Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Kumar Enterprises Through Its Proprietor & Anr. v. Arci Ltd. & Ors.

Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal
Nov 22, 2013
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — Kumar Enterprises v. Asset Reconstruction Company (India) Ltd. (Appeal against D.R.T.-III order dated 27.09.2012)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellants obtained an overdraft facility from respondent No. 2 Bank initially of Rs. 19 lakhs, later renewed as Rs. 10 lakhs overdraft and Rs. 9 lakhs demand loan, and subsequently enhanced/renewed in October 2000 as a Cash Credit (Hypothecation) facility for Rs. 44 lakhs secured by mortgage of property bearing No. 1/641, Loni Road, Shahdara, Delhi by deposit of the original sale deed.

The loan account was classified as a Non-Performing Asset (N.P.A.) on 31st March, 2002. The Bank filed O.A. No. 198/2002 before D.R.T.-III for recovery of Rs. 54,54,604.48 with pendente lite and future interest. The D.R.T. issued orders to maintain status quo of the mortgaged property (an order dated 25th April, 2013 is recorded in the opinion) and thereafter an order dated 30th May, 2003 continued that status quo with an additional condition that the defendants would not transfer or part with possession.

During pendency of the O.A., the Bank issued a demand notice dated 31st January, 2003 under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act claiming Rs. 57,51,365.48; the borrowers did not repay. The Bank assigned the debt to respondent No. 1 (A.R.C.I.L.) by assignment deed dated 23rd June, 2008. A.R.C.I.L. applied under Section 14 of the SARFAESI Act to the C.M.M., Delhi and the A.C.M.M., Delhi appointed a Court Receiver on 14th September, 2012 to take physical possession of the mortgaged property.

The appellants filed S.A. No. 528/2012 before the Tribunal below challenging A.R.C.I.L.'s actions and sought interim relief to prevent possession by the Receiver. The Tribunal (D.R.T.-III) rejected the interim relief by order dated 27th September, 2012. Respondent No. 1 took physical possession through the Court Receiver. The appellants appealed to this Court seeking restoration of possession as interim and final relief.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the account of the appellants was validly classified as a Non-Performing Asset (N.P.A.) on 31st March, 2002 in accordance with the prevailing RBI prudential norms and guidelines.
  2. Whether the appellants were entitled to interim relief (restoration of possession) pending disposal of S.A. No. 528/2012, i.e., whether they established a prima facie case, balance of convenience, and irreparable injury.
  3. Whether the Bank's conduct in relation to the appellants' response dated 7th April, 2003 to the demand notice of 31st January, 2003 violated the obligation later introduced by Section 13(3A) of the SARFAESI Act (i.e., whether the secured creditor was required to communicate reasons for non-acceptance of any representation).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (as advanced by Mr. M. Dutta)

  • The account could not have been classified as N.P.A. because, under RBI guidelines then prevailing (for the years 2001–2002), an overdraft/cash credit account could be classified as N.P.A. only if it had remained 'out of order' continuously for 180 days or more.
  • An account is 'out of order' only if the balance remains continuously in excess of the sanctioned limit/drawing power; the statement of account (Annexure A-4) purportedly shows the account was within the sanctioned limit of Rs. 44 lakhs until 21st September, 2001.
  • On 3rd October, 2001 the Bank allegedly sanctioned an ad hoc/temporary overdraft limit of 10% (Rs. 4.4 lakhs) for 90 days, raising the effective sanctioned limit to Rs. 48.4 lakhs (expiring 1st January, 2002); therefore, the 180-day period required for N.P.A. classification had not expired by 31st March, 2002.
  • The statement of account allegedly shows the balance remained within Rs. 48.4 lakhs up to 31st December, 2001 and only thereafter exceeded the sanctioned limit.
  • The appellants also contended they had sent a response dated 7th April, 2003 to the Section 13(2) demand notice, and that the Bank did not communicate non-acceptance in compliance with Section 13(3A) of the SARFAESI Act (implying procedural impropriety by the Bank).

