- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Madhukar Prabhakar K... v. State Of Maharashtra...
Court Opinion Summary
Factual and Procedural Background
The original petitioner (who later died during the proceedings) sought relief under Article 226 of the Constitution of India by way of a writ of mandamus to obtain a declaration that a reservation on his land had lapsed and to direct the State to notify the lapsing in the Official Gazette, together with consequential reliefs. The land in question is Survey No. 523, E-Ward, Kolhapur (admeasuring 1,543.5 sq. meters), purchased on 8 December 1953 by the petitioner and his brother. A portion (284 sq. meters) was acquired by South Central Railways in 1971 and appears in the property card in that name; the petitioner became sole owner after his brother bequeathed his share.
The land was shown as reserved for the Rehabilitation of Displaced Shop Keepers in the Final Development Plan (came into force in 1977) and again in the Revised Development Plan (came into force on 18 December 1999). No acquisition steps were taken within the statutory period following the Revised Plan. The petitioner served a notice under section 127 of the MRTP Act on 26 June 2012 (served 27 June 2012). Respondents requested title documents and the measurement map by letter dated 7 July 2012; the petitioner produced documents on 31 July 2012. Subsequent communications from the 2nd Respondent (letters dated 5 November 2012 and 26 December 2012) sought further documents; the petitioner responded (letter dated 12 November 2012 received 17 November 2012, and a later reply).
The petitioner applied under Sections 44, 45, 58 and 69 of the MRTP Act read with Section 253 of the Maharashtra Municipal Corporation Act, 1949 for development permission; that application was received on 15 February 2014 and was rejected by the 2nd Respondent by order dated 5 March 2014. The petitioner challenged the non-acknowledgement of the reservation lapse and the rejection of the development application in the writ petition.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the reservation on the petitioner's land reserved under the Development Plan has lapsed because no acquisition steps were taken within the statutory period following the Revised Development Plan (18 December 1999).
- Whether the notice under section 127 of the MRTP Act given on 26/27 June 2012 (and the subsequent filings) constituted a valid purchase notice despite initial objections about missing documents, specifically the Power of Attorney.
- Whether the legal heirs of the original petitioner, who died during the pendency of the petition, could maintain and benefit from the purchase notice and the writ petition.
- Whether the 2nd Respondent's rejection of the petitioner's application for development permission (order dated 5 March 2014) was sustainable in view of the alleged lapse of reservation.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The land was reserved in the Final and Revised Development Plans, but no steps were taken to acquire the land within the 10-year period after the Revised Development Plan (i.e., up to 18 December 2009); therefore the reservation lapsed by operation of law.
- The petitioner served a valid notice under section 127 of the MRTP Act on 26 June 2012 (received 27 June 2012); any initial objections about documents were complied with—photocopies of property card, sale deed and measurement map were produced on 31 July 2012.
- The objection that a Power of Attorney was not produced did not constitute a legal requirement that would invalidate the notice; any defect was cured by subsequent production of the Power of Attorney.
- After the death of the original petitioner, his legal heirs have stepped into his shoes and can claim the benefits of the purchase notice and the petition.
Respondents' Arguments (2nd and 3rd Respondents)
- The application/purchase notice was incomplete because the Power of Attorney was not annexed; the applicant did not disclose the right, title and interest of the Power of Attorney holder.
- Because the purchase notice/application was incomplete and did not establish the applicant's right, title and interest, the 2nd Respondent was not obliged to proceed under section 127 of the MRTP Act and could refuse permission.
- It was contended that without the Power of Attorney the right and title of the purported applicant could not be ascertained; furthermore, after the original petitioner's death the legal heirs could not necessarily take advantage of the notice (this contention was rejected by the court).
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the chronology and documentary record provided in the pleadings and affidavits. It accepted the following undisputed facts: the land was reserved in the Final Development Plan (1977) and in the Revised Development Plan (18 December 1999); the State did not acquire the land nor initiate acquisition proceedings within the statutory period of ten years following the Revised Plan; and a purchase notice under section 127 was issued on 26 June 2012 and received on 27 June 2012.
