Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Iq City Foundation And Another v. Union Of India And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Feb 6, 2018
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners—IQ City Medical College, Burdwan—sought a writ of certiorari to quash the Central Government’s order dated 31-5-2017 passed under Section 10-A of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956, which had refused the College a 4th renewal of permission to admit its 5th batch of 150 MBBS students for the academic year 2017-2018.

A letter of permission for establishment had originally been issued on 15-7-2013, and successive annual renewals were granted for 2014-2015, 2015-2016 and 2016-2017. After a surprise inspection on 3-11-2016 and 4-11-2016, the Medical Council of India (MCI) recommended non-renewal, citing deficiencies. The Central Government’s Hearing Committee, however, considered the deficiencies remediable and sent the matter back to MCI for review.

MCI conducted a further inspection on 21-3-2017 and reiterated its recommendation of non-renewal. On 31-5-2017 the Ministry of Health & Family Welfare rejected the renewal. In an earlier judgment (1-8-2017, 2017 16 SCC 249) the Supreme Court found the 31-5-2017 order unreasoned, set it aside, and remanded the matter to the Central Government with directions to involve the newly-constituted Oversight Committee and furnish a reasoned decision within two weeks.

Pursuant to remand, a fresh hearing took place on 22-8-2017. The Hearing Committee, with an Oversight Committee member present, again found (i) 15.9% faculty deficiency and (ii) 25.88% resident-doctor deficiency—both beyond permissible limits—and therefore recommended refusal of renewal. The Ministry accepted this view and on 22-8-2017 reaffirmed its earlier decision. The present judgment reviews that second decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Central Government’s reiterated refusal, post-remand, to grant the 4th renewal for 2017-2018 was vitiated by perversity, non-application of mind, or violation of the Supreme Court’s earlier directions.
  2. Whether the Hearing Committee and the Ministry were obliged to ignore deficiencies not specifically earmarked for “compliance verification” after remand.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners’ Arguments

  • The deficiencies noted on 21-3-2017 were situational—many faculty and residents were away at medical camps or postgraduate counselling—and were within acceptable limits during the earlier November 2016 inspection.
  • Extensive documentation (salary slips, OPD statistics, photographs of medical camps, certificates from “Operation Smile” and ING-International Foundation) proved adequate staffing and functioning infrastructure, which the Hearing Committee failed to evaluate properly.
  • The Committee should have confined itself to verifying compliance with previously-identified deficiencies rather than conducting a broad re-assessment.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • MCI maintained that the March 2017 inspection revealed faculty and resident deficiencies far exceeding the 5% tolerance prescribed by the Regulations.
  • The Ministry contended that the remand did not fetter MCI from noting any deficiencies it discovered, and that the Hearing Committee’s findings were reasoned and compatible with MCI Guidelines.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Manohar Lal Sharma v. Medical Council of India (2013) 10 SCC 60 Interplay of Section 10-A, Rules and Regulations governing establishment and renewal of medical colleges. Cited to underline that MCI’s powers during inspections are broad and not confined to a narrow “limited remand.”
Medical Council of India v. Kalinga Institute of Medical Sciences (2016) 11 SCC 530 Standards of judicial review over MCI and Government decisions on medical colleges. Referred while discussing scope of court’s interference with administrative decisions.
Royal Medical Trust v. Union of India (2015) 10 SCC 19 Need for objective assessment and reasoned decision-making in medical education regulation. Used to emphasise that Central Government must assign reasons but that the concept of “limited remand” is inapplicable.
Amma Chandravati Educational & Charitable Trust v. Union of India (2017) 16 SCC 265 Constitution Bench order constituting a new Oversight Committee for medical education. Formed the basis for directing Central Government to involve the Oversight Committee at the remand stage.
IQ City Foundation v. Union of India (2017) 16 SCC 249 Earlier judgment in the same matter requiring a reasoned order on renewal and clarifying that compliance verification is not a restricted exercise. Provided the procedural framework and directions that led to the present, second round of decision-making.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reviewed the post-remand process and found:

  • The Hearing Committee, inclusive of an Oversight Committee member, re-examined the College’s documentation and still recorded 15.9% faculty shortage and 25.88% resident shortage—figures accepted by the College itself in prior correspondence.
  • Such shortages exceed the maximum 5% deviation allowed by MCI Guidelines; therefore, the recommendation to refuse renewal was rational.
  • The petitioners’ claim that the Committee should have confined itself to earlier deficiencies was untenable in light of paragraph 31 of the earlier Supreme Court judgment (2017 16 SCC 249), which had expressly rejected the notion of a “limited remand.”
  • The Ministry’s order dated 22-8-2017 reiterated its earlier stance with recorded reasons, thereby satisfying the requirement of a reasoned, “informed” decision mandated by the remand.
  • No perversity, arbitrariness or violation of natural justice was demonstrated; consequently, judicial interference was unwarranted.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF: The Supreme Court upheld the Central Government’s refusal to grant the 4th renewal for the academic year 2017-2018. However, it directed that:

  • The College’s application for the 2018-2019 academic year be considered afresh.
  • The existing bank guarantee shall be treated as the requisite deposit for the forthcoming inspection.

The ruling has immediate effect only on the parties; it sets no new legal precedent beyond reinforcing the principles already articulated in the Court’s earlier judgment.

Show all summary ...

Dipak Misra, C.J.— The present writ petition, as the circumstances would have it, witnesses a second verdict. The first one was disposed of by us on 1-8-2017 (2017) 16 SCC 249. At that time, we had noted the facts to the effect that the petitioners had prayed for issue of a writ of certiorari for quashment of the order dated 31-5-2017 passed under Section 10-A of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 (for brevity “the Act”) by the Secretary, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, the first respondent herein, and further issue a direction to the said respondent to grant permission to the petitioner College for 4th renewal for the academic year 2017-2018 to facilitate admission of the 5th batch (150 students) for MBBS course.

2. The essential facts which have been noted in the earlier judgment are that the Medical Council of India (MCI) had conducted an inspection and granted the letter of permission (LoP) on 15-7-2013 for the establishment of the new medical college at Burdwan, West Bengal with an annual intake of 150 students with effect from the academic year 2013-2014. Vide letters dated 4-7-2014, 10-6-2015 and 15-12-2015, renewals of permission for the 2nd (1st renewal), 3rd (2nd renewal) and 4th (3rd renewal) batches of MBBS students at the petitioner College for the academic years 2014-2015, 2015-2016 and 2016-2017 respectively were granted by Respondent 1. On 6-7-2016, the petitioner College submitted its scheme along with the requisite fees for the 4th renewal for the academic year 2017-2018 which pertains to admission of the 5th batch of 150 students in MBBS course. On 9-7-2016, the 2nd respondent informed the College that the assessment for renewal of permission for the academic year 2017-2018 would be undertaken by the assessors appointed by it at any time after 15-7-2016 and the petitioners were asked to fill in the Standard Inspection Form A, Form B and Declaration Form for the academic year 2017-2018 and keep them ready for scrutiny at the time of assessment. There was also a direction for submission of the soft copies of the said forms. As averred, the petitioners duly submitted a compact disc containing soft copies of Form A, Form B and Declaration Form and upon receipt of the necessary documents, the 2nd respondent constituted a team of assessors and directed them to carry out the assessment inspection of the College.

3. The inspection team, that is, the assessors, conducted a surprise inspection of the College on 3-11-2016 and 4-11-2016. The assessors pointed out certain deficiencies to the College and noted the same in the assessment report dated 4-11-2016. It is put forth that in the Regular Inspection Report, the shortfall in teaching faculty and resident doctors were only 4.5% and 3.50% respectively which were well within the prescribed limit. Two other deficiencies that were pointed out, as asserted, were completely remediable and were duly remedied by the College. On 22-12-2016, the Executive Committee of Respondent 2 considered the assessment report of the assessors and decided to recommend to Respondent 1 not to renew the permission to the College for the 4th renewal for the academic year 2017-2018. It was also noted that the 1st respondent, by its letter dated 3-2-2017, communicated to the College the recommendation dated 28-1-2017 of Respondent 2 for disapproving the permission to the College for the 4th renewal for the academic year 2017-2018 and called upon the College to submit a detailed point-wise compliance with documentary evidence. The College was further intimated about the hearing that was to be held on 9-2-2017 before the Hearing Committee.

4. A team of representatives of the College appeared before the Hearing Committee on the date fixed and submitted the compliance report keeping in view the remarks and observations made by the assessors of Respondent 2. In the second week of March, 2017, the petitioners received a copy of the order dated 1-3-2017 issued by the 1st respondent recording the recommendations/order passed by the Hearing Committee of Respondent 1 under Section 10-A(4) of the Act. The recommendation of the Hearing Committee was to the effect that the deficiencies pointed out by the 2nd respondent were not such to warrant disapproval at that stage. Despite the aforesaid findings of the Hearing Committee, the 1st respondent, instead of taking a final decision, referred the matter back to Respondent 2 to review the same in the light of the recommendations/findings of the Hearing Committee along with documents submitted by the petitioners and to furnish its recommendation.

5. On the earlier occasion, it was asserted that the 2nd respondent, on 17-3-2017, constituted a team to carry out a compliance verification assessment of the College. The team of assessors, instead of carrying out a compliance verification, conducted a regular inspection on 21-3-2017 in a random manner and proceeded to make a different kind of assessment instead of limiting to their scope of reviewing the compliance of the remarks/observations of the Hearing Committee. At this juncture, it was contended that though the Compliance Inspection Report was submitted, yet the assessors required the College to submit a representation and, accordingly, the College submitted the necessary representation to Respondent 2. The assessors, as per the stand of the petitioners, noted certain deficiencies in their Compliance Verification. The Executive Committee of Respondent 2 held its meeting on 28-4-2017 but the minutes of the meeting were not uploaded on the official website of Respondent 2 until 29-5-2017 and were not communicated to the petitioners.

6. On earlier occasion, it was submitted that the petitioner had approached the 1st respondent on 20-5-2017 and submitted a detailed representation with regard to compliance verification of the deficiencies found by the assessors as pointed by Respondent 2. Despite the same, the 1st respondent, vide order dated 31-5-2017, accepted the recommendation of the 2nd respondent and rejected the scheme of permission for the 4th renewal (admission of the 5th batch of 150 students in MBBS course) for the academic year 2017-2018. It was urged that the order dated 31-5-2017 was communicated to the College on 30-6-2017. That apart, it was highlighted that the entire approach of MCI was contradictory to the Act and the Establishment of Medical College Regulations, 1999 (for short “the Regulations”) and further when the Central Government had sent back the matter to MCI to have a relook at certain aspects, it could not have proceeded for a fresh compliance inspection.

7. The contentions raised by the petitioners were opposed by MCI. This Court, referring to the decisions in Manohar Lal Sharma v. Medical Council of India (2013) 10 SCC 60, Medical Council of India v. Kalinga Institute of Medical Sciences (2016) 11 SCC 530 and Royal Medical Trust v. Union of India (2015) 10 SCC 19 and thereafter referring to Section 10-A of the Act and the Regulations, opined thus: (IQ City Foundation case (2017) 16 SCC 249, SCC para 31)

“31. On a reading of Section 10-A of the Act, Rules and the Regulations, as has been referred to in Manohar Lal Sharma (2013) 10 SCC 60, and the view expressed in Royal Medical Trust (2015) 10 SCC 19, it would be inapposite to restrict the power of the MCI by laying down as an absolute principle that once the Central Government sends back the matter to MCI for compliance verification and the assessors visit the College they shall only verify the mentioned items and turn a Nelson's eye even if they perceive certain other deficiencies. It would be playing possum. The direction of the Central Government for compliance verification report should not be construed as a limited remand as is understood within the framework of Code of Civil Procedure or any other law. The distinction between the principles of open remand and limited remand, we are disposed to think, is not attracted. Be it clearly stated, the said principle also does not flow from the authority in Royal Medical Trust (2015) 10 SCC 19. In this context, the objectivity of the Hearing Committee and the role of the Central Government assume great significance. The real compliant institutions should not always be kept under the sword of Damocles. Stability can be brought by affirmative role played by the Central Government. And the stability and objectivity would be perceptible if reasons are ascribed while expressing a view and absence of reasons makes the decision sensitively susceptible.”

8. After so holding, the Court took note of the fact that the order passed by the Central Government is not a reasoned one and in that backdrop, this Court directed: (IQ City Foundation case (2017) 16 SCC 249, SCC para 32)

“32. … It is obligatory on its part to ascribe reasons. For the said purpose, we would like the Central Government to afford a further opportunity of hearing to the petitioners and also take the assistance of the newly constituted Oversight Committee as per the order dated 18-7-2017 passed by the Constitution Bench in Amma Chandravati Educational and Charitable Trust v. Union of India (2017) 16 SCC 265 and thereafter take a decision within two weeks. Needless to say, the decision shall contain reasons. We repeat at the cost of repetition that the decision must be an informed one.”

9. To appreciate the controversy, we may first record the letter dated 21-3-2017 before the order of remand. The said letter written by the petitioner to MCI reads thus:

“In connection with the above subject I would like to submit the following paragraphs for your kind consideration:
1. That during the last MCI inspection held on 3-11-2016 and 4-11-2016 our Faculty & Resident deficiency was 2.18 and 3.38 respectively. However, on 21-3-2017, surprise inspection and due to their personal commitment they could not come by 11 a.m. and could not appear before the assessors.
2. Secondly, the State NEET Postgraduate counselling and the Diplomate in National Board (DNB) counselling in process, many of the Senior and Junior Residents and few faculty members had gone to Kolkata for their counselling hence were not able to appear in the inspection conducted on 21-3-2017.
3. Thirdly, most of these faculties and residents are working with us since long time and kind of documentary proof for the same can be submitted, but because of the counselling they were unable to make it.
4. It will not be out of place to mention here that our faculties and residents had gone to attend medical camps in suburban areas as such they could not reach by 11 a.m. to appear before the assessors.
Hence their absence may kindly be considered to offset the faculty and resident deficiency.”

10. Another letter was issued on 10-4-2017. The relevant part of the said communication reads thus:

“(3) That for our 4th renewal inspection we were inspected on 3-11-2016 and 4-11-2016 and a subsequent compliance inspection was conducted on 21-3-2017.
(4) That on 21st March when the surprise compliance inspection was conducted, few of our faculty and residents were on deputation for attending our regular medical camps in the rural areas. In view of the inspection these faculties and residents were called back to the hospital and college but by the time they arrived the time for signing the attendance sheet was over i.e. 11 a.m. They were denied signing in the attendance sheet and were not considered during the head count which led to deficiency of faculty and residents—15.99% and 25.88% respectively, even though our deficiency was less than 5% for both categories in the inspection held on 3-11-2016 and 4-11-2016.
(5) That on 22-3-2017 we also sent one representation letter along with photograph of few of our medical camps which were going on vide Letter No. IQMC/2016-17/09 dated 21-3-2017. The photographs are once again enclosed.
(6) That we are an established running medical college and hospital with more than thousand employees working having all the requisite infrastructure, faculties and residents and clinical materials as per the council norms.”

And again:

“Hence, it is requested that our faculty & resident deficiency on the day of the inspection may kindly be considered sympathetically and permission may be accorded to us to admit the 5th batch of 150 students and continue our services in Medical Education & Health Care Services.”

11. As the facts would show, the petitioner Institution was afforded an opportunity of hearing by the Hearing Committee which, thereafter, recorded the following findings:

“1. On detailed examination of the documents, the deficiency of the faulty (sic faculty) is still persisting. Hence not acceptable.
2. The shortage of residents is 25.88% (maximum acceptable is 5%).
3. It has been recorded in the minutes of the MCI meeting that the assessor resorted to only random checking of OPDs in just three departments, namely, TB & Respiratory, ENT and Psychiatry Department and has arrived at a figure without counting the total number of patients registered in all the departments, which seems unreasonable and inaccurate.
4. Student hostel: The college authorities are producing the Chartered Architect Certificate on completion and occupancy of the hostel (to be verified).
5. The Anatomy Department had the requisite number of mounted/unmounted specimens on the date of inspection and is being treated as complied with.
Conclusion: The deficiency of faculty found by assessor was 15.9% and was accepted by the College. The reasons provided by the College for this deficiency are not compatible with MCI Guidelines of acceptable leave. Also the deficiency of residents was 25.88%. Therefore, renewal is not recommended.”

12. The Central Government, considering the remarks of the Hearing Committee, passed an order which is to the following effect:

“10. Now, therefore, in compliance with the above direction (2017) 16 SCC 249 of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the Ministry granted hearing to the College on 22-8-2017. A member of the newly constituted Oversight Committee also attended the Hearing Committee meeting. The Hearing Committee submitted its report to the Ministry with the following conclusion:
The deficiency of faculty by assessor was 15.9% and was accepted by the College. The reasons provided by the College for this deficiency are not compatible with MCI Guidelines of acceptable leave. Also the deficiency was 25.88%. Therefore, renewal is not recommended.
A copy of the Hearing Committee Report containing their observations is enclosed.
11. Accepting the recommendations of the Hearing Committee, the Ministry reiterates its earlier decision dated 31-5-2017 not to renew the permission to admit MBBS students at IQ City Medical College, Burdwan for the academic year 2017-2018.”

13. Thus, it is demonstrable that the competent authority of the Central Government, considering various aspects, had reiterated the order.

14. We have heard Mr Mukul Rohatgi and Mr P.S. Patwalia, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners, and Mr Ajit Kumar Sinha, learned Senior Counsel for the 1st respondent, and Mr Vikas Singh, learned Senior Counsel along with Mr Gaurav Sharma, learned counsel for the 2nd respondent MCI.

15. We may note here with profit that after the remand, the petitioner Institution filed certain documents before the Hearing Committee on 22-8-2017. The petitioner Institution also filed salary slips of the teaching faculty and salary slips of Senior Resident Doctors and Junior Resident Doctors before the Hearing Committee. The said documents have also been brought on record. Para 14 of the letter dated 22-8-2017 by the petitioner Institution to the Secretary, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India reads as under:

“It needs to be mentioned that our Teaching Hospital has received accolades from a team of 7 International Doctors headed by Dr Partha Sadhu and Dr Klas Erik Kaspersson of “Smile” and “INGA-International Foundation” who are carrying out a major camp for corrective surgery of Cleft Lip/Cleft Palate in our Medical College & Hospital from 16-8-2017 to 24-8-2017 under the name and style called “operation smile”. A total of 87 corrective surgeries for cleft lip and cleft palate have already been performed as of date in our Hospital during the said period. The Operation Smile and INGA-International Foundation have till date conducted more than 100 such camps and performed more than 29,000 surgeries, pan India. The said “Smile” and “INGA-International Foundation” have issued a letter of appreciation to our College and Hospital stating that it is rare to find such outstanding “State-of-the-Art” medical and infrastructure facilities.”

16. That apart, the details of OPD patients between 15-3-2017 to 29-3-2017 have also been filed before the Hearing Committee as well as this Court. The grievance that has been vehemently agitated is that, had the Hearing Committee scrutinised the documents and appreciated the stand of the Institution in proper perspective, the opinion of the Hearing Committee would have been quite different and as a corollary, the view of the Central Government would have been guided in an affirmative way in favour of the Institution. The aforesaid submission, on a first blush, looks quite attractive but, on a keener scrutiny, pales into total insignificance. We are disposed to think so inasmuch as the Hearing Committee, on verification of every aspect, found that the deficiency of faculty members was 15.9 and the deficiency of resident doctors was 25.88 and, accordingly, it did not recommend for renewal. The Central Government, in its turn, observed that the deficiency found by MCI was not compatible with the MCI Guidelines. In such a situation, it is difficult to hold that there has been any perversity in the action of the authorities denying the renewal to the Institution. Though we have given the stamp of approval to the decision of the Central Government, yet we are inclined to direct that the prayer for renewal shall be considered for the year 2018-2019 and any bank guarantee that has been furnished shall be treated as deposit for the inspection and consideration for the next year, that is, 2018-2019. Be it clearly stated, our opinion is restricted to the non-granting of renewal for the year 2017-2018 and not an expression of opinion with regard to the consideration of the prayer for 2018-2019.

17. The writ petition is accordingly disposed of without any order as to costs.