Respondent's Arguments (as advanced by Ms. Rungta)

  • The account was rightly classified as N.P.A. on 31st March, 2002 because it had remained out of order (in excess of the sanctioned limit) for more than 180 days.
  • The Bank had never sanctioned any ad hoc limit of Rs. 4.4 lakhs on 3rd October, 2001 as alleged; this specific denial appears in para. 5.9 of the reply to the appeal.
  • After 22nd September, 2001, the balance always remained in excess of the sanctioned limit of Rs. 44 lakhs; if on some days it reduced below Rs. 44 lakhs due to deposits, it again exceeded the limit by the close of that day.
  • Regarding the 7th April, 2003 response, the appellants only demanded documents/information and did not make a representation or objection in the legal sense; therefore, the later-inserted Section 13(3A) (introduced by Act No. 30 of 2004) was not applicable retrospectively and did not impose an obligation on the secured creditor at that time.

Table of Precedents Cited

The opinion refers to statutory provisions and RBI guidelines but does not cite judicial precedents (case law).

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the record, in particular the statement of account (Annexure A-4), and addressed the competing factual contentions strictly on the documentary record:

  1. The Court found the appellants' averment that an ad hoc limit of Rs. 4.4 lakhs was sanctioned on 3rd October, 2001 to be unsupported by documentary proof (no sanction letter was produced), while the respondent had categorically denied such sanction in its pleadings.
  2. On a close reading of Annexure A-4, the Court observed that on 3rd October, 2001 an amount of Rs. 8 lakhs was deposited which reduced the debit balance during the day; however, withdrawals made the same day resulted in the closing debit balance being again at the higher level (Rs. 45,68,418.48). Thus the intra-day deposit did not operate as evidence of any sanctioned ad hoc limit.
  3. The Court emphasized the financial reality of overdraft/cash-credit accounts: balances often exceed sanctioned limits temporarily, but classification as N.P.A. depends on whether the excess persisted beyond the permissible period. The documentary record showed the balance exceeded the sanctioned limit of Rs. 44 lakhs from 22nd September, 2001 and remained in excess up to the date of N.P.A. (31st March, 2002), with any temporary reductions below Rs. 44 lakhs not persisting to the close of the day.
  4. Accordingly, the Court concluded the account was rightly classified as N.P.A. in accordance with the prevailing RBI guidelines, and there was no ground to interfere with the impugned order on that basis.
  5. On the procedural contention under Section 13(3A) of the SARFAESI Act, the Court noted that Sub-section (3A) was inserted into Section 13 by Act No. 30 of 2004, which came into force on 11th November, 2004 — more than a year after the appellants' response dated 7th April, 2003. The Court thus held that the obligation created by Section 13(3A) was prospective and not retrospective; consequently, the secured creditor was not bound at that earlier time to communicate reasons for non-acceptance of a representation under that provision.
  6. The Court accepted the Tribunal below's view that the appellants' 7th April, 2003 communication merely sought documents/information and did not constitute the kind of representation that would engage the later statutory requirement; therefore, any failure to reply at that time did not amount to contravention of the law as it stood then.
  7. Given these findings — valid N.P.A. classification, absence of procedural illegality under the law then in force, and the appellants' indebtedness (a debt exceeding Rs. 57 lakhs to respondent No. 1) — the Court concluded the appellants had failed to make out a prima facie case for interim relief (restoration of possession), and the Tribunal below was correct in refusing interim relief.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Appeal dismissed.

Consequences and practical effects of the Court's decision (as set out in the opinion):

  • The impugned order of the Tribunal dated 27th September, 2012 refusing interim relief is upheld; the appellants failed to show a prima facie case for restoration of possession.
  • Physical possession already taken over by respondent No. 1 through the Court Receiver shall not be restored to the appellants during the pendency of the S.A.
  • There is no order as to costs.
  • The Court expressly clarified that the Tribunal below should not be influenced by any opinion expressed in this appellate order and directed the Tribunal to endeavour to dispose of S.A. