Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

M/S. Sunbeam High Tech Developers Private Limited & Ors. Petitioners v. Mcgm & Ors. S

Bombay High Court
Mar 26, 2018
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India was filed by M/s. Sunbeam High Tech Developers Private Limited and others challenging the demolition of the petitioners' structures by the Municipal Corporation (Respondent/Corporation) on 28/09/2017. The petitioners alleged that demolition was carried out without issuance of any notice of demolition to them. They sought directions permitting reconstruction of the demolished structures, repair and relocation of two porta cabins to their original place, or alternatively an order permitting reconstruction subject to reimbursement of reconstruction costs by the Respondents.

Relevant factual background as pleaded: the land originally in the possession of Raghunath Mahadev Salvi (from 1952) contained residential structures in existence since the 1960s. The petitioners acquired possession through transfers and were operating a restaurant and bar in a 2,800 sq. ft. structure with various licenses (eating house, shop and establishment, F.L.III for bar, and license from the Food and Drug Department). Documents produced included a non-agricultural (NA) order dated 25/04/1972 showing assessment tax payment, licenses (Exhibits B, C, D), and confirmation from the District Inspector of Land Records and City Survey Officer that the structures existed during survey on 01/04/1964 (Exhibit I), authenticated by the Additional Collector (Exhibit J).

Procedurally, the petition challenges the demolition action of 28/09/2017 (the demolition occurred within 15 days from notice which respondents say was pasted on 20/09/2017). The petition was argued before the Court and judgment was pronounced on 26/03/2018 by a Bench of A.S. Oka and P.N. Deshmukh, JJ.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the demolition of the petitioners' structures on 28/09/2017 was lawful when the petitioners allege no notice of demolition or opportunity to be heard was issued to them.
  2. Whether, having been demolished without following due process, the petitioners are entitled to reconstruct the demolished structures and to have two porta cabins repaired and relocated to their original place.
  3. Whether the procedure laid down by this Court in Sopan Maruti Thopte (AIR 1996 Bom 304) was followed by the Corporation before effecting demolition and, if not, what relief should follow.
  4. Whether cancellation of the petitioners' licenses (as amended into the petition) without giving an opportunity of hearing affects entitlement to relief.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The demolition carried out on 28/09/2017 was without issuance of any notice of demolition to the petitioners and so was illegal.
  • The notice that was issued (allegedly under Section 351 of the MMC Act) was issued in the wrong name and therefore bad in law.
  • Documents from the District Inspector of Land Records and the City Survey established that the subject structures existed since the survey on 01/04/1964; hence the petitioners had legitimate possession and paid relevant taxes and held requisite licenses for running a restaurant and bar.
  • The petitioners relied on the procedure laid down by this Court in Sopan Maruti Thopte and contended that the Corporation did not follow that procedure before demolition.
  • The petition was amended to record that the petitioners' licenses were cancelled without giving them an opportunity of hearing.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Respondent Nos.1 to 3 contended that a repair permission had been issued earlier by Respondent No.3 for carrying out repairs to the structure in favour of the original owner (Raghunath Salvi), and no precise dimensions were mentioned in that permission.
  • The respondents asserted that the petitioners did not produce a copy of the application for repair permission and therefore had not approached the Court with clean hands; this suggested the construction was without permission.
  • Respondents stated they had requested the Deputy Collector to provide documents establishing authenticity of the subject structures but had not received a reply; they maintained demolition was legal and stated demolition followed a notice claimed to have been issued/pasted on 20/09/2017 and that demolition occurred on 28/09/2017.
  • To support their position, the respondents filed the affidavit of the concerned Mukadam (official) who deposed to visiting the premises on 20/09/2017 at multiple times, finding it closed, pasting the notice on the outer side, and obtaining photographs.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sopan Maruti Thopte & Anr. vs. Pune Municipal Corporation & Anr., AIR 1996 Bom 304 The procedural directions municipal corporations must follow before demolition under Section 351 B.M.C. Act / Section 260 B.P.M.C. Act and related provisions: (i) 15 days to submit reply on notices under Section 351/260; (ii) demolition may be carried out 15 days after order communicated; (iii) in case of detected ongoing unauthorised construction, short notice of 24 hours after panchanama and photographs may be given; (iv) reconstruction within one year may be demolished after 24 hours' notice; (v) special rules where structure assessed as non-agricultural for two years (15 days) and discretion for oral hearing; (vi) in other cases a 7-day show cause notice. The Court found the Corporation had not followed the due process as required by Sopan Maruti's directions before demolishing the petitioners' structures. On that basis the Court permitted reconstruction subject to conditions and clarified that any future demolition by the Corporation must follow the procedure laid down in Sopan Maruti's case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reviewed the record and proceeded through the following analytical steps (as recorded in the opinion):

