Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Md. Shakil v. The State Of Bihar .

Patna High Court
Aug 25, 2005
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — M.L. Visa, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal challenges the judgment and order dated 3.6.1992 of the Special Judge, Essential Commodities Act, Nalanda at Biharsharif in Silao Police Station Case No. 188 of 1986, which convicted the appellant under Section 7 of the Essential Commodities Act ("EC Act") for contravening Section 3 of the EC Act and sentenced him to rigorous imprisonment for five years.

The prosecution case, as narrated in the trial court, arose from an incident on 24.9.1986 at about 7 A.M. The informant (Ramjee Singh, P.W.7), then a constable at Silao Police Station, reported seeing three thellas, each allegedly loaded with three bags of sugar, being pulled by Jugal Manjhi (P.W.3), Umesh Manjhi (P.W.4) and Dhobi Manjhi (P.W.5). The thella pullers allegedly disclosed that the sugar belonged to the appellant and was being taken to Silao bazar for sale. The appellant purportedly admitted ownership and that the sugar was being taken to market. The informant submitted a written report (Exhibit-3) and a formal first information report under Section 7 of the EC Act (Exhibit-6) was recorded.

After investigation and filing of a chargesheet, the appellant was tried. The prosecution examined eight witnesses; the defence examined one witness (Ajay Kumar, D.W.1). The trial court convicted the appellant under Section 7 EC Act for contravening Section 3 EC Act. The appellant appealed to the court delivering this opinion.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the evidence on record was sufficient to establish that the seized sugar bags belonged to the appellant.
  2. Whether the evidence proved that the bags seized on the three thellas were the same bags allotted to the appellant for his fair price shop.
  3. Whether the facts shown amounted to an attempt to sell the allotted sugar on the black market such as to constitute an offence under the EC Act, or whether they were mere preparation not constituting an offence.
  4. Whether the conviction could be sustained in view of inconsistencies and hostile witnesses in the prosecution case and other evidentiary deficiencies identified in the record.

Arguments of the Parties

Prosecution's Position

  • The prosecution relied principally on the informant Ramjee Singh's (P.W.7) report and evidence that three thellas bearing nine bags of sugar were observed and that persons at the scene identified the sugar as belonging to the appellant.
  • Prosecution produced formal documents: a production-cum-seizure list and ancillary documents (Exhibits 1, 4, 5 and 6) and relied on the supply inspector's (P.W.2) enquiry report (Exhibit-2) stating that nine bags were allotted to the appellant in September 1986 and were found at Silao Police Station.
  • The prosecution treated the appellant's admissions in his Section 313 CrPC examination as acknowledging receipt of nine bags and the fact of possession or carriage of sugar toward the market.

Appellant's (Defence) Position

  • Defence called Ajay Kumar (D.W.1), a member of Silao notified area who said distribution from the appellant's fair price shop occurred in September 1986 in his presence and that eight quintals sixteen kilograms and two hundred forty grams represented the total stock for September after accounting for prior balance.
  • D.W.1 produced and identified entries in the stock/distribution register (Exhibits A/2, B) and stated distribution occurred between 14.9.1986 and 22.9.1986, leaving a small balance (30.50 Kgs.) at the end of distribution.
  • At trial the appellant, in his Section 313 CrPC answers, admitted being the licensee and receiving nine bags in September 1986 for distribution but denied carrying those bags to Silao bazar for sale on the black market and denied that those bags were seized by police.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Nalkiat Singh v. State of Punjab, AIR 1970 Supreme Court 713 Holds that mere preparation for an offence under the EC Act (i.e., preparatory acts) does not constitute the offence; attempt requires more than mere preparation. The court relied on this authority to conclude that even if the bags found on the thellas were the appellant's and were being carried to market, that circumstance at best showed preparation and not a punishable attempt under the EC Act; therefore conviction could not rest on such a finding alone.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The appellate court examined the entirety of the evidence and identified several infirmities in the prosecution's case:

