Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Vijay Kumar Rastogi v. Uttar Pradesh State Roadways Transport Corporation .

Supreme Court Of India
Feb 9, 2018
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

On 26 January 2005, the appellant, Vijay Kumar Rastogi, and his father-in-law sustained serious injuries when their car was struck by bus No. UP-25-G-9132, owned by the respondent and driven rashly by one Alam Beg. The appellant suffered multiple fractures, hemorrhage, and 25% permanent disability (lower limb) and underwent extensive medical treatment.

The appellant filed a claim petition before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (MACT), Karkardooma, Delhi, on 27 January 2006 against the driver and the owner of the bus. On 4 April 2009, the Tribunal awarded him ₹5,59,584 with 7% interest under various heads and awarded a separate amount to his father-in-law.

Dissatisfied, the appellant and his father-in-law filed separate appeals, while the respondent filed two cross-appeals. By judgment dated 6 December 2016, the High Court of Delhi disposed of all four appeals, enhancing only the rate of interest from 7% to 9% and declining any increase in the compensation amount. The appellant’s review petition was dismissed on 18 January 2017. The present Supreme Court appeals challenge those High Court orders, seeking enhanced compensation.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court erred in affirming the Tribunal’s exclusion of the appellant’s income from commission and bank interest when computing loss of income and future loss of income.
  2. Whether the appellant was entitled to additional compensation of ₹80,000 for damage to his Maruti car.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The Tribunal incorrectly calculated his annual income at ₹44,511 by excluding ₹50,556 earned as commission and bank interest, despite these figures being disclosed in his Income-tax Return (ITR) for Assessment Year 2004-05.
  • The exclusion of such taxable earnings contravenes Supreme Court precedent mandating consideration of taxable income for compensation calculation.
  • The High Court compounded this error by acknowledging the higher taxable income (₹77,480) yet still upholding the Tribunal’s figure.
  • Sought compensation of ₹80,000 for total damage to his car, supported (according to him) by a Mechanical Inspection Report.

Respondent's Arguments

The opinion does not provide a detailed account of the respondent’s arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Indira Srivastava (2008) 2 SCC 763 “Income” for compensation includes all taxable earnings, not merely basic salary. Used to justify inclusion of commission and interest shown in the ITR when calculating loss of income.
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Jashuben (2008) 4 SCC 162 Reiterated that taxable emoluments and benefits must be considered in assessing compensation. Supported the principle that exclusion of commission/interest was erroneous.
Kavita v. Deepak (2012) 8 SCC 604 Affirmed that all components forming part of taxable income are relevant for “just compensation.” Strengthened the appellant’s claim to reckon full taxable income.
Sayed Sadiq v. Divisional Manager, United India Insurance Co. Ltd. (2014) 2 SCC 735 Guidelines for computing future loss of income, multiplier, and disability assessment. Applied to adopt a 40% enhancement and multiplier of 15 when recalculating future loss of income.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court identified a “manifest error” in the High Court’s reasoning: although the High Court acknowledged the appellant’s taxable income of ₹77,480 and tax paid of ₹4,496, it inexplicably affirmed the Tribunal’s lower income figure of ₹44,511. Relying on the precedents above, the Court held that taxable income—including commission and interest—must form the basis of compensation.

After deducting income tax, the Court fixed the net annual income at ₹72,984. Recomputing:

  • Loss of income for 11 months: (₹72,984 ÷ 12) × 11 = ₹66,902.
  • Future loss of income: 40% of ₹72,984 = ₹29,194; applying multiplier 15 → ₹4,37,910.

Comparing with the Tribunal’s earlier awards under these heads (₹40,802 and ₹1,78,044 respectively), the appellant was entitled to an enhancement of ₹2,85,966 in total. The Court declined the claim for ₹80,000 car damage because no supporting documents were produced, echoing the High Court’s finding.

Holding and Implications

Appeals ALLOWED IN PART. The appellant is awarded an additional ₹2,85,966 towards loss of income and future loss of income, with interest at 9% per annum from the date of the claim petition until realisation. The remainder of the Tribunal’s award, including refusal of car-damage compensation, stands affirmed. No costs were awarded.

