Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. (S) v. Shanti Bopanna & Ors. (S)

Supreme Court Of India
Apr 18, 2017
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Venkata Subramanyam Bopana, aged about 49 years, was Vice-President of M/s Surya Pharmaceutical Ltd. On 30 March 2009 he died in a road accident while travelling as an occupant in a company-owned car driven by another person. His widow and adopted minor son filed a claim petition under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Samba. The deceased’s mother was not impleaded on the ground that she had executed a release deed (17 February 2010) relinquishing her rights in the estate.

The Tribunal assessed the annual income at ₹22,92,148, added 30 % for future prospects, deducted 30 % towards income tax and one-third towards personal expenses, applied a multiplier of 11 and awarded ₹1,68,09,089 for loss of dependency, besides ₹2,000 (funeral), ₹5,000 (loss of consortium) and ₹2,500 (loss of estate), together with 6 % interest.

The New India Assurance Company Ltd. challenged the award in CIMA No. 303/2012 before the High Court of Jammu & Kashmir, which dismissed the appeal on 08 March 2013. The insurer then approached the Supreme Court by way of Special Leave Petition (C) No. 23853/2013. Leave was granted and the present civil appeal was heard and decided on 18 April 2017.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a comprehensive (package) motor insurance policy obliges the insurer to indemnify the insured for the death of an employee travelling as a non-fare-paying occupant, notwithstanding the minimum requirements of Section 147(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
  2. Whether the Tribunal and High Court erred in adding 30 % towards future prospects when the deceased was alleged to be above 50 years of age.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sarla Verma v. DTC, (2009) 6 SCC 121 Thumb rule that future prospects are generally not added when the deceased is above 50 years of age; departure only in rare and exceptional cases. The insurer relied on the rule. The Court held the deceased was 49 years old; therefore, the prohibition did not apply and the 30 % addition for future prospects was sustained.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Liability under the Insurance Policy: The vehicle was covered by a comprehensive “package” policy. Clause (i) expressly indemnified the insured for “death of or bodily injury to any person including occupants carried in the vehicle (provided such occupants are not carried for hire or reward).” The Court held that this contractual provision fully covered the widow and adopted son’s claim. Section 147(1) limitations did not apply because the parties had agreed to a wider risk cover. Consequently, the deceased was treated as a third party vis-à-vis the insurer, and the insurer’s liability was affirmed.

Future Prospects: The insurer argued that, because the deceased was allegedly 51 years old, future prospects should not have been added in view of Sarla Verma. The Court noted that neither the Tribunal nor the High Court had recorded a categorical finding that the deceased was above 50; the Tribunal had treated his age as 49. Accepting that finding, the Supreme Court concluded that the 30 % addition was justified, particularly in light of the deceased’s imminent promotion from Vice-President to Managing Director.

Dispute regarding the Mother’s Share: The Court observed that there was insufficient material to resolve the dispute between the deceased’s mother and the claimants concerning entitlement to compensation. It relegated the mother (Respondent No. 5) to pursue “appropriate proceedings” for her alleged share.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED – Tribunal’s award and High Court judgment upheld.

As a direct consequence, the compensation (with interest) deposited before the Supreme Court is to be released to the widow and adopted son, subject to the Tribunal’s directions on fixed deposits. The mother may initiate separate proceedings to claim any share she believes due. The judgment reaffirms that comprehensive motor insurance policies can create liability beyond the statutory minimum, but does not establish a new legal precedent beyond the facts of this case.

Show all summary ...

1. Leave granted.

2. This is an appeal filed by New India Assurance Company Ltd. (for short, “the appellant-company) against the judgment and order of the High Court passed in CIMA No. 303 of 2012, dated 08.03.2013, upholding the award of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Samaba (for short, “the Tribunal”) granting compensation of Rs. 1,68,09,089/-, Rs. 2500/-, Rs. 2000/- and Rs. 5000/- under the head i) loss of dependency, ii) loss of Estate, iii) funeral expenses and loss of consortium respectively. The High Court further upheld the award of interest @ 6% and dismissed the appeal.

3. The deceased-Venkata Subramanyam Bopana was travelling in a car which belonged to his employer, the M/s. Surya Pharmaceutical Ltd. He held the post of Vice President and was due to be promoted as a Managing Director of the aforesaid company. The car was being driven by another person. An accident was occurred on 30.03.2009 in which the deceased died. At the relevant time, his age was about 51 years. A claim Petition was filed under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short, “the Act”) by the Widow and the minor son against the appellant-company and others. The respondents-herein omitted to implead the mother of the deceased as a respondent to the Claim Petition. According to them, though it is required by Section 166 of the Act that all the legal representatives be impleaded, they did not do so because the employee was not a legal representative, having relinquished all her rights in respect of Estate of the claimant-widow on 17.02.2010, i.e, after the accident and during the pendency of the Claim Petition.

