Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Parijat Construction v. Commissioner Of Central Excise

Bombay High Court
Oct 13, 2017
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Appellant is a registered provider of "Commercial or Industrial Construction" services. Between May 2006 and November 2007 the Appellant executed a contract for construction of administrative and academic buildings for the Mumbai Educational Trust. Believing the transaction attracted service tax, the Appellant paid service tax without collecting it from its customer and deposited the amounts with the Central Government.

On 11 March 2008 the Appellant filed a refund claim for Rs. 12,62,900, asserting that the services were provided for an educational institution and thus exempt under the department clarification in para 13.2 of CBEC Circular No. 80/10/2004-ST dated 17 September 2004. A show cause notice was issued on 30 May 2008. The Assistant Commissioner, by Order-in-Original No. 05.ST.(R)/2009 dated 31 March 2009, rejected refund claims aggregating Rs. 9,73,292 as time-barred under Section 11B of the Central Excise Act, 1944; Rs. 2,89,608 of the refund claim was allowed.

The Appellant appealed to the Commissioner (Appeals), who by Order-in-Appeal dated 18 November 2009 partly allowed the appeal to the extent of Rs. 73,330 and otherwise upheld the Orders-in-Original. The Appellant further appealed to the Customs, Excise & Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (West Zonal Branch, Mumbai). By a common order dated 5 May 2016 the Appellate Tribunal dismissed the Appellant's appeal. The present appeals to the High Court challenge that Tribunal order (the Court refers to Appeal No. 306 of 2016 for convenience).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the one-year limitation under Section 11B of the Central Excise Act, 1944 applies to refund claims of service tax paid under a mistake of law (i.e., where the service was not leviable to service tax).
  2. Whether the Appellate Tribunal correctly applied Section 11B (and whether it could or should have relaxed the statutory time limit) in rejecting the Appellant's refund claim as time-barred.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Section 11B's one-year limitation is inapplicable to refunds of service tax paid under a mistake of law; therefore the Appellant's refund claim should not be time-barred.
  • The Appellate Tribunal erred in applying Section 11B to a case where the Appellant admittedly paid tax on services that were not leviable to service tax.
  • Reliance on precedents (Division Bench decisions in Hindustan Cocoa Products v. Union of India and Commissioner Central Excise, Nagpur v. SGR Infratech Ltd.) supports the position that Section 11B does not apply where tax was paid under mistake of law.
  • The Supreme Court decision in Collector of C.E., Chandigarh v. Doaba Co-Operative Sugar Mills (relied on by the Tribunal) is distinguishable because an exception exists for payments made under mistake of law.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The limitation under Section 11B applies to all refund claims, including service tax refunds.
  • Because the Appellant's refund claims were filed after one year from the date of payment, they were correctly held to be barred by limitation by the Appellate Tribunal.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Hindustan Cocoa Products v. Union of India, 1994 74 ELT 525 (Bom.) Holds that limitation under Section 11B is not applicable to refund claims for service tax paid under a mistake of law. The Court treated this Division Bench decision as squarely applicable and relied on it to conclude Section 11B did not bar the Appellant's refund claim.
Commissioner of Central Excise, Nagpur v. SGR Infratech Ltd., Central Excise Appeal No. 26 of 2014 (dated 28 Oct 2015) Same principle: Section 11B does not apply where service tax was paid under mistake of law. The Court held this Division Bench decision to be squarely applicable and supportive of allowing the refund despite Section 11B.
Collector of Central Excise, Chandigarh v. Doaba Co-Operative Sugar Mills, 1988 37 E.L.T 478 (S.C.) Supreme Court decision applying Section 11B but, as interpreted, it permits an exception where duty was paid under a mistake of law. The Appellate Tribunal relied on this decision. The High Court observed that Doaba's application of Section 11B recognizes an exception for mistakes of law and therefore does not support rejecting the refund on limitation grounds.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by identifying the central issue—whether Section 11B's limitation applies to refunds of service tax paid under a mistake of law—and observed that this question was no longer res integra. The Court relied on two Division Bench decisions of the Bombay High Court (Hindustan Cocoa and SGR Infratech) which had held that the one-year limitation under Section 11B is not applicable to refund claims where service tax was paid under a mistake of law.

