- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Bihar Education Service Association, Patna And Ors. v. State Of Bihar And Ors.
Judicial Opinion Summary — Delivered by V.N. Sinha, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
Two writ petitions were before the Court. CWJC No. 10091 of 2006 was filed by the Bihar Education Service Association and members of the Bihar Education Service challenging the State Government's Resolution dated 7 July 2006 (Annexure-1) which merged the Teaching Branch (Male and Female) of the Bihar Subordinate Education Service with the Bihar Education Service Class II, purportedly in compliance with various High Court and Supreme Court orders and with reference to an earlier Government Resolution dated 11 April 1977 (Annexure-3).
CWJC No. 14678 of 2006 was filed by 51 petitioners seeking the benefit of the higher pay scale of Bihar Education Service Class II in light of the 11 April 1977 Resolution and the subsequent 7 July 2006 Resolution, alleging unjust discrimination in not including them for merger.
The State respondents opposed the petitions, asserting that the 7 July 2006 Resolution implemented the 11 April 1977 Resolution in conformity with a sequence of earlier orders of the High Court and the Supreme Court (including proceedings in CWJC Nos. 12122/1998, 8147/1999, LPA Nos. 980/2000 and 998/2000, various Special Leave Petitions, and Civil Appeal No. 4466 of 2003). Intervenor-Respondents supported the State's action, relying on the need to comply with prior judicial directions.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the State Government's Resolution dated 7 July 2006 (Annexure-1) validly merged the Teaching Branch (Male and Female) of the Bihar Subordinate Education Service into the Bihar Education Service Class II in purported compliance with the Resolution dated 11 April 1977 (Annexure-3) and prior judicial orders.
- Whether the posts of the Teaching Branch of the Bihar Subordinate Education Service were covered by the Resolution dated 11 April 1977 (Schedule I, Serial No. 7) and the Committee report (paragraph 11.10 of Annexure-2), which dealt with inclusion of certain miscellaneous cadre posts in the Bihar Education Service.
- Whether petitioners in CWJC No. 14678 of 2006 are entitled to the benefit of merger and higher pay scale in the Bihar Education Service Class II, or whether they have been validly excluded.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners (CWJC No. 10091 of 2006)
- Challenged the 7 July 2006 Resolution as being contrary to earlier orders of the High Court and the Supreme Court and contrary to the terms of the 11 April 1977 Resolution (Annexure-3).
- Asserted that the 11 April 1977 Resolution only provided for inclusion of posts of the miscellaneous cadre of the Education Department (e.g., teachers except Netarhat teachers, stadium managers) as reflected in Schedule I, Serial No. 7, and did not refer to the Bihar Subordinate Education Service.
- Pointed to the Chief Secretary's compliance report dated 27 March 2003 (Annexure-10), which, they submitted, showed that the posts contemplated by the 1977 Resolution had already been included earlier, and therefore the 7 July 2006 Notification should not have been issued.
- Argued that the Bihar Subordinate Education Service (Teaching Branch) is inherently different from Bihar Education Service Class II (mode of recruitment, minimum qualifications, nature and duties), and thus merger cannot be permitted; relied on several Supreme Court authorities to support this proposition.
Petitioners (CWJC No. 14678 of 2006)
- Claimed they (or their husbands) were appointed as teachers in the Bihar Subordinate Education Service and sought equal treatment and the benefit of merger with Bihar Education Service Class II in light of the 11 April 1977 Resolution and the 7 July 2006 Resolution.
- Contended there was no rational basis to distinguish their cases from other members already merged.
State Respondents
- Submitted that the 7 July 2006 Resolution was issued in compliance with the 11 April 1977 Resolution and a series of judicial orders (writ petitions, LPAs, Special Leave Petitions, and Civil Appeal No. 4466 of 2003) which ultimately left the authorities with no option but to implement the 1977 Resolution.