  1. Evaluation of witness testimony:
    • Many of the prosecution witnesses named as thella pullers (P.W.3, P.W.4, P.W.5) and other witnesses on the production-cum-seizure list (e.g., P.W.1, P.W.6) were declared hostile and denied the prosecution case. Some testified that signatures were obtained on blank papers at the dictation of the Officer-in-charge.
    • The informant (P.W.7) testified that the thellas were coming from Karah bazar and that the thella pullers disclosed the sugar belonged to the appellant; he also said the appellant admitted the sugar was his and was being taken to market. However, the informant's written report asserted that the appellant said he was taking the sugar to Silao market "for sale on black market" — a detail the court found missing from the informant's oral testimony.
  2. Gaps in proof of seizure and ownership:
    • The court observed there was no evidence on record establishing from where the nine bags of sugar were seized by police.
    • The appellate court emphasized that there was no direct evidence proving the seized bags belonged to the appellant, or that the bags on the three thellas were the same bags allotted to the appellant for his fair price shop.
  3. Reliability and scope of official enquiry evidence:
    • The Supply Inspector (P.W.2) prepared an enquiry report indicating nine bags were allotted to the appellant, but he admitted that his jurisdiction was for rural Rajgir and that the place of occurrence fell within the notified area under a different Supply Inspector. He further admitted he did not examine any consumers and did not visit the appellant's shop to verify stock.
    • The court noted these limitations in the Supply Inspector's investigation and the absence of corroborative enquiry by the appropriate official or by consumers.
  4. Consideration of defence evidence:
    • Ajay Kumar (D.W.1) testified that distribution from the appellant's fair price shop had taken place in September 1986 in his presence and that the stock register entries supported distribution and a small closing balance. The lower court had regarded the stock register as a document prepared at the instance of the appellant; the appellate court took this defence evidence into account when assessing whether there was any allegation or proof that the allotted sugar had not been distributed.
  5. Legal principle on attempt vs. preparation:
    • Applying the Supreme Court authority in Nalkiat Singh, the appellate court held that even if it were assumed (for argument's sake) that the bags belonged to the appellant and were being carried to Silao market, the facts would at most show preparation and not a punishable attempt under the EC Act.
  6. Cumulative conclusion:
    • Given hostile witnesses, absence of direct proof of seizure provenance, deficiencies in the investigating officer's enquiry, credible defence testimony about distribution, and the legal principle distinguishing preparation from attempt, the court concluded the conviction could not be sustained on multiple independent grounds.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The appellate court set aside the conviction and sentence of the trial court and acquitted the appellant. The appellant was discharged from the liability of his bail bonds.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The appellant's conviction and sentence were quashed and he was acquitted; bail bonds were discharged.
  • On the law: The court applied existing Supreme Court authority distinguishing mere preparation from a punishable attempt under the EC Act to the facts; the opinion does not purport to create new precedent beyond applying that established principle.

This summary is prepared exclusively from the provided opinion. No information beyond the text of the opinion has been added or inferred.

Show all summary ...

M.L Visa, J.:— This appeal is directed against the judgment and order dated 3.6.1992 passed by Special Judge, Essential Commodities Act, Nalanda at Biharsharif in Silao Police Station Case No. 188 of 1986 convicting and sentencing the appellant to undergo rigorous imprisonment for five years under Section 7 of Essential Commodities Act (for short “EC Act”).

2. Brief facts of the case are that on 24.9.1986 at about 7 A.M when informant Ramjee Singh (P.W 7), the then constable of Silao Police Station was going from police station to Silao choraha for taking tea, he saw three thellas, each loaded with three bags of sugar carried by Jugal Manjhi (P.W 3), Umesh Manjhi (P.W 4) and Dhobi Manjhi (P.W 5), all thella pullers. When informant enquired from all thella pullers about sugar bags, they disclosed that sugar bags belonged to appellant which were being taken to a shop in Silao bazar for sale. In the meantime, appellant also reached there and admitted that sugar bags belonged to him and he was carrying the bag to Silao bazar for sale and he further disclosed that he was going to sell the sugar in Silao bazar on black market. The informant then brought the sugar bags and appellant at police station and submitted his written report (Exhibit-3) on the basis of which formal first information report under Section 7 of EC Act (Exhibit-6) was drawn against the appellant and after investigation, chargesheet against the appellant was submitted and cognizance of the case was taken and the appellant was put on trial and after conclusion of trial, he was found guilty under Section 7 of EC Act for contravening the provisions of Section 3 of EC Act and was convicted and sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for five years.