On the procedural objection raised by the respondents (that the purchase notice/application was incomplete for want of a Power of Attorney and therefore the authority could not ascertain right, title and interest), the court noted: (a) the petitioner produced photocopies of the sale deed, property card and measurement map on 31 July 2012 and the respondents admitted receipt of that reply; (b) the subsequent insistence on a Power of Attorney was not communicated with sufficient specificity in the earlier letter of 26 December 2012 so as to make compliance obvious; (c) there is no legal impediment to a notice under section 127 being given through a Power of Attorney holder; and (d) during the hearing two original Power of Attorneys were produced (a General Power of Attorney dated 14 August 2000 and a Special Power of Attorney dated 16 June 2010) which expressly empowered the attorney to represent the owner before government and local bodies.
The court treated the omission (if any) of the Power of Attorney at the time of the initial notice as a defect that was subsequently cured by production of the documents. It found that the 2nd Respondent had in fact received the documents of title on 31 July 2012 and therefore ought not to have persisted in rejecting the notice on the ground of incompleteness. The court then turned to the statutory scheme: it observed that no declaration under sub-section (2) or sub-section (4) of Section 126 of the MRTP Act had been issued within the time stipulated in sub-section (1) of Section 127. On that basis, applying the statutory time limits and the admitted fact of inaction by the authority, the court concluded that the reservation had lapsed by operation of law.
Finally, the court rejected the contention that the legal heirs could not take advantage of the notice after the original petitioner’s death, holding that the heirs stepped into the shoes of the deceased and could enjoy rights that had accrued to him.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The Writ Petition is allowed and the reservation on the petitioner's land is declared to have lapsed.
Direct consequences ordered by the court (as set out in the judgment):
- The court declared that the reservation on CS No. 523, E-Ward, Kolhapur (belonging to the original petitioner) has lapsed and that the land is available to the owner for development as permissible with respect to adjacent land.
- The State Government was directed to notify the lapsing of the reservation by an order to be published in the Official Gazette in accordance with section 127(2) of the MRTP Act, to be done as expeditiously as possible and preferably within three months from the date of uploading of the order.
- The order of the 2nd Respondent dated 5 March 2014 (Exh. H), which had rejected the petitioner's development application, was set aside.
- The petitioners were granted liberty to make an application for grant of development permission on the land, which application shall be considered in accordance with law.
- The Writ Petition stands allowed on the stated terms; no order as to costs was made.
Implications: The decision resolves the parties' dispute by declaring the specific reservation lapsed and directing statutory notification and reconsideration of development permission. The opinion does not discuss broader precedential consequences or set out any novel legal doctrine beyond its application of the MRTP Act to the present facts.
Vibha Kankanwadi, J.:— Heard the learned counsel appearing for the Petitioner, the learned AGP for the 1st and 3rd Respondents and the learned counsel appearing for the 2nd Respondent. The original Petitioner has invoked the Writ Jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India for issuance of a Writ of Mandamus for declaration of lapsing of reservation of his land and to direct 1 Respondent to notify the same after passing an order for publishing it in the Official Gazette as well as for other consequential reliefs.
2. The facts emerging which led to filing the petition are that, the original petitioner and his brother Laxman had purchased a land bearing Survey No. 523, E-Ward, situated at Kolhapur, admeasuring 1543.5 sq. meters on 8th December 1953, from one Sitabai Govindrao Korgaonkar. Land admeasuring 284 sq. meters, out of the said land, was acquired by the South Central Railways in the year 1971. A portion of the said land stands in the name of South Central Railways in the property card. The Petitioner's brother Laxman, bequeathed his half share from the said land in favour of the Petitioner. After the demise of Laxman Korgaonkar, the Petitioner is the sole owner of the land. The said land was reserved under the Development Plan made as per the provisions of Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (for short the “MRTP Act”). The Final Development Plan for the city of Kolhapur, came into force some time in the year 1977, wherein, the said land was reserved for the purpose of Rehabilitation of Displaced Shop Keepers. However, the property was neither acquired nor any steps were taken for the acquisition of the said land in pursuance to the Development Plan. The Revised Development Plan for the city of Kolhapur came into force on 18 December 1999 wherein, again the said land was reserved for the purpose of Rehabilitation of Displaced Shop Keepers. Even thereafter also, the said land was neither acquired nor steps were initiated for the acquisition of the land within the stipulated period of 10 years. The Petitioner