Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Daulat Singh And Others v. Maharaja Kesho Prasad Singh .

Patna High Court
May 19, 1920

Sultan Ahmad, J.:— The plaintiff brought this suit for declaration that the land in suit was Jagir land granted to the father of the defendant No. 1, who having left the service the plaintiff was entitled to take possession of the same. The defendant Nos. 2 and 6 contested the suit on the ground that the land was part of their guzashta land.

2. The trial Court decreed the suit, but on an appeal having been filed before the learned Judge, be held that the onus lay upon the plaintiff landlord to prove that the land in suit was his zirait land. There was a further appeal to the High Court of Calcutta, which set aside the judgment of the lower Appellate Court and remanded the case for a re-hearing of the appeal. On 14th May, 1918, the lower Appellate Court took up the case for disposal. The appellants-tenants were, however, not present, but the learned Judge heard the respondent and dismissed the appeal on the merits.

3. This second appeal has been filed against the judgment and decare of the learned Subordinate Judge. Mr. Parmeshwar Dayal appearing on behalf of the appellants mainly contends that the dismissal of the appeal on merits by the learned Subordinate Judge was ultra vires. He urges that the utmost that could be done was that the appeal should have been dismissed for default, and be brings to his and a decision in the case of Phul Koer v. Hashmat Ullah Khan(1). In my opinion, this contention has got no force.

4. In case the appellant does not appear on the date fixed, the lower Appellate Court has to follow the provision of Order 41, rule 17, which runs as follows:—

“Where on the day fixed, or on any other day to which the hearing may be adjourned, the appellant does not appear when the appeal is called on for hearing, the Court may make on order that the appeal be dismissed.”

5. It will be noticed that the language of section 556 of the old CPC, which corresponded to Order 41, rule 17, was different from the latter. Section 556 clearly stated that, “if the appellant does not appear on the day fixed then the appeal shall be dismissed.” It gave no discretion to the Court. But in the present Code a wide discretion is given to the Appellate Court; and, in my opinion, the lower Appellate Court could enter into the merits of the case and decide the appeal on its merits. The procedure, which has to be followed by the trial Court, however, is different from the procedure, which has to be adopted by the Appellate Court, when a party does not appear. Order 17, rule 2, says:

“Where, on any date, to which the hearing of the suit is adjourned, the parties, or any of them fail to appear, the Court may proceed to dispose of the suit, in one of the modes directed in that behalf by Order 9, and make such other order as it thinks fit.”

6. It is conceded that the words “or make such order as it thinks fit” in this rule do not mean the disposal of the suit on its merits. Then we refer to Order 9, rule 8, which provides the procedure where the defendant only appears and the plaintiff does not appear. This rule lays down that if the plaintiff does not appear and the defendant appears, then the Court shall make an order that the suit be dismissed. This means that there is no discretion left in the first Court as is given to the lower Appellate Court under Order 41, rule 17 While the first Court is bound to dismiss the suit for default under Order 9, rule 8, the Appellate Court is not bound to make an order that the appeal be dismissed. Under these circumstances, in my opinion, the lower Appellate Court had jurisdiction to decide the appeal on merits. The case reported as Phul Koer v. Hashmat Ullah Khan, cited above is a case where an order passed refusing to entertain an application under Order 9, rule 9 of the CPC, related to a suit and did not refer to an appeal, and, therefore, that decision in my opinion, has got no bearing upon the powers of an Appellate Court dismissing an appeal in the absence of a party.

7. This is the only ground that has been urged before me and it having failed, this appeal must be dismissed with costs.

8. Appeal dismissed.