- Contended that the High Court and the Supreme Court had directed implementation of the 11 April 1977 Resolution and that the members of the Teaching Branch were merged accordingly; urged dismissal of CWJC No. 10091 and consideration of CWJC No. 14678 petitioners' representations.
Intervenor-Respondents
- Supported the impugned notification and submitted it was issued to comply with the orders of the High Court and the Supreme Court; asked the Court not to interfere since the matter had been extensively considered in earlier proceedings.
- Placed reliance on the Chief Secretary's report dated 27 March 2003 being before the Supreme Court but not accepted by that Court as constituting compliance of the 11 April 1977 Resolution.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| S.P. Shivprasad Pipal v. Union of India, (1998) 4 SCC 598 | Relied upon by petitioners to support the proposition that distinct services should not be indiscriminately merged where there are inherent differences. | Noted as one of the authorities cited by petitioners in support of their contention that merger of distinct services was impermissible; the Court recorded reliance but decided the matter on the specific textual and factual analysis of the 1977 Resolution and the Committee report. |
| Association for the Officers of the W.B. Audit and Accounts Service v. W.B. Audit and Accounts Service Association, 1995 Supp (4) SCC 44 | Relied upon by petitioners to support arguments on non-merger of distinct services. | Recorded as cited by petitioners; the Court did not apply it as a dispositive precedent but acknowledged it among authorities raised by petitioners. |
| Inder Singh v. Vyas Muni, 1987 Supp SCC 257 | Relied upon by petitioners (authority cited by them). | Noted as cited by petitioners; the Court's decision turned on interpretation of Resolution and administrative records rather than direct application of this authority. |
| Hydro-Electric Employees Union, U.P. v. Sudhir Kumar Sharma, (1998) 6 SCC 706 (paras 18 & 19) | Relied upon by petitioners (authority dealing with service law issues cited in submissions). | Referenced among authorities relied upon by petitioners; the Court recorded the citation but did not treat it as the basis of its order, which rested on the text of the Resolution and the Chief Secretary's report. |
| Two judgments cited by the Division Bench in LPA proceedings: 1992 Supp (2) SCC 432 and 1995 Supp (4) SCC 541 | Cited by the Division Bench as containing directions about the manner in which inter-departmental disputes are to be settled. | The Court recorded that these authorities were referred to in the Divisional Bench proceedings on 28 January 2003 and formed part of the context in which the Chief Secretary examined compliance; the present decision used those proceedings as background rather than as direct precedent deciding the present petition. |
| Janardan Rai v. State (CWJC No. 8679 of 2002) and related High Court/Supreme Court orders including Civil Appeal No. 4466 of 2003 | Part of the litigation history; Supreme Court observed that the High Court should decide whether the 11 April 1977 Resolution had been implemented in the required manner. | The Court relied on the procedural history to explain why the State issued the 7 July 2006 Resolution; it further interpreted the 11 April 1977 Resolution and the Chief Secretary's report to conclude that the 7 July 2006 action was unnecessary as regards the Bihar Subordinate Education Service. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court undertook a focused textual and factual analysis of the Government Resolution dated 11 April 1977 (Annexure-3), the Committee report that formed its basis (Annexure-2, in particular paragraph 11.10 at page 25), Schedule I of the 1977 Resolution (specifically Serial No. 7), and the Chief Secretary's compliance report dated 27 March 2003 (Annexure-10).
Key steps in the Court's analysis:
- Examined Schedule I, Serial No. 7 of the 11 April 1977 Resolution and the Committee report paragraph 11.10, and concluded that the 1977 Resolution addressed inclusion of various posts of the miscellaneous cadre of the Education Department (for example teachers except Netarhat teachers, stadium managers).
- Considered the Chief Secretary's report dated 27 March 2003 (Annexure-10), which indicated that compliance with the 11 April 1977 Resolution had already been effected earlier by instructions dated 10 May 1982; the Court noted that the contents of Annexure-10 were not disputed by intervenors.