Implications are confined to correcting the computation methodology in this case; the decision reiterates existing Supreme Court precedent that taxable income, inclusive of commission and interest, must be used when assessing “just compensation” under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, but does not announce a new legal rule.

Show all summary ...

A.M. Khanwilkar, J.:— The present appeals take exception to the judgment of the High Court of Delhi in MAC Appeal No. 393/2009 dated 6 December, 2016, whereby the High Court declined to enhance the compensation amount awarded to the appellant by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal and to the order dated 18 January, 2017 dismissing the Review Petition No. 20 of 2017.

2. The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (for short, “the Tribunal”) vide order dated 4 April, 2009, awarded compensation to the appellant and his father-in-law to the tune of Rs. 5,59,584/- and Rs. 4,53,131/-, respectively, against which four appeals were filed before the High Court, one each by the appellant and his father-in-law and two cross appeals by the respondent, all of which were disposed of by the impugned judgment. The appellant alone has assailed the impugned judgment and prays for grant of enhanced compensation amount.

3. As can be gleaned from the claim petition, the appellant and his father-in-law suffered serious injuries on 26 January, 2005, when their car was hit by bus no. UP-25-G-9132, owned by the respondent and being rashly and negligently driven by one Alam Beg. The extent of the injuries caused to the appellant included haemorrhage, multiple cuts, bruises and fractures all over the body and post traumatic optic neuropathy. The appellant was treated at several hospitals and operated upon but suffered disability of 25%. He then filed a claim petition in the Tribunal, Karkardooma, Delhi, against the driver of bus no. UP-25-G-9132, Alam Beg, and the respondent on 27 January, 2006.

4. Ultimately, the Tribunal, vide order dated 4 April, 2009, inter alia held that bus No. UP-25-G-9132 was rashly and negligently driven by the driver, Alam Beg, and accordingly, awarded the appellant with compensation of Rs. 5,59,584/- along with interest at 7% p.a. under the following heads:

“23. Keeping in view all the relevant factors, principles of law laid down in above mentioned cases and evidence on record, I am of the view that the petitioner is entitled for compensation as per following details:

1. Cost of medicines :Rs. 1,08,883.00 2. Cost of future treatment :Rs. 25,000.00 3. Loss of Income :Rs. 40,802.00 4. Loss of future income :Rs. 1,78,044.00 5. Loss of income for 15 days :Rs. 1,854.62 6. Loss of enjoyment of life & Limb etc. :Rs. 1,00,000.00 7. Pain and Sufferings :Rs. 50,000.00 8. Compensation for attendant :Rs. 20,000.00 9. Special Diet :Rs. 20,000.00 10. Conveyance :Rs. 15,000.00 Total :Rs. 5,59,583.62 or say :Rs. 5,59,584.00”

5. Be it noted that the Tribunal in paragraph 17 of its judgment has adverted to Ext. PW-6/F, which reveals the date of birth of the appellant as 7-11-1969 and on that basis, has recorded a finding that on the date of accident on 26 June, 2005, the appellant was 36 years of age. Further, the Tribunal in paragraph 16 of its judgment has taken note of the fact that the appellant on the date of accident was working as Medical Representative with M/s. Stadmed Private Ltd., and after the accident he could not perform his duty because he remained confined to bed.

6. The Tribunal, while recording that the appellant earned a sum of Rs. 50,556/- from ‘other sources’ namely bank interest and commission, over and above his salary, did not consider the said income on the ground that commission and interest could not be considered for computation of loss of income. The appellant had annexed his income tax returns for the year 2004-05 as proof that his taxable income was considerably higher than the amount considered by the Tribunal, as given hereunder:

