- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Surya Narayan Yadav And Others (Petitioners) v. The Bihar State Electricity Board And Others (S).
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Nagendra Prasad Singh, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
These writ applications (leading case C.W.J.C. No. 4472 of 1982 with C.W.J.C. Nos. 2558 and 2562 of 1983 heard together) were filed by engineers who had been selected by the Bihar State Electricity Board (the Board) in 1975–76 for training under the Apprentice Act, 1961 and an Employment Promotion Programme. The trainees were given notices that training did not guarantee employment, but the Board continued trainees and later created ex-cadre posts to accommodate them.
The Board created ex-cadre posts and provisionally appointed these trainees (notifications dated 29-5-1980). A committee recommended provisional-regular appointments with two years' probation; the Board later created ex-cadre posts and issued provisional appointment orders stating appointments were “purely provisional for a period of two years terminable on one month's notice.”
Subsequent administrative actions included: an office order dated 26-11-1981 re-designating pay scale for Assistant Electrical Engineers (ex-cadre), a second office order dated 1-12-1981 that revised that pay scale (challenged by petitioners), issuance of Employment Notice No.1/83 on 26-5-1983 advertising cadre vacancies (challenged by petitioners), and communications (letter dated 15-6-1983) from the Secretary of the Board stating that ex-cadre appointees would not get revised pay scales effective 1-4-1981. The petitioners sought writs of mandamus directing absorption/appointment to cadre posts and quashing of the Board's orders (including the 1-12-1981 order and the 15-6-1983 communication).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Board can be directed by writ of mandamus to absorb/appoint petitioners (appointed to ex-cadre provisional posts) into the regular cadre posts of Assistant Executive Engineer/Assistant Electrical Engineer and Junior Electrical Engineer without following the statutory recruitment procedure prescribed by the Board's Rules/Regulations.
- Whether the Bihar State Electricity Board (Generation-cum-Transmission Cadre) Rules, 1976 and related Regulations (framed under clause (c) of section 79 of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948) are ultra vires or otherwise inapplicable so as to permit direct absorption of ex-cadre appointees into cadre posts without advertisement and selection.
- Whether the Board's office order dated 1-12-1981 (recalling/revising the 26-11-1981 pay-scale decision) and the Secretary's communication dated 15-6-1983 (ex-cadre employees not to get revised pay scales) were justified or should be quashed.
- Whether the advertisement (Employment Notice No.1/83 dated 26-5-1983) inviting applications for cadre posts was invalid insofar as it permitted filling cadre vacancies by open recruitment rather than by absorbing ex-cadre appointees.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The petitioners contended that they ought to be absorbed into the regular cadre posts (Assistant Electrical Engineer/Junior Electrical Engineer) on the basis of assurances, the committee recommendation of 10-3-1979 and that they formed a class deserving special treatment.
- They challenged the validity of certain Board Rules as being ultra vires or labelled wrongly (Rules vs. Regulations), and alternatively contended that Regulations should prevail over Rules and permit absorption without advertisement.
- They asserted estoppel and reliance on prior Committee recommendations/assurances to claim regularisation/confirmation after probation.
- They challenged the advertisement and the Secretary's communication (15-6-1983) excluding ex-cadre appointees from revised pay scales as arbitrary and discriminatory.
- They relied on authorities (including Supreme Court and High Court decisions) to support entitlements to regularisation or relief where the substantive procedure had been followed in substance or where special classification justified different treatment.
Board and Interveners' Arguments
- The Board maintained that the petitioners were appointed to ex-cadre provisional posts; statutory Rules and Regulations (framed under section 79(c) of the Act) govern cadre recruitment and require advertisement and constitution of a Selection Committee (Rule 7), so absorption into cadre without following the prescribed procedure was impermissible.
- The Board argued petitioners accepted provisional appointments on stated conditions and did not challenge them for two years, and therefore cannot now claim direct appointment to cadre posts without following recruitment procedure.
- The Board asserted that the advertisement (Employment Notice No.1/83) was valid and that petitioners were eligible to apply for cadre posts and be considered along with other applicants; the maximum age condition in advertisement (maximum 42 years as on 1-4-1983) applied to all.
- Interveners (persons who had applied in response to the advertisement) opposed any relief that would prevent the Board from filling cadre vacancies by open recruitment.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| I.J. Divakar v. Government of Andhra Pradesh (Civil Appeal No. 2484 of 1982) | Inviting applications does not create a right to the post; Government may alter the regulatory framework and withdraw posts from a selection body's purview; regulation/notification power can be validly exercised. | The court held the decision in I.J. Divakar was of no help to petitioners because the Board had not exercised any power comparable to the proviso to clause (3) of Article 320; thus the case was distinguishable on facts. |
| S.S. Moghe v. Union of India ((1981) 3 SCC 271 : AIR 1981 SC 1495) | When a new service is constituted, the authority may decide policy on sources of recruitment; sub-rule permitting temporary/adhoc incumbents to be eligible for permanent appointment is valid. | The court observed that Moghe supports policy choice in framing recruitment sources, but found no analogous rule in the Board's regulations that gave petitioners special entitlement; hence Moghe did not assist the petitioners here. |
| Ajit Singh v. State of Punjab ((1983) 2 SCC 217 : AIR 1983 SC 494) | Case concerned arbitrary action against temporary employees; illustrates where action may be arbitrary. | The court stated it could not appreciate how Ajit Singh was relevant to present facts and did not rely upon it to aid the petitioners. |
| Ramesh Prasad Singh v. State of Bihar ((1978) 1 SCC 37 : AIR 1978 SC 327) | Doctrine of equality (Arts. 14 & 16): equality guarantees do not demand identical rules for differently situated persons; reasonable classification is permissible. | The court cited this case to explain that classification by the appointing authority is permissible and that it is for the authority to make reasonable classifications; it refused to compel the Board to create a special class for petitioners. |
| Md. Usman v. State of Andhra Pradesh ((1971) 2 SCC 188 : AIR 1971 SC 1801) | Authority on equality and classification under Arts. 14 & 16 referenced in context of permissible distinctions. | Used as supporting authority for the proposition that equal treatment does not require identical rules for all; the court referenced it in the classification discussion. |
| Chiranjit Lal Chowdhuri v. Union of India (1950 SCR 869 : AIR 1952 SC 41) | Foundational proposition on equality and reasonable classification. | Referenced to support the same principle regarding permissible classification under Articles 14 and 16. |
| T. Devadasan v. Union of India (AIR 1964 SC 179) | Art.16(1) ensures equality of opportunity in employment; every opportunity to apply should be afforded to all eligible persons whenever posts are to be filled. | The court relied on this principle to stress that statutory recruitment procedures must afford equal opportunity and thus advertisement/selection cannot be bypassed to the prejudice of other eligible candidates. |
| Dr. G.P. Sarabhai v. Union of India (Delhi High Court, (1983) Labour & Industrial Cases 910) | Where substantive requisites of the controlling provision are followed in substance, appointments may be deemed regular. | The court noted the decision but did not treat it as controlling; it observed that if rules compelling regularisation were complied with in substance, regularisation could be deemed—but that was not the situation here. |
| Sharif Ahmad v. The Regional Transport Authority, Meerut ((1978) 1 SCC 1 : AIR 1978 SC 209) | Court may direct authority to perform duty in appropriate cases. | The court observed the principle but held that where statutory rules prescribe a particular recruitment mode, mandating a different mode (absorption without following rules) was not appropriate here. |
| Jit Ram Shiv Kumar v. State of Haryana ((1981) 1 SCC 11 : AIR 1980 SC 1285) | Limits on invoking estoppel against statutory/regulatory prescriptions; care in applying estoppel to public law/statutory contexts. | The court relied on this line of authority to reject estoppel arguments by petitioners seeking enforcement of assurances contrary to statutory recruitment rules. |
| Moti Lal Padampat Sugar Mills Co. (P) Ltd. v. State of Uttar Pradesh (ATR 1979 S.C. 621) | Discussed in context of estoppel and public law limitations. | The court referred to the case while explaining why estoppel cannot be used to override statutory recruitment rules in the instant facts. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court conducted a textual and structured analysis of the Board's Rules and Regulations (noting they were framed under clause (c) of section 79 of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948) and the applicable recruitment provisions for Generation-cum-Transmission cadre and for general cadre posts. The reasoning proceeded by identifying the statutory framework and applying it to the facts as pleaded.
