- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Vikas Kalsi v. Union Of India
Rajwant Sandhu, Member (A):— This OA has been filed under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 seeking the following relief:—
“Annexure A-1 dated 12.4.2013 be quashed and set aside being against the transfer guidelines issued by respondents No. 2 & 3 or the posting be deferred till March, 2014”
Interim relief was also sought as follows:—
“Pending final decision on the original application, applicant prays that operation of impugned order dated 12.4.2013 (Annexure A-1) be stayed as balance of convenience lies in favour of the applicant. The applicant has not yet been relieved to the transferred place in pursuance of order dated 12.4.2013 (Annexure A-1)”.
Through order dated 18.4.2013, the impugned order was stayed and this position continues till date.
2. Brief facts of the case are that the applicant joined the respondent department as Junior Engineer on 11.3.2004 and remained posted at various stations such as under CWE Pathankot, GE(W) Pathankot and GE 970 EWS Srinagar. Applicant was posted at the present station i.e under the respondent No. 5 since July, 2010. Vide letter dated 14.11.2012 (Annexure A-2.A), respondents issued “Posting/Transfer: Subordinates Warning List for the year 2012-13 where in the Appendix ‘C’, name of the applicant was shown at serial No. 28. After issuance of this Posting/Transfer list, applicant submitted representation through Respondent No. 5 to the respondent No. 3 for deferment of the posting till March 2014 as per guidelines dated 17.4.2013 (Annexure A-2). The applicant had been elected unanimously for the first time as Secretary for the All India MES Civilian Engineers Association vide letter dated 21.3.2012 (Annexure A-3) and tenure of this post is two years from the date of election. However, the applicant was transferred by the respondent No. 3 from GE(I), Air Force, Pathankot to CWE Khumbathang.
3. Averment has been made in the OA that as per the Guidelines of Management of Group ‘C’ and ‘D’ posts of MES dated 17.4.2010 (Annexure A-2) issued by the respondents, para 14(b) is reproduced as under:—
“Personnel who are important office bearers of recognized unions/associations and are entitled for protections for posting as per existing Rules with the date upto which they are exempted (first time elected members only are entitled)”.
According to these guidelines, applicant is not due for transfer. Aggrieved by his posting to CWE, Khumbathang, the applicant made a representation dated 24.11.2012 (Annexure A-4) to the respondent No. 3 for deferment of the posting till March 2014 as per aforesaid Guidelines for Management of Group C & D posts of MESD dated 17.4.2010 The respondent No. 5 recommended the application of the applicant vide letter dated 30.11.2012 (Annexure A-5). Respondent No. 4 also duly recommended the application of the applicant vide letter dated 2.1.2013 (Annexure A-6). Respondents intimated the applicant that his case was forwarded to the higher authority for further consideration. But till date, no action was taken by the respondents against the representation of the applicant. As per policy, the tenure is to be calculated based on the Guidelines framed by the respondent No. 3 and the applicant can be considered at sensitive appointment only w.e.f March 2014 and hence, he has not completed two years tenure after having been elected as Secretary for the AIMCE Association.
4. In the grounds for relief, it has been stated as follows:—
(i) Impugned order dated 12.4.2013 is against the Transfer Policy dated 17.4.2010 (Annexure A-2), as such, the impugned transfer order dated 28.6.2011 (Annexure A-1) requires to be quashed/set aside.
(ii) The applicant is an elected Union member i.e Secretary of AIMCE Association for the first time in his career, thus, the action of the respondents transferring the applicant is wholly arbitrary and against the guidelines framed by the respondents themselves.