- Observed that Bihar Subordinate Education Service is not a 'State Service' as defined (reference to Appendix 16 of Bihar Service Code) and therefore was not part of the miscellaneous cadre that the 1977 Committee had considered for inclusion; consequently, there was no basis in the 1977 Resolution to treat the Bihar Subordinate Education Service's Teaching Branch as covered by its terms.
- Concluded that, because the 1977 Resolution did not contemplate the Bihar Subordinate Education Service and because the relevant posts had, according to the Chief Secretary's report, already been included earlier, there was no occasion for the State to issue the 7 July 2006 Resolution merging the Bihar Subordinate Education Service Teaching Branch into the Bihar Education Service Class II in purported compliance with the 11 April 1977 Resolution.
- Therefore, the 7 July 2006 Resolution (Annexure-1) was found to be contrary to the factual and textual matrix and was quashed. However, the Court expressly granted the State liberty to consider the position of the Bihar Subordinate Education Service Teaching/Inspecting Branch on merits and in accordance with law if the State concluded their case was similar to the miscellaneous cadre teachers.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
CWJC No. 10091 of 2006 is ALLOWED; the State Government's Resolution dated 7 July 2006 (Annexure-1), insofar as it merged the Teaching Branch (Male and Female) of the Bihar Subordinate Education Service into the Bihar Education Service Class II in purported compliance with the Resolution dated 11 April 1977, is quashed.
CWJC No. 14678 of 2006 is disposed of with a specific direction (liberty) to the State Government.
Implications / Consequences:
- Direct effect: The specific 7 July 2006 resolution merging the Teaching Branch of the Bihar Subordinate Education Service with the Bihar Education Service Class II has been set aside by the Court.
- The State Government is granted liberty to reconsider, on proper administrative and legal grounds and in accordance with law, whether the Bihar Subordinate Education Service Teaching/Inspecting Branch should be included/merged with the Bihar Education Service Class II.
- The Court did not purport to formulate any new general principle of law; the decision rests on interpretation of the 11 April 1977 Resolution, the Committee report, the Chief Secretary's report, and the statutory/administrative classification (Appendix 16 of Bihar Service Code). No broader precedent beyond the disposition of the petitions is declared in the text of the order.
Disposition as recorded in the opinion: "In the result, CWJC No. 10091 of 2006 is allowed and CWJC No. 14678 of 2006 is disposed of with aforementioned liberty to the State Government to consider the case of Bihar Subordinate Education Service, Teaching/Inspecting Branch for inclusion/merger in the Bihar Education Service in accordance with law."
The order of the court was delivered by
V.N Sinha, J:— Heard learned Counsel for the parties at length.
2. Bihar Education Service Association, an Association of the members of Bihar Education Service and other Members of the said Service have filed CWJC No. 10091 of 2006, praying inter alia to quash the resolution of the State Government, bearing Memo. No. 1209 dated, 7th July, 2006, Annexure-1, whereunder the State, Respondents, in compliance of the different Orders of this Court and the Hon'ble Supreme Court, referred to in the said resolution, have merged Teaching Branch of the Bihar Subordinate Education Service, Male and Female with the Bihar Education Service Class II in the light of the Resolution No. 3521 F2 dated, 11th April, 1977, Annexure-3 with effect from 1st January, 1977 on the ground that in compliance of the different Orders of this Court as also of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the Members of the Teaching Branch of the Bihar Subordinate Education Service were not entitled for being merged with the Bihar Education Service Class II and the impugned resolution has been issued ignoring the contents of the different Orders of this Court and of the Hon'ble Supreme Court as also the aforesaid Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977, which only provide for inclusion of the various posts of teachers of the miscellaneous cadre of Education Department (except the teachers of Netarhat), Stadium Managers etc. in Bihar Education Service, as is evident from Serial No. 7 of Schedule 1 of the said resolution.