-
Validity and scope of the Rules/Regulations:
The court observed that, although the Board labelled the Scheme as 'Rules', the provisions fell within the ambit of section 79(c) and therefore could not be held ultra vires. The Board's Generation‑cum‑Transmission Cadre Rules, 1976 and other cadre rules were held to be applicable to appointments to the respective cadre posts.
-
Procedural requirement to advertise and select:
Rule 7 (Generation-cum-Transmission Rules) requires, for direct recruitment, publication of advertisement and constitution of a Selection Committee. Regulation 4(i) and (ii) of the Board's Service Regulations were interpreted to mean that where specific cadre rules exist (as here), those specific rules govern recruitment; there was no conflict between rule 7 and regulation 4(ii)(b). Thus direct recruitment must follow the rule 7 procedure and cannot be bypassed by relying on general Regulations.
-
Claims for merger/absorption under Regulations 82 and 84:
The court held regulation 82 (on merger of ex-cadre posts into a cadre) to be an enabling power for the Board, but it was not appropriate for the Court to command the Board by writ to exercise that discretionary power to merge ex-cadre posts and absorb the petitioners. Regulation 84 (on absorption of outsiders in certain circumstances) was found inapplicable because it addresses outsiders absorbed on nationalisation or permanent absorption of government servants, not persons already in Board service as ex-cadre appointees.
-
Junior Electrical Engineers (Regulation 8):
Regulation 8(b) requires further vacancies to be filled "after competitive tests and/or interview in the manner prescribed by the Board." The court concluded that this does not permit outright absorption of ex-cadre Junior Engineers without selection; an advertisement and selection process for general‑cadre posts was required and the advertisement in question could not be held arbitrary on that ground.
-
Estoppel and reliance on Committee recommendations:
The court found that the Committee recommendation describing appointments as “provisional regular” and recommending confirmation on availability of permanent posts and satisfactory probation could not override statutory recruitment rules. The principle that there is no estoppel against a statute was applied; petitioners had not been put to disadvantageous action in reliance so as to attract equitable estoppel in face of statutory requirements.
-
On the challenged administrative decisions concerning pay:
The court found the Board's reversal (office order dated 1-12-1981) of its earlier 26-11-1981 pay decision unexplained in the record and the Board did not justify the reversal satisfactorily; thus that part of the 1-12-1981 order affecting Assistant Electrical Engineers appointed against ex-cadre posts was quashed. Further, the Secretary's communications dated 15-6-1983 (stating ex-cadre employees would not get the revised scales effective 1-4-1981) were quashed for both Assistant and Junior Electrical Engineers because the Board had not shown a rationale or that the Secretary had authority to exclude ex-cadre employees from the benefit without Board consideration. The court directed the Board to consider the pay-revision question afresh in light of its earlier decisions and the record.
-
Remedies sought by the petitioners:
The court emphasised that it could not issue a writ of mandamus to compel the Board to contravene its own statutory recruitment rules or to direct the Board to amend its rules/policies to create special preferential absorption for petitioners. The advertisement inviting direct applicants for cadre vacancies was not held to offend the Rules/Regulations and therefore was not quashed.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The writ applications are allowed in part.
Direct, case-specific effects and directives:
- The office order dated 1-12-1981 (Annexure-28) is quashed insofar as it revises/withdraws the earlier 26-11-1981 pay-scale decision affecting Assistant Electrical Engineers appointed against ex-cadre posts; the court found no satisfactory explanation for the reversal and quashed the 1-12-1981 order as it affected those ex-cadre appointees.
- The communication of the Secretary of the Board dated 15-6-1983 (Annexure-37 and its counterpart Annexure-14 for Junior E.E.) informing that ex-cadre Assistant Executive/Assistant Electrical Engineers and Junior Electrical Engineers would not be entitled to the revised pay scales is quashed; the Board is directed to consider the pay-revision question afresh and to give reasons if it proposes to deny the revision to ex-cadre appointees.
- The court refused to compel the Board to absorb/appoint the petitioners into cadre posts without following the statutory recruitment procedure (advertisement and selection) required by the Board's Rules and Regulations; the challenged advertisement (Employment Notice No.1/83) was not quashed on the grounds presented in these writs.
- Parties were directed to bear their own costs.
Implications beyond the parties: The decision enforces the principle that courts will not order administrative authorities to contravene their own statutory recruitment rules or to create special exceptions through mandamus; it limits equitable remedies (such as estoppel) where statutory recruitment procedures govern appointments. The opinion does not purport to lay down any novel precedent beyond applying existing principles to the facts; its orders were confined to quashing specific administrative communications/orders and directing reconsideration on pay revision.
Disposition: Petition allowed in part; parties to bear own costs. (Nagendra Prasad Singh, J.; concurrence by Surendra Narain Jha, J.)
