- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Union Of India & Ors. Petitioners v. Haresh Virumal Milani
Factual and Procedural Background
The petition challenges an impugned order passed in Application Exh.43 in M.A. No. 946 of 2012. The Petitioners (represented by Dr. Sharma) contend the order was passed in gross violation of principles of natural justice because the Application under Section 30 r/w. Order XI, Rule 12 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) was not served on them, they were not given opportunity to file a reply or to be heard, and the Collector, Pune (to whom directions were issued) was not a party. The Respondent (represented by Mr. Ojha) says the Application was filed under Section 340 Cr.P.C., the learned trial Judge held Section 30 CPC inapplicable and proceeded to consider Section 340 and Section 311 Cr.P.C., and issued directions to the Collector, Pune to submit records relating to acquisition of Survey No. 233A of village Lohegaon, Taluka-Haveli (including award and notification/declaration). By order dated 17.02.2017 notice for final disposal was issued returnable on 16.03.2017 and, until the next date, the impugned orders were stayed. At the hearing before R.G. Ketkar, J., Dr. Sharma sought time to respond; the matter was stood over to 24.03.2017 and the earlier ad-interim relief was ordered to remain in force until then.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the impugned Order was passed in violation of principles of natural justice because the Application (Exh.43) was not served on the Petitioners and they were not heard.
- Whether the learned trial Judge properly applied Section 30 r/w. Order XI, Rule 12 CPC or, alternatively, whether the trial Judge correctly proceeded under Section 340 and Section 311 of the Cr.P.C.
- Whether the Petitioners have locus to maintain this Petition challenging the directions issued to the Collector, Pune.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments (Dr. Sharma)
- The impugned Order was passed in gross violation of natural justice because Application Exh.43 (M.A. No. 946 of 2012 under Section 30 r/w. Order XI, Rule 12 CPC) was not served on the Petitioners.
- The Petitioners were not given an opportunity to file a reply or to be heard before the learned trial Judge.
- The Order is contrary to Order XI, Rule 12 CPC.
- The Collector, Pune is not a party to the proceedings; the learned trial Judge was not justified in issuing directions to the Collector.
Respondent's Arguments (Mr. Ojha)
- The impugned Order (dated 11.01.2017) in Exh.43 in M.A. No. 946 of 2012 was filed under Section 340 Cr.P.C.; although styled under Section 30 r/w. Order XI, Rule 12 CPC, the learned trial Judge held Section 30 CPC not applicable (paragraph 8) and proceeded under Section 340 and Section 311 Cr.P.C.
- Relied on Pritish v. State of Maharashtra, (2002) 1 SCC 253 : AIR 2002 SC 236 to contend the Petitioners have no locus and are not required to be heard.
- The learned trial Judge issued directions to the Collector, Pune to submit records concerning acquisition of Survey No. 233A, village Lohegaon, Taluka-Haveli (including award and notification/declaration).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Pritish v. State of Maharashtra, (2002) 1 SCC 253 : AIR 2002 SC 236 | To contend that the Petitioners have no locus and are not required to be heard. | Relied upon by Respondent's counsel to argue lack of locus; the opinion records this reliance but does not record a final adjudication on that point. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court recorded the submissions of both counsel. It noted the factual posture that the Application was styled under Section 30 r/w. Order XI, Rule 12 CPC but that the learned trial Judge had held Section 30 CPC not applicable and had considered Sections 340 and 311 Cr.P.C. while issuing directions to the Collector. The court also recorded the Respondent's reliance on Pritish (Supra) regarding locus. Rather than deciding the merits, the court dealt with interlocutory relief and case management: it observed the parties' competing requests on continuation of ad-interim orders and the risk of rendering the petition infructuous if time were granted to the Petitioners, and accordingly granted the Petitioners' request for time while preserving the ad-interim relief until the next date.
Holding and Implications
The petition was stood over to 24.03.2017 and the ad‑interim relief previously granted was ordered to remain in force until that date.
Direct consequences: the matter remains pending; the earlier ad‑interim relief is preserved; notice for final disposal had been issued returnable 16.03.2017 and, by the earlier order of 17.02.2017, the impugned orders were stayed until the next date. The opinion does not announce any broader precedent or final determination on the merits.
R.G Ketkar, J.:— Heard Dr. Sharma, learned counsel for the Petitioners and Mr. Ojha, learned counsel for the Respondent.
2. In support of this Petition, Dr. Sharma submitted that the impugned Order is passed in gross violation of principles of natural justice. He submitted that the Application Exh.43 filed in M.A No. 946 of 2012 under Section 30 r/w. Order XI, Rule 12 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (For short “CPC”) was not even served on the Petitioners. They did not get opportunity to file a reply. They were also not heard by the learned trial Judge before passing the impugned Order. He submitted that the Order passed by the learned trial Judge is also in the teeth of the Order XI, Rule 12 of CPC. He submitted that the Collector, Pune is not a party to the proceedings. The learned trial Judge was, therefore, not justified in passing the impugned Order.
3. Mr. Ojha submitted that the learned trial Judge has passed the impugned Order on 11.01.2017 in an Application Exh.43 in M.A No. 946 of 2012 filed by the Respondent under Section 340 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (For short “Cr.P.C”). Though the Application is styled as one under Section 30 r/w. Order XI, Rule 12 of the CPC, the learned trial Judge has held in paragraph 8 that section 30 of cpc is not applicable. The learned trial Judge has, thereafter, proceeded to consider Section 340 and Section 311 of Cr.P.C while issuing directions.
4. Mr. Ojha relied upon decision of the Apex Court in the case of Pritish v. State of Maharashtra, (2002) 1 SCC 253 : AIR 2002 SC 236 to contend that the Petitioners have no locus to maintain this Petition. As held by the Apex Court in the case of Pritish (Supra), they are not required to be heard. In any case, by the impugned Order, the learned trial Judge has issued directions to the Collector, Pune to submit concerned record in respect of acquisition of Survey No. 233A of village Lohegaon, Taluka-Haveli including award, if any, made in respect of the said land and notification/declaration.
5. Dr. Sharma seeks time so as to respond to the submissions made by Mr. Ojha as also cite Judgments in support of his submissions. Mr. Ojha submitted that this Court will not continue the ad-interim Order. By Order dated 17.02.2017, notice for final disposal was issued to the Respondent, returnable on 16.03.2017 Till the next date, the impugned Orders were stayed. If the request of Mr. Ojha is acceded to, Petition will be rendered infructuous. At the request of Dr. Sharma, stand over to 24.03.2017. Till the next date, the ad-interim relief granted earlier shall remain in force.
Alert