3. In this connection, it was pointed out that various posts referred to in the resolution belong to the Misc. cadre of the Education Department as indicated in paragraph 11.10 of the report of the Committee constituted to assess the extent of stagnation prevailing in different State Services, Annexure-2, which was the basis for taking the decision contained in the Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977, Annexure-3. With reference to the compliance report of the Chief Secretary dated, 27th March, 2003, Annexure-10, it was submitted that the posts which were to be included in terms of the Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977, were included in the State Services much earlier as would be evident from the said report of the Chief Secretary dated, 27th March, 2003, Annexure-10 and in view of the report of the Chief Secretary the impugned Notification dated, 7th July, 2006, Annexure-1 should not have been issued at all. In this regard assertions have been made by the Petitioners of CWJC No. 10091 of 2006 in paragraph 25 of the writ petition. It was further submitted that merger of the Bihar Subordinate Education Service, Teaching Branch, Male and Female cannot be allowed with the Bihar Education Service Class II as the two services are inherently different from each other not only in the mode of recruitment but also in the minimum qualification required for entry in the two services as also in the nature, duties of the two services. In this connection reliance was placed on the Judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of S.P Shivprasad Pipal v. Union of India, (1998) 4 SCC 598, in the case of Association for the Officers of the W.B Audit and Accounts Service v. W.B Audit and Accounts Service Association, reported in 1995 Supp (4) SCC 44, in the case of Inder Singh v. Vyas Muni, reported in 1987 Supp SCC 257 and in the case of Hydro-Electric Employees Union, U.P v. Sudhir Kumar Sharma, reported in (1998) 6 SCC 706, paragraphs 18 and 19.
4. C.W.J.C, No. 14678 of 2006 has been filed by 51 Petitioners claiming that the Petitioners or their husband were appointed as teacher in the Bihar Subordinate Education Service and they be also allowed the benefit of the higher pay scale of Bihar Education Service Class II in the light of Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977 in compliance of the different Orders of this Court referred to in the subsequent resolution of the State Government dated, 7th July, 2006 and the State Respondents is not justified in discriminating against them by not including their services in the Bihar Education Service Class II for which names were called for by the Director, Administration, the Cadre Controlling Authority of the Bihar Education Service Class II and there is no earthly reason to distinguish the case of the Petitioners or their husbands from the other members of the Bihar Subordinate Education Service, who have already been merged in the Bihar Education Service Class II.
5. Learned Counsel for the State has opposed the prayer made in the two writ applications with reference to the averments made in the counter affidavit/supplementary counter affidavit filed in both the applications and submitted that the contents of the Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977 was the subject matter of CWJC Nos. 12122 of 1998 and 8147 of 1999, whereunder prayer was made to implement the Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977 as anomaly was being created in the light of subsequent Notification dated, 8th February, 1999 and this Court having considered the prayer made in the two writ applications, directed the Commissioner-cum-Secretary of the Secondary, Primary and Mass Education Department of the State Government to act upon the Government's decision contained in Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977, which Order became the subject-matter of L.P.A Nos. 980 and 998 of 2000 and Petition(s) for Special Leave Petition to Appeal (Civil) No. 4937-4938/2001 and subsequently another writ petition, bearing CWJC No. 8679 of 2002 was filed in which observations were made that the authorities of the State Government were in contempt of the earlier Orders of this Court as also of the Hon'ble Supreme Court as they had not yet implemented Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977 and ultimately matter was taken to the Division Bench by the State Respondents in L.P.A No. 65 of 2003, which was also dismissed and then the matter was again taken to Hon'ble Supreme Court in Petition(s) for Special Leave to Appeal (Civil) No. 6450 of 2003.Civil Appeal No. 4466 of 2003, which was also dismissed under Orders dated, 19th April, 2006 and the authorities thereafter, had no option but to issue the impugned Resolution dated, 7th July, 2006 in the light of the Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977. In the light of different Orders of this Court and the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the members of the Teaching Branch of the Bihar Subordinate Education Service, Male and Female have been merged in the Bihar Education Service Class II and this Court should dismiss CWJC No. 10091 of 2006 and direct the authorities to consider the representation of the Petitioners of CWJC No. 14678 of 2006 for being granted the benefit of merger with the Bihar Education Service Class II.