  1. Documentary evidence produced by the petitioners (Exhibits A, B, C, D, I and J) established: (a) an NA order dated 25/04/1972 evidencing assessment tax payment; (b) eating-house and shop & establishment licenses; (c) licence for bar/restaurant operations; and (d) confirmation from District Inspector of Land Records and City Survey Officer that the structures existed at the time of the 01/04/1964 survey, authenticated by the Additional Collector.
  2. The Court accepted that demolition took place on 28/09/2017 and that the respondents contend a notice was pasted on 20/09/2017; the petitioners alleged no notice was issued to them. The demolition thus occurred within 15 days of the pasted notice.
  3. The Court compared the Corporation's conduct with the procedural requirements laid down in Sopan Maruti Thopte, which prescribe safeguards (including specified periods for reply, opportunity to be heard, and limits on short notice demolitions in certain circumstances).
  4. The Court found that respondents had not established that they followed the due process mandated by Sopan Maruti Thopte before demolition. The affidavit of the Mukadam stated only that a notice had been pasted on the premises and photographs were taken; the Court found this insufficient to show compliance with the required procedural safeguards.
  5. Given the documentary proof of existence and the absence of established compliance with the due process requirements, the Court concluded that the Corporation had shown "complete disregard to the law" and had illegally demolished the petitioners' structures.
  6. The Court therefore exercised remedial discretion: permitting reconstruction of the demolished structures described in paragraph 4 of the petition, subject to terms designed to protect the Corporation's statutory rights (including that reconstruction would not confer authenticity and the Corporation may initiate lawful demolition thereafter following Sopan Maruti's procedure).
  7. The Court refused the petitioners' relief to reconstruct two porta cabins in their original place because an earlier owner had been served with notice under Section 51(1) of the MRTP Act, 1966 and had instituted L.C. Suit No.2811/2012 in the City Civil Court seeking interim protection, which was said to remain in force; thus the petitioners were directed to pursue their remedies in the competent court on that subject.
  8. The Court set additional conditions: reconstructed structures must be of the same dimensions and similar construction material; prior to reconstruction the petitioners must serve notice on the designated officer of the concerned ward; reconstruction would still be treated as without development permission if original construction was without such permission, and the Corporation could thereafter initiate demolition in accordance with law as per Sopan Maruti's directions.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Rule in the writ petition was partly made absolute on terms: the petitioners are permitted to reconstruct the demolished structures as described in paragraph 4 of the petition, at the same place and of the same dimensions and similar materials, subject to conditions (including prior notice to the designated officer). The petitioners were denied relief to reconstruct the two porta cabins to their original place. No orders as to costs were made.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The petitioners may reconstruct the demolished structures subject to the Court's conditions (notice to the designated officer before reconstruction; no authenticity conferred by reconstruction; the Corporation retains the right to initiate lawful demolition thereafter using the procedure in Sopan Maruti Thopte).
  • Specific denial: Relief to reconstruct two porta cabins was refused because the matter was the subject of pending proceedings (L.C. Suit No.2811/2012) before the City Civil Court with interim protection said to be in force; the petitioners were directed to pursue available remedies before the competent court on that point.
  • Procedural safeguard reiterated: The Court required that any future demolition by the Corporation must follow the procedural safeguards and directions established in Sopan Maruti Thopte (AIR 1996 Bom 304).
  • No new legal principle or precedent was created by this order beyond applying and enforcing the established procedure laid down in Sopan Maruti Thopte; the decision provides remedial relief in the particular facts of this case.

