informant before accepting Final Report. Supported the principle that the informant is entitled to hearing before closure of case but not necessarily before cognizance under Section 190(1)(b).
Rajendra Kumar Agarwal v. State of U.P, 1994 31 A.C.C 341 Requirement of hearing before re-investigation order. Distinguished on facts; no hearing required before process issuance; applicants can appear and contest thereafter.
Pratap v. State of U.P, 1991 28 ACC 422 No right of accused to hearing before issuance of process under Section 190(1)(b). Affirmed that Magistrate need not afford hearing before issuing process; process issuance is not a conviction or adverse decision.
Chandra Deo v. Prakash Chandra, AIR 1963 SC 1430 = 1963 1 SCR 202 Accused has no locus standi before issuance of process. Supported the view that accused’s right to be heard arises only after process issuance.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the procedural requirements applicable after submission of a Final Report by the police. It noted that when a Protest Petition and affidavits are filed by the complainant, the Magistrate is not bound to follow the complaint procedure under Section 200 Cr. P.C. unless cognizance is taken under Section 190(1)(a). In the present case, since the Magistrate did not record the complainant’s statement under Section 200 Cr. P.C., it was concluded that cognizance was taken under Section 190(1)(b), which allows the Magistrate to take cognizance based on the police report and material on record without following the complaint procedure.

The court further clarified that the Magistrate has three options after receiving the Final Report: accept it and drop proceedings, take cognizance under Section 190(1)(b), or order further investigation. The Magistrate here chose the second option, which is legally permissible.

Regarding the argument that the applicants were not given an opportunity of hearing before issuance of process, the court relied on established precedent that no such hearing is required at this stage. The issuance of process is not a conviction or adverse order but merely a direction to face trial. The accused have ample opportunity to present their case once the trial begins. This interpretation is consistent with Article 21 of the Constitution, which guarantees protection of life and liberty according to procedure established by law.

Holding and Implications

The application to quash the Magistrate’s order is rejected.

The court held that the Magistrate validly took cognizance under Section 190(1)(b) without following complaint case procedure and was not required to afford the applicants an opportunity of hearing before issuing process. The direct effect is that the applicants must face trial and may present their defense before the Magistrate at the appropriate stage. This decision does not set any new precedent but reaffirms the settled legal position regarding Magistrate’s powers after submission of a police Final Report.

Show all summary ...

J.C Gupta, J.:— Heard the applicants counsel and the learned A.G.A

2. By means of this application the applicants have prayed for the quashing of the order of the Magistrate dated 28.1.92 by which he has rejected the Final Report submitted by the police and has issued process against the applicants.

3. Learned counsel for the applicants firstly argued before that the impugned order of summoning the applicants as accused is bad in law in as much as it cannot be inferred from the said order whether the Magistrate has taken cognizance under the provisions of Section 190(1)(a) or Section 190(1)(b) of the Code of Criminal Procedure. According to him after the filing of Final Report by the police, if the complainant moves a Protest Petition and also files some affidavits or other material, the only course open for the Magistrate is to take cognizance under the provisions of Section 190(1)(b) after following the procedure provided in respect of complaint cases and since such a procedure has been followed in the present case, the impugned order is liable to be quashed. He placed reliance upon the decision in Bhagwan Das v. State . 1988 25 ACC 571..

4. In the aforesaid decision Hon'ble Palok Basu, J. went into the question, “will it be legal, and if yes, then what wilt be the procedure to be followed in cases where after investigating the First Information Report, Investigating Officer files a Final Report and the informant challenges the said Final Report by filing protest petition and affidavits before the Magistrate who then takes the cognizance and summons the accused?” It has been held in the said decision that after the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Bhagwant Singh v. States . 1986 A.W.C 26. it is incumbent upon the Magistrate to issue notice to the Informant before accepting the Final Report forwarded by the Investigating Officer. The learned Single Judge in the case of Bhagwan Das (Supra) has further held that in pursuance of the notice issued to the complainant, the Magistrate is not to hear the informant orally only and if the Magistrate permits the informant to produce application, affidavit and other material, he is not bound to follow the procedure provided for the complaint cases. The learned Judge observed:

“The Hon'ble Supreme Court never appears to have desired that in such a case an informant should be asked to shoulder the burden of the complainant even though the Final Report deserves rejection.”

5. It has also been held in the aforesaid decision of Bhagwan Das that when the Magistrate takes cognizance on a complaint and he wishes to proceed with it he has to record statement of the complainant on oath and so long as this is not done, the Magistrate will be deemed to be considering only the police report.