Nagendra Prasad Singh, J.:— These applications have been filed on behalf of the petitioners for writ of mandamus directing the Bihar State Electricity Board (hereinafter to be referred to as ‘the Board’) to absorb/appoint the petitioners to the post of Assistant Executive Engineer/Junior Engineer and for quashing the order of the Board dated 1-12-1981 by which an earlier order dated 26-11-1981 was modified. Copies of the orders dated 26-11-1981 and 1-12-1981 are Annexure 27 and 28 to the writ application.
2. Originally, writ application (C.W.J.C No. 4472 of 1982) had been filed on behalf of 5 petitioners. Later, other applicants seeking similar relief against the Board were added as petitioners. The other writ applications (C.W.J.C Nos. 2558 and 2562 of 1983) have been filed for more or less similar reliefs on behalf of others. It may be mentioned that petitioners in C.W.J.C No. 4472 of 1982 and C.W.J.C No. 2562 of 1983 are Assistant Electrical Engineers (ex cadre) in the Board, whereas the petitioners of C.W.J.C No. 2558 of 1982 are Junior Electrical Engineers (ex-cadre) in the Board. As common questions of law and facts are involved, they were heard together and are being disposed of by a common judgment. C.W.J.C No. 4472 of 1982 was heard as the leading case, as such facts and documents are being mentioned with reference to that writ application.
3. Several degree holders and diploma holders engineers were selected in the year 1975-76 by the Board for training in accordance with the provisions of the Apprentice Act, 1961 and under “Employment Promotion Programme”. By a notice dated 11-3-1977 it was notified that the training will be for a period of six months, and after that, “the Board will make every possible efforts to give preference to its trainees in the matter of employment against vacant posts Suitable to their qualifications.” However, it was specifically stated in that notice that “the recruitment will be done as per Recruitment Rules and procedure of the Board. This training will, however, not mean guaranteed employment in the Board.” A copy of that notice is Annexure-1 to the writ application. On 28-3-1977 these petitioners who had been selected for the training aforesaid, were asked to join from 1-4-1977. The Board resolved on 13-8-1977 that existing trainees be continued as trainees on existing stipends till they are absorbed against regular posts on the basis of chain system. A copy of that resolution is Annexure-2. On 2-9-1977 a communication was issued by the Director, Personnel, of the Board that training of the petitioners shall continue till they are appointed by the Board, a copy of the said communication is Annexure-3. On 26-9-1978 an order was issued by the Board deputing the graduate and diploma holders engineers were undergoing the training at different places mentioned in that order for a period of 15 days with effect from 30-9-1978. During this period such graduate engineer trainees were to get special allowance of Rs. 10 per day and diploma holder trainees Rs. 7.50 per day during the period of deputation. Therefore, some representations were filed on behalf of the petitioners requesting the Board to absorb them in the regular cadre in view of earlier assurance. Copies of those representations have been annexed to the writ application. On 26-10-1978, a decision was taken by the Board that persons who had undergone training as Apprentices “shall have to appear at an examination conducted by the Board” and those who were successfull will be employed in the Power Stations for running and maintenance of the Power Stations”. In that decision it was made clear that “those who fail in such examination shall be given another chance of six months' training” and, therefore, they will have to appear at another examination and if they again fail to qualify, then “their engagement as Apprentice shall be terminated.” A copy of the Board's decision is Annexure-8. This caused a great resentment amongst such trainees including these petitioners and they staged Dharna and adopted a path of agitation. Ultimately, a Committee was constituted consisting of some members of the legislative Assembly including the then Speaker and some officers of the Board to consider the demand of such trainees for absorption in the service of the Board. The Committee recommended that trainees who had completed one year of training till October, 1979, should be appointed to the posts of Assistant Electrical Engineer and J unior Electrical Engineer on “provisional regular basis.” That recommendation further said that such appointments shall be on probation for a period of two years, if during the period of probation the services of the appointees were found to be satisfactory, on availability of the permanent posts they should be confirmed in accordance with seniority. The Committee recommended that the decision to hold an examination before appointment be recalled. That recommendation was approved by the Board. Copy of the aforesaid recommendation dated 10-3-1979 and the approval of the Boar is Annexure-9 to the writ application.
4. An agenda was put up before the Board for creation of ex-cadre posts of Assistant Electrical Engineers and Junior Electrical Engineers for appointment of the trainees aforesaid. In the meantime, three writ applications (C.W.J.C Nos. 2720, 2883 and 2927 of 1979) were filed by persons who were not trainees under the Board challenging the aforesaid decision of the Board to appoint such graduate and diploma trainees against the posts of Assistant Electrical Engineers and Junior Electrical Engineers. According to the petitioners of those writ applications appointments to the posts of Assistant Electrical Engineer or Junior Electrical Engineer without advertisement and affording opportunity to persons who were eligible to apply was against the statutory Rules and Regulations framed by the Board. This Court held that as the trainees were going to be appointed against ex cadre posts there was no contravention of the Rules and the Regulations of the Board which governed recruitment only cadre posts. Copies of the aforesaid judgments dated 13-12-1979 and 9-5-1980 are Annexures 13 and 14 to the writ application.
5. After the judgment the Secretary of the Board put up the proposal for creation of 185 posts of Assistant Electrical Engineers (ex cadre) and 189 posts of Junior Electrical Engineers (ex cadre) for a period of two years to accommodate the gruduate and diploma holder trainees and for their appointment on provisional and adhoc basis, copy whereof is Annexure-17. On 26-5-1980, the Board approved the proposal for creation of posts with effect from 1-6-1980 and for provisional appointment against those ex-cadre posts. In that very order of approval it was specifically stated as follows:
“Their appointment will be purely provisional for a period of two years terminable on one month's notice.”
6. A copy of the aforesaid resolution of the Board dated 26-5-1980 is Annexure 18. Notifications dated 29-5-1980 for creation of the aforesaid ex cadre posts and appointment of the petitioners on those posts on provisional basis are Annexures 19 and 20 to the writ application. In the notifications appointing the petitioners, again it was specifically mentioned that their appointment shall be purely provisional for a period of two years terminable on one month's notice. The petitioners were appointed in Generation-cum-Transmission Organisation of the Board.
7. Thereafter, representations were filed on behalf of the petitioners that although they had been appointed against ex-cadre posts they should be absorbed against regular cadre posts. Copies of those representations have been annexed to the writ application. In respect of the demand of such appointees that they should be absorbed against the cadre posts, a note was put up by the Secretery of the Board giving the detailed history of the appointment of the petitioners, and, after making a reference to the aforesaid judgments of this Court, it was pointed out that these petitioners could not be appointed or absorbed on the cadre posts; they can continue only against ex-cadre posts, but are entitled to all other benefits. This proposal was approved by the Board on 24-11-1981. A copy of the proposal put up to the Board and the approval of the Board is Annexure-26.