Additional note recorded in the judgment: After pronouncement the Municipal Corporation sought an eight-week stay. The petitioners' senior counsel stated they would not enforce the reconstruction order for eight weeks; the Court accepted that statement and therefore did not consider the stay prayer separately.

Show all summary ...

rsk 1/7 13-2-18-WP-2613-17.doc

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

WRIT PETITION NO.2613 OF 2017

M/s. Sunbeam High Tech Developers Private Limited & Ors. ..Petitioners

vs.

MCGM & Ors. ...Respondents

----

Mr. M. M. Vashi, Senior Advocate a/w Ms. Aparna Deokar i/b M.P. Vashi & Associates for the Petitioners.

Ms.Vandana Mahadik for the Respondents.

----

CORAM : A.S. OKA & P. N. DESHMUKH, JJ.

DATE ON WHICH JUDGMENT IS RESERVED : 13th FEBRUARY, 2018.

DATE ON WHICH JUDGMENT IS PRONOUNCED : 26th MARCH, 2018.

JUDGMENT [PER : P.N. DESHMUKH, J.]

. This petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, challenges the action of demolition of petitioner's subject structures by the Respondent/Corporation on 28/9/2017 without issuing any notice of demolition or otherwise to the Petitioners. In the circumstances, the specific prayer clause (b) of the petition is for direction to the Respondents to allow the Petitioners to reconstruct the demolished structures and to repair and relocate the two porta cabins in its original place. In the alternative, it is further prayed that the Respondents be ordered and directed to permit the petitioner to reconstruct the subject structure demolished on 28/9/2017 or to allow the Petitioners to reconstruct the same subject to the Respondents reimbursing the cost whatever shall be incurred by the Petitioner for reconstruction.

2. It is the case of the Petitioners that one Raghunath Mahadev Salvi was the owner and in occupation of land ad-measuring 2000 sq. yard at Survey No.39(part) CTS No.1 situated at Village Valnai from 1952 and

1

had constructed 8 residential structures each ad-measuring 375 sq.ft. and was making payment of nonagricultural assessment tax since 1972 as per the order of the Revenue authorities. It is further the case of the petitioner that in addition to above residential structures there was one more structure ad-measuring 1200 sq. ft. which was also assessed by Respondents on which property tax was regularly paid.

3. The entire property that is the above referred structures were sold by his legal heirs to one Mr. R. Mugum Pariar, who transferred and assigned all his rights title and interest in respect of the subject structures in favour of one Sambhaji Dattu Chauvan from whom the Petitioner came into possession of the subject structures and was in occupation of the same, which consists of 2800 sq. ft. used for running a restaurant on obtaining eating house license and shop and establishment license both issued by the Respondent department. It is also the case of the Petitioner that he was also having a Bar for which he was issued with F.L.III license by the competent authority as well as was issued with license from the Food and Drug Department required for the purpose of carrying out business of Restaurant and Bar.

4. It further appears to be the case of the Petitioner that on 9/12/2016 one notice came to be issued in the name of directors of his firm purportedly under section 351 of the MMC Act which is duly replied through his advocate and in the meantime he had obtained necessary documents from the office of the District Inspector of land records and the City Survey to establish as to since when, the structures which is the subject matter in the petition were in existence. It is the case of the petitioners that City Survey office had confirmed that the structures were found in existence during the survey which was carried out on 1/4/1964.

