Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Farzana Sabaff v. State Of Bihar & Ors.

Patna High Court
Mar 31, 2014
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner obtained a caste/certificate dated 17.10.2001 from the Block Development Officer, Raniganj, declaring her to belong to the "Shekhara" caste described as an extremely backward caste (per Resolution No. 756). She contested the 2006 Mukhiya election in Gram Panchayat Bagheli reserved for an extremely backward woman and her nomination was accepted on the basis of that caste certificate; she was declared elected. Respondent No. 6 objected at the time of nomination but the Returning Officer/District Magistrate did not accept the objection. Respondent No. 6 later approached the State Election Commission (SEC), which declined to interfere after completion of the election process, advising the remedy was an election petition. Respondent No. 6 then challenged in C.W.J.C No. 9299 of 2006; a Single Judge set aside the earlier conclusion and directed the SEC to decide the matter on merits within two months, observing that the qualification/disqualification issue could be decided by the Election Commission.

Pursuant to the Single Judge's direction, the SEC directed the Collector, Araria, to verify the petitioner’s caste certificate and there were concurrent appeals (L.P.A. No. 1015/2007 by SEC and L.P.A. No. 584/2008 by the petitioner). The District Magistrate instituted Misc. Case No. 25 of 2007-2008 for verification. The Collector issued a final order dated 12.02.2008 (Annexure 1) cancelling the caste certificate as based on incorrect facts. On the basis of the Collector's order, the SEC passed a final order (Annexure 20) disqualifying the petitioner from the Mukhiya post and treating the post as vacant. The petitioner filed the present writ petition challenging the Collector's order (and sought amendment to challenge the SEC's order).

Subsequently, a Division Bench allowed both appellate proceedings (L.P.A. Nos. 1015/2007 and 584/2008), set aside the Single Judge's order, dismissed C.W.J.C No. 9299/2006, and set aside the SEC order that had been rendered in compliance with the Single Judge. After that decision, the petitioner did not press the amendment application (I.A. No. 2364/2008) as the SEC order had been set aside by the Division Bench.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Collector's order (Annexure 1) cancelling the petitioner's caste certificate is invalid because it was part of a proceeding initiated by the State Election Commission that was a forum non juris (i.e., without jurisdiction) under Section 135 of the Bihar Panchayati Raj Act, 2006?
  2. Whether the Collector's verification/scrutiny of the caste certificate violated the directions of the Supreme Court in Kumari Madhuri Patil and related authority (Dayaram v. Sudhir Batham), which prescribe the procedure and constitution of a scrutiny committee for social status certificates?
  3. Whether, in view of the above, the appropriate course is to quash the Collector's order and refer the certificate for reconsideration to the scrutiny committee constituted by the State in compliance with the Supreme Court directions?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The proceeding before the State Election Commission (and actions taken pursuant to it) was without jurisdiction in view of Section 135 of the Bihar Panchayati Raj Act, 2006; therefore, the SEC's final order was rendered by a forum non juris and that invalidates the Collector's order which was part of the same proceeding.
  • The Collector's verification contravened the Supreme Court's directions in Kumari Madhuri Patil which prescribe a specific procedure and a constituted scrutiny committee for verification of caste certificates (the petitioner relied on the 15 directions issued by the Apex Court).
  • Reliance on Dayaram v. Sudhir Batham to show that the Kumari Madhuri Patil scheme remains operative until replaced by legislation and that the proper forum for verification is the scrutiny committee; therefore, the Collector lacked jurisdiction.
  • The petitioner asserted she belongs to "Shekhara" caste and that the Collector misunderstood the community (confusing "Shekhara" with "Sheikh"); copies of other family certificates (including her uncle's) were placed on record to support her claim.
  • Relying on Sudhakar Vithal Kumbhare, the petitioner suggested that, given the tenure has expired and she is not in service, the immediate need for scrutiny is limited and the respondents could be given liberty to approach the scrutiny committee if they wish; alternatively, interim protection could be considered as in that precedent.

