- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Patna Municipal Corporation v. Workmen Of Patna Municipal Corporation And Others
Untwalia, J.:— The Patna Municipal Corporation has obtained a rule from this Court under Arts. 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India against the respondents to show cause why the award dated the December 10, 1968 of the Industrial Tribunal, Bihar, (respondent No. 3), a copy of which award is annexure 3 to the writ application, be not quashed by grant of a writ of certiorari and the said respondent be not directed to decide the reference in accordance with law by grant of a writ of mandamus. Cause has been shown on behalf of both the respondents who are different labour unions of the employees of the Patna Municipal Corporation.
2. The relevant facts which are necessary to be stated for the disposal of this case can be put in a narrow compass. The Patna Municipal Corporation was formed and came into existence on and from August 15, 1952. It is not necessary to state the entire past history of the disputes between the Corporation and its employees. In the year 1960, disputes were referred in Reference Case No. 10 of 1960 to the Industrial Tribunal for adjudication. An award was made on April 30, 1962, which was exhibit 3.a in the present proceeding. Under this award, benefits were given to certain categories of Corporation employees with effect from April 1, 1962. All categories of employees were not benefited under the said award. In accordance with the recommendations of the second Bihar Pay Revision Committee, 1961, as adopted by them in their resolution dated March 10, 1965, different scales of pay and dearness allowance were given to many categories of employees from April 1, 1965 but not to all. Some remained ou??? of this due to one reason or the other. Disputes were raised in the year 1964 also which led to Reference Case No. 6 of 1964. During the pendency of this Reference case, parties agreed to refer their disputes to the arbitration of then Minister, Local Self Government of the Government of Bihar. The Minister gave hrs award on August 16, 1965. This award was incorporated as an award of the Tribunal, in Reference case No. 6 of 1964 on September 29, 1965. It was implemented. While implementing the award, it is agreed on all hands that the pay structure either as fixed by the award in Reference case No. 10 of 1960 or given under the replacement scale was not disturbed. Only the dearness allowance was increased. The present disputes which gave rise to Reference case No. 19 of 1968 were the following:—
“1. Whether there should be increase in the dearness allowance of the workmen and whether the dearness allowance should be linked with the cost of living index? If so, what should be the quantum of increase and since when?
2. Whether the wages structure of the workmen should be revised? If so what should be the wage structure and since when?
3. Whether the existing medical facilities available to the workmen are satisfactory? If not, what more improvement should be made in it?
4. Whether the existing rates of daily wages of the different categories of the daily rated workmen are adequate? If not, what should be the rates of open wages and since when?
5. Whether interpretation that the workmen are entitled to the additional dearness allowance of Rs. 10/- per month as sanctioned by the State Government from April 1, 1967 over and above the inetrim relief of Rs. 10/- per month allowed to the workmen by the Corporation with effect from February, 1967, is correct?”
3. The Tribunal has considered items 1, 2 and 5 of the disputes together and has given its award which has been challenged by the Corporation in this writ case. Item 3 of the disputes has been decided against the employees. Item 4 has been partially decided in their favour but at the time of the argument of this case, nothing of substance was said to attack the decision of the Tribunal in that regard.
4. The Tribunal, while considering the disputes under items 1, 2 and 5, has taken into consideration the financial capacity of the Corporation, rise in the price index in different years, wages which are given to the employees of the Patna Water Board and in other concerns or undertakings. It has thereafter quantified a portion of the dearness allowance with the basic structure of wages, refixed the dearness allowance at different rates for different periods and has made the award effective in case of all the employees from April 1, 1964. The Corporation challenges this award on the following grounds as urged on its behalf by the learned Advocate General:—
(i) The Tribunal has not discussed and answered the first part of question No. 2 as to whether the wages structure of the workmen should be revised or not. It has committed an error in assuming that it had to be revised.
(ii) Several errors have been committed in the discussion of the matter of financial capacity of the Corporation inasmuch as the evidence of M.W 4 has been misread, so also the budget of the Corporation: has not been correctly read and appreciated and many other irrelevant matters have been taken into consideration on the question of the financial capacity of the Corporation.
(iii) The pay scales which have been fixed are in excess of the recommendations of the Pay Revision Committee.