6. Intervenor-Respondents of CWJC No. 10091 of 2006 including the Bihar Education Service Association, Intervenor Respondent No. 10 as also Counsel for Sri Janardan Rai, Petitioner in CWJC No. 8679 of 2002 reiterated the same submissions in support of the impugned notification and submitted that the same has been issued in compliance of the different Orders of this Court and the Hon'ble Supreme Court and this Court should not interfere in the matter as the matter has already been considered by this Court and the compliance report dated, 27th March, 2003, Annexure-10 was also placed on the records of Civil Appeal No. 4466 of 2003 before the Hon'ble Supreme Court but the same was not accepted by the Hon'ble Supreme Court as compliance of the Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977.
7. In order to consider the correctness or otherwise of the submissions made by the learned Counsel for the parties, it is necessary to take a birds eye view of the Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977, Annexure-3, whereunder the State Government has considered the report of the Committee constituted to assess the extent of stagnation prevailing in the different State Services together with the different Orders of this Court and the Hon'ble Apex Court. It appears from Schedule I of the said resolution that the recommendation of the Committee as regards the Education Department were made in paragraph 11.10 at page 25 of the report, Annexure-2, which was considered at serial No. 7 and decision was taken to include various posts of misc. cadre of Education Department like teachers (except the teachers of Netarhat), Stadium Managers etc. in the Bihar Education Service Cadre. The said Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977 became the subject matter of C.W.J.C Nos. 12122 of 1998 filed by the Bihar State Government Secondary School Teachers Association and others, and 8147 of 1999 and both the writ applications were considered by the learned Single Judge of this Court under Orders dated, 2nd February, 2000, Annexure 4 and this Court having taken into account the anomaly created by a subsequent notification dated, 8th February, 1999, directed the Commissioner-cum-Secretary of the Secondary, Primary and Mass Education Department of the State Government to act upon the Government decision contained in Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977. Subsequently, the said Order became the subject matter of L.P.A No(s). 980 and 998 of 2000 at the instance of the State, which were dismissed under Orders dated, 27th November, 2000, Annexure-6 with observation that this Court under Orders dated, 2nd February, 2000 had directed the Government to comply with the Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977, there appears to be no reason for the State to be aggrieved by such direction. The State of Bihar, thereafter preferred Petition(s) for Special Leave to Appeal (Civil) Mo. 4937-4938 of 2001 against the Order dated, 27th November, 2000, Annexure-6 in which the Hon'ble Supreme Court under Orders dated, 3rd April, 2001 directed that the Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977 be placed on record and the matter was finally considered on 16th April, 2001 when the Hon'ble Court having perused the Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977 observed that the final direction which has been given to the State is to implement the Resolution dated, 11th April 1977 in the manner, it is to be implemented and having made such observations, the Hon'ble Court disposed of the said S.P.L While the matter-remained pending one Janardan Rai, a member of the Teaching Branch of the Bihar Subordinate Education Service, approached this Court by filing CWJC No. 8679 of 2002 complaining inter alia that although he has superannuated but has not been allowed the consequential benefit of merger in the Bihar Education Service in terms of the resolution of the State Government dated, 11th April, 1977, whereafter this Court under Orders dated, 12th August, 2002 issued notice to the State Respondents to file counter affidavit and under Orders dated, 3rd September, 2002 allowed I.A No. 3898 of 2002 filed by the Bihar State Government Secondary School Teachers' Association, the original writ petitioners in CWJC No. 12122 of 1998 and further called upon the Additional Finance Commissioner and the Finance Commissioner to be present in Court on 17th September, 2002 so as to explain their failure to comply with the Orders dated, 2nd February, 2000, passed in the said CWJC No. 12122 of 1998. On 17th September. 