Respondents' Position (as reflected in affidavits)

  • Counter affidavits were filed by respondent Nos. 2, 3 and 4 defending the Collector's impugned order.
  • The Principal Secretary, General Administration Department (Government of Bihar) stated by counter affidavit that in compliance with the Supreme Court directions the State Government had constituted a Directorate/Committee for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes via memo no. 3887 dated 08.11.2007; however, there was a lacuna whether that committee could verify Backward Classes/EBC certificates.
  • A supplementary counter affidavit appended a resolution dated 05.02.2014 (Annexure A) stating that a separate committee has now been formed for inquiry with respect to caste certificates of Backward Classes and Extremely Backward Classes, and directed immediate publication of that decision in the official Gazette.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kumari Madhuri Patil v. Additional Commissioner, Tribal Development ((1994) 6 SCC 241) Supreme Court issued 15 directions for verification/scrutiny of social status/caste certificates (SC/ST and Backward Classes), including constitution of a committee and specifying competent authorities for grant/verification of certificates (e.g., applications to and certificates by Revenue Sub-Divisional Officer / Deputy Collector / Deputy Commissioner rather than lower-level officers). The Court held that the Collector's verification was in violation of these directions and that verification should be carried out by the constituted scrutiny committee following those directions. The Court required the newly formed committee to follow the Kumari Madhuri Patil directions when deciding the petitioner's certificate.
Dayaram v. Sudhir Batham ((2012) 1 SCC 333) Three-Judge Bench considered whether the directions in Kumari Madhuri Patil were legislative; held that the scheme laid down in Kumari Madhuri Patil would continue until replaced by suitable legislation and that it operates as a stop-gap mechanism for urgent verification of certificates. The Court relied on Dayaram to reinforce that the Kumari Madhuri Patil scheme remains operative and, therefore, scrutiny by a properly constituted committee (as per those directions) is the correct route; the Collector lacked jurisdiction to conduct the scrutiny contrary to those decisions.
Sudhakar Vithal Kumbhare v. State of Maharashtra ((2004) 9 SCC 481) The precedent involved setting aside an order of the High Court and ordering reinstatement on a promoted post until the matter was referred by the employer to a scrutiny committee; it illustrates interim relief and referral to scrutiny committee for verification. The petitioner cited this case to argue for limited relief (given tenure had expired) and for the approach of referring matters to the scrutiny committee while allowing interim continuation. The Court considered the precedent but ultimately directed referral to the scrutiny committee rather than accepting the petitioner's suggestion to forbear scrutiny on grounds of tenure expiry.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the rival contentions and reached a conclusion based on two independent legal grounds arising from the record:

  1. First, the Court found that the Collector's order (Annexure 1) was part of the same proceeding initiated by the State Election Commission pursuant to the Single Judge's direction (Annexure 3). The Division Bench subsequently held that the Single Judge's direction and the SEC proceedings were without jurisdiction (forum non juris) because disqualification under Section 135 of the Bihar Panchayati Raj Act, 2006 could not be gone into by the SEC. Since the Collector's inquiry was initiated at the behest of the SEC as part of that proceeding, the Court concluded the Collector's order was vitiated by being part of a forum non juris and therefore liable to be quashed.
  2. Second, the Court analysed the procedure required by the Apex Court in Kumari Madhuri Patil and subsequent consideration in Dayaram. The petitioner’s caste certificate had been granted by the Block Development Officer, which the Court noted contravenes the first direction in Kumari Madhuri Patil that applications should be made to and certificates should be issued by Revenue Sub-Divisional Officer / Deputy Collector / Deputy Commissioner rather than lower-level officers. The Court held that even if the State's scrutiny committee was not in place at the time, the absence or inaction of the State government does not confer jurisdiction on the Collector to conduct scrutiny in complete violation of the Supreme Court's directions. Consequently, the Collector's exercise was legally improper on this second ground as well.