3. In order to prove its case, prosecution examined eight witnesses, Nagendra Sharma (P.W 8) is the formal witness who has proved seizure-cum-production list in the handwriting and signature of Vidyapati Singh, the then Officer-in-charge of Silao Police Station which is marked Exhibit-4. He has further proved carbon copy of a letter, addressed by Vidyapati Singh to Marketing Officer, Rajgir (Exhibit-5) and formal first information report (Exhibit-6). Baikunth Singh (P.W 1) is said to be witness of production-cum-seizure list and although he has proved his signature (Exhibit-1) on production-cum-seizure list but has clearly stated that in his presence informant had not produced bags of sugar said to be loaded on three thellas and Officer-in-charge of police station had obtained his signature on a blank paper. He has been declared hostile by the prosecution. Jugal Manjhi (P.W 3), Umesh Manjhi (P.W 4) and Dhobi Manjhi (P.W 5) are said to be thella pullers on which sugar bags were found by informant being carried. They have not supported the case of prosecution and have denied that they were carrying thellas loaded with sugar bags and they have been declared hostile by the prosecution. Tapesar Singh (P.W 6) is another witness on production-cum-seizure list and he has also not supported the case of prosecution and has been declared hostile by the prosecution and when his attention was drawn towards his signature although he proved his signature (Exhibit-1/1) on production-cum-seizure list but has stated that at the dictate of Officer-in-charge, he had put his signature on a blank paper. Ramjee Singh (P.W 7) is the informant and he, in his evidence, has said that on 24.9.1986 in the morning, he was going to take tea at Silao choraha and when he came out of the police station, he saw three thellas each loaded with three bags of sugar coming from Karah bazar and Jugal Manjhi (P.W 3), Umesh Manjhi (P.W 4) and Dhobi Manjhi (P.W 5) who were thella pullers disclosed that the sugar belonged to appellant who was a fair, price dealer and they further said that they were carrying sugar bags to Silao bazar and in the meantime, Officer-in-charge came there and on being asked, appellant disclosed to Officer-in-charge that the sugar bags belonged to him and he was carrying the sugar to market and thereafter, all the sugar bags loaded on thellas and appellant were brought to police station where he submitted his written report (Exhibit-3) and he also put his signature (Exhibit-1/2) on production-cum-seizure list. Narendra Tiwary (P.W 2) is the Supply Inspector and he said that on 24.9.1986 when he was in his office, he received a letter (Marked X for identification) of Officer-in-charge through a police constable addressed to Marketing Officer and on the basis of that letter, the Marketing Officer ordered him to go to Silao bazar alongwith constable to make enquiry and after enquiry, he submitted his enquiry report. He has proved his enquiry report which is marked Exhibit-2. He has said that appellant was a dealer and nine bags of sugar in the month of September, 1986 were given to him for distributing among consumers. He has further said that, he found nine bags of sugar at Silao Police Station. In cross-examination, he has admitted that at Rajgir, there were two Supply Inspectors, one for notified area, Rajgir and another for rural area and he was Incharge of rural area whereas place of occurrence of the case falls within notified area which is not under his jurisdiction and Raghunandan Prasad was Supply Inspector of notified area. He has further admitted that distribution of sugar by a dealer among consumers is made in presence of Ward Commissioner and after recommendation of Ward Commissioner, further allotment is made in favour of dealer and when recommendation of Ward Commissioner is approved by Supply Inspector, further allotment is made by Marketing Officer. He has proved the writing and recommendation of Raghunandan Prasad, Supply Inspector of notified area recommending the allotment for the month of September, 1986 in the stock register of appellant. This writing and signature is marked Exhibit-A. He has also proved the writing and signature of Marketing Officer (Exhibit-A/1) below the aforesaid recommendation and has said that Marketing Officer had recommended for allotment of eight bags of sugar. In para-7 of his evidence, he has said that during investigation, he did not examine any consumer and he had not gone to the shop of appellant to verify the stock.