2

5. In the background of above stated facts, the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner thus contended that the impugned notice which even otherwise was issued in the wrong name is bad in law and as the act of demolition is carried out by the Respondents without following due process as laid down by this Court in the case of Sopan Maruti Thopte & Anr. vs. Pune Municipal Corporation and Anr.1, the petition be allowed. The Petitioner by effecting amendment to the petition has also brought on record fact of cancellation of his licenses without giving any opportunity of hearing to the Petitioners.

6. Respondent Nos.1 to 3 resisted the petition by filing affidavit in reply contending that the repair permission was issued by the Respondent No.3 for carrying out repair to the structure to the original owner Raghunath Salvi. No exact dimensions were mentioned in the said repair permission and that since the Petitioner has not submitted a copy of the application for repair permission to the Respondents nor has annexed such document in the petition, he has not approached with clean hands which fact itself shows that the construction is without obtaining any permission from the competent authority. Another contention raised by the Respondent No.3 is that though, the Respondents issued letter to Deputy Collector requesting to provide documents establishing the authenticity of the subject structures, till date no reply is received from the concerned authority and has further stated that the act of demolition thus carried out by the Respondent is legal which is stated to be carried out by issuing notice 28/9/2017. To establish the said case, Respondent has filed affidavit of the concerned Mukadam, stating that on instructions of his superior he has visited the subject structure on 20/9/2017 at 2.30, 3.30 and again at

4.30 p.m., however as the premises were found closed he pasted the notice on the outer side of the premises and obtained its photographs. Thus, it

1 AIR 1 996 Bom 304

3

appears to be the case of respondents that on pasting notice as aforesaid subject structures came to be legally demolished.

7. We have given careful consideration to the facts and submissions and from the documents it is established that the subject structures were in existence since 1/4/1964 and were in possession of the Petitioners. Admittedly, demolition came to be effected on 28/9/2017 i.e. within 15 days from the date of notice of demolition which was pasted to structure on 20/9/2017 which even otherwise is not issued to the petitioners.

8. In the case of Sopan Maruti (supra) the first Court has issued following directions in paragraph Nos.19 to 21 which reads thus.

"19. Hence, on the basis of the law as discussed above, it is directed that after 1st May, 1996 the Bombay Municipal Corpo ration or the Municipal Corporations con stituted under the B. P.M.C. Act would follow the following procedure before taking action under Section 351 of the B.M.C. Act or under S.260 of the B.P.M.C. Act.

"(i) In every case where a notice under Section 351 of the B.M.C. Act/ under Sec. 260 of B.P.M.C. Act is issued to a party 15 days' time shall be given for submitting the reply. In case the party to whom notice is issued sends the reply with the documents, and shows cause, the Municipal Commissioner or Deputy Municipal Commissioner shall consider the reply and if no sufficient cause is shown, give short reasons for not accepting the contention of the affected party.

(ii) It would be open to the Commissioner to demolish the offending structure 15 days after the order of the Commissioner/Deputy Municipal Commissioner is communicated to the affected person.

(iii) In case the staff of the Corporation detects the building which is in the process of being constructed and/or reconstructed and/ or extended without valid permission from the Corporation, it would be open to the Commissioner to demolish the same by giving a short notice of 24 hours after drawing a panchanama at the site and also by taking photographs of such structure and/or extension. The photographs should indicate the date when the same were

4

taken.

(iv) In case where the Municipal Corporation has followed due process of law and demolished the unauthorised structure and or extension, if the same is reconstructed without valid permission within a period of one year, it would also be open to the Corporation to demolish the same by giving a short notice of 24 hours.

(v) If the offending structure and/or extension which is assessed by the Corporation for two years, notice shall provide for 15 days' time to show cause. If the Deputy Municipal Commissioner comes to the conclusion that he requires assistance of the party, he may give an oral hearing if he deems fit and proper before passing the order. It is made clear that oral hearing is not at all compulsory but it is at the discretion of the authority.