Having quashed the Collector's order on both grounds, the Court then considered the appropriate remedial course. It evaluated the petitioner's submission that, because her tenure had expired and she was not in service, there was no present need for scrutiny and respondents could be given liberty to approach the committee. The Court observed precedents (e.g., Sudhakar Vithal Kumbhare) but concluded the better course was to refer the matter to the newly constituted scrutiny committee for Backward Classes (Annexure A) to remove the cloud permanently.

The Court specified the manner of scrutiny: the committee must follow Kumari Madhuri Patil directions, issue notice, provide opportunity to parties, consider all relevant documents and submissions, and take a final decision within three months from receipt/production of a copy of the order. The committee may proceed on the record if parties do not cooperate. The committee must examine facts and reach its own conclusion regarding the petitioner's claim of belonging to an extremely backward caste and should not reject the claim solely because the original certificate appears to have been issued by an incompetent authority.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is allowed and the impugned order contained in Annexure 1 is quashed and set aside.

Implications and immediate consequences:

  • The Collector's order dated 12.02.2008 (Annexure 1) cancelling the petitioner's caste certificate is nullified on the grounds that it formed part of a proceeding initiated by a forum non juris and that the Collector's verification violated Supreme Court directions in Kumari Madhuri Patil (and related authority).
  • The newly constituted scrutiny committee for Backward Classes (notification in Annexure A) is directed to examine, verify and scrutinize the petitioner's caste certificate in accordance with the directions in Kumari Madhuri Patil and Dayaram, giving notice and reasonable opportunity to the petitioner and respondents and deciding the matter within three months from the date the committee receives or is provided a copy of this order.
  • If parties fail to cooperate, the committee may decide the issue on available materials; the committee must examine the factual claim that the petitioner belongs to the extremely backward "Shekhara" caste and should not reject the claim merely because the original certificate appears to have been issued by an authority the Court observed was not competent.
  • The decision orders remedial process (referral to a constitutionally/compositionally correct scrutiny committee) rather than creating a new legal precedent; it follows and applies existing Supreme Court authorities (Kumari Madhuri Patil and Dayaram) and manages the specific dispute between the parties.
Show all summary ...

1. I have heard the parties and have perused the records of this case.

2. The factual matrix emanating out of the pleadings of the parties which would be necessary for consideration of the case stands enumerated as under:—

3. The petitioner was granted a certificate dated 17.10.2001, as contained in Annexure 2, by the Block Development Officer, Raniganj, declaring her to be belonging to “Shekhara” caste which has been described as extremely backward caste in the resolution no. 756 dated, issued by the Personnel and Administrate Reforms Department, Government of Bihar, Patna. The petitioner, thereafter, contested the election of Mukhiya of Gram Panchayat Baghaily in the year 2006 which was reserved for extremely backward woman candidate. Her nomination was accepted on the basis of her caste certificate as contained in Annexure 2 treating her to be a woman belonging to extremely backward caste. The respondent no. 6 raised objection regarding that at the time of nomination, but it was not accepted by the Returning Officer-cum-District Magistrate, Supaul. She was declared elected as Mukhiya of Gram Panchayat, Bagheli. The respondent no. 6, thereafter, made a challenge to her candidature on the basis of the aforesaid caste certificate before the State Election Commission but the same was rejected on the ground that, after completion of election process and declaration of the result, the only remedy available to the respondent no. 6 was to file election petition before the Election Tribunal. Aforesaid order was challenged by the respondent no. 6 before this Court in C.W.J.C No. 9299 of 2006 which was set aside by a learned Single Judge of this Court vide order dated 05.09.2007 contained in Annexure 3 and the State Election Commission was directed to issue notice to the parties and decide the matter on its merit within a period of two months. While passing such order the Single Bench of this Court had noticed the dispute regarding the grant of certificate showing her to be a member of extremely backward caste candidate and held that the matter relating to qualification or disqualification could be decided by the Election Commission. The State Election Commission, thereafter, vide its order dated 27.11.2007, directed the Collector, Araria to verify the correctness of the caste certificate granted to the petitioner and at the same time it had also preferred L.P.A No. 1015 of 2007 challenging the aforesaid order passed by the Single Bench of this Court in C.W.J.C No. 9299 of 2006. Subsequently, another L.P.A No. 584 of 2008 also came to be preferred by this petitioner before a Division Bench of this Court. In the meantime, the District Magistrate concerned instituted Miscellaneous Case No. 25 of 2007-2008 upon the direction of the Bihar State Election Commission for verification of the correctness of the caste certificate granted to the petitioner. A final order dated 12.02.2008, as contained in Annexure 1, was passed by the Collector, Araria holding that the concerned caste certificate granted to the petitioner was based on incorrect facts and, accordingly, that was cancelled. The petitioner preferred the present writ application against the aforesaid order. Subsequently, on the basis of the order passed by the Collector contained in Annexure 1, the State Election Commission also appears to have passed the final order a copy of which has been appended as Annexure 20. Upon consideration of the order of cancellation of the caste certificate by the Collector the petitioner was disqualified from holding the post of Mukhiya treating the concerned post of Mukhiya to be vacant and to be filled up in accordance with the law and procedure. The petitioner filed I.A No. 2364 of 2008 for amendment in the prayer portion of the writ petition as he wished to challenge the aforesaid order of the State Election Commission also which was based on the impugned order contained in Annexure 1.