8. On 26-11-1981 an order was issued saying that the ex-cadre Assistant Electrical Engineers who had been appointed by office order dated 29-5-1980 aforesaid shall be “re-designated as Assistant Executive Engineer (ex-cadre) in the scale of pay of Rs. 630-1330”. Only a few days after on 1-12-1981 another office order was issued deleting the aforesaid line “re-designated as Assistant Executive Engineer (ex-cadre) in the scale of pay of Rs. 630-1330” and substituting the scale of pay of Rs. 600-1275. Copies of the aforesaid two orders are Annexures 27 and 28 to the writ application. Representation was filed on behalf of the petitioners for restoration of order dated 26-11-1981. Ultimately, the present writ application was filed.
9. During the pendency of the writ application on 26-5-1983 the Board issued Employment Notice No. 1/83 which was published in the daily newspapers inviting applications for appointment against vacant posts of Assistant Electrical Engineers (general cadre), Assistant Executive Engineer (GTO cadre), Junior Electrical Engineer (general cadre) and Junior Electrical Engineer (GTO cadre). A copy of that advertisement is Annexure-31 to a petition for amendment filed on 2-6-1983. The petitioners have also challenged the validity of the advertisement aforesaid. According to them, the Board is not entitled to fill up the cadre posts by open advertisement and it should be directed to appoint/absorb the petitioners against those vacant cadre posts of Assistant Executive Engineers and Junior Electrical Engineers.
10. Another decision which has been taken during the pendency of the writ application (C.W.J.C No. 4472 of 1982), by the Board is to revise the pay scale of Junior Electrical Engineers and Assistant Electrical Engineers with effect from 1-4-1981. A copy of the resolution dated 3-6-1983 in respect of Junior Electrical Engineer is Annexure-12 to the writ application) C.W.J.C No. 2558 of 1983) and a copy of the resolution dated 8-4-1983 in respect of Assistant Electrical Engineers is Annexure-36 (C.W.J.C No. 4472 of 1982). By a letter dated 15-6-1983 the Secretary of the Board informed the different General Managers-cum-Chief Engineers that “ex-cadre Assistant Executive Engineers and ex cadre Junior Electrical Engineers are not to be given the revised scale of pay effective from 1-4-1981, communicated vide resolution No. 332 dated 8-4-1983 and resolution No. 533 dated 3-6-1983” (copy of the aforesaid communication is Annexure-37 to C.W.J.C No. 4472 of 1982 and Annexure-14 to C.W.J.C No. 2558 of 1983). By amendment petitions the petitioners have challenged the aforesaid communication on the ground that there was no rationale basis to discriminate these petitioners in the matter of revision of scale of pay on the ground that they have been posted on ex cadre posts.
11. A counter-affidavit has been filed on behalf of the Board. An application for intervention has also been filed on behalf of the persons who are not in service of the Board and who have applied pursuant to the aforesaid advertisement dated 26-5-1983. The Board as well as the Inter veneers aforesaid have opposed the claim of the petitioners that they are entitled to be absorbed to the cadre posts of Assistant Executive Engineers and Junior Electrical Engineers which have been advertised by the Board. In the counter-affidavit, the Board has taken a stand that the petitioners were unemployed Engineers and had been selected for training on monthly stipend of Rs. 400 and Rs. 250. After completion of training the two categories of trainees appealed to the Board to extend their period of training. Thereafter, the trainees resorted to relay fast and dharna for their appointment under Board- Just to accommodate them, ex cadre posts were created as the petitioners could not have been appointed to the cadre posts in respect of which statutory rules have been framed by the Board. It has been stated on behalf of the Board that as the petitioners had been appointed against the ex cadre posts, this High Court in the earlier writ applications did not quash the order of the Board appointing the petitioners, without following the statutory rules for recruitment framed by the Board. It was pointed out by the Board that as in the earlier writ application this Court has held that the statutory Rules for recruitment framed by the Board were applicable to the appointment on cadre posts, petitioners cannot be appointed or absorbed on cadre posts without following the procedure prescribed by the Rules. In the counter-affidavit it has been emphasised that in the order of appointment of the petitioners it had been made clear that they were being appointed provisionally on ad hoc basis against ex-cadre posts; the petitioners having accepted their appointment on those conditions and having not challenged for two years could not now claim that they should be appointed against regular cadre posts without following the procedure prescribed by the statutory rules of the Board regarding the recruitment to the cadre posts. According to the Rules, the existing vacancies in the cadre have to be advertised, applications have to be invited, thereafter, a Selection Committee has to prepare a list in order of merit of the selected candidates, on basis of which appointments are to be made. It has been asserted that in the advertisement the maximum age prescribed is 42 years on 1-4-1983, and, as such, the petitioners are entitled to apply and they shall be considered along with other applicants for appointment to the cadre posts. Similar is the stand of the Board in respect of absorbing/appointing Junior Electrical Engineers.
12. In exercise of the powers conferred on the Board by clause (c) of section 79 of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948 (hereinafter to be referred to as ‘the Act’), the Bihar State Electricity Board (Generation-cum-Transmission Cadre) Rules, 1976 (hereinafter to be referred to as ‘the Rules’) have been framed. The aforesaid Rules' are applicable to the Assistant Electrical Engineers. From the object and reasons mentioned in the Rules itself it appears that it was necessary to have a separate cadre of Engineers, Design, Planning, Construction, Operation and Maintenance of Generating Stations, Extra High Voltage Transmission Lines…………”, and with that object the Rules have been framed replacing the old Bihar State Electricity Board (Generation Cadre) Regulation, 1971. Rule 3 defines ‘cadre’, ‘service’, ‘Organisation’ etc. Rule 4 provides that there shall be a cadre known as “Generation-cum-Transmission Engineers Cadre” of the Bihar State Electricity Board for manning the activities and the establishments of the Board detailed in that rule. Rule 5 specifies the composition of the cadre which includes Engineers who are directly recruited in the Board to the cadre and those who are promoted to the rank of Assistant Engineers against the promotion quota not exceeding 30 per cent, out of the Juniors Engineers engaged in generation, transmission and allied work. Rule 6 specifies the strength of the cadre. Rule 7, which is relevant for the present case, provides that depending on the number of vacancies existing in the cadre “there shall be an advertisement by the Board published in the important news papers.” inviting applications by a fixed date. Thereafter, the Baord has to constitute a Selection Committee consisting of the members mentioned in rule 7(H) to select the candidates amongst the applicants. Thereafter, appointments have to be made. Rule 8 is a provision in respect of promotion of Junior Engineers in the service of the Board, who have put in at least 8 years of service in the generation, transmission or allied work, to the posts of Assistant Engineers. The other rules relate to scale of pay, transfer and other service conditions.