(iv) The Tribunal has committed a serious error of law in making its award effective from April 1, 1964, whereas it ought to have been made effective from January 13, 1966.
5. I do not find any substance in the first contention of the petitioner. In the award, the Tribunal has given reasons for arriving at the conclusion as to why there was a necessity of revising the pay structure. From the very fact that a revised pay structure has been fixed, which I shall show here-in-after is not excessive or highly disproportionate to the pay structure prevalent in the Patna Water Board or in any other concern or undertaking, referred to in the award of the Tribunal, it would be clear that the revision of the pay structure was essential and that seems to be the reason that the Tribunal has said in its award that this aspect was not seriously disputed on behalf of the Management.
6. It is no doubt true that while considering the financial capacity of the Corporation some errors have been committed by the Tribunal. The mere fact that the Government was not giving a share of the taxes to the Corporation could not be a relevant factor to be taken into account for judging the financial capacity of the Corporation because it was not within the power of the Corporation to force the Government to part with a portion of the tax collected by them. While considering the evidence of M.W 4 it has not been referred from the figures in the budget as to what items were capital expenditure and what items were revenue expenditure. Most of the expenditure of the Corporation, strictly speaking, were and would come under the category of revenue expenditure. Again, the mere fact that the Corporation was able to give replacement scale of pay to certain categories of employees would not lead to the conclusion of the soundness of the financial position of the Corporation. In spite of these infirmities in the discussion of the question, there are certain matters mentioned in the course of the discussion which were relevant for judging that issue. In my opinion, it was quite pertinent to take into account the inefficiency with which the affairs of the Corporation are managed. A lot of taxes are not collected and, especially, of the Government buildings. It may be, as has been said by the Tribunal, that the Corporation is not a profit earning concern but it looks after the civic amenities of the people of Patna and it cannot expect its employees to efficiently look after these amenities if they are not paid barely proper wages. It has to augment its income from whatever source that may be to run its administration. It is a matter of common experience that the affairs of the Corporation are very much mismanaged. Very many roads are not repaired nor other amenities which should be provided for by the Corporation are adequately provided. The argument on behalf of the Corporation was that only the Administrator, the Deputy Administrator or the Assistant Administrator cannot be responsible for the mismanagement of the affairs. The responsibility has to be divided amongst all categories of the employees and if that be so, submission was that the employees who are responsible for the mismanagement of the affairs of the Corporation, cannot ask for more wages. It is difficult to accept this argument in circle. One of the accepted principles in labour cases is that until the workmen are paid proper wages, their difficulty cannot increase. It may well be that even after payment of proper wages they do not work efficiently. But, for that the Corporation authorities or as a matter of that, the Government have to take suitable steps for making them work efficiently, for improving the financial position of the Corporation and for running its administration efficiently and properly. To deny barely proper wages to the employees of the Corporation on the ground of financial stringencies and lack of funds, it seems to me, will not be justified. It is just the other way round. The Corporation has got to tap its sources of income to augment it in order to enable it to meet the demands of workers which have been fairly and squarely adjudicated by the Tribunal.
7. I do not think that there is much substance in the third point urged on behalf of the petitioner as only a few items could be shown to us where the Tribunal has awarded more wages or dearness allowance taking the two together to some category of employees than recommended by the Pay Revision Committee.
8. The last point urged on behalf of the petitioner has got some substance and has to prevail partially. As it appears from the award, the stand taken before the Tribunal was that the revised wages structure should be made applicable from April 1, 1965. It was on this basis that almost all the employees were placed under the replacement scales from that date. The Corporation had written to the Government also to that effect on January 12, 1968, a copy of which letter was exhibit B before the Tribunal. The Tribunal, however, fixed the date of the effect of the award from April 1, 1964 on the ground that on behalf of the unions a request had been made to fix the new pay structure on the basis of the price index of 1963 and that in other public sectors of the State of Bihar, revision in the wage structure has been given effect to from April 1, 1964.