2002, this Court having considered the show cause filed by the Commissioner and the Additional Commissioner, Finance Department, who were present in Court recorded that there appears to be a dispute going on in between Education and Finance Department of the State Government and this Court will not like to become an Arbitrator in the inter departmental dispute and granted them further indulgence to comply with the Orders of this Court and adjourned the matter to 27th November, 2002 and thereafter, having heard Counsel for the parties disposed of the Writ Petition under Orders dated, 9th December, 2002 granting six weeks further time to comply with the Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977, failing which liberty was granted to Janardan Rai to approach the Court again inviting non-compliance on the part of the authorities by filing interlocutory application. In spite of the indulgences granted by this Court under Order dated. 9th December, 2002, Resolution dated, 11th April 1977 was not complied with, and Petitioner filed I.A No. 272, 315 of 2003, which were considered under Orders dated, 22nd January, 2003 and notice was issued directing that the matter be listed after three weeks. Meanwhile, State Respondents challenged Order dated, 9th December, 2002, passed in C.W.J.C No. 8679 of 2002 by filing L.P.A No. 65 of 2003 and in the said L.P.A, Division Bench of this Court under Orders dated, 27th January, 2003 directed for appearance of Chief/Finance/Education Secretary(s) and Director Administration, Education Department, Government of Bihar, who were present before this Court in 28th January, 2003 and in their presence, with reference to the directions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, contained in Judgment reported in 1992 Supp (2) SCC 432 and 1995 Supp (4) SCC 541 as regards the manner in which the inter departmental dispute is required to be settled, at the request of the Chief Secretary the matter adjourned by four weeks observing that only anxiety of the Court is that the State of Bihar will ensure that the Orders of the Hon'ble Supreme Court having attained finality is not compromised. In the light of the proceedings taken before the Division Bench in L.P.A No. 65 of 2003 on 28th January, 2003, the Chief Secretary examined the contents of the Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977 as also other relevant documents to verify whether the said resolution has been complied with, and having examined the relevant records referred to in his report, prepared report dated, 27th March, 2003, as contained in Annexure-10 but before the said report could be tiled in L.P.A No. 65 of 2003, the same was dismissed under Orders dated, 10th March, 2003 against which Order the matter went to the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Petition(s) for Special Leave to Appeal (Civil) No. 6450 of 2003 in which under Orders dated, 17th April, 2003, notices were issued and the contempt proceedings were stayed. Later the petition(s) for Special Leave to Appeal (Civil) No. 6450 of 2003 was converted in Civil Appeal No. 4466 of 2003, which appeal, after hearing the parties was dismissed under Orders dated, 19th April, 2006 and the stay of the contempt proceeding was also vacated observing as to whether the implementation of the Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977 has been done in the manner required by the said resolution, is for the High Court to decide. Under Orders dated, 10th May, 2006, passed in C.W.J.C No. 8679 of 2002 (Janardan Rai v. State), this Court took notice of the fact that Civil Appeal arising out of the contempt matter has already been dismissed and the stay of the contempt proceeding has also been vacated, directed the Commissioner-cum-Secretary of Finance and Education Departments) along wtth their predecessor in office to remain in attendance on 10 July, 2006. Before which date the State Government considered the memorandum dated, 3th July, 2006, Annexure-13 in the light of the different Orders of the High Court and the Hon'ble Supreme Court referred to in the said memorandum as also in the light of the advice tendered by the learned Advocate General, who opined that in view of the different Orders of the Hon'ble Supreme/High Court, the State Government has no option but to implement the Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977 as regards the merger of the Bihar Subordinate Education Service, Teaching Branch with the Bihar Education Service Class II. The Government having considered the matter in the light of the different Orders passed by this Court and the Hon'ble Supreme Court referred to in the Resolution dated, 7th July, 2006, Annexure-1, issued Resolution dated, 7th July, 2006, merging the Teaching Branch, Male and Female of the Bihar Subordinate Education Service with the Bihar Education Service Class II.