13. In view of the aforesaid rules, if the posts of Assistant Engineer in Generation-cum-Transmission Engineers cadre, have to be filled up by direct recruitment, then the procedure of rule 7 has to be followed. The Rules which are statutory in nature do not, conceive any procedure under which an Assistant Electrical Engineer (ex cadre) can be absorbed in the cadre without following the procedure of rule 7. Dr. Chitale appearing on behalf of the petitioners very frankly conceded this. He, however, submitted that the Rules themselves being ultra vires do not stand in the way of petitioners in their being absorbed as Assistant Electrical Engineers on regular basis. It was submitted on behalf of the petitioners that under clause (c) of Section 79 of the Act the Board is empowered only to make regulations; the Rules are to be framed by the State Government under section 78 of the Act. As such, it was not open to the Board to make the Rules in question. From a bare reference to the Rules it shall appear that although they are labelled as ‘Rules’ in reality they are just ‘Regulations’ while reciting the backgrounds in which those Rules are being framed, in the object and reasons it has been clearly stated as follows:
“Whereas, the Bihar State Electricity Board is satisfied that circumstances exist which render it necessary for the Board to take immediate action to replace the Bihar State Electricity Board (Generation Cadre) Regulations, 1971 with new regulations.”
(emphasis added)
14. As such, on face of it, the Board purported to make new Regulations substituting the old Regulations, but named them as ‘Rules’. It is an admitted position that the different provisions of the Rules are within the ambit of section 79(c) of the Act. As such, in my view, the Rules cannot be held to be ultra vires. I may point out that for recruitment to the posts of Assistant Electrical Engineer in General Cadre, Bihar State Electricity Board Electrical Engineers (General) Cadre Rules, 1976 have been framed by the Board. Rule 6(ii) of that Rules also require the Board to advertise the vacancies existing and thereafter to make appointment according to the procedure prescribed in those Rules.
15. It was then submitted that even if it is assumed that the Rules aforesaid are deemed to have been framed under section 79(c) of the Act it is not applicable to the appointments to the post of Assistant Electrical Engineers. According to the petitioners, such appointments are governed by the Bihar State Electricity Board Service Regulations, 1976 (hereinafter to be referred to as ‘the Regulations’). The said Regulations have also been framed by the Board under section 79 (c) of the Act. Regulation No. 1 (ii) is as follows:—
“(ii) Except as otherwise provided or under these Regulations they shall apply to all employees appointed to any post in the Board or to any post under any of the establishments of the Board including the Area Board and Generation-cum-Transmission Organisation.”
16. Chapter II contains provisions regarding recruitment to the service of the Board. Regulation 4 prescribes the procedure for recruitment. On behalf of the petitioners reliance has been placed on regulation 4(ii)(b), which is as follows:
“Recruitment shall be made only through specially constituted Selection Committees. Such Selection Committees shall be constituted on only with the authority of the Board or an Area Board or Generation-cum-Transmission. Organisation or by any other authority whom the Board by specific order or rule authorised to constitute a Selection Committee :.”
17. According to the petitioners, because of Regulations 1(v) and 112 (iv), aforesaid regulation 4 (ii) (b) shall have an overriding effect and shall prevail over rule 7 of the Rules aforesaid. Regulations 1(v) and 112 (iv) say that if there is any conflict between Regulations and any other Rules and Regulations framed by the Board the Regulations shall prevail. It was submitted that this regulation 4(ii) (b) does not speak of any advertisement for filling up the posts including the post of Assistant Electrical Engineers, in other words, according to the petitioners, a Selection Committee constituted by the Board can select the petitioners who are already in service of the Board. I have already pointed out that the petitioners are in Generation-cum-Transmission Organisation. The Rules, referred to above, have been specifically framed, providing the mode of appointment, terms and conditions of Engineers in Generation-cum-Transmission cadre. Regulation 4(i) and (ii), on which reliance have been placed on behalf of the petitioners itself says in specific terms that if there are some separate Rules governing the recruitment in respect of establishment, Generation-cum-Transmission Organisation, then recruitment shall be made in accordance with those relevant rules. Relevant portions of regulation 4 are as follows:
“(i) Recruitment to any Service or cadre of the Board or any of its establishments including the Area Boards and Generation-cum-Transmission Organisation shall be in accordance with the rules/standing orders governing the relevant recruitment;
(ii) Recruitment of categories of employees in respect of whom there are no separate recruitment rules shall be in accordance with the following procedure---………………”
18. In my view, there is no conflict between rule 7 and regulation 4 (ii) (b) so that regulation 4(ii) (b) can prevail. Regulation 4(i) and (ii) exclude appointments which are governed by some other Rules or Regulations. As such, regulation 4(ii)(b) shall apply only to such cases of recruitment to any service of the Board which are not governed by any specific rules. The Rules having been framed by the Board for recruitment to the different cadre posts in Generation-cum-Transmission Organisation, the direct recruitment to the posts of Assistant Electrical Engineers shall be governed by rule 7 aforesaid.
19. On behalf of the petitioners it was also submitted that even if it is assumed that in the facts and circumstances of the case the Board has to follow the procedure of rule 7, if appointment is to be made by direct recruitment, the Board can avoid that procedure in the interest of justice by merging ex cadre posts in the cadre in accordance with regulation 82, which is as follows:—
“On the merger of any ex-cadre post, in a cadre, the seniority of the ex-cadre employee shall be determined on the principle of ‘continuous officiation’ in the grade equal to the grade of the merged post.” On a plain reading, regulation 82 is an enabling provision under which any ex-cadre post can be merged in cadre under the exigency of the situation, But it is not open to this Court to issue a writ of mandamus on the respondent Board to exercise its power under regulation 82 in respect of all ex-cadre posts against which these petitioners have been appointed
20. Reliance was also placed on behalf of the petitioners on regulation 84, the relevant portion whereof is as follows:—
“Where, as in the case of employees of private electric supply undertaking on their nationalisation or permanent absorption of Government servants in the Board's service, it may become necessary to absorb outsiders in the Board's service, the following principles shall govern seniority of the absorbed employees…”
21. It was urged that the Board can transfer these employees and absorb in its service which means in the cadre of the Board. This regulation 84, on face of it, conceives of absorption of outsiders under the situations mentioned in that regulation. It is not applicable to cases where the person concerned is already in the service of the Board. It is well known that it is for the appointing authority to decide the mode and procedure of appointment which is consistent with the Rules. Regulations governing such appointments. In the instant case, it is not possible for this Court to hold that the advertisement (annexure-31) has been issued in contravention of any rule or regulation framed by the Board jeopardising the interest of the petitioners.