The Court examined the Appellate Tribunal's reliance on the Supreme Court decision in Collector of C.E., Chandigarh v. Doaba Co-Operative Sugar Mills and concluded that Doaba, when properly read, allows an exception to Section 11B where the payment of duty/tax was made under mistake of law. Consequently, the Appellate Tribunal's application of Section 11B to bar the Appellant's refund claim was erroneous because the Appellant admittedly paid service tax on a service not leviable to such tax (i.e., under a mistake of law).

On this basis the Court concluded that the impugned order of the Appellate Tribunal was unsustainable: the Tribunal's finding that Section 11B barred the refund claim was not supported by the precedents and did not account for the recognized exception for mistakes of law.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court allowed the appeals, quashed and set aside the impugned Appellate Tribunal order insofar as it was against the Appellant, and fully allowed the refund of Rs. 8,99,962. The Respondent was directed to refund Rs. 8,99,962 to the Appellant within three months. There was no order as to costs.

Implications: The direct effect is that the Appellant is entitled to the refunded amount of Rs. 8,99,962 to be paid by the Respondent within three months. The opinion rests on prior Division Bench decisions and an interpretation of Doaba permitting an exception where tax was paid under a mistake of law; the judgment did not purport to set a new broader precedent beyond applying those principles to the facts before the Court.

Show all summary ...

Riyaz I. Chagla, J.:— The Appellants by the present Appeals are challenging a common order dated 5 May 2016 passed by the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal, West Zonal Branch at Mumbai (for short “Appellate Tribunal”) by which the Orders-in-Appeal Nos. AKP/104.NSK/2009 and AKP/104.NSK/2009, both dated 18 November 2009 passed by the Commissioner (Appeals) of Central Excise and Customs, Nashik were upheld. For the sake of convenience, we are referring to the facts in Appeal No. 306 of 2016.

2. The Appellant is engaged in providing “Commercial or Industrial Construction” service and are registered as a service provider under that category. The Appellant had during the period May 2006 to November 2007 secured a contract from Mumbai Educational Trust for construction of administration and Core Course building. The Appellant being under the bonafide belief that the transaction attracts service tax paid the same without collecting the same from the customer and deposited it to the credit of the Central Government. The Appellant filed a refund claim on 11 March 2008 for Rs. 12,62,900/-. The refund claim was filed as the Appellant had provided construction services for use of organisation or institutions being established solely for educational, religious, charitable, health, sanitation or philanthropic purposes and not for purposes of profit and were thus exempted as per the department clarification issued under para 13.2 of CBEC circular No. 80/10/2004-ST dated 17 September 2004. A show cause notice dated 30 May 2008 issued to the Appellant by the Assistant Commissioner to show cause as to why the Appellant's claim for refund shall not be rejected. The Appellant filed a detailed reply to the show cause notice. The Assistant Commissioner vide Order-in-Original No. 05.ST.(R)/2009 dated 31st March 2009 rejected the refund claim for Rs. 9,73,292/- filed by the Appellant as not been sustainable on account of the refund claim being time barred under the provisions of Section 11 B of the Central Excise Act, 1944. The refund claim of Rs. 2,89,608/- was allowed. The Appellant being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the said orders filed Appeal before the Commissioner of Central Excise (Appeals), Nashik. By Order-in-Appeal dated 18 November 2009, the Commissioner (Appeals) partly allowed the Appeals of the Appellant to the extent of Rs. 73,330/- and for the remaining amounts the Orders-in-Original were upheld. The Appellant filed Appeal before the Appellate Tribunal challenging the said order of the Commissioner (Appeals). By the impugned order dated 5 May 2016, the Appellate Tribunal dismissed the Appeal filed by the Appellant. Hence the present Appeal has been filed.