(vi) In any other case the Corporation is directed to issue a show cause notice in case of any structure and/or extension other than those mentioned in clauses (i) to (iv) above. The Corporation shall provide for 7 days' time to show cause in such a case."

20. In case the notice is issued under Sec. 478 of the B.P.M.C. Act, 1949 and if the person has not complied with the requisitions of the Commissioner, then it would be open to the Commissioner to demolish the unauthorised structure after expiry of 30 days of the period specified in the notice for removal of such construction.

21. The Municipal Corporations in the State of Maharashtra would follow the above directions so as to avoid unnecessary litigation:"

9. Documents filed in support of the petition, being at Exhibit "A"

establishes, the fact of NA order issued by the office of the Additional District Deputy Collector dated 25/4/1972, on the basis of which the erstwhile owner of the property Raghunath Salvi was paying assessment taxes. Exhibit "B" and "C" establish eating house license and Shop and Establishment licenses issued to the Petitioners, while Exhibit "D" establish the petitioners running Bar and Restaurant on possessing valid license from Collector, Sub-urban Bombay, being Competent Authority. Exhibit "I"

issued by the District Inspector of Land Records and City Survey Officer establishes authenticity of the structures, which are found in existence during the survey carried out on 1/4/1964 which document is found duly

5

authenticated by the Additional Collector by letter at Exhibit J, particularly upon the request made by the Respondents. This documents thus establish that the subject structure was in existence as aforesaid. Even otherwise from the case of respondents, there is nothing to establish that before action of demolition was carried out, due procedure as contemplated in law as aforesaid is followed.

10. Hence, we find this to be a fit case where the Respondent has shown complete disregard to the law and has illegally demolished all the subject structures of the petitioners without following due process of law. In the circumstances, we have no option but to permit the Petitioners to reconstruct the subject structure more particularly as described in paragraph 4 to the petition, subject to right of the Respondent No.1 to initiate action of demolition in accordance with law and clarify that reconstruction of the subject structures will not confer any authenticity of the subject structures. We, however deny the Petitioners any relief to reconstruct two porta cabins to its original place in view of the fact that the erstwhile owner of said subject structure having being served with notice under section 51(1) of the MRTP Act 1966 had filed L.C. Suit No.2811/2012 before the City Civil Court and had sought interim protection in respect of said subject structure which is said to be still in force. In that view of the matter, the Petitioner is at liberty to take recourse available under law on this subject of the petition before the Competent Court.

11. Hence, we pass the following order:

(i) It will be open for the petitioners to reconstruct the structures as has been stated in paragraph 4 of the Petition at the same place where it was in existence earlier and of the same dimensions. The construction material shall be of similar nature;

6

(ii) Before commencing the work of reconstruction, the petitioner shall serve a notice to the designated officer of the concerned ward of the respondent department. Needless to state that even if the structures are reconstructed on the basis of this order no authenticity will be conferred on the subject structures;

(iii) If the original subject structures were constructed without obtaining development permission, the reconstructed structures which are now permitted to be reconstructed will have to be treated as constructed without obtaining the development permission. Therefore, after reconstruction it will be open for the Respondent/Corporation to initiate action of demolition of the subject structures which however, shall not be taken without following the law laid down in Sopan Maruti's case supra;

(iv) Rule is partly made absolute on the above terms with no orders as to costs.

(P.N. DESHMUKH, J) (A.S. OKA, J.)

After the judgment is pronounced, the learned counsel appearing for the Municipal Corporation seeks stay for a period of eight weeks. The learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Petitioners on instructions states that the order of reconstruction will not be enforced by the Petitioners for a period of eight weeks from today. We accept the said statement. Hence, it is not necessary for us to consider the prayer for stay.

(P.N. DESHMUKH, J) (A.S. OKA, J.)

7