22. So far as the petitioners (C.W.J.C No. 2558 of 1983), who are Junior Electrical Engineers (ex cadre) in Generation-cum-Transmission Organisation, are concerned, their recruitment and terms and conditions are governed by the Bihar State Electricity Board Junior Engineers (Generations-cum-Transmission Cadre) Regulations, 1976 which have been framed under section 79 of the Act. Regulation 8 says that initially all the posts in the cadre shall be filled from amongst the Junior Engineers in the employment of the Board, who hold Diploma in Electrical/Mechanical/Electronic/Telecommunication Engineering and have experience of at least 5 years of working. Regulation 8 (b) which is applicable now is as follows:—
“After the cadre has been constituted and the posts filled initially in the manner stated in Regulation 8 (a) above further vacancies shall be filled from Diploma holders in Electrical/Mechanical/Electronic/Telecommunication Engineering (Three years course) after competitive tests and/or interview in the manner prescribed by the Board for recruitment of Junior Engineers.”
23. It is an admitted position that the cadre of Junior Electrical Engineers in accordance with regulation 8(a) has been constituted and now further vacancies have to be filled up in accordance with regulation 8(b) aforesaid. On behalf of the petitioners it was submitted that regulation 8(b) does not speak of any advertisement, and, as such, the Board should not have advertised the cadre posts of Junior Electrical Engineers and should absorb these petitioners against these posts.
24. It is true that regulation 8(b) does not speak of any advertisement like rule 7 aforesaid, but, nonetheless, it speaks about a competitive test/or interview in the manner prescribed by the Board for recruitment. It does not say that persons appointed as Junior Electrical Engineers (ex cadre) can be absorbed in the cadre outright. In this Background, if an advertisement has been made giving opportunity to all eligible persons in cluding the petitioners then it cannot be held to be an arbitrary or mala fide decision. It need not be pointed out that under regulation 8(b) some rationale procedure for selection has to be adopted because it speaks of recruitment of Junior Engineers by manner prescribed by the Board. Our attention was also drawn to Bihar State Electricity Board Junior Electrical Engineer (General) Cadre Rules, 1982 which is another set of rules framed under section 79 (c) of the Act and which has come in force from 11-10-1982. This governs recruitment and terms and conditions from 11-10-1982. This governs recruitment and terms and conditions of Junior Electrical Engineers in general cadre. In have already pointed out that by the impugned advertisement posts of Junior Electrical Engineers (Generation-cum-as well as Junior Electrical (General Cadre) both have been advertised. Some of the petitioners who are in Generation-cum-Transmission Oraganisation are, perhaps entitled to apply for the post of Junior Electrical Engineer (General Cadre.) Rule 7 of the which has come in force in 1982 and which governs recruitment to general cadre of Junior Electrical Engineers has fixed a quota of 75 and 25 for appointment by direct recruitment and absorption respectively. About filling of the posts by direct recruitment it as follows:—
“Depending on the number of vacancies existing in the cadre there shall be published an advertisement by the Board in the important news papers and the number of vacancies, age and other qualification… Application shall be invited fixed date.”
25. As such, it cannot be disputed that in respect of filling the posts of Junior Electrical Engineers (General Cadre) by direct recruitment an advertisement has to be published. On this ground also the advertisement, which has been challenged by the petitioners of C.W.J.C No. 2558 of 1983, cannot be held to be against the Rules and Regulations framed by the Board, so as to be liable to be quashed.
26. It was then submitted on behalf of the petitioners that it is always open to the appointment authority to treat a class of persons ina particular manner in manner of recruitment. In the words, according to the learned counsel, when the petitioners have been appointed by the Board as Assistant Electrical Engineers and Junior Electrical Engineers it is the duty of the Board to make their appointment regular. In this connections our attention was drawn to the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of I.J Divakar v. The Government of Andhra Pradesh (Civil Appeal No. 2484 of 1982) disposed of on 21-10-1982. In that case the Andra Pradesh Public Services Commisions had invited application for the post Junior Engineers in Andra Pradesh Engineering Service and other allied services in the year 1977. In response to the advertisement applications were received and all the eligible cadidates were asked to paper at a viva-voce test. The Government of Andhra Pradesh issued to appear at a viva-voce test. The Government of Andhra Pradesh issued a notification in exercise of power conferred by proviso to clause (3) of Article 320 of the Constitution excluding from the purview of the Commision all appointment made by the direct recruitment to any post in any category at all level in the State and subordinate services and which were continuing temporarily on 8-8-1979. Thereafter by another notification the State Government regularised the service of all temporary Government servants who were appointed by direct recruitment to any category or post and were continuing in services, as on August 9, 1979 without subjecting them to any test, written or oral. In the notification certain conditions had been mentioned which had to be satisfied be the temporary employees concerned before their services could be regularised. This process of regulations was challenged by the applicants who had applied in response to the advertisement aforesaid and who were not in service of the State Government on temporary basis. In that context it was pointed out by the Supreme Court:
“Proviso to clause (3) of Art. 320 confers power on the Government as respects services and posts in connection with the affairs of the State to make regulations specifying the matters in which either generally or in any particular class of case or in any particular circumstances it shall not be necessary for a Public Service Commission to be consulted. Armed with this power G.O 646 was issued withdrawing various posts from the purview of the Commission. The only contention urged was that at the time when the advertisement was issued the post of Junior Engineer was within the purview of the Commission and even if at a later date the post was withdrawn from the purview of the Commission it could not have any retrospective effect. There is no merit in this contention and we are broadly in agreement with the view of the Tribunal that inviting the applications for a post does not by itself create any right to the post in the candidate who in response to the advertisement makes an application…………… If, therefore, on September, 14, 1979 (when G.O 646 was issued the appellants had no right to the post, at least they cannot be heard to contend that it was improper for the 1st respondent to withdraw the post of Junior Engineer from the purview of the Commission. It fact, it must be made distinctly clear that not merely the post of Junior Engineers but various other posts though within the purview of the Commission were withdrawn by the impugned G.O only to the extent that there were certain direct recruits holding the posts for long number of years and as the Government had decided to regularise their services to the extent the posts were held by temporary servants eligible to get regularis-ation of service the corresponding posts were withdrawn from the purview of the Commission. The power to make such a regulation was not disputed because the power flows from the proviso to clause (3) of Article 320.”
27. In my opinion, the aforesaid decision of the Supreme Court is of no help to the petitioners because in that case the State Government issued a notification under proviso to clause (3) to Article 320 of the Constitution withdrawing from the purview of the Commission, all appointments to be made by direct recruitment to all posts at all level in the state. In the instant case, the Board has not taken any such decision nor there is any such provision in any of the rules and Regulation framed by the Board vesting them with power similar to proviso to clause (3) of Article 320 of the Constitution. In absence of any such provision in the Rules nnd Regulations, this Court cannot direct by a writ of mandamus to the Board to regularise the services of the petitioners and not to fill the cadre posts on basis of the advertisement already made.