3. Mr. Raichandani, learned counsel for the Appellant has submitted that Section 11 B of the Central Excise Act which prescribes the time period of one year for filing a refund claim is inapplicable in the case of refund for service tax which was paid under mistake of law. Mr. Raichandani has further submitted that the Appellate Tribunal has erroneously applied Section 11 B of the said Act in the present case where admittedly the Appellant had paid service tax on commercial or industrial construction service though such service was not leviable to service tax. The Appellate Tribunal has arrived at an erroneous finding that since refund of any amount is governed by Section 11 B, there would be no other provision of limitation for filing a refund claim and that the Appellate Tribunal being a creature under the Central Excise/Customs Act cannot go beyond the statute and relax time prescribed under the statute. The Appellate Tribunal rejected the refund claim of the Appellant on the ground that it was filed after one year and hit by limitation and thereby the upheld the orders of the Commissioner (Appeals). Mr. Raichandani has relied upon a judgment of the Division Bench of this Court in Hindustan Cocoa Products v. Union of India 1994 74 ELT 525 Bom. judgment of Division Bench of this Court (Nagpur Bench) in the case of The Commissioner Central Excise, Nagpur v. SGR Infratech Ltd. Central Excise Appeal No. 26 of 2014 dated 28th October 2015. in support of his contention that, the limitation prescribed under Section 11 B of the said Act is not applicable, where admittedly the tax could not have been demanded and/or service tax was paid under a mistake of law. Mr. Raichandani has also submitted that the Supreme Court order relied upon by the Appellate Tribunal viz. Collector of C.E, Chandigarh v. Doaba Co-Operative Sugar Mills 1988 37 E.L.T 478 S.C. would not be applicable as an exception has been culled out in cases where duty was paid under the mistake of law. In the present case where admittedly the Appellant had paid service tax on Commercial or Industrial Construction Service although such services were not liable to service tax.

4. Mr. Dwivedi learned counsel for the Respondent has supported the impugned order. Mr. Dwivedi contended that limitation prescribed under Section 11 B under the said Act is applicable to all refund claims and since the refund claims of the Appellant was filed beyond one year from the date of payment of service tax, the refund claim was correctly held by the Appellate Tribunal to be hit by limitation.

5. We are of the view that the issue as to whether limitation prescribed under Section 11 B of the said Act applies to a refund claimed in respect of service tax paid under a mistake of law is no longer res integra. The two decisions of the Division Bench of this Court in Hindustan Cocoa (Supra) and Commissioner of Central Excise, Nagpur v. SGR Infratech Ltd. (Supra) are squarely applicable to the facts of the present case.

6. Both decisions have held the limitation prescribed under Section 11 B of the said Act to be not applicable to refund claims for service tax paid under a mistake of law. The decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Collector of C.E, Chandigarh v. Doaba Co-Operative Sugar Mills (Supra) relied upon by the Appellate Tribunal has in applying Section 11 B, limitation made an exception in case of refund claims where the payment of duty was under a mistake of law. We are of the view that the impugned order is erroneous in that it applies the limitation prescribed under Section 11 B of the Act to the present case were admittedly Appellant had paid a service tax on Commercial or Industrial Construction Service even though such service is not leviable to service tax. We are of the view that the decisions relied upon by the Appellate Tribunal do not support the case of the Respondent in rejecting the refund claim on the ground that it was barred by limitation. We are, therefore, of the view that the impugned order is unsustainable.

7. We accordingly allow the present Appeals and quash and set aside the impugned order, in so far as it is against the Appellant in both Appeals. We fully allow refund of Rs. 8,99,962/- preferred by the Appellant. We direct that the Respondent shall refund the amount of Rs. 8,99,962/- to the Appellant within a period of three months. There shall be no order as to costs.