9. When the question of stay of the operation of the award was being mooted in this Court, an affidavit in reply was filed on behalf of the petitioner on September 6, 1969. In Paragraph 3 of this affidavit it was stated that the award of the Tribunal in Reference case No. 10, 1960, giving the revised pay scale was in effect from April 1, 1962 and it remained in effect until it was terminated by the notice given on behalf of the workmen on November 13, 1965, a copy of which notice was annexed as annexure 7 to the affidavit in reply. A counter-affidavit to this affidavit was filed on behalf of the Patna Corporation Employees' Union, respondent No. 1, wherein this fact was not denied. Learned Advocate General, therefore, submitted with reference to the provisions of Section 19(6) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, that the award in Reference Case No. 10 of 1960 remained binding on the parties until January 13, 1966 because the notice terminating the award was received by the Corporation, as admitted in the affidavit in reply referred to above, on November 13, 1965. In reply to this it was pointed out by Mr. Gurubachan Singh, learned Counsel for respondent No. 1 and Mr. Balbhadra Prasad Singh, learned Counsel for respondent No. 2, that the operation of the award was not extended beyond a period of one year by the State Government under sub-section (3) of Section 19 of the Industrial Disputes Act. The legal position on reading the two sub-sections aforesaid seems to be that the operation of the award is for a period of one year from the date on which the award becomes enforceable under Section 17-A and this period may be extended from time to time up to a maximum period of three years under the second proviso to sub-section (3) of Section 19. A party to the award cannot terminate it so long it remains operative either during the period of one year or during the extended period under sub-section (3) of Section 19. But it does not cease to be binding on the parties merely by the lapse of the period of its operation. Any party can get rid of it by service of two months' notice under sub-section (6) of Section 19 of the Industrial Disputes Act. In my opinion, therefore, the contention as put forward on behalf of the petitioner that the award ceased to be binding on the parties from January 13, 1966 is correct. But the difficulty in accepting the argument as presented is that the award, exhibit 3.a, did not cover the case of all employees. Many categories of employees, as was shown to us from the chart given on behalf of the petitioner, were left out of the operation of this award. Some categories of employees who had got benefit under this award were placed under the replacement scale and got some further benefits. Many categories of employees who had not got benefit of the 1962 award, exhibit 3.a, were also placed in the replacement scale and were extended the benefits thereunder. On a consideration of the material facts which were placed before us by lerned counsel for the parties, it appears that the Corporation had no objection in extending the benefit of the replacement scale to certain other categories of the employees also. But due to one reason or the other, they either did not come under that category or were not placed under it. Although the technical point raised on behalf of the petitioner that in case of those employees who got benefit in the 1962 award, exhibit 3.a, but were not placed in the replacement scale, benefit under the present impugned award could not be extended beyond January 13, 1966, is sound, the technicality on the facts and circumstances of the case, can justifiably be met by an equally cogent technicality that the point was not taken before the Tribunal and the letter dated November 13, 1965, on which reliance has been placed in this Court was not produced before the Tribunal and no argument seems to have been advanced before it on its basis. In my opinion, however, the award ought not to have been made effective from April 1, 1964, as has been done by the Tribunal. Many categories of the employees, whether they had got benefit under the 1962 award, exhibit 3.a, or not, were placed under the replacement scale from April 1, 1965. If the present award would have been made effective from that date, that would have placed all categories of employees on the same footing without any discrimination; and fixing of this date i.e April 1, 1965 for giving effect to the award would not have been unjust or improper in any manner to any kind of category. It was not necessary to follow the date, April 1, 1964, from which new pay structures might have been applied to the employees of other concerns or undertakings. It ought to have been remembered that some disputes were raised by the employees in the year 1964 on the basis of which Reference Case No. 6 of 1964 was started culminating in the award of the Tribunal on the basis of the arbitration award of the Minister of the Local Self Government of the Government of Bihar under which, as already stated, dearness allowance was increased. In my opinion, therefore, taking into consideration all the relevant factors which ought to have been considered by the Tribunal but have not been so done, I think the award requires a modification in regard to the date from which it will be given effect to. Since this part of the award is severable from the rest, there is no difficulty in modifying it in exercise of the powers of this Court under Art. 227 of the Constitution.
10. In the result, I allow the application in part, modifying the award of the Tribunal only to the extent indicated above and affirm it in other respects. In the circumstances, I shall make no order as to costs.
S.N.P Singh, J.:— I agree.
12. Application partly allowed.
Alert