28. It was then urged that it is open to this Court to direct the Board to amend its Rules and Regulations and to make provision in those Rules and Regulations for absorbing these petitioners. In support of this contention reliance was placed on the case of S.S Moghe v. Union of India ((1981) 3 SCC 271 : AIR 1981 SC 1495). In that case the Supreme Court pointed out that when a new service is proposed to be constituted it is within the competence of the Government to decide as a matter of policy the sources from which the personnel required for manning the services are to be drawn. There sub-rule (1) of rule 6 which was under consideration, provided that all persons who as on the appointed day were already working in the organisation on a temporary or adhoc basis would be eligible for appointment to the new service at the stage of its initial constitution. In that context it was pointed out that once the power was there under sub-rule (1) of rule 6 to permanently appoint in accordance with rule there was no question of making any distinction between persons who were appointed by the direct recruitment and those who were on deputation. In the instant case, as I have already pointed out, no such rule or regulation has been framed by the Board giving any preferential treatment to the class to which the petitioners belong treating them as a special class. It is not for this Court to issue direction to the appointing authority as to what policy it should adopt in the matter of receuit-ment. Reference was also made to the case of Ajit Singh v. State of Punjab ((1983) 2 SCC 217 : AIR 1983 SC 494). There the Board of Trustees under the Act in question had been dissolved and services of temporary employees were dispensed with soon thereafter, the Trustees were re-constituted. On the basis of the materials produced the Court came to the conclusion that the action was thoroughly arbitrary an J only with an object to get rid of temporary employees. I am not able to appreciate as to how the aforesaid case is relevant in the facts and circumstances of the present case.
29. On behalf of the petitioners it was submitted that the petitioners form a class by themselves and they need a special treatment in the matter of recruitment to the cadre posts. In this connection our attention was drawn to the case of Ramesh Prasad Singh v. State of Bihar ((1978) 1 SCC 37 : AIR 1978 SC 327) where it was observed:
“We would like to reiterate and re-emphasise what has been oft repeated by this Court viz. that the doctorine of equality before law and equal protection of laws and equality of opportunity in the matter of employment and promotion enshrined in Arts. 14 and 16 of the Constitution which is intended to advance justice by avoiding discrimination is attracted only when equals are treated as unequals or where unequals are treated as equals, (See Md. Usman v. State of Andhra Pradesh (1971) 2 SCC 188 : AIR 1971 SC 1801. The guarantee of equality does not imply that the same rules should be made applicable to all persons in spite of differences in their circumstances and conditions. (See Chiranjit Lal Chowdhuri v. The Union of India (1950 SCR 869 at page 911 : (AIR 1952 SC 41 at page 57, 58)”.
30. In the aforesaid case it was found that the person whose appointment by promotion was being challenged was a class by himself because of his qualification and, as such, it was held that his promotion did not violate Article 14 or 16 of the Constitution. It is well known that it is for the State or the Authority concerned to make reasonable classification of its employees for any special treatment; it is not for this Court to issue a writ of mandamus directing the state or the Authority to classify its employ-yees for any special treatment saying that it, will be a reasonable classification within the meaning of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution. Once the Board has laid down the procedure for appointment under the statutory rules and regulations which have not been held to be discriminatory, the Board has to afford equal opportunity to each eligible candidate in the matter of appointment so as to fulfil the requirement of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution. It was observed in the well known case of T. Devadasan v. Union of India (AIR 1964 SC 179):
“We would like to emphasise that the guarantee contained in Art. 16 (1) is for ensuring equality of opportunity for all citizens relating to employment, and to appointments to any office under the State. This means that on every occasion for recruitment the State should see that all citizens are treated equally. The guarantee is to each individual citizen and, therefore, every citizen who is seeking employment or appointment to an office under the State is entitled to be afforded an opportunity for seeking such employment or appointment whenever it is intended to be filled.”
31. Reliance was also placed on behalf of the petitioners on a judgment of the Delhi High Court in the case of Dr. G.P Sarabhai v. Union of India (1983) Labour and Industrial Cases 910). From a bare reference to the judgment of that case it shall appear that the High Court recorded a finding that for requirement, section 17(3) which had to be followed had in substance been followed: therefore, it was held that in the facts and circumstances of that case it shall be deemed that the appointments had been made on regular basis. Reference was made also to the case of Sharif Ahmad v. The Regional Transport Authority, Meerut ((1978) 1 SCC 1 : AIR 1978 SC 209) in support of the contention that in appropriate cases this Court may direct the authority concerned to perform its duty; as in this case to appoint the petitioners on regular basis. If any of the rules and regulations, referred to above, enjoined the Board to appoint these petitioners against the cadre posts there would have been no difficulty on the part of this Court in issuing a writ of mandamus directing the Board to perform its statutory duty. But, I have already pointed out that the existing rules and regulations of the Board enjoin them to make direct recruitment only after advertisement. In such a situation, there is no question of issuing a writ of mandamus directing them to first absorb/appoint the petitioners to those posts.
32. On behalf of the petitioners it was then urged that Board the has to confirm the services of the petitioners in view of the assurance given by the Board from time to time. In this connection our attention was drawn to the recommendation of the Committee dated 10-3-1979, referred to above, and approval of the Board dated 3-5-1979 of the said recommendation (annexure-9). The Committee had recommended that these petitioners should be appointed on “provisional regular basis”, and on probation for a period of two years. It further said that if the work during the period of probation was found to be satisfactory and if permanent posts were available then they should be confirmed in service. I have not been able to understand as to what the Committee meant by “provisional regular” appointment. It is admitted position that later the Board while taking the decision to create ex-cadre posts for these petitioners and making their appointment in Generation-cum-Transmission side never said that their services shall be confirmed (vide resolution dated 26-5-1980.—Annexure-18). Same is the position so far as the Notification of appointment of the petitioners dated 29-5-1980 is concerned which I have mentioned above ft simply said that the appointment was purely provisional for a period of two years terminable on one month's notice (vide annexure-20). Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that although the recommendation of the Committee which was approved earlier by the Board was not incorporated in the later resolution and notification of appointment still the Board on principle of estoppel is bound to carry on the other part of the recommendation which it had approved, i.e to confirm the petitioners. In my view, no principle of estoppel can be invoked in the facts and circumstances of this case. I have already pointed out that under the existing rules and regulations the petitioners cannot be absorbed/appointed against the cadre posts without following the procedure prescribed and it is well known that there is no estoppel against an statute. Apart from that, even the general principle of estoppel, in my view, is not attracted. For the petitioners' ex-cadre posts were created and they were appointed on those posts because of dharna, relay fast. The Committee no doubt, recommended that they should be confirmed after the expiry of the period of probation which was also approved by the Board. But how principle of estoppel is attracted, I am not able to understand. It is an admitted position that the petitioners have not put themselves in a disadvantageous position on basis of any assurance or representation, given by the Board so that this Court can direct the authorities concerned not to act in any arbitrary manner ignoring their earlier representation This aspect of the matter has been considered in several judgments of the Supreme Court and reference in this connection may be made to one of the judgments in the case of Jit Ram Shiv Kumar v. The State of Haryana ((1981) 1 SCC 11 : AIR 1980 SC 1285) where the earlier judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Moti Lal Padampat Sugar Mills Co. (P) Ltd. v. State of Uttar Pradesh (ATR 1979 S.C 621) on which reliance has been placed on behalf of the petitioners has been explained. I need not point out that in March, 1979 when the Committee made the recommendations, the rules and regulations which governed the recruitment to the cadre posts of Assistant Engineers and Junior Engineers were in force. Any recommendation or assurance cannot be enforced in face of those statutory rules and regulations.