4. On behalf of appellant, Ajay Kumar (D.W 1) has been examined who has said that he is a member of Silao notified area and he represents Karah bazar and in his village, there are three shops under Public Distribution System and one belongs to appellant and sugar, oil etc. are distributed among consumers in his presence and in the month of September, 1986, sugar was distributed from the shop of appellant in his presence and in that month, eight quintals of sugar was allotted to appellant and because in the month of August, 1986, 16.240 Kgs. of sugar had remained in balance, therefore, in the month of September, total stock of sugar was eight quintals sixteen kilograms and two hundred forty grams. He has proved his signature (Exhibit-A/2) on the stock register and has said that in the month of September, distribution started from 14.9.1986 and continued till 22.9.1986 and after distribution, 30.50 Kgs. of sugar remained in balance and he then recommended allotment for next month by writing on distribution register. He has proved his writing and signature which is marked Exhibit-B.

5. The enquiry report (Exhibit-2) of Narendra Tiwary (P.W 2) simply states that appellant is a dealer of a fair price shop within Silao notified area and for the month of September, 1986, nine bags of sugar was allotted to him for distribution among consumers and bringing those nine bags of sugar in Silao bazar from Karah village was illegal.

6. In this case, there is only evidence of informant Ramjee Singh (P.W 7) and of Narendra Tiwary (P.W 2), Supply Inspector. Admittedly, informant Ramjee Singh (P.W 7) at the time of occurrence was a police constable and his evidence is that three thellas, each loaded with three bags of sugar were coming from Karah bazar and the thella pullers told him that the bags of sugar belonged to appellant and that appellant also reached there and on being asked by Officer-in-charge, he admitted that sugar belonged to him and he was carrying the same to market. In his written report, he has stated that the appellant told him that he was taking the sugar bags to Silao market for saie on black market. This statement is absent in his evidence where he has simply stated that the appellant told Officer-in-charge that the sugar belonged to him and he was taking the sugar to market. The Court below in its judgment has observed that the appellant has accepted the fact that he was carrying sugar to Silao bazar for selling for calendestine purposes that is on black market and this fact was stated before the informant. As stated above, the evidence of informant does not show that appellant made any such statement. In this case, three persons who have been alleged as thella pullers carrying sugar have not supported the case of prosecution that they were carrying sugar bags. There is no evidence on record to show from where nine bags of sugar were seized by police. The Court below in its judgment has stated that the appellant in his examination under Section 313 of Criminal Procedure Code admitted that he is a licensee of a fair price shop bearing licence No. 528 of 1980 of Ward No. 5 of village-Karah. He has further admitted that he received nine bags of sugar in the month of September, 1986 for distribution among consumers but he denied that he was carrying those nine bags of sugar from his fair price shop to Silao bazar for its sale on black market. He has further denied that those nine bags of sugar were seized by police. The Court below has observed that the appellant has not given any explanation about the nine bags of sugar which were received in the month of September, 1986 for his fair price shop but the court below has failed to observe that Ajay Kumar (P.W 1), in his evidence, has stated that sugar supplied in the month of September, 1986 for the fair price shop of appellant was distributed among consumers in his presence. The Court below has held this evidence not convincing by observing that the stock register is the new one and it has been prepared at the instance of the appellant. Although there is no evidence that nine bags of sugar which were allotted to appellant for his fair price shop were being carried on three thellas to Silao market as alleged by informant but for the sake of argument if it be assumed that those bags belonged to appellant and were found being carried on three thellas even then it cannot be held that appellant made any attempt for selling the sugar on black marketing because it will amount only a preparation which is not an offence under any of the provisions of EC Act as held by Apex Court in its judgment in the case of Nalkiat Singh v. State of Punjab (AIR 1970 Supreme Court 713). Notwithstanding this fact, in the present case, there is no allegation even against the appellant that sugar which was allotted to him in the month of September, 1986 for distribution among consumers was not distributed. In absence of any such allegation by any consumer or any competent authority, no offence is made out against the appellant. The conviction of appellant in this case by Court below cannot be sustained on a number of grounds. The first ground is that there is no evidence on record that the nine bags of sugar seized in this case belonged to appellant. Another ground is that the evidence on record does not show that the nine bags of sugar seized in this case on three thellas were the same bags which were allotted to appellant for his fair price shop. By mere finding of nine bags of sugar loaded on three thellas, it cannot be said that there was any attempt to sell those bags on black market.

7. I, therefore, find and hold the appellant not guilty. The judgment and order of Court below convicting and sentencing the appellant is hereby set aside and the appellant is acquitted. As the appellant is on bail, he is also discharged from the liability of his bail bonds.