Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M/S. Bharat Heavy Electricals v. The Govt. Of Orissa & Others Opp. Parties.

Orissa High Court
Apr 23, 1997

S.N Phukan, C.J:— The petitioner, namely, M/s. Bharat Heavy Electricals Ltd., is a public sector undertaking of the Govt. of India having its corporate office in Delhi. It has several units, of which the Industrial System Group is one having its office at Bangalore. The petitioner-corporation executes jobs at different parts of the country and abroad. During the period from 1979 to 1987, the petitioner through its unit Industrial System Group, bad undertaken two different contract works successfully in the Rourkela Steel Plant of the Steel Authority of India Ltd. M/s. English Electric Co. Ltd. was its sub-contracttor. The petitioner had opened an administrative office at Rourkela where some woxkmen including opposite parties 4 to 7 herein were appointed on temporary basis. Their services were extended from time to time till the contract works were completed. Thereafter the services of the workmen including the above opposite parties were terminated on payment of notice pay and retrenchment compensation as required under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.

2. Opp. party No 4, Shri A. Mishra, was a driver and worked from 10-11-1979 to 6-6-1986. Opp. patty No. 5, Shri D.K Mahanty, worked as Office Attendaat-cum Messenger from 29-3-1979 to 2-5-1985. Opposite party No. 6, Shri P.N Sahu, worked as Driver from 26-12-1979 to 29-7-1985. Opposite party No. 7, Shri B. Prasad, worked as Cook from 1-2-1983 to 1-3-1986.

3. The General Secretary of the Steel Employees Trade Union, opp. party No. 3, raised an industrial dispute demanding regularisation of services of seven workmen working under the petitioner-corporation under the aforesaid two contracts including the present opp. parties 4 to 7. As the conciliation proceeding failed, the State Government made the following reference to the Industrial Tribunal, Bhubaneswar:—

“Whether S/Sri T.M Thomas, Typist, A. Mishra, Driver, M. Ravindra, Driver, D.K Mohanty, Office Assistant-cum-Messenger, P.M Sahu, Driver, B. Prasad, Cook and Smt. Saroja Behera, Sweepress, the work-charged workmen of Bharat Heavy Electrical Ltd., (Industrial System Group), a contractor of Rourkela Steel Plant are entitled for regularisation in the regular post of Bharat Heavy Electricals Ltd., and if so, from which date?”

4. In respect of Shri T.M Thomas, Typist, and Shri M. Ravindra, Driver, no relief was granted by the Industrial Tribunal since the above two workmen were provided employment in the State of Tamil Nadu. In respect of Smt. Saroja Behera also, no relief was granted since she had submitted resignation from service. Before the Tribunal, on behalf of the workmen three witnesses were examined and four documents were exhibited. On behalf of the petitioner, one witness was examined and 34 documents were exhibited.

5. From the award of the Tribunal, we find that as many as six issues were framed. After considering the evidence on record, the Tribunal directed regularisation of services of opp. parties 4 to 7 in their respective posts which they were holding under the petitioner-corporation from the date of their initial appointment on temporary basis (emphasis supplied). The Tribunal fuither directed payment of all pecuniary benefits which the workman were entitled to.

6. The Tribunal noted that the Industrial System Group unit of the petitioner undertakes contract works both in India and abroad. It also took note of the documents annexed as Annexures-5 and 6, which were exhibited as Exts. 2 and 3, and noted that the petitioner had taken up a contract work at Varanasi for which it needed certain man power. Therefore, by the above letters, the petitioner-corporation (Industrial System Group) intimated its different units to forward the names of those employees who could be spared for giving employment. It was also noted that as the work at Rourkela Steel Plant was likely to be closed, N.M.R employees who would be retrenched from their service should be considered lor absorption in the vacancies at Varanasi. On the ground that the management at Varanasi agreed to take employees working at Rourkela Steel Plant, the Tribunal held that the workmen should have been regularised in service in the respective posts as they were working for 3 to 7 years. Hence, the present writ petition.

7. We have heard Mr. S.B Nanda, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr. B.M Patnaik, learned counsel for the woikmen.

8. We may now consider whether the Tribunal was justified in giving a direction for regularisation of services of opp. parties 4 to 7, and that too from the date of their initial appointment. Before considering the facts, let us extract the law on the subject.

