Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ram Pal Singh v. Union Of India

Patna High Court
Feb 9, 2009
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Letters Patent Appeal)

Factual and Procedural Background

This Letters Patent Appeal arises from a challenge to an order of compulsory retirement dated 16.5.2000 (communicated by letter dated 24.5.2000). The learned single Judge dismissed the appellant's writ petition by judgment and order dated 1.7.2002, and the present appeal is directed against that dismissal.

The appellant was employed at the Central Institute of Plastic Engineering and Technology (the Institute), an entity registered as a society and under the administrative control of the Ministry of Chemicals and Fertilizers, Government of India. At the time of compulsory retirement he held the post of Manager (Processing/Testing) at the Institute's extension centre at Patna.

Appellant's career milestones alleged in the writ petition (uncontroverted in material respects) include:

  • August 1978: appointed Chargeman (Trainee).
  • May 1979: placed as Supervisor (Trainee); September 1979: confirmed as Supervisor with effect from 30.8.1978.
  • February 1981: appointed Foreman Instructor; confirmed after one year.
  • 1984: post redesignated as Assistant Engineer.
  • 30.4.1992: promoted from Assistant Engineer (Training) to Manager (Processing/Testing) and transferred to Amritsar.
  • 28.6.1996: confirmed in the Manager post with effect from 30.4.1993.
  • 24.12.1997: transferred from Amritsar to Patna extension centre.
  • May 2000: compulsorily retired; the retirement order was challenged in writ petition (dismissed), leading to this appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the order of compulsory retirement of the appellant was valid and sustainable in the public interest, or whether it was vitiated by mala fide or a colourable exercise of power.
  2. Whether Article 311(2) of the Constitution (protection against dismissal/ removal without inquiry for government servants) applied to the appellant, i.e., whether he was a government servant for that purpose.
  3. Whether an order of compulsory retirement attracts the principles of natural justice or stigma, and the extent to which judicial scrutiny is permissible.
  4. Whether adverse confidential records (ACRs) predating a promotion may be given weight for the purpose of compulsory retirement, in light of the principles laid down in Baikunth Nath Das v. Chief District Medical Officer (1992) 2 SCC 299.
  5. Whether the committee's consideration of the appellant's service record (including alleged errors in the committee minutes and assessment of promotions and ACRs) was proper and reasonable.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The Writ Court failed to appreciate important facts and did not properly consider allegations of mala fide or colourable exercise of power; these issues were dismissed in a single sentence.
  • The Writ Court incorrectly handled the questions of stigma and natural justice without properly addressing the factual matrix and service record.
  • The appellant relied on the Supreme Court decision in Baikunth Nath Das (paragraph 34) and submitted that conclusions (iii) and (iv) of that decision applied to his case — i.e., courts may interfere where the order is mala fide, unsupported by evidence or arbitrary, and adverse ACRs prior to promotion should not be given weight.
  • The appellant pointed to his service record and a letter he wrote on 17.9.1998 to the Director alleging poor administration and corruption at Patna; he contended that subsequent adverse entries and the single 'poor' overall rating for 1999 were retaliatory and attributable to his whistle-blowing.
  • The appellant asserted that the committee's recommendation (dated 6.5.2000) incorrectly recorded that he had only one promotion during 22 years of service, whereas his record showed multiple promotions; this and other errors indicated a colourable exercise of power.

Respondents' Position (as reflected in the record)

  • In the counter affidavit, the respondents denied the allegations made in paragraph 27 of the writ petition, asserting that the appellant did not bring the alleged defects in administration to the management's notice.
  • The record shows that the respondents' affidavit failed to address or disclose the appellant's letter dated 17.9.1998; the opinion records that counsel for the respondents was unable to defend that reply in the counter affidavit.
  • The respondents proceeded on the basis of the committee's recommendation (Annexure G/1) favouring compulsory retirement; the minutes of that committee are part of the material considered by the Court.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Baikunth Nath Das v. Chief District Medical Officer, (1992) 2 SCC 299 The principles summarized in paragraph 34: (i) compulsory retirement is not punishment and implies no stigma; (ii) such orders are passed on the subjective satisfaction of the government; (iii) natural justice ordinarily has no place but courts may interfere where the order is mala fide, unsupported by evidence, or arbitrary/perverse; (iv) the government/committee must consider the entire service record, giving more importance to later years, and adverse ACRs prior to promotion lose their sting; (v) mere taking into account uncommunicated adverse remarks is not by itself a ground for quashing. The Court relied on conclusions (iii) and (iv) to test whether the compulsory retirement order suffered from mala fide/colourable exercise or arbitrary assessment and whether the committee improperly relied on pre-promotion adverse ACRs. The Court applied these principles to the appellant's service record and found the retirement order to be a colourable exercise of power and thus quashed it.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in distinct steps, each applying the factual record to the legal principles available in the authorities and to the particular procedural posture of the case:

  1. The Court accepted the Writ Court's determination that the appellant was not a government servant for the purposes of Article 311(2) of the Constitution; accordingly Article 311(2) did not apply.
  2. The Court reiterated the legal position (from Baikunth Nath Das) that an order of compulsory retirement is not a punishment, carries no stigma, and ordinarily does not attract the rules of natural justice. The appellant did not dispute these legal propositions.
  3. The Court focused on the exceptions recognized in Baikunth Nath Das (paragraph 34): judicial interference is permissible where the retirement order is mala fide, unsupported by evidence, arbitrary or perverse, or where the process of reviewing the service record was flawed (for example, by inappropriately emphasizing pre-promotion adverse entries).
  4. The Court examined the appellant's uncontroverted service record and the documentary material, including the appellant's letter dated 17.9.1998 to the Director complaining of poor administration and alleged corrupt/favouritist practices at Patna.
  5. The Court found that the respondents' counter-affidavit had failed to address the appellant's letter and that counsel for respondents was unable to defend that omission. The Court treated the omission as significant when testing the bona fides of the committee's recommendation and the decision to retire the appellant compulsorily.
  6. The Court scrutinized the committee's recommendation dated 6.5.2000 (Annexure G/1) and identified errors and misstatements — for example, that the committee recorded the appellant had only one promotion during 22 years, contrary to the appellant's service record. The committee also highlighted a single 'below average' ACR from 1989 (pre-promotion), which the Court noted should not have been given decisive weight, according to the principle in Baikunth Nath Das that pre-promotion adverse ACRs lose their sting.
  7. The Court considered the chronology of ratings after the appellant's promotion in 1992: two subsequent 'good' ratings (1993, 1994), then several 'average' ratings, and only a single 'poor' overall rating in 1999 immediately preceding compulsory retirement. The timing of the adverse rating (after the appellant's whistle-blowing) supported an inference that it was retaliatory.
  8. On that factual foundation and applying the legal standard for interference (mala fide, lack of evidence, arbitrary/perverse decision-making), the Court concluded that the order of compulsory retirement was a colourable exercise of power and that no reasonable person would have formed the requisite opinion that compulsory retirement was in the public interest.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The Court set aside the judgment and order under appeal, quashed the order of compulsory retirement, and allowed the writ petition as well as the Letters Patent Appeal.

Consequential directions and practical effect:

  • The appellant is entitled to all consequential benefits arising from the quashing of the compulsory retirement order.
  • Those consequential benefits must be made available to the appellant within three months from the date of the Court's order.

The opinion does not purport to lay down a new principle of law; it applies established principles from the Supreme Court decision in Baikunth Nath Das to the facts and service record of the appellant and arrives at relief on the ground of mala fide/colourable exercise and perverse conclusion.

Show all summary ...

Shiva Kirti Singh & J.N Singh, JJ. This Letters Patent Appeal is directed against the judgment and order dated 1.7.2002 whereby the learned single Judge has dismissed the writ petition preferred by the appellant challenging his compulsory retirement by an order dated 16.5.2000 which was communicated by a letter dated 24.5.2000

2. At the time of his compulsory retirement, petitioner was working as Manager (Processing/Testing) in the Central Institute of Plastic Engineering and Technology (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Institute’), at its extension centre at Patna. The Institute is a society registered under the Society Registration Act, having its head office at Chennai. It is admittedly an authority under the control of Ministry of Chemicals and Fertilizers, Government of India.