33. From the facts and circumstances disclosed in these writ applications it is apparent that the petitioners who have been appointed against the ex cadre posts are now insisting that they should be absorbed against the vacant cadre posts and those posts should not be advertised, giving opportunity to other eligible persons. This problem of late has arisen in different wings of the state including the statutory authorities like the Board, Appointments are made either on provisional or adhoc basis for a limited period without following the Rules and Regulations and, thereafter either under the pressure or coercion of the appointees concerned or under the exigency of the situation such ad hoc provisional appointees are allowed to continue beyond the period for which they had been appointed. Such appointments under the relevant statutory rules cannot be continued beyond a limited period because for regular appointments statutory rules have been framed by different statutory/corporate bodies as well as by the State Government which make provisions for selection of the candidates either through Public Service Commission or through a Selection Committee. These Rules/Regulations have been made with the object to select the best among the applicants. But persons who are appointed on ad hoc/provisional/temporary basis for a limited period after having continued for some time start pressing that they should not be forced to face the Selection Committee/Public Service Commission. The reason for such attitude is obvious the risk of being not selected because they have to compete with other applicants who may have better merit. I am not able to appreciate as to why steps are not taken for regular appointment through the procedure prescribed at an earliest occasion and such ad hoc/provisional/temporary appointees are allowed to continue for years. This gives scope for argument that having continued in service although on provisional/ad hoc basis for so long, they should not be thrown out of the employment. When such question is raised before this court it is not possible to issue a writ of mandamus on the authorities concerned to violate and contravene their own statutory Rules and Regulations prescribing the mode of recruitment. Apart from that any such direction is bound to effect the rights of other eligible applicants for those posts and they can legitimately make a grievance regarding violation of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution.
34. So far as the grievance of the petitioners in C.W.J.C No. 4472 of 1982 and C.W.J.C No. 2562 of 1983 that the Board has arbitrarily by its order dated 1-12-1981 (Annexure-28) recalled its order dated 26-11-1981 (Annexure-27) by which the pay scale of Assistant Electrical Engineers who had been appointed on ex-cadre posts had made at par with the Assistant Electrical Engineers holding cadre posts, is concerned, it cannot be ignored. It is an admitted position that the Board by its office order dated 26-11-1981 (Annexure-27) had decided that even the Assistant Electrical Engineers holding ex-cadre posts shall get the same pay scale which is meant for cadre posts. This decision was consistent with the earlier decisions of the Board where is had been pointed out that although it was not possible to appoint such Assistant Electrical Engineers on the cadre posts nonetheless as they were doing the same nature of work they were entitled to the pay scale meant for the Assistant Electrical Engineers posted on cadre posts. Only within five days why this decision was recalled by office order dated 1-12-1981 has not been explained in the counter-affidavit filed on behalf of the Board. Learned Additional Advocate General, who appeared for the Board, could not give any satisfactory explanation as to why the Board revised its decision taken only a few days earlier. It is always open to the appointing authority to revise the terms and conditions of its employees on some rationale basis and under the exigencies of the situation. But, when any such decision is challenged in a court of law saying that it effects the employee concerned without any rationale basis, the then authority concerned has to justify its action. In absence of any explanation on behalf of the Board. I am left with no option but to quash the office order dated 1-12-1981 (Annexure-28) so far as the Assistant Electrical Engineers appointed against the ex-cadre posts are concerned. Same is the position so far as the impugned communication dated 15-6-1983 issued by the Secretary of the Board (annexure-37) is concerned. The Secretary of the Board has informed the persons concerned that the Assistant Electrical Engineers holding ex-cadre posts shall not be entitled to the benefit of revision of the scale of pay. On behalf of the petitioners it has been asserted that the Secretary of the Board has issued the aforesaid communication without approval of the Board. Learned Additional Advocate General again could not explain as to how the Secretary of the Board has taken such a decision without the approval of the Board. I have already pointed oat that the Board is treating these petitioners as Assistant Electrical Engineers (ex-cadre) and if the petitioners are doing the same nature of work and earlier Board had resolved that they shall not be discriminated so far as the other terms and conditions are concerned except that they cannot be appointed to cadre posts, apparently there does not appear to be any justification for not allowing the benefit of the revision of the scale of pay to such petitioners. Any way, while quashing the communication of the Secretary I direct that this question should be considered by the Board afresh. Accordingly, the communication dated 15-6-1983 (Annexure-37) is quashed.
35. So far as the Junior Electrical Engineers are concerned, the order dated 1-12-1981 did not make any alteration in its earlier order dated 26-11-1981. Later, by office order dated 3-6-1983 (Annexure-12 to C.W.J.C No. 2558 of 1983) the pay scale of Junior Electrical Engineers has been revised. The Secretary of the Board by aforesaid communication dated 15-6-1983 (Annexure-14 to C.W.J.C No. 2558 of 1983.) has informed that the Junior Electrical Engineers holding ex-cadre posts shall not be entitled to the benefit of the revision of pay scale. Against, same grounds of challenge have been urged even on behalf of the petitioners of this writ application. Accordingly. I quash the communication dated 15-6-1983 in respect of Junior Electrical Engineers as welt and direct that the Board should consider the question afresh as to why the Junior Electrical Engineers holding ex-cadre posts should not be allowed the benefit of the revised pay scale in light of the earlier decision of the Board.
36. In the result, these writ applications are allowed in part to the extent indicated above. Parties shall bear their own costs.
Snrendra Narain Jha, J.:— I agree.
37. Petition allowed.
Alert