6. In the case in hand, the complainant of course presented a protest petition and filed some affidavits before the Magistrate but it further appears that the Magistrate did not think it necessary to record the statement of the first informant under Section 200 Cr. P.C By filing Protest Petition the complainant simply invited the attention of the Magistrate that he was not agreeing with the Final Report submitted by the police and he was submitting his objections in the form of the Protest Petition. Undisputedly the Magistrate has not recorded the statement of the complainant under Section 200 Cr. P.C and has not followed the procedure provided for complaint cases. It would thus be deemed that the Magistrate was considering only the police report while taking cognizance of the case in exercise of powers under Section 190(1)(b) of the Code.

7. It is now well-settled law that when a Final Report is submitted by the police after investigation, three courses are open to the Magistrate:

(1) He may accept the Final Report and drop the proceedings, after hearing the complainant/First informant.

(2) He may disagree with the conclusion arrived at by the police officer and straight away take cognizance in exercise of powers under Section 190(1)(b) of Cr. P.C

(3) He may order further investigation.

8. In the present case the Magistrate appears to have acted under clause (2) aforesaid and therefore the impugned order would not be bad in law on the ground that the Magistrate has not followed the procedure provided for complaint cases.

9. Relying upon the decision of a learned Single Judge of this court in the case of Rajendra Kumar Agarwal v. State of U.P . 1994 31 A.C.C 341., the learned counsel for the applicant contended that the impugned order is invalid as before issuing process against the applicants, no opportunity of hearing was given to them. The facts of the said case were entirely different from the facts of the present case. In the case of Rajendra Kumar Agarwal (supra) no order of summoning was passed but the Magistrate had-ordered re-investigation. On the other hand in the present case processes have been issued against the applicants and they have still with them a remedy to have their say before the Magistrate by putting their appearance in pursuance of the impugned order. They can plead and place facts before the Magistrate that there is no sufficient ground against them to proceed further. In the decision in Pratap v. State of U.P . 1991 28 ACC 422., the same question arose for consideration and Hon'ble G.P Mathur, J. gave a detailed judgment and held that the accused has got no right to be heard at a stage prior to issue of process against him. It was observed:

“Neither under the Code of Criminal Procedure nor under any principle of natural justice the Magistrate is required to issue notice or afford an opportunity of hearing to an accused in a case where the police has submitted Final Report but on consideration of the material on record the Magistrate takes cognizance of the offence in exercise of his powers under Section 190(1)(b) and directs issue of process to the accused. The Code does not contemplate holding of two trials one before the issue of process and the other after the process is issued.”

10. In paragraph-3 the learned Judge further observed:

“Therefore, before issuing summons or warrant against the accused, the Magistrate taking cognizance of an offence, has to form an opinion on the limited question as to whether there is sufficient ground for proceeding. When process is issued by a Magistrate the person concerned is not being condemned in any manner. The order issuing process does not adversely affect the accused. He is neither being convicted nor sentenced. He is merely being asked to face trial in a court of law. It cannot be said that merely because process has been issued against a person, a decision adversely affecting him has been taken. It cannot, therefore, be said that any principle of natural justice is infringed, if the Magistrate issues process against a person without first affording him an opportunity of hearing.”

11. It is, further, observed:

“The legislature has taken extreme care and has made elaborate procedure to give full opportunity to an accused once the trial begins in the court of law. Article 21 of the Constitution lays down that no person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty except according to the procedure established by law.”

12. The Apex Court in the case of Chandra Deo v. Prakash Chandra . AIR 1963 SC 1430 = 1963 1 SCR 202., has also held that an accused has no locus standi till process is issued.

13. Where a Final Report is submitted by the police, the Magistrate can straightaway take cognizance disagreeing with the conclusion arrived at by the Investigating Officer, even without issuing notice to the informant. The necessity of issuing notice arises only where the Magistrate does not take cognizance after the submission of Final Report. The rational behind this appears to be that where a Final Report is submitted, that is the end of the matter as far as the first informant is concerned and since he is the person who had set the law into motion, he is entitled to a hearing before the matter is finally closed. The same analogy cannot be applied in respect of an accused for the reason that he gels an opportunity after the process is issued against him and it cannot be said that merely because a process has been issued against him, a decision adversely affecting him has been taken. Such an order does not adversely affect the rights of the accused, since he has got ample remedy with him to have his say before the Magistrate at appropriate stage.

14. In my opinion, the view taken by Hon'ble G.P Mathur, J. in the aforesaid case of Pratap is the correct view of law. Concurring with that view it must be held that neither under the Code of Criminal Procedure nor under any principle of natural justice the Magistrate is required to issue notice or afford an opportunity of hearing to an accused in a case where the police has submitted Final Report but on consideration of the material on record the learned Magistrate takes cognizance of the offence in exercise of his powers under Section 190(1)(b) and directs issue of process to the accused.

15. For the above reasons. I do not find any force in the aforesaid submission of the learned counsel.

16. This application has no merits and is accordingly rejected.

Application Rejected.