“STATEMENT OF INCOME

NAME OF ASSESSEEVijay Kumar Rastogi

FATHER'S NAMESh. Nand Kishore Rastogi

DATE OF BIRTH7 Nov. 1969

ADDRESSOFFICEStadmed Private Limited 138-B, Moahammed Pur, New Delhi - 110066

RESIDENCEC-40, ZI, Dilshad Garden, Delhi - 110095

STATUS:Individual

RESIDENTIAL STATUS:Resident & Ordinarily Resident in India

PA NUMBER STATUS:AEYPR8620R

PREVIOUS YEAR ENDED ON:31 MARCH 2004

ASSESSMENT:2004-2005

COMPUTATION OF TAXABLE INCOME

Income From Salary Gross receipt from salary as per Salary certificate 66,766.50 Less: Standard deduction u/s 16(i) 22,225.50 44,511.00 Income from Business or Profession Income as per Income and Expenditure Account 99,805.00 Less: Income not covered under the said head Income from Salaries 66,766.50 Income from other sources (17,518.00) 50,556.50 Income from other sources Bank Interest 72.00 Commission 50,454.00 50,556.50 Gross Total income 77,549.50 Less: Exemption U/S 80L Bank interest 72.00 Gross Total income 77,477.50 Income Rounded off 77,480.00 Income Tax Due on Rs. 77480/- 4,496.00 Less: Deduction U/s 88 EPF contribution 6,491.00 LIP Paid 13,225.00 19,716.00 Amount allowed @ 20% 3,943.00 Tax Due 553.00 Tax Paid 553.00 Balance Payable/Receivable NIL

(VIJAY KUMAR RASTOGI)”

7. Aggrieved by the Tribunal's award, the appellant filed an appeal before the High Court, alleging that while passing the award, the Tribunal had erroneously calculated his income as Rs. 44,511/- per annum, disregarding his income from other sources and also reducing the actual income earned by the appellant by following the standard deduction method. In the impugned judgment, the High Court while recording that the appellant's taxable income was Rs. 77,480/- less tax paid of Rs. 4496/-, and while accepting that the accident had been caused by the rash driving of the bus driver, Alam Beg and that the appellant had in no way contributed to the causing of the accident, only enhanced the rate of interest on the compensation awarded from 7% to 9% as it felt that the rate of interest awarded was on the lower side but it did not enhance the compensation itself, on the ground that no case had been made out for enhancement. The appellant challenged the aforesaid judgment by way of a review petition, which was also dismissed.

8. The short point which arises for our consideration is: whether the High Court committed manifest error by not considering other sources of income of the appellant including compensation of Rs. 80,000/- on account of damage to the Maruti car of the appellant while upholding the compensation awarded by the Tribunal?

9. We have heard Ms. Rekha Rastogi, learned counsel for the appellant as also Ms. Garima Prashad, learned counsel for the respondent.

10. The principal issue that needs to be addressed in these appeals is about the denial of claim in reference to commission and interest amounts earned by the appellant during the relevant period, as disclosed in the Income Tax Return filed by the appellant. The appellant claimed income from other sources under two heads, namely, Bank Interest : Rs. 72/-; and Commission : Rs. 50,454/-. The Tribunal opined that commission and interest cannot be considered for computation of loss of income and confined the claim of the appellant only on the basis of his net annual salary income to Rs. 44,511/-. The Tribunal noted that the appellant did not file any document of his age, educational qualification or profession. The High Court, on the other hand, in paragraph 11 of the impugned judgment observed thus:

“11. Regarding the deduction of tax paid from the net income of injured - Vijay Kumar Rastogi is concerned, I find that the total income of injured - Vijay Kumar Rastogi as per the tax return (Ex.PW-6/F) is Rs. 77477.50 and after deduction of tax of Rs. 4,496/- the net income has been rightly taken into consideration by the learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal. The disability of 25% suffered by injured Vijay Kumar Rastogi has been rightly taken to be the functional disability while keeping in view that the injured - Vijay Kumar Rastogi was working as the Medical Representative. No case for enhancement of compensation while taking the gross income of injured - Vijay Kumar Rastogi is made out, as net income has to be taken into consideration while assessing the compensation in such cases. Regarding the application of multiplier of 15 is concerned, I do find that in case of injured Vijay Kumar Rastogi multiplier of 15 ought to have been adopted but by adoption of multiplier of 16, the difference in the compensation worked out is marginal and the same is set off by the fact that future prospects of injured Vijay Kumar Rastogi has not been taken into consideration and therefore, this Court is not inclined to interfere with the awarded compensation on this account.”

11. Strikingly, the High Court noted the taxable income disclosed in tax return of the appellant for the relevant period as Rs. 77,480/- (rounded off) and tax deduction of Rs. 4,496/-, yet proceeded to hold that the net income of the appellant has been rightly taken into consideration by the Tribunal. It is unfathomable that the High Court, despite having accepted the claim of the appellant founded on his tax return for the relevant period, disclosing the taxable income of the appellant as Rs. 77,480/- (rounded off) and deduction of tax of Rs. 4,496/-, could have affirmed the conclusion of the Tribunal that the net annual income of the appellant was Rs. 44,511/-. It ought to have reckoned the taxable income for computing the head towards loss of income. This, in our opinion, is the manifest error committed by the High Court. The appellant is justified in relying upon the decisions of this Court which have taken the view that loss of taxable earning should be reckoned for the purpose of determining just compensation as enunciated in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Indira Srivastava (2008) 2 SCC 763, which has been followed in Oriental Insurance Company Limited v. Jashuben (2008) 4 SCC 162, and Kavita v. Deepak (2012) 8 SCC 604 It has been held that the “income” should include those benefits, either in terms of money or otherwise, which are taken into consideration for the purpose of payment of income tax or professional tax, although some elements thereof may or may not be taxable due to the exemption conferred thereupon under the statute.

12. The computation of taxable income as disclosed by the appellant in his tax return for the assessment year 2004-2005 for the previous year ended on 31 March, 2004, unambiguously reinforces the claim of the appellant that his annual taxable income was Rs. 77,480/- (rounded off) and income tax due thereon was Rs. 4,496/-. After providing deduction of the income tax payable by the appellant, the amount towards the head ‘loss of income’ of the appellant would be Rs. 72,984/- and not Rs. 44,511/- as assumed by the Tribunal.

13. In other words, compensation under the head ‘loss of income for 11 months’ would be (Rs. 72,984 ÷ 12) × 11 = Rs. 66,902. Similarly, towards the head ‘loss of future income’ computed by the Tribunal on the basis of disability suffered by the appellant to the extent of 25% in relation to his lower limb and keeping in mind that the age of appellant was only 36 years on the date of the accident and the exposition in the case of Sayed Sadiq v. Divisional Manager United India Insurance Co. Ltd. (2014) 2 SCC 735 (paragraphs 10 and 11), the appellant would be entitled to 40% of Rs. 72,984 i.e. Rs. 29,194 (rounded off) × 15 (multiplier), which comes to Rs. 4,37,910. Thus, the appellant would be entitled to receive enhanced compensation [Rs. 66,902 - Rs. 40,802 = Rs. 26,100 (Rupees twenty six thousand one hundred) and Rs. 4,37,910 - Rs. 1,78,044 = Rs. 2,59,866 (Rupees two lakh fifty nine thousand eight hundred and sixty six)] under these two heads, instead of Rs. 40,802/- and Rs. 1,78,044/- awarded by the Tribunal. In other words, the compensation amount towards these two heads would stand enhanced by Rs. 2,85,966/- (Rupees two lakh eighty five thousand nine hundred and sixty six only) as indicated above, to which the appellant would be entitled along with interest at the rate of 9% (nine percent) per annum in terms of our decision.

14. The appellant has also claimed further compensation towards damage to his Maruti Car which, according to the appellant, was completely damaged, as mentioned in the Mechanical Inspection Report (Ext. PW-6/D) and the value of the car providing third party insurance (Ext.PW-6/E). On a careful scrutiny of the judgment of the Tribunal, we find that the Tribunal has not analysed this claim at all. That grievance was made by the appellant before the High Court, as noted in 13 paragraph 9 of the impugned judgment claiming compensation of Rs. 80,000/- towards the same. The High Court in paragraph 13 of the impugned judgment, however, rejected the claim on the finding that the appellant had failed to invite its attention to any document indicating that the appellant had incurred the expenses of Rs. 80,000/- towards car repair. Even in the present appeals, the appellant has failed to invite attention of this Court to any document on record in support of the said claim. Resultantly, we find no reason to interfere with the opinion expressed by the High Court on the issue under consideration.

15. A priori, the appellant would succeed in getting additional amount of Rs. 2,85,966/- (Rupees two lakh eighty five thousand nine hundred and sixty six only) as enhanced compensation towards ‘loss of income’ and ‘loss of future income’, along with interest at the rate of 9% (nine percent) per annum thereon from the date of filing of the claim petition before the Tribunal till the date of realization.

16. The appeals are allowed to that limited extent in the above terms with no order as to costs.