9. In Jaswant Singh v. Union of India, (1979) 4 SCC 440 : A.I.R 1980 S.C 115, the Apex Court held that worked charged employees are engaged on temporary basis as their appointments are made for execution of a specific work and from the very nature of their employment, their services automatically come to an end on the completion of work, the sole purpose for which they were employed.

10. In State of Haryana v. Piara Singh, (1992) 4 SCC 118 : A.I.R 1992 S.C 2130, the question of regularisation of the services of temporary/ad hoc employees came up for consideretion. In that case, over the last several years, a large number of appointmests were made to class III and Class IV service in the States of Punjab and Haryana on ad hoc basis. Though persons were initially appointed for six months or so, they were allowed to continue for years together. Both the State Governments issued directions from time to time regarding regularisation of services of such ad hoc employees; but as some of the employees could not qualify, they were not regularised. So they approached the High Court and some of them also directly approached the Apex Court. Besides the ad hoc/temporary employees, employees working under work-charged establishment, daily wagers, casual labourers and those employed in temporary/time-bound projects also wanted regularisation through Court. A Division Bench of the High Court of Punjab and Hasyana directed, inter alia, regularisation of the employees. The Apex Court, after considering its earlier decisions held that:—

(i) creation or abolition of posts is the prerogative of the Executive and the main concern of the Court is to ensure the rule of law and to see that the Executive acts fairly and givas a fair deal to its employees Consistent with the requirements of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution;

(ii) the Court while giving direction for regularisation must act with due care and caution, and a practical and pragmatic view has to be taken inasmuch as every such direction not only tells upon the public exchequer but also has the effect of increasing the cadre strength of a particular service, class or category.

11. The Apex Court held that the direction that all those ad hoc/temporary employees who had continued for more than a year should be regularised, if implemented, would mean creation of posts, and, that apart, a person not qualified for the post may get regularisation and therefore such direction cannot be given.

12. In Delhi Development Horticulture Employees' Union v. Delhi Administration, (1992) 4 SCC 99 : A.I.R 1992 S.C 789, it was held that for regularisation, there must be regular and permanent pests or it must be established that although the work is of regular and permanent nature, the device of appointing and keeping the workers on ad hoc or temporary basis has been resorted to in order to deny them the legitimate benefits of permanent employment (see paragraph 9). It was also held that there was no scope for regularisation in the absence of a sanctioned post or sanctioned strength of workers.

13. We may now refer to Ghaziabad Development Authority v. Vikram Chaudhury, (1995) 5 SCC 210 : A.I.R 1995 S.C 2325. A writ petition was filed before the Allahabad High Court claiming parity in appointment and pay with regular employees and also regularisation of service. As the petitioners were appointed on daily wage basis in a project, a learned single Judge of the said High Court rejected the prayer for regularisation, but gave direction to follow the principles contained in sections 25-F and 25 G of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. The Apex Court held that as the petitioners were temporary daily wage employees, so long as there was no regular post available for employment, the question of making pay at par with regular employees did not arise and that they would be entitled to get minimum wages as prescribed under the law or the prevailing wages as available in the locality.

14. In State of U.P v. U.P Madhyamik Shiksha Pariskad Shramik Sangh, (1996) 7 SCC 34 : A.I.R 1996 S.C 708, the Apex Court did not approve of the direction given by the High Court that as the employees had been regularly working for over 15 years and doing similar work at par with regular class IV employees, they shall be entitled to get equal pay for equal work and also regularisation of their services by creating appropriate posts. It was also held that it is an administrative procedure that creation of a post is a condition for filling up the post on permanent basis, and that the exigencies of the administration and the need for creation of a number of posts are matters of executive policy of the Government. The Apex Court took note of the fact that during the examinations conducted by the Board when the exigencies demand for doing manual work like lifting of bundles, pasting of envelopes, etc, daily wagers are engaged and are paid at the rate fixed under the Minimum Wages Act. Therefore, unless posts are created, the petitioners are not entitled to be fitted into any regular post. The Apex Court noted that if posts are created or fall vacant, the Board used to regularise the services of the daily wagers on the basis of their length of engagement and performance of the work. Therefore, the Apex Court directed that when regular posts are created or posts fall vacant, the daily wage employees, on the basis of their seniority, length of service and performance of work, may be considered for regularisation according So rules and the rules of reservation in force.