4. However, in the meantime a Division Bench of this Court heard L.P.A No. 1015 of 2007 (preferred by the State Election Commission) as well as L.P.A No. 584 of 2008 (preferred by the petitioner). Both the appeals were disposed of by a common judgment. The appeals were allowed and the judgment and order under appeals was set aside. The writ petition, i.e, C.W.J.C No. 9299 of 2006 was dismissed and at the same time, the order of the State Election Commission rendered in compliance of the direction contained in the aforesaid judgment and order under appeal (Annexure 20 to I.A No. 2364 of 2008) was also set aside.

5. In the aforesaid background of the facts, the petitioner did not press I.A No. 2364 of 2008 as the concerned order of the State Election Commission was already set aside by the Division Bench of this Court as discussed above.

6. Learned counsel for the petitioner has raised a question that, in view of the entire proceeding of the State Election Commission for passing an order after verification of the caste certificate of the petitioner on the basis of the direction of a Single Bench of this Court contained in Annexure 3 having been held to be without jurisdiction, and, thereafter, the final decision taken on the basis of the order of the Collector, which was also at the behest of the State Election Commission, having already been set aside on the ground that the proceeding before the Election Commission was without jurisdiction as disqualification mentioned in Section 135 of the Bihar Panchayati Raj Act, 2006 could not have been gone into by the State Election Commission, thus, the final order passed by the State Election Commission for disqualification of the petitioner was a decision, rendered by a forum non juris, would also invalidate the order passed by the Collector which was also part of the same proceeding as admittedly the State Election Commission had asked the Collector to verify the caste certificate of the petitioner for the aforesaid purpose and, ultimately, it was his decision that had formed the basis of the final order that was set aside by the Division Bench. It is contended that order of the Collector would also be without jurisdiction and, thus, the same also requires to be quashed and set aside.

7. It is next contended that the impugned order passed by the Collector is also in violation of the direction of the Apex Court in Kumari Madhuri Patil v. Additional Commissioner, Tribal Development [(1994) 6 SCC 241]. It is submitted that the Hon'ble Supreme Court has issued 15 directions for verification/scrutiny of a caste certificate granted either to the Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribe or Backward Classes. The Apex Court directed all the State Governments to constitute a committee for such verification/scrutiny and has also specifically named the particular authorities which would be the members of the committee. It is contended that the impugned verification by the Collector which is admittedly and apparently against the direction of the Apex Court, would have to be held to be without jurisdiction.