4. We might add, at the outset, that the Release Deed is on record and we have heard learned counsel for respondent No. 5, the mother of the deceased and we find that there is no evidence and sufficient material to resolve the dispute between the mother and the deceased on the one hand and the claimants, i.e, widow and adopted child on the other. We, therefore, relegate this dispute to be decided by appropriate proceedings, which the mother may adopt, if so advised. 5. The Tribunal found that at the relevant time, the deceased was found to have an income of Rs. 22,92,148/- per annum as Vice President of the company. The Tribunal added 30% towards future prospects; it deducted 30% towards income tax and thus arrived at the actual salary of Rs. 22,92,148/-. The Tribunal also deducted 1/3 towards personal expenses of the deceased and arrived at the multiplicand of Rs. 15,28,099/- per annum. The Tribunal held the age of the deceased as 49 years. The multiplier applied was 11. The loss of dependency to the family was found to be Rs. 1,68,09,089/- As noted above, Rs. 2000/-, Rs. 5000/- and Rs. 2500/- were added on account of funeral expenses, loss of consortium and loss of Estate respectively.

THE INSURANCE POLICY

5. The vehicle belonged to M/s. Surya Pharmaceutical Ltd. and it was covered by package policy, also known as a comprehensive policy. This policy was clearly not an Act Policy under Section 147 of the Act. It is not in dispute that this policy was not Act policy under Section 147 of the Act. The relevant terms of the policy are as follows :

…Subject to the limits of liability as laid down in the schedule thereto, the company will indemnify the insured in the event of accident caused by or arising out of the use of the insured vehicles against all sums which the insured shall become legally liable to pay in respect :—

(i) death of or bodily injury to any person including occupants carried in the vehicle (provided such occupants are not carried for hire or reward) but except so far as it is necessary to meet the requirements of Motor Vehicle Act, the company shall not be liable where such death or injury arises out of and in the course of employment of such person by the insured.”

6. The clause of the policy reproduced above clearly covers the insured against all sums which the insurer may become liable to pay in respect of :

“(i) death of or bodily injury to any person including occupants carried in the vehicle (provided such occupants are not carried for hire or reward)….”

7. We thus find that the claim of the widow and the adopted son is fully covered by the clause in the insurance contract, i.e, the policy and there is no scope for acceding to the submission made on behalf of the appellant-company that the claim is excepted by virtue of the provisions of Section 147(1) of the Act in this case. We, therefore, reject the contention made on behalf of the appellant that the deceased was not a third party because he was an employee sitting in the car. It is obvious from the circumstances that the deceased was indeed a third party being neither the insurer not the insured.

8. The next contention raised on behalf of the appellant is that the future prospects have been unreasonably granted to the respondents. According to the appellant, the High Court noted that according to the appellant-company the deceased was 51 years but we find that no categorical finding was recorded that the deceased was 51 years of age. We, therefore, accept the finding of the Tribunal that the deceased was 49 years of age. It might therefore, not be necessary to consider the submission made by the appellant-company that because the deceased was above 50 years of age, the thumb rule laid down in the case of Sarla Verma v. DTC reported in (2009) 6 SCC 121 ought to have been followed. We find from the observations relied on in Sarla Verma's case (supra) that there is a thumb rule that future prospects may not be awarded in case the deceased is above 50 years of age. This Court has observed as follows :

“….A departure therefrom should be made only in rare and exceptional cases involving special circumstances.”

9. We find that the High Court has rightly observed as follows:

“the deceased was holding the post of a Vice President and was due to be promoted as Managing Director thereby his income would have raised to 5.00 lacs per month (sic). Thus 30% had to be added to his income for future prospects as rightly done by the Tribunal.”

10. There is, thus, no merit in this contention made on behalf of the appellant.

11. In the result, the appeal is liable to be dismissed and is dismissed accordingly.

12. However, It will be open to respondent No. 5, the mother of the deceased to take appropriate proceedings in respect of her alleged share in the compensation received by respondent Nos. 1 and 2.

13. The amount deposited in this Court shall be released to respondent Nos. 1 and 2. Respondent No. 1 shall abide by the directions of the Tribunal relating to fixed deposit to be made in favour of herself and her son (respondent No. 2).

SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS

Petition(s) for Special Leave to Appeal (C) No(s). 23853/2013

(Arising out of impugned final judgment and order dated 08/03/2013 in CIMA No. 303/2012 passed by the High Court Of J & K At Jammu)

New India Assurance Co. Ltd.….Petitioner(s)
v.
Shanti Bopanna & Ors.….Respondent(s)

(With interim relief and office report)

Date : 18/04/2017 This petition was called on for hearing today.

(Before S.A Bobde and L. Nageswara Rao, JJ.)

For Petitioner(s) Mr. Vishnu Mehra, Adv.

Ms. Manjeet Chawla, Adv.

For Respondent(s) Dr. Kylashnath Pillai, Sr. Adv.

Mr. G. Ananda Selvam, Adv.

Mr. Gopal Balwant Sathe, Adv.

Mr. Ram Sankar, Adv.

Mr. Gaurav Pachnanda, Sr. Adv.

Ms. Renu Gupta, Adv.

Mr. H. Maini, Adv.

Ms. Diksha Rai, Adv.

UPON hearing the counsel the Court made the following

14. Leave granted.

15. The appeal is dismissed in terms of the signed order.