15. In State of Himachal Pradesh v. Suresh Kumar Verma, (1996) 7 SCC 562 : A.I.R 1996 S.C 1565, the Apex Court noted that the project in which the respondent-employees were engaged had come to an end and therefore, their services were terminated for want of work, and held that the Court cannot give any direction to reengage the employees in any other work or appoint them against existing vacancies; otherwise, the judicial process would become other mode of recruitment de hors the rules.

16. We may now summarise the law of regularisation as laid down by the Apex Court:—

(i) It is the prerogative of the executive or the employer to create and abolish posts and the concern of the Court is to ensure that the executive ox the employer gives a fair deal to its employees consistent with the requirements of Articies 14 and 16 of the Constitution.

(ii) The Court while giving direction for regularisation must act with due cate and caution and a practical and pragmatic view has to be taken inasmuch as every such direction will have the effect of creating new posts thereby, in case of State or authorities under Article 12 of the Constitution, increating the financial burden of the State or the authorities, as the case may he. It would also have the effect of increasing the cadre strength of a particular service, class or category, if there is any rule limiting the cadre strenth.

(iii) In the event it is directed that ad hoc/temporay employees, who have continued for a particular period, should be regularised, it would mean creation of new posts and, further, persons who might not qualify, either under the service rules ox executive directions, would enter into service by back door method.

(iv) Unless there are sanctioned posts or sanctioned strength of workers, Court cannot direct regularisation of employees appointed on ad hoc/temporary basis. Of course, such a direction can be given if the device of appointing or keeping the workers on ad hoc/temporary basis is resorted to for denying them the legitimate benefit of permanent employment.

(v) If there is no tegular post available for employment, the question of directing the employer to grant equal pay at par with the regular employees to persons appointed on daily wage basis in a project doss not arise.

(vi) If a person is eagaged in a particular project, Court cannot direct re-engagement of such person in any other work or appoint him against any existing vacancy otherwise, the judicial process would become other mode of recruitment de hors the rules.

17. It is not disputed that the works which were taken up by the petitioner-corporation came to an end on 14-8-1987. Therefore, the establishment of the petitioner-corporation was closed with effect from that date. Accordingly, a circular was issued, vide Annexme-3, which was marked as Ext. J before the Tribunal. This fact was not noted by the Tribunal, That apart, from the reference itself made by the State Government to the Tribunal, it is absolutely clear that the opposite party-workmen were work-charged employees under the petitioner-corporation. Annexure-4 is the procedure for employment of work-charged personnel on monthly or daily rates and payment to them. This document was proved and exhibited before the Tribunal. It provides, inter alia, that the employment of work-charged staff should be regulated according to actual needs and the progress of work from time to time. It also provides that their services are terminable after the prescribed period of notice end that they would have no claim for employment in the regular establishment. This aspect was also not considered by the Tribunal.

18. As laid down by the Apex Court ((1979) 4 SCC 440 : A.I.R 1980 S.C 115) work-charged employees are engaged on temporary basis and their appointments are made for execution of a specific work and from the very nature of their employment, their services automatically came to an end on the completion of the work, the sole purpose for which they were employed. As the project undertaken by the petitioner-corporation has come to an end, and as the workmen is question were work-charged employees, they have no Tight to claim either regularisation or continuance in employment, in view of the above legal position. We may state here that the services of the opposite party-workmen were duly terminated by payment of wages in lieu of notice and retrenchment compensation, as provided under the Industrial Disputes Act.

