Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Lachmi Singh v. Brij Mohan Lal Opposite Party.

Patna High Court
Nov 3, 1916

1. This is an application for revision of an order of the District Judge of Chapra, directing the prosecution of the applicants for various offences alleged to have been committed by them in respect of a suit brought by the applicant Lachmi Singh in the Darbhanga District in the Court of a Munsif exercising Small Cause Court powers on the basis of a hand note. It appears that Lachmi Singh having obtained a decree ex parte caused the decree to be transferred to the Chapra District for execution, and in execution the defendant Brij Mohan Eaut was actually arrested in the Chapra District on 21st August 1913 Brij Mohan Eaut then brought a suit in the Court of the 2nd Munsif of Chapra to have the decree obtained by Lachmi Singh set aside on the ground that it had been obtained by fraud. Brij Mohan Raut obtained a decree in June 1914 setting aside the decree. Lachmi Singh appealed but his appeal was dismissed on 8th March, 1915, and a second appeal by him to the High Court was also dismissed on 13th July, 1915. Brij Mohan did not become aware of the order of the High Court dismissing Lachmi Singh's appeal until January 1916. On 2nd February, 1916, he presented an application to the 2nd Munsif of Chapra for sanction to prosecute Lachmi Singh and others who had assisted him in various ways in the false suit. The Munsif dismissed the application. Thereupon Brij Mohan Raut appealed to the District Judge of Chapra, who has ordered the prosecution of Lachmi Singh and others for various offences set out at the end of his order.

2. The case came before Roe, J., during, the vacation and that learned Judge thinking that there was some conflict between two rulings of this Court referred the case to this Bench. One of the cases referred to by him was that of Ambica Tewari v. Emperor(1). In that case what was decided was that as no appeal lay to the District Judge against an order of a Small Cause Court rejecting an application for sanction, the District Judge could not at the hearing of the appeal pass an order under Section 476 of the Cr PC. That case seems to have no bearing on the present casa. The other case referred to is Rajkumar Singh v. Emperor(2) decided by this Bench on 2nd June, 1916. In that case we held that the District Judge of Arrah had jurisdiction to direct the prosecution of certain persons in connexion with a false suit brought by them in the Central Provinces. It is suggested that the cases against the present applicants cannot be made over to a Magistrate in Chapra for trial inasmuch as the offences were committed in the Darbhanga District. It appears to us that the requirements of Section 476 of the Cr PC, have been satisfied. The District Judge's order under S. 476 was passed in the course of a judicial proceeding.

3. Certain offences referred to under Section 195 of the Cr PC, were brought to his notice in the course of a judicial proceeding and he was therefore authorized by S. 476 to send the case for inquiry or trial to the nearest Magistrate of the first class. In our opinion, the proper Magistrate at Chapra will have jurisdiction to try the cases which have been sent to him under the order of the District Judge of Chapra. The only defect in the order of the District Judge is that he has failed to specify the Magistrate to whom the cases are to be sent. On receipt of our order the District Judge will specify the Magistrate to whom the cases are sent in order that the provisions of S. 476 may be complied with. Subject to this, the application is dismissed.

V.S/R.K

4. Application dismissed.