has therefore, served a notice under section 127 of the mrtp act on 26 June 2012 through his Power of Attorney Holder to the 2 and 3 Respondents. The said notice was served upon the 2 Respondent on 27 June 2012. Thereafter, the 3 Respondent had issued a letter dated 7 July 2012 to the Power of Attorney Holder of the Petitioner to produce documents of title and the original Measurement Map. The Petitioner was also called upon to submit the said documents before 2 Respondent. The Petitioner had immediately responded and all the documents called for, were produced before the 3 Respondent on 31 July 2012. However, the 2 Respondent called upon the Petitioner again to submit the document of title by his letter dated 5 November, 2012. The Petitioner had again responded immediately by addressing a letter dated 12 November, 2012 and pointing out the compliance of the requirement of the submission of documents. The said letter was received by the 2 Respondent on 17 November 2012. However, the 2 Respondent issued letter dated 26 December 2012, reiterating the same contentions. Once again the compliance was made by the Petitioner by giving letter. Thus, the 2 Respondent had not acquired the said land nor had taken any step for the commencement of acquisition proceeding of the said land within the stipulated period of 12 months from the receipt of notice under section 127 of the mrtp act or from the date of furnishing the relevant documents to the 2 Respondent. Therefore, the reservation on the said land has lapsed as per the statutory provision. The land is now completely free from reservation for Rehabilitation of Displaced Shop Keepers as per the Development Plan of 18 December 1999. The Petitioner therefore, applied under the provision of Sections 44, 45 and 58 and 69 of MRTP Act, read with Section 253 of the Maharashtra Municipal Corporation Act, 1949 for seeking a permission to carry out construction on the said land for the purpose of developing the land. The application was received by the 2 Respondent on 15 February 2014. However, the said application came to be rejected by the 2 Respondent vide order dated 5 March 2014. The 2 Respondent has not acknowleded the lapsing of reservation over the said land. Hence the petition.
3. An affidavit-in-reply has been filed by Shri. Mahadev Gangadhar Phulari, Junior Engineer, Assistant Town Planner, Kolhapur Division, Kolhapur, Municipal Corporation on behalf of the 2 and 3 Respondent. He has accepted the position that the land belonging to the Petitioner was reserved in the Town Planning Scheme. It is stated that an application dated 26 June 2017 was filed by one Shri. Dinesh Madhukar Korgaonkar, claiming to be the Power of Attorney of the Petitioner. The Power of Attorney was not annexed with the application. The Petitioner had also not annexed relevant documents depicting his right, title or interest in the said land. Therefore, the reply was sent on 7 July 2012 to the Petitioner informing him that the application is incomplete and documents have not been annexed. A reply was sent by the Petitioner annexing photocopies of property card, sale deed, City Survey Map. However, a copy of the Power of Attorney was not annexed. The letter dated 5 November, 2012 was in fact issued because the Petitioner had failed to comply with the earlier letter dated 7 July 2012. The Petitioner was repeatedly called upon to comply with the objections as the application was not disclosing the right, title and interest of the Applicant's Power of Attorney holder. As the application was incomplete, the purchase notice/application was not scrutinized. It is denied that the reservation has lapsed and therefore, the permission to make construction/redevelopment of the land has been rejected. It was incumbent upon the Petitioner to file a valid purchase notice. It has been contended that for want of a valid purchase notice, the action under section 127 of the mrtp act is not called for.
4. It will not be out of place to mention here that during the pendency of the petition the original Petitioner has expired and his legal heirs have been brought on record.
5. It has been submitted on behalf of the Petitioners that there is no dispute as regards fact that the land belonging to the Petitioner was reserved for Rehabilitation of Displaced Shop Keepers in the Development Plan. The Final Development Plan for the City of Kolhapur came into force in 1977 and the Revised Development Plan came into force on 18 December 1999. Neither any steps were taken for acquisition nor the land was actually acquired till 18 December 2009 for the period of 10 years which is stipulated under the Act. Therefore, the notice under Section 127 of the Act was given on 26 June 2012 which was duly received by the 2 Respondent. The only objection that was raised was that the documents of title and the Measurement Map has not been produced. The said objection has been complied with. The objection appears to be that even the Power of Attorney given by the Original Petitioner to his son ought to have been forwarded. This objection cannot be said to be a legal requirement. The learned counsel appearing for the 2 Respondent has submitted that since the Power of Attorney was not made available, the right, title and interest of the Petitioner could not be ascertained. He also submitted that since now the Original Petitioner has expired, the legal heirs have been brought on record and therefore, they cannot claim that the reservation over the plot should be declared as lapsed.
6. The fact is not in dispute that the Original Petitioner had purchased the property with his brother by a sale deed dated 8 December, 1953. A photocopy of the sale deed has been produced on record. As per the Petitioner's contention, his brother has bequeathed his half share in favor of the Petitioner by executing a will. The property card extract was sufficient evidence regarding the right of the Petitioner over the said property. The photocopy of the property register card has also been produced. Only a portion of a land that is 284 sq.mtrs has been acquired by South Central Railways, the rest of the area is owned by the Petitioner.
7. The 2 Respondent is not disputing the reservation of the plot for the Rehabilitation of Displaced Shop Keepers in final Development Plan, 1977 and the Revised Development Plan which came into force on 18 December 1999. When the Petitioner noted that the land has not been actually acquired and no action was taken in order to acquire the land, the purchase notice was given. The 2 Respondent has also not disputed the issuance of the purchase notice. The only objection is that the said notice is incomplete. The Petitioner was called upon to produce documents of title and the map. The Petitioner had forwarded the property card, sale deed, copy of original Measurement Map to the Respondent No. 3 on 31 July 2012. The 2 and 3 Respondents are not disputing the fact that they have received the said reply from the Petitioner dated 31 July 2012. The only objection thereafter, appears to be the fact that the Power of Attorney was not produced. Again a letter was issued by the 2 Respondent on 26 December 2012, calling upon the Petitioner to comply with the said defect but there was no specific mention that petitioner should also send the copy of the Power of Attorney. Unless the thing would have been made clear, it was not possible for the petitioner to comply with the same. The said letter was replied by the Petitioner's Power of Attorney on 8 January 2013. There was no legal impediment to issue notice under section 127 of the mrtp act through a Power of Attorney holder. In fact, during the hearing of the present petition, the Power of Attorney holder of the Petitioner was called upon to produce the document of Power of Attorney. Accordingly, two original Power of Attorneys have been produced, one is a General Power of Attorney executed on 14 August, 2000 and the another is the Special Power of Attorney which was executed on 16 June 2010. In both the Power of Attorneys, there is a specific mention that the Power of Attorney holder can do all others acts and to represent him before the Government, Semi Government, Local Body, Corporations or Companies, etc. on his behalf. It can be therefore said that the Power of Attorney holder i.e the son of the Petitioner was empowered to give a notice under section 127 of the mrtp act on behalf of the Petitioner in respect of the land under reservation. Thus, it can be seen that when the documents of title i.e property register card was already submitted before the 2 Respondent along with letter dated 31 July 2012, the 2 Respondent ought not to have insisted upon the production of Power of Attorney. Even if for the sake of arguments, it is accepted that along with notice dated 27 June 2012, no document of title was forwarded; yet, that defect was cured in the reply dated 31 July 2012. The Revised Development Plant had come into force on 18 December 1999, the further process of acquisition ought to have been started within the stipulated period of 10 years thereafter. Therefore, we do not see any defect in the notice that has been issued by the Petitioner. As no declaration either under sub-section (2) or sub-section 4 of Section 126 of the MRTP Act has admittedly not been issued within the time stipulated in sub-section (1) of Section 127. The inevitable conclusion is that the reservation of the Petitioner's land in question has lapsed and the land is now available to the Petitioner to be developed as permissible in law.
8. We do not agree with the submission on behalf of 2 Respondent that legal heirs of original Petitioner can not take advantage of the said notice. In fact, after death of original Petitioner, they have stepped into the shoes of the deceased. They can enjoy the fruits of all the rights which had accrued to the deceased. The Writ Petition, therefore, deserves to be allowed. Hence following order:—
(a) It is hereby declared that the reservation on land bearing CS No. 523, E-Ward, Kolhapur belonging to the original Petitioner has lapsed and the said land is available to the owner for development as otherwise permissible in respect of the adjacent land;
(b) The State Government is directed to notify the lapsing of the reservation by an order to be published in the Official Gazette as per the requirement of section 127(2) of the mrtp act, which should be done as expeditiously as possible and preferably within a period of 3 months from the date of uploading of this order;
(c) The order passed by the 2 Respondent dated 5 March 2014 (Exh.H) is hereby set aside;
(d) The Petitioners are at liberty to make an application for grant of development permission on the aforesaid land which shall be considered in accordance with law;
(e) The Writ Petition stands allowed on the above terms.
(f) No orders as to costs.
Alert