3. From the uncontroverted averments in the writ petition, the career profile of the appellant is as follows. In August 1978, he was appointed as Chargeman (Trainee). In May 1979, he was placed as Supervisor (Trainee). In September 1979, he was confirmed on the post of Supervisor with effect from 30.8.1978, after completing his probation satisfactorily. He was selected and appointed as Foreman Instructor in February 1981 on which post he was confirmed after one year. In 1984, the post of Foreman Instructor was redesignated as Assistant Engineer. It appears that appellant was aggrieved by promotion granted to his junior and he filed a writ petition in Madras High Court. According to appellant, on that account he incurred displeasure and was subjected to frequent transfers to Bhubneshwar in 1987, to Ahmedabad in 1989, to Bhubneshwar in 1990 and to Madras in 1991. However, by order dated 30.4.1992, the appellant was promoted from the post of Assistant Engineer (Training) to the post of Manager (Processing/Testing) and transferred to Amritsar. He was confirmed on that post by an order dated 28.6.1996 but with effect from 30.4.1993 By order dated 24.12.1997, he was transferred from Amritsar to the extension centre at Patna. There he was compulsorily retired in the month of May 2000. The order of compulsory retirement was challenged by him in writ petition which has been dismissed by the order under appeal.

4. Learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that certain important facts having bearing on the validity of order of compulsory retirement were not appreciated by the Writ Court and the issue of malafide and colourable exercise of power was rejected as one without merit in a single sentence in paragraph 5 of the judgment under appeal without considering the averments in the writ petition and without looking into the service record of the appellant from that angle. It was further submitted that the issues of stigma and requirement of natural justice to hear in matters of compulsory retirement, were considered in detail by the Writ Court and on that account only, the writ petition was dismissed without noticing the relevant facts which, according to learned counsel for the appellant, would have demonstrated that the order of compulsory retirement against the appellant was bad in law even in the light of the Supreme Court judgment in the case of Baikunth Nath Das v. Chief District Medical Officer, (1992) 2 SCC 299.

5. This Court finds that the Writ Court has rightly held that appellant was not a government servant and, therefore, Article 311(2) of the Constitution was not attracted in his case. It has further been correctly held that an order of compulsory retirement is not a punishment, it implies no stigma and the principles of natural justice are not attracted in case of compulsory retirement. Learned counsel for the appellant has also not disputed the aforesaid propositions of law and has, in fact, placed reliance on the discussions and conclusions as made in the case of Baikunth Nath Das in which a Bench of three Judges of the Supreme Court considered the law of compulsory retirement in detail. Paragraph 34 of that judgment which has been quoted by the Writ Court in paragraph 16, is as follows :

“34. The following principles emerge from the above discussion :

(i) An order of compulsory retirement is not a punishment. It implies no stigma nor any suggestion of misbehavior.

(ii) The order has to be passed by the Government on forming the opinion that it is in the public interest to retire a Government servant compulsorily. The order is passed on the subjective satisfaction of the government.

(iii) Principles of natural justice have no place in the context of an order of compulsory retirement. This does not mean that judicial scrutiny is excluded altogether. While the High Court or this Court would not examine the matter as an appellate court, they may interfere it they are satisfied that the order is passed (a) mala fide or (b) that it is based on an evidence or (c) that it is arbitrary-in the sense that no reasonable person would form the requisite opinion on the given material; in short, if it is found to be a perverse order.

(iv) The government (or the Review Committee as the case may be) shall have to consider the entire record of service before taking a decision in the matter-of course attaching more importance to record of and performance during the later years. The record to be so considered would naturally include the entries in the confidential records/character rolls, both favourable and adverse. If a government servant is promoted to a higher post notwithstanding the adverse remarks, such remarks lose their sting, more so, if the promotion is based upon merit (selection) and not upon seniority.

(v) An order of compulsory retirement is not liable to be quashed by a Court merely on the showing that while passing it uncommunicated adverse remarks were also taken into consideration. That circumstance by itself cannot be a basis for interference.”

6. According to learned counsel for the appellant conclusions no. (iii) and (iv), quoted above, are attracted in the case of the appellant on the basis of uncontroverted facts as well as his service record. It was highlighted that the High Court was not required to examine the matter as an appellate court but the issues of mala fide in the sense of colourable exercise of power, lack of any evidence and arbitrary action in the sense that no reasonable person would form the required opinion for compulsory retirement, were required to be considered by the Writ Court which was not done, as would appear from paragraph 5 of the judgment under appeal. The relevance of conclusion no. (iv) was highlighted on the basis of service record of the appellant which were called for by another Division Bench of this Court by order passed on 22.12.2008 and which were perused by the parties and the Court at the time of final arguments. It was demonstrated by the learned counsel for the appellant that the order of compulsory retirement was preceded by recommendation of the Committee constituted to review the performance of the appellant and the recommendation against the appellant dated 6.5.2000 shows that the authorities considered ACRs for 15 years, including those prior to his promotion in 1992 and instead of concluding that prior to 1992 he had only one overall rating of ‘below average’ the conclusion was misleading that except overall rating for two years, out of 15 years, the rating were either ‘average’ or ‘below average’. The only entry of ‘below average’ was prior to appellant's promotion in the year 1992 and as per conclusion no. (iv) of the Supreme Court, noticed above, such adverse ACR prior to last promotion could not have been looked into for the purpose of compulsory retirement. It was also demonstrated that after 1992, for the next two years appellant had overall rating of ‘good’ followed by rating of ‘average’ till 1998 and in the year preceding his compulsory retirement only he was given a rating of ‘poor’. According to learned counsel for the appellant, the last rating of ‘poor’ for the year 1999 was on account of malafide and annoyance on the part of his superiors at Patna because, as alleged in paragraph 27 of the writ petition, appellant considered himself as an honest officer and as such he has raised the issues regarding malfunctioning as well as rampant corruption and favoritism in the Institute. No doubt, in counter affidavit filed on behalf of the respondents 1 to 5, in paragraph 27 a clear denial was made and it was replied that the appellant in fact did not bring any such thing in the notice of the Management. But in the service record appellant's letter dated 17.9.1998 is available at page 38. The said letter is addressed to the Director of the Institute at Chennai. In that letter he has referred to his previous letter regarding poor administration and has expressed many problems being faced, for instance, attendance register not being available for signature, the attendance register being absent from the authorized place and being marked in most casual manner once in a week or so, behaviour of the Helpers not being proper, the Helpers were reported to be working in the house of one Abdul Rahman, Manager and only occasionally available for office work. He also raised a grievance that his salary for the month of August 1998 had not been paid. On behalf of the appellant, it was pointed out that letters and reports against the appellant were created by the Manager at Patna only after such complaint by the appellant to the Director. It was pointed out that the letters and warning contained in Annexures E, E/1 and E/2 dated 13.10.1998, 19.2.1999 and 29.9.1999 are all after the appellant had allegedly acted as a whistle blower and pointed out wrong practices at Patna office.

7. Learned counsel for the respondents was unable to defend the reply in the counter affidavit to averments made in paragraph 27 of the writ petition. The letter of the appellant dated 17.9.1998 was clearly ignored and overlooked at the time of preparing the counter affidavit and clearly the attempt was to prevent this Court from examining the material facts in respect of allegation of malafide/colourable exercise of power. The fact that while making its recommendations on 6.5.2000 for compulsory retirement of the appellant vide Annexure G/1 to the supplementary counter affidavit, the Committee wrongly mentioned that the appellant had got only one promotion during his tenure of 22 years of service. The uncontroverted facts in the writ petition noticed earlier clearly show that he got more than two promotions. It also could not be disputed that only overall rating of ‘below average’ taken note by the Committee was on the basis of an adverse ACR of the year 1989 which was prior to appellant's promotion in the year 1992 and as per the Supreme Court judgment, the same should not have been highlighted or given importance which it has been accorded in the minutes of the Committee contained in Annexure G/1. In fact, the two subsequent ratings of ‘good’ for the year 1993 and 1994 have been also totally ignored.

8. On a proper consideration of the service record of the appellant noticed above and his averments in paragraph 27 of the writ petition which were falsely denied, we are satisfied that the order of compulsory retirement has been passed in colourable exercise of power and the only ‘poor’ rating given to the appellant in the preceding year before subjecting him to compulsory retirement clearly appears to be on account of his complaint made against the Manager at Patna. It was on account of such complaint that soon thereafter the authorities at Patna began to level allegations and complaint against the appellant leading to adverse rating of poor for only one year since his promotion in the year 1992. We are also satisfied that in the light of service record of the appellant since his promotion in the year 1992 and also otherwise, no reasonable person should have come to the opinion that the appellant should be retired compulsorily in public interest.

9. In view of aforesaid discussions and findings, the judgment and order under appeal is set aside. The order of compulsory retirement of the appellant is quashed. The writ petition as well as the appeal is allowed. As a result of setting aside of the impugned order of compulsory retirement, the appellant would be entitled to all the consequential benefits which must be made available to him within three months.