5. In the written statement filed on behalf of the respondents, it has been stated that the applicant being a government servant having transferable job is liable to be transferred at any time in exigency of service and job requirement. However, the applicant has already completed 02 years 10 months stay and is going to complete 3 years on 4.7.2013 The Northern Command area is fully surrounded by international borders including Field Area and most of the Stations are Field/Tenure Stations. In order to repatriate the employees in the Hard Tenure Station after completing two years of stay, it is mandatory to replace them by other employees. Therefore, the applicant is not entitled to any relief and his services are required at tenure station being due for tenure posting. The applicant's request dated 24.11.2012 (Annexure A-1) for not posting him to tenure station in his own turn on grounds of being elected as Secretary of All India MES Civilian Engineers Association was rejected after consideration by competent authority because this request was not covered by any Government order/SOP. The applicant's contention that he was entitled for deferment of his posting as per Para 14(b) in respect of important office bearers of recognized unions/Associations who are entitled for protection for posting as per existing rules. This protection from posting as per the provision of SOP is available to only those office bearers who are entitled for exemption from posting as per rule, but, there is no rule as on date which entitles exemption from posting to applicant as formation of ibid Association and election of applicant is not covered by statutory rules. Only because of non-entitlement for exemption from posting, no other office bearer of any Association has requested for such exemption. As per Government of India, MOD, New Delhi OM No. 13(24)/75.D(Apts) dated 2.4.1980, elected members of Works Committee framed under statutory rules are given protection against transfer (Annexure R II). Thus, applicant's plea is only because of blissful ignorance and it is devoid of any merit. It is further stated in the written statement that the applicant is trying to avoid his move to tenure station. His application was already considered and rejected and there is no requirement of giving reply on representations received on warning list as its purpose is to ensure transparency and updating of date which was ensured in this case also.
6. Arguments advanced by the learned counsel for the parties were heard. Learned counsel for the applicant stressed that the applicant is the elected Secretary of the All India MES Civilian Engineers Association (AIMCA), Area Headquarter, Pathankot, and hence was not liable to be transferred for a period of two years keeping in view the guidelines as depicted in para 14(b) of the Guidelines for Management of Group ‘C’ & ‘D’ Posts of MES. He also referred to OM dated 19.9.1966 (Annexure MA-1) issued by the Ministry of Defence wherein it had been clarified that protection from transfer was given to Government servants who are office bearers of recognized Trade Unions or Staff Associations and such protection was given to an individual Government servant only once in respect of a particular station. The applicant had been elected as an office bearer of the Association for the first time and hence, he was entitled to the two year protection from transfer, learned counsel stated that the applicant only wanted deferment of his transfer and since two-year tenure as office bearer would be completed in March, 2014, he should not be transferred out till then.
7. On behalf of the respondents, the matter was argued by Sh. S.K Guevera, proxy counsel for the respondents. Learned counsel referred to para 3.17(2) relating to transfer of workmen elected as representatives in the Works Committees as per Government of India Ministry of Defence OM No. 13(24)/75.D(Appls)-dated 2.4.1980 He stated that from the content of para 2, it was clear that only such workmen were protected from transfer where the Works Committees had been formed under statutory rules. The applicant had to show that he was a member of the Works Committee constituted under the Industrial Disputes Act, but he had not been able to establish this position. Moreover, the office bearers of local units of the Association were not protected from transfer and hence, the claim of the applicant regarding protection from transfer for the two year period since when he was elected, was without basis.
8. Having perused carefully the pleadings of the parties, the material on record and heard the learned counsel at length, I am of the view that since the applicant was only an office bearer of a local chapter of the All India MES Civilian Engineers Association, he was not entitled to the protection from transfer as referred to in para 14 of the Guidelines for Management of Group ‘C’ & ‘D’ posts of MES and he had been advised accordingly when his representation for cancellation of the transfer was rejected. Further, keeping in view the fact that transfer is an incident of service as had been held by the Apex Court time and again and transfers ordered in routine keeping in view the administrative exigencies and transfer policies, are not to be interfered with, it is felt that there is no merit in this OA. Moreover, the applicant has been at his present place of posting since July, 2010 and has completed his tenure there. Therefore, he is in any case, due for transfer. In view of this position, this OA is rejected. No costs.
Alert