8. Mr. Sanjay Kumar, learned counsel for the petitioner, placed reliance upon another decision of the Apex Court in Dayaram v. Sudhir Batham [(2012) 1 SCC 333] to demonstrate that the aioresaid decision of the Two Judges Bench of the Supreme Court was again considered by Three Judges Bench on the issue as to whether certain direction given by the Apex Court in Kumari Madhuri Patil (supra) is legislative in nature? An issue was raised that in case a Court feels that some law should be made then it can only make a recommendation to that effect to the legislature but it cannot itself legislate. However, Three Judges Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court after due consideration has opined that the scheme laid down in Kumari Madhuri Patil (supra) would continue till it is replaced by a suitable legislation since such scheme was only as a stop gap arrangement specially framed in view of urgent need requiring scrutiny of the certificates with utmost expedition and promptitude. The Apex Court, While passing such guideline, had observed that the genuine candidates were being denied admission to the educational institutions or appointments for want of social status certificates and ineligible or spurious candidates have gained entry by presenting false certificates.

9. Thus, it is contended that only option available either for the State Election Commission or for the respondent no. 6, was to approach the scrutiny committee constituted by the State Government in compliance of the direction in Kumari Madhuri Pali (supra).

10. Counter affidavits have been filed on behalf of the respondent nos. 2 and 3 and also the respondent no. 4 defending the impugned order passed by the Collector. On the issue of constitution of scrutiny committee, raised by the petitioner during earlier hearings, a counter affidavit was also filed on behalf of the Principal Secretary, General Administration Department, Government of Bihar stating that the State Government in compliance of the direction of the Apex Court contained in Civil Appeal No. 5854 of 1994 (Kumari Madhuri Patil v. Additional Commissioner, Scheduled Tribes), has already constituted a Directorate/Committee dealing with the cases of Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes vide memo no. 3887 dated 08.11.2007 However, on a question being asked to learned Additional Advocate General No. 11 as to whether a Committee of Directorate formed for concerned purpose for scrutiny of the certificate with respect to the Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribes would be able to verify the certificate granted to the Backward Classes or Extremely Backward Classes, an apparent lacunae appeared and adjournment was sought for rectification specially in view of the direction no. 4 given by the Apex Court in Kumari Madhuri Patil (supra) that for scrutiny of Backward Classes certificate the committee would have to be constituted consisting an Additional or Joint Secretary or any officer higher in rank of the Director of the department concerned, the Director, Social Welfare/Tribal (sic) Welfare/Backward Class Welfare, has not been included in the committee. Thereafter, a supplementary counter affidavit has been filed on behalf of the Principal Secretary, General Administration Department, Government of Bihar appending therewith another resolution dated 05.02.2014 as Annexure A with a statement that now a separate committee has been formed for making inquiry with respect to caste certificates granted to the Backward Classes and Extremely Backward Classes. There is a direction in Annexure A for immediate publication of this decision of the Government in the official Extra-Ordinary Gazette.

11. Upon consideration of the rival contentions, I find force in the submission made on behalf of the petitioner. The order contained in Annexure 1 passed by the Collector would be invalid on both counts. The first ground would be that it was part of a proceeding by which the State Election Commission was making scrutiny of the caste certificate granted in favour of the petitioner in compliance of a direction given by the Single Bench vide Annexure 3. The aforesaid proceeding having been found by the Division Bench to be without jurisdiction as being pursued by a forum non juris, in my considered opinion, that would definitely include the proceeding before the Collector that was initiated on the basis of direction of the State Election Commission. The order impugned would have to be quashed and set aside for another reason also as the same is in violation of the direction of the Apex Court contained in Kumari Madhuri Patil (supra) as well as Dayaram (supra). It has been submitted on behalf of the petitioner that if the Election Commission wanted verification/scrutiny of the caste certificate, it could have referred the matter to the scrutiny committee concerned. However, the scrutiny committee was also not available at that point of time but, in my considered opinion, the inaction on the part of the State Government or its authority would not confer any jurisdiction upon the Collector for scrutiny of the caste certificate in complete violation of the direction of the Hon'ble Supreme Court rendered in Kumari Madhuri Patil (supra).

