Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Vinod Kumar v. The State Of Bihar & Ors.

Patna High Court
Sep 8, 2003
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion arises from a letters patent appeal filed by a petitioner seeking a compassionate appointment by the State of Bihar following the death of his father, a government employee. The petitioner had married twice, which brought his claim under scrutiny due to the prohibition of bigamy under government regulations. Two other petitioners seeking similar relief succeeded, but the petitioner appellant did not. The petitioner sought relief despite the alleged violation of the Bihar Government Servants' Conduct Rules, 1976, which prohibit bigamy and classify it as misconduct with possible dismissal and criminal consequences.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a petitioner who has contracted bigamy can be granted a compassionate appointment under government service rules.
  2. The applicability and enforcement of the Bihar Government Servants' Conduct Rules, 1976, concerning bigamy and misconduct in government service appointments.
  3. Whether the desire for male progeny justifies or excuses bigamous relationships under Indian law or societal norms.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The petitioner sought compassionate appointment on the basis of his father's death while employed in a Class IV post.
  • He acknowledged having two wives but argued for the appointment as a form of immediate succour due to his bereavement.
  • The petitioner’s counsel suggested that Indian society permits bigamy in cases where the first wife bears only daughters and a son is sought from the second wife.

Respondent’s Position (State of Bihar)

  • The State relied on the Bihar Government Servants' Conduct Rules, 1976, which prohibit bigamy during the subsistence of a marriage.
  • The State contended that bigamy constitutes misconduct punishable by dismissal and is also a criminal offence.
  • The State implicitly opposed granting any relief that would effectively endorse or permit bigamous relationships.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court emphasized that the petitioner’s attempt to secure a compassionate appointment while maintaining a bigamous relationship is contrary to law and public policy. It rejected the notion that societal or cultural preferences for a male child can justify bigamy or circumvent statutory prohibitions under the Bihar Government Servants' Conduct Rules, 1976. The Court underscored that permitting such a claim would undermine the integrity of government service regulations and make the High Court a subject of ridicule. The Court also noted the responsibility of legal professionals to discourage such claims rather than facilitate them. The petitioner’s argument was found legally untenable, and the Court warned that future similar cases would be directed to criminal proceedings for bigamy rather than entertained as civil petitions.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED.

The Court refused to grant the petitioner compassionate appointment due to his bigamous status, reinforcing the application of the Bihar Government Servants' Conduct Rules, 1976. This decision directly affects the petitioner by denying relief and serves as a clear message that bigamy will not be tolerated or legitimized through government employment benefits. The opinion does not establish new precedent but reaffirms existing legal principles concerning misconduct and bigamy in government service.

Show all summary ...

1. The last submission of learned counsel for the petitioner was that an appropriate order be passed in this letters patent appeal. The court did ask the counsel whether he would like an order on a serious note or a lighter note? The hint apparently was not taken. Undaunted a bigamous husband has no regard for the law and would like to receive a prophylactic guard from the High Court to give him immunity for all times to come and make a laughing-stock out of the High Court.

2. The court wonders if this was the responsibility of the lawyers to advise on such causes between the temptation of bigamy and continuing amorous adventures.

3. One man, two women and a macho misadventure should not have been advised to come to the High Court to take a seal of approval to licentious affairs with two women and claim a prize as a government job for yet more affairs.

4. Of the three persons, who had filed petitions seeking relief that they be granted appointment by the State of Bihar on the rule of harness or as compassionate appointment, two succeeded and one did not. The petitioner was the one who did not. The petition itself should have been filed separately. However, the story which the petitioner appellant tells runs like this:

5. When his father died on a Class IV post, he applied for a job as a compassionate appointment. He faced a situation when the department concerned confronted him with an issue that he has married twice and under government regulations he would immediately come within the mischief of the Rule known as Bihar Government Servants' Conduct Rules, 1976. The case of the State was that if a government servant marries again during the subsistency of a marriage, then the law does not permit bigamy. The government views such adulterous relationship as misconduct, with dismissal from service as penalty, criminal offence apart.

6. But in so far as petitioner appellant is concerned, he acknowledges the luxury of keeping two women. He seeks a compassionate appointment on the principle that such an appointment is to give immediate succour to the person who is to be given a government job on the death of a parent on a government employment.

7. But, the petitioner cannot have the luxury to have two women under one roof, break the law, break the government regulations and to crown it all have an order from the High Court to give him a job. Tomorrow the State respondents will virtually tell the High Court that it encourages bigamy and adultery, both.

8. When the Court asked learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner appellant why his client took a second woman, the answer was that the first wife gave four daughters and he was looking for a son from the second woman and that Indian Society permits this. Does it?

9. The petitioner appellant and his counsel seem to be under an impression that the desire for male progeny permits a license to bigamy. They should at least leave the law courts out of this dirt. Bad habits taken note of make bad law also.

10. Such a case should not become a business for the profession. This is not for a lawyer's brief. The second case, if filed, the Court will send it to the Magistrate to answer a charge for bigamy.

11. Dismissed.