8. While dismissing the Civil Appeal No. 4466 of 2003 and vacating the stay of contempt proceeding under Orders dated, 19th April, 2006, Hon'ble Supreme Court categorically observed that it was tor the High Court to decide whether the resolution of the State Government dated, 11th April, 1977 has been implemented in the manner required to be implemented by the said resolution, but without inviting the High Court to record findings about the implementation of the Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977. the State Government, with reference to the earlier Orders of the High Court and the Hon'ble Supreme Court, including the one passed in Petition(s) for Special Leave to Appeal (Civil) No. 6450 of 2003.Civil Appeal No. 4466 of 2003, proceeded to merge the services of the Teaching Branch of the Bihar Subordinate Education Service in the Bihar Education Service Class II in the light of the Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977.
9. In the circumstances, I have examined the Government decision contained in Resolution dated, 7th July, 2006, Annexure-1 in the light of the Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977, Annexure-3 and from perusal of Schedule I of the said Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977, to me it appears that thereunder the Government had considered the report of the Committee to assess the extent of stagnation prevailing in different State Services, Annexure-2 and having considered paragraph 11.10 at page 25 of the said report, vide Serial No. 7 of Schedule I appended to the Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977, resolved to include various posts of teachers (except the teachers of Netarahat), Stadium Managers etc, of misc. cadre of the Education Department in the Bihar Education Service. From the report of the Chief Secretary dated, 27th March, 2003, Annexure-10 in CWJC No. 10091 of 2006, it appears that compliance of the Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977 was made fay the State Government earlier vide instructions dated, 10th May, 1982 and statement to that effect has been made in the report of the Chief Secretary dated, 27th March, 2003, Annexure-10 contents whereof has not been disputed by any of the intervenor Respondents, including Janardan Rai, Petitioner in CWJC No. 6679 of 2002. Reference in this connection be made to paragraph 33 of I.A No. 3897 of 2006 filed by intervenor-Respondent No. 6. In the circumstances, there was no occasion at all for the State to have issued the subsequent Notification dated, 7th July, 2006, Annexure-1 merging the Teaching Branch of the Bihar Subordinate Education Service with the Bihar Education Service Class II in compliance of Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977. Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977 provides for inclusion of posts of teachers (except the teachers of Netarhat), Stadium Managers etc. of Misc. cadre of the Education Department in the Bihar Education Service as was recommended in paragraph 11.10 at page 25 of the report, Annexure-2. Bihar Subordinate Education Service is not a State Service, which is evident from perusal of Appendix 16 of the Bihar Service Code and thus their case was never being considered by the Committee to assess the extent of stagnation prevailing in the different State Services and if there was no report submitted as regards the stagnation prevailing in the Bihar Subordinate Education Service then there was no occasion for the State to take a decision about Bihar Subordinate Education Service while passing Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977, which is evident from Schedule I Serial No. 7, which approved inclusion of various posts of teachers (except the teachers of Netarhat), Stadium Managers etc of Misc. cadre of the Education Department in the Bihar Education Service. Bihar Subordinate Education Service is not part of Misc. cadre of the Education Department, in the circumstances, there was no occasion to merge the Teaching Branch, Male and Female of the Bihar Subordinate Education Service with the Bihar Education Service in compliance of Resolution dated, 11th April, 1977 and Resolution dated, 7th July, 2006, Annexure-1 in CWJC No. 10091 of 2006 is, accordingly, quashed, however, with liberty to the State Government to consider the case of Bihar Subordinate Education Service, Teaching/Inspecting Branch and if the Government is of the view that the case of the members of the Bihar Subordinate Education Service, Teaching/Inspecting Branch is similar to that of the teacher of the Misc. cadre of the Education Department, then the State Government is at liberty to take appropriate decision about their inclusion/merger in the Bihar Education Service Class II.
10. In the resalt, CWJC No. 10091 of 2006 is allowed and CWJC No. 14678 of 2006 is disposed of with aforementioned liberty to the State Government to consider the case of Bihar Subordinate Education Service, Teaching/Inspecting Branch for inclusion/merger in the Bihar Education Service in accordance with law.
Alert