12. In above view of the matter, the impugned order as contained in Annexure 1 is quashed and set aside.

13. However, now the question is as to whether this Court should stop here or it should direct the newly formed scrutiny committee to consider to verify scrutinize the caste certificate of the petitioner?

14. The petitioner has taken a plea that she belongs to “Shekhara” caste and such certificate was not only granted to her but also to her own uncle, copies of which have been appended as Annexures 13 series to the writ petition. It has been contended that the Collector, under complete misconception, has held that the petitioner appears to be “Sheikh” and not to “Shekhara” community. It has been urged that though the title “Sheikh” stands it is mentioned in the Survey Records in column of caste the word “Muslim” has been recorded which is obviously a community and not a caste, thus, the impugned order appears to have passed under gross misconception. Learned counsel submitted that in identical situation the Apex Court in Sudhakar Vithal Kumbhare v. State of Maharashtra [(2004) 9 SCC 481] had set aside the judgment and order of the concerned High Court and had further ordered for reinstatement of the petitioner on the promoted post of Assistant Engineer till the matter is referred by the Maharashtra Electricity Board to scrutiny committee, however, the petitioner was allowed to continue on the post till the matter is decided by such committee. Thus, it has been contended that the order impugned should be quashed and set aside only since the petitioner's tenure of Mukhiya has already expired also, since the petitioner is not in any service, there would be no requirement for scrutiny/verification by the scrutiny committee at this juncture. Thus, a liberty should be granted to the respondents to approach the committee if they want to challenge the certificate of the petitioner.

15. Prima facie, the aforesaid submission appears to be attractive but upon deeper scrutiny it appears that the caste certificate has been granted to the petitioner by the Block Development Officer which is also in violation of the direction of the Apex Court as contained in Kumari Madhuri Patil (supra). The first direction given by the Apex Court in Kumari Madhuri Patil (supra) is reproduced as under:—

“(1) The application for grant of social status certificate shall be made to the Revenue Sub-Divisional Officer and Deputy Collector or Deputy Commissioner and the certificate shallbe issued by such officer rather than at the officer, taluk or mandal level.”

16. It is apparent that an application for grant of social status certificate shall be made to the Revenue Sub-Divisional Officer and Deputy Collector or the Deputy Commissioner whereas the petitioner's certificate has admittedly been granted by the Block Development Officer which cannot be held to be granted by Revenue Sub-Divisional Officer and Deputy Collector or the Deputy Commissioner and as such, it appears that such certificate was also granted in violation of the direction of the Apex Court in Kumari Madhuri Patil (supra). Otherwise also, it would be better that the matter should be scrutinized by the newly constituted committee to remove the doubt of cloud permanently. As a result, this writ application is allowed and impugned order as contained in Annexure 1 is quashed and set aside.

17. However, the newly formed scrutiny committee for Backward Classes, constituted vide notification contained in Annexure A. to the Supplementary counter affidavit, should examine and verify/scrutinize the caste certificate granted to the petitioner. While doing so, the committee concerned would follow the direction given in Kumari Madhuri Patil (supra) and grant opportunity to the petitioner as well as the respondents and would consider all the relevant documents and, thereafter, would consider all the submissions made by the petitioner and the respondents and take a final decision within a period of three months from the date of receipt/production of a copy of this order. The committee would be required to issue notice to the party/parties concerned and grant reasonable opportunity to all concerned before taking such decision. However, it is made clear that if the parties including the petitioner do not co-operate then the committee would be at liberty to take a decision in the matter on its own merit and in accordance with law after consideration of all the materials available on the record. It is further made clear that the committee would be required to examine the fact and come to its own conclusion regarding the claim of the petitioner of belonging to extremely backward caste. Petitioner's claim should not be rejected merely on the ground that the caste certificate granted to her does not appear to have been issued in her favour by a competent authority as has been observed by this Court.