Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

The Designated Authority & Ors. v. M/S. Sandisk International Limited & Ors. S

Supreme Court Of India
Feb 16, 2017
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeals challenged a judgment and order of the Delhi High Court which interfered with the Designated Authority’s final findings dated 19 December 2014 issued under Rule 17 of the Customs Tariff (Identification, Assessment and Collection of Anti-Dumping Duty on Dumped Articles And For Determination of Injury) Rules, 1995. One appeal was filed by the Designated Authority (arising out of SLP (C) No. 14099 of 2015) and another by the domestic industry (arising out of SLP (C) No. 14524 of 2015). During the pendency of the appeals, a final notification under Rule 18 was published on 22 May 2015 and remained operative, with duty collected on that basis.

The Court allowed applications for intervention, granted leave, and heard counsel for the parties. It also perused the disclosure statement dated 5 December 2014 (Rule 16), related correspondence dated 8, 9 and 12 December 2014, and the final findings dated 19 December 2014.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, in the facts of the case, the Delhi High Court was justified in exercising writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution to set aside the Designated Authority’s final findings dated 19 December 2014 issued under Rule 17.
  2. Whether the writ petitioner (respondent M/s Sandisk International Ltd.), subject to locus, should instead await the final notification under Rule 18 and pursue the statutory appellate remedy under Section 9C of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

On reviewing the disclosure statement, correspondence, and final findings, the Court found “seriously disputed questions” regarding (i) the locus of the respondent M/s Sandisk International Ltd. to maintain the writ petition and (ii) whether the information sought by it was actually furnished by the Designated Authority in the communications and orders.

While the Court declined to lay down an inflexible rule that final findings of the Designated Authority can never be challenged under Article 226, it held that, on these facts, the High Court was not justified in exercising writ jurisdiction to set aside the final findings. The Court reasoned that the High Court should have required the writ petitioner to await the final notification under Rule 18 and then challenge that notification before the appropriate appellate forum under Section 9C. In that event, the appellate authority would necessarily consider the final findings and would be better equipped to examine the challenge.

The Court also noted the subsequent publication of the final notification dated 22 May 2015 during the pendency of the appeals (without the Court’s leave). It declined to examine the legality or propriety of that publication on this ground because the respondent had not sought interference with the notification or a restraint on its operation, and no importer subject to the levy had intervened to challenge it.

Holding and Implications

ALLOWED; HIGH COURT ORDER SET ASIDE. The respondent (subject to its locus) and other aggrieved parties were left to pursue an appeal under Section 9C of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 challenging the final notification dated 22 May 2015, with a request that the Appellate Tribunal dispose of any such appeal expeditiously.

The direct effect is that the High Court’s interference with the Designated Authority’s final findings dated 19 December 2014 was undone, and challenges were channelled to the statutory appellate route against the Rule 18 notification. The Court expressly stated it expressed no opinion on the merits, leaving the Appellate Tribunal free to consider all aspects, including the correctness of the final findings, if properly challenged. No broader implications or new precedent were articulated beyond these directions.

Show all summary ...

1. Applications for intervention are allowed.

2. Leave granted.

3. We have heard the learned counsels for the parties at considerable length.

4. The challenge in these appeals is against the judgment and order of the Delhi High Court interfering with the final findings dated 19 December, 2014 issued by the Designated Authority under Rule 17 of the Customs Tariff (Identification, Assessment and Collection of Anti-Dumping Duty on Dumped Articles And For Determination of Injury) Rules, 1995 (hereafter referred to as “the Rules”).

5. Civil Appeal arising out of Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 14099 of 2015 has been filed by the Designated Authority whereas Civil Appeal arising out of Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 14524 of 2015 has been filed by the domestic industry.

6. We have perused the disclosure statement dated 5 December, 2014 issued by the Designated Authority under Rule 16 of the Rules and the correspondences that have been exchanged by and between the parties thereto dated 8 December, 2014, 9 December, 2014 and 12 December, 2014. We have also perused the exhaustive final findings dated 19 December, 2014 of the Designated Authority.

7. From a perusal of the aforesaid materials on record we find that there are seriously disputed questions with regard to the locus of the respondent - M/s Sandisk International Ltd. to file the writ petition before the Delhi High Court and also as to whether the information sought for by the said respondent was actually furnished to it by the Designated Authority in the above communications and orders. Though we would not deem it appropriate to lay down any inflexible proposition of law that in no case the final findings of the Designated Authority can be subject to challenge under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, we are of the view that in the facts of the present case the High Court was not justified in exercising its writ jurisdiction and in setting aside the final findings of the Designated Authority. Rather, according to us, the High Court should have asked the writ petitioner before it to await the issuance of the final notification under Rule 18 of the Rules and to challenge the same before the appropriate appellate forum under Section 9C of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 as and when such a notification is issued. In such an eventuality the final findings of the Designated Authority were bound to be considered by the appellate authority which authority would also have been better equipped to examine such a challenge.

8. In the present case, there is a further/additional development that has taken place during the pendency of the appeals. The final notification under Rule 18 of the Rules has been published on 22 May, 2015 and the same has been operative since then and duty has been collected on that basis. Though the said notification was published during the pendency of the present appeals without the leave of the Court we are not inclined to go into the legality or even the propriety of the said exercise on the said ground inasmuch as the respondent - M/s Sandisk International Ltd. itself, admittedly, has not approached this Court for interference with the said notification or for orders seeking a restraint on its operation. Neither has any importer, on whom the levy is imposed, come to the Court to seek intervention in the present proceedings to challenge the notification in question.

9. In the aforesaid circumstances, we are of the view that the respondent - M/s Sandisk International Ltd., subject to its locus, and all other aggrieved parties should be left with the option of challenging the final notification dated 22 May, 2015 before the appellate authority by means of an appeal under Section 9C of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975. If such an appeal is filed we would request the Appellate Tribunal to consider and dispose of the same as expeditiously as possible. The order of the High Court is set aside and the appeals consequently are allowed. We make it clear that we have expressed no opinion on the merits of the case and it is open for the Appellate Tribunal to consider all aspects of the matter, including the correctness of the final findings dated 19 December, 2014 issued by the Designated Authority, in the event of a challenge being made before it by an aggrieved party.