- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Amlesh Kumar v. State Of Bihar
Summary of Legal Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner was the elected Pramukh of Sahebganj Panchayat Samiti, Muzaffarpur. A special meeting held on 26.12.2014 resulted in a no confidence motion being passed against the petitioner, ousting him from office; the minutes of that meeting are Annexure-4 to the writ petition. The petitioner challenged the no confidence motion by filing a writ petition, contending that the notice for the special meeting dated 16.12.2014 (issued by the Executive Officer-cum-Block Development Officer, Sahebganj) did not comply with section 44(3)(v) of the Bihar Panchayat Raj Act, 2006 because it was not accompanied by reasons/charges. The matter was listed for orders on office notes regarding service of notice but, with parties present, the writ petition was taken up for final disposal. The Court had earlier issued notice on 22.1.2015 to non-appearing respondents and directed official respondents to file a counter affidavit; a counter affidavit was filed and accepted as acknowledging the infirmity in the notice.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the notice dated 16.12.2014 for the special meeting complied with section 44(3)(v) of the Bihar Panchayat Raj Act, 2006 (specifically, whether it was required to be accompanied by reasons/charges).
- If the notice was non-compliant, whether the no confidence motion convened pursuant thereto (held on 26.12.2014) is invalid and liable to be set aside, with consequent restoration of the petitioner to the post of Pramukh.
- What directions, if any, should be given regarding convening and circulating a fresh special meeting in accordance with section 44(3)(i) read with section 44(3)(v) of the Act, and the duties of the Executive Officer-cum-Block Development Officer in that process.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner challenged the no confidence motion on the specific ground that the notice dated 16.12.2014 (Annexure-3) issued by the Executive Officer-cum-Block Development Officer did not comply with section 44(3)(v) of the Bihar Panchayat Raj Act, 2006 because it was not accompanied by reasons/charges.
Private Respondents' Arguments
- The private respondents' counsel (Mr. Shri Prakash Srivastava) admitted to infirmities in the notice but submitted that the requisition (Annexure-1) did not suffer from any infirmity, and therefore submitted that the Pramukh should be directed to fix the date of a special meeting.
State / Official Respondents' Position
- The official respondents filed a counter affidavit which was accepted by the Court and which, according to the opinion, acknowledged the infirmity in the notice.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded on the basis that the parties were present and consented to final disposal. The Court identified an apparent illegality in the proceedings: the notice dated 16.12.2014 (Annexure-3) did not comply with the statutory requirement under section 44(3)(v) of the Bihar Panchayat Raj Act, 2006 because it was not accompanied by reasons/charges as required. The counter affidavit filed by official respondents accepted this infirmity, and counsel for the private respondents also fairly admitted the defect in the notice while pointing to the validity of the requisition (Annexure-1).
The Court observed that even if the requisition itself had no infirmity, the Pramukh remains bound by section 44(3)(i) of the Act to fix the date of a special meeting. On the specific point at issue, because the notice issued by the Executive Officer-cum-Block Development Officer contravened the statutory provision in section 44(3)(v), the Court treated that contravention as rendering the notice (and any proceedings convened pursuant to it) invalid. The Court therefore set aside the defective notice and, as a direct consequence, invalidated the no confidence motion that had been convened under that notice.
The Court also issued a warning to the Executive Officer-cum-Block Development Officer, Sahebganj, reminding him of his duties when circulating notices of special meetings and cautioning that any future lapse in issuing notice in contravention of the statutory provisions would be treated as deliberate violation of the Court's order.
The petitioner undertook to convene a special meeting for consideration of the requisition by 8.4.2015 and to communicate the date to the Executive Officer for circulation. The Court directed that the Executive Officer-cum-Block Development Officer must notify the date of the special meeting in conformity with section 44(3)(i) read with section 44(3)(v) of the Act, and that any failure to follow the prescribed legal procedure would be treated as contempt of the Court's order.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The writ petition is allowed. The notice dated 16.12.2014 (Annexure-3) is set aside; the no confidence motion convened pursuant thereto on 26.12.2014 is invalidated and set aside; and the petitioner is restored to the post of Pramukh.
Implications:
- The petitioner is restored to office and has undertaken to convene a fresh special meeting by 8.4.2015 for consideration of the requisition; the Executive Officer-cum-Block Development Officer is directed to circulate the notice of that meeting in strict conformity with section 44(3)(i) read with section 44(3)(v) of the Bihar Panchayat Raj Act, 2006.
- The Court warned that any failure by the Executive Officer to abide by the statutory procedure and this order will be treated as contempt. The opinion does not articulate any broader precedent beyond the direct effect on the parties.
Final procedural disposition: The writ petition is allowed and the interlocutory application is disposed of.
Jyoti Saran, J.:— Heard Mr. Ravi Ranjan, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner, Mr. Nirbhay Kumar Singh, learned Government Pleader No. 26 for the State, Mr. Girish Pandey for the State Election Commission and Mr. Shri Prakash Srivastava for the private respondents.
2. Although this matter has been listed under the heading ‘For orders on office notes’ as regarding service of notice but since the parties have appeared hence with consent of the parties the writ petition itself has been taken up with a view to its final disposal at the present stage itself.
3. The petitioner who was an elected Pramukh of Sahebganj Panchayat Samiti in the district of Muzaffarpur has questioned the no confidence motion passed against him on 26.12.2014, whereby he stands ousted from the post. The minutes of the special meeting are present at Annexure-4 to the writ petition.
4. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has questioned the no confidence motion on a very limited ground and i.e that the notice issued by the Executive Officer-cum-Block Development Officer, Sahebganj dated 16.12.2014, whereby the members were informed about the special meeting to be held on 26.12.2014 was not in tune with the provisions underlying section 44(3)(v) of the Bihar Panchayat Raj Act, 2006 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’) inasmuch as it is not accompanied with reasons/charges.
5. As the illegality in the proceedings was apparent that this Court vide order passed on 22.1.2015 issued notice to the non-appearing respondents as well as required the official respondents to file counter affidavit and which has since been filed and the infirmity has been accepted.
6. Mr. Shri Prakash Srivastava, learned appearing for the private respondents fairly admits to the infirmities but submits that since there is no infirmity found in the requisition hence the petitioner as a Pramukh would be directed to fix the date of special meeting.
7. In view of the apparent infirmity in the notice and taking note of the submission made by Shri Prakash Srivastava regarding absence of any infirmity in the requisition placed at Annexure-1 even if the motion passed cannot be upheld, yet the Pramukh is bound under section 44(3)(i) of ‘the Act’ to fix the date of special meeting. Having said so this Court would also remind the Executive Officer-cum-Block Development Officer, Sahebganj of his objection and caution him about the duty cast upon him while circulating the notice of special meeting and for any lapse on his part in issuing notice in contravention of the statutory provisions underlying section 44(3)(v) of ‘the Act’ would be treated as deliberate violation of the present order.
8. In view of the admitted infirmity in the notice dated 16.12.2014 placed at Annexure-3, the same cannot be upheld and is accordingly set aside and as a consequence the no confidence motion convened pursuant thereto on 26.12.2014 also becomes invalidated and is set aside. The petitioner is restored to the post of Pramukh.
9. Mr. Ravi Ranjan, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner undertakes on behalf of the petitioner that the Pramukh would be convening the special meeting for consideration of the requisition by 8.4.2015 and would communicate the same to the Executive Officer for its circulation amongst the Members. The Executive Officer-cum-Block Development Officer, Sahebganj would notify the date of special meeting in tune with the provisions of section 44(3)(i) read with section 44(3)(v) of ‘the Act’ and any failure on his part to abide by the legal procedure would be construed contempt of this Court present order.
10. The writ petition is allowed with the direction aforementioned. The interlocutory application stands disposed of.
Alert