19. From the award, we find that the Tribunal was swayed away by the facts that two workmen were engaged by the petitioner-Corporation in another State and that as work was available in Varanasi unit, letters were sect to the concerned authority in the Rourkela project regarding absorption of NMR. employees working at Rourkela in the project at Varanasi. The two letters in this regard, annexed as Annexures-5 and 6, were duly proved and exhibited before the Tribunal. In the letter dated 11-12-1984, Annexure-5, it was mentioned that there were certain N.M.R employees who had been working at Rourkela site office for several years and as the work at the site office at Rourkela was tapering off and the site was likely to be closed down, the N.M.R employees will have to be retrenched. Therefore, the head office of the petitioner corporation at Bangalore wanted to know whether any of these employees could be considered against the vacancies at Varanasi and accordingly, biodata was called for. This letter does not give a right to any work tharged employee working at Rourkela either for his appointment or for regularisation of his service in the post in whith he was initially appointed. The Tribunal did not consider this aspect of the matter and, therefore, its findings are not sustainable. The mere fact that two other workmen were given employment elsewhere would not give a legal right to the opposite patty-workmen to get regularisation in the posts they were holding or for their regularisation in any other posts under the petitioner-corporation.

20. Annexure-6 is a letter from the Personnel Officer of the Bharat Heavy Electrical Ltd., Corporate Office, New Delhi, to the Head of Personnel of various units intimating the type of man-power required for Varanasi project with a request that it be circulated amongst the employees of each unit. It was also desired that the names of those employees, who wanted transfer and could be spared, be forwarded to the Project Administrator at Varanasi unit. This letter also does not confer any legal right on the opposite party-workmen to get employment at Varanasi unit as they were appointed as work-charged employees in the two projects at Rourkela.

21. In the award the Tribunal has directed regularisation of the opp party-werkmen in the respective posts held by them from the date of their initial appointment. If this is given effect to, it will amount to giving direction to create posts in a project which has been closed down. This, in view of the decisions of the Apex Court, cannot be done. In fact, as urged by the learned counsel for the petitioner, the award is unexecutable. That apart, giving such direction for regularisation would amount to not only creation of permanent posts, but also additional burden on the finance of the petitioner-corporation, which, in the light of the decisions of the Apex Court, cannot be done.

22. From the procedure for employment of work-charged personnel on monthly or daily races, vide Annsxure-4, it appears that the petitioner-corporation decided to engage persons on the basis of requirement in a particular project. If a direction is given for regularisation, it will mean that the opp. party-workmen would be permanent employees of the petitioner-corporation and they will have to be posted wherever any contract work is undertaken by the petitioner-corporation, which is not permissible under the law laid down by the Apex Court.

23. When the matter came up for final hearing, keeping in view the interest of the present workmen, we wanted to know from the petitioner-corporation whether they could be engaged in some other project. We also asked the opp. party-workmen to give a list of projects being undertaken by the petitioner-corporation. According to them, the following projects have been undertaken by the petitioner-corporation:

(a) Rourkela Steel Plant.

(b) Indravati Project.

(c) N.T.P.C, Kaniha.

(d) Ib Valley Project of M.C.L,

24. In the additional affidavit filed on 23-6-1993 by the Manages (Personnel & Administration) of the petitioner-corporation the matter has been explained in detail. In paragraph 2 of the said affidavit it has been stated that to assist the core group of the petitioner-corporation in executing particular work, local personnel are recruited in the cadre of drivers, cooks, messengers, sweepers, etc. as and when required, on purely temporary basis and are retained till their services are required for the specific project site work. Therefore, it will not be in public interest to direct regularisation of the present workmen as it will deprive the local personnel of the area where a particular contract is executed by the petitioner-corporation. However, in paragraph 6 of the affidavit, it has been fairly stated that the Industrial System Group of the petitioner-corporation has recently taken up the work of “electrics for Sintering Plant Stage II Project work” at Rourkela Steel Plant and that if in future need arises, opportunity will be given to the ex-workmen of the last completed project at Rourkela on the basis of seniority. We are of the opinion that this is a fair stand taken by the petitioner.

25. For the reasons stated above, we set aside the impugned award dated 26-8-1992 passed by the Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal, Bhubaneswar, in Industrial Disputes Case No. 50 of 1986. However, we direct the petitioner-corporation to consider re-engagement of the opposite patty-workmen on work-charged basis according to their seniority, if there is any such need in the project, namely, contract work for “electrics for Sintering Plant Stage-II” at Rourkela Steel Plant. This observation, however will not give any right to the opposite party-workmen to claim regularisation in view of the policy of the petitioner-corporation and the settled position of law. With the aforesaid observation, the writ petition is dispossed of Parties shall bear their own costs.

A. Pasayat, J.:— I agree.

26. Writ petition disposed of.