Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Karmanya Singh Sareen And Another v. Union Of India And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Apr 18, 2017
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petition challenges recent clauses introduced by WhatsApp Inc. that allow data-sharing with Facebook Inc. The petitioners argue that these clauses threaten individual freedom and violate constitutional protections. During the present hearing before the Supreme Court of India, multiple counsel appeared for the petitioners, the Union of India, TRAI, WhatsApp Inc., and Facebook Inc. The Chief Justice had administratively directed the matter to be listed before a Constitution Bench of five judges, prompting a preliminary objection from Respondents 2 and 3. The Court, in this interim order, heard initial submissions, directed the petitioners to formulate written propositions by 24-04-2017, and fixed the next hearing for 27-04-2017.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Chief Justice may list the case before a Constitution Bench without formally framing questions of reference under Article 145 of the Constitution.
  2. Whether WhatsApp’s updated data-sharing policy is “unconscionable,” constitutionally infirm, or otherwise violates the fundamental freedoms of users.
  3. Whether the actions of WhatsApp and Facebook comply with Section 79 of the Information Technology Act, 2000 and the Information Technology (Reasonable Security Practices and Procedures and Sensitive Personal Data or Information) Rules, 2011.
  4. The broader question of creating a regulatory regime to safeguard net neutrality and user data, as indicated by the Union of India.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners’ Arguments

  • The impugned clauses in WhatsApp’s policy are “unconscionable,” unconstitutional, and infringe upon cherished individual freedoms.
  • WhatsApp, by unilateral imposition, cannot mandate such data-sharing practices.
  • The Chief Justice, as master of the roster, may place significant matters before a five-judge bench without a formal Article 145 reference.

Respondents’ Arguments (WhatsApp Inc. and Facebook Inc.)

  • WhatsApp does not share the content of voice or message communications; therefore, no private content is disclosed to third parties.
  • Their conduct fully complies with Section 79 of the Information Technology Act, 2000.
  • The impugned policy conforms to the 2011 IT Rules regarding reasonable security practices and sensitive personal data.
  • The preliminary placement before a Constitution Bench is procedurally improper without framed questions of law.

Union of India’s Position

  • A forthcoming regulatory framework is contemplated to preserve net-neutrality and protect databases, reflecting the Union’s official stance.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court did not enter into substantive adjudication at this stage. It acknowledged the preliminary objection regarding reference to a Constitution Bench but deferred a ruling on that point, stating it would be addressed in the final judgment. The bench focused on efficient case management: it instructed the petitioners to crystallise their propositions in writing and scheduled the matter for further hearing. The order thus primarily served to organise future deliberations rather than to resolve the merits.

Holding and Implications

ORDER: The petitioners shall file their formulated propositions by 24-04-2017, and the matter is listed for further hearing at 3:00 p.m. on 27-04-2017.

Implications: The order is procedural and keeps the dispute alive; it neither validates nor invalidates WhatsApp’s policy. No precedent is set at this stage, and the substantive constitutional and statutory questions remain open for determination in the forthcoming hearings.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. Heard Mr Harish N. Salve, learned Senior Counsel along with Ms Madhavi Divan, learned counsel for the petitioners, Mr Mukul Rohatgi, learned Attorney General, Mr Tushar Mehta and Mr P.S Narasimha, learned Additional Solicitor General for the Union of India, Mr Kapil Sibal, learned Senior Counsel for Respondent 2, WhatsApp Inc., Mr Sidharth Luthra, learned Senior Counsel for Respondent 3, Facebook Inc., and Mr Sanjay Kapur, learned counsel for Respondent 5.

2. At the commencement of the hearing, after giving some introduction with regard to the functioning of the internet, Mr Harish N. Salve, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioners, drew our attention to the affidavit filed by the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI), Respondent 5 and the counter-affidavit that has been filed by the Union of India, Respondent 1. At this juncture, Mr Mukul Rohatgi, learned Attorney General for India has submitted that the stand of the Union of India is that there is going to be a regulatory regime to save the database to guide the concept of net-neutrality.

3. On being questioned, what are the real issues involved, before Mr Salve, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners could answer, Mr Kapil Sibal, learned Senior Counsel appearing for Respondent 2, which was immediately echoed by Mr Sidharth Luthra, learned Senior Counsel appearing for Respondent 3, submitted that the matter could not have been referred SLP (C) No. 804 of 2017 to the Constitution Bench without framing the questions that needed to be referred. The said preliminary objection was resisted by Mr Salve on the foundation that the direction for listing the matter before a five-Judge Bench need not be treated as a reference as postulated under Article 145 of the Constitution of India. The learned Senior Counsel would urge that the Hon'ble the Chief Justice of India is the master of the roster and he has the authority on the administrative side to place the matter before a five-Judge Bench regard being had to the gravity, significance and importance of the matter. We shall delve into this preliminary objection at the time of delivery of the final verdict. When an issue is raised, the same has to be addressed and we think we shall put the controversy to the rest in this regard.

4. In the course of hearing, Mr Salve has taken pains to take us through certain documents and attacked the clauses which have come in vogue, as to how they are going to affect the freedom of an individual. According to Mr Salve, the policy that is formulated by WhatsApp is unconscionable and is unacceptable and also suffers from constitutional vulnerability since it maladroitly affects the freedom which is a cherished right of an individual under the Constitution. The learned Senior Counsel would contend that by imposition, WhatsApp cannot formulate such a policy under the garb of data-sharing.

5. Mr Sibal vehemently resisting the submission of Mr Salve, would contend that WhatsApp does not share data protection of voice and messages, so no part of the content which is exchanged between two individuals is ever revealed to third party and, therefore, the submission of Mr Salve is sans substance. That apart, it is submitted by Mr Sibal and Mr Luthra that their action is compliant with Section 79 of the Information Technology Act, 2000. It has also been contended by them that the actions of Respondents 2 and 3 are in consonance with the Information Technology (Reasonable Security Practices and Procedures and Sensitive Personal Data or Information) Rules, 2011. Be that as it may, we would like Mr Salve to formulate his propositions and file it by 24-4-2017.

6. Let the matter be listed at 3 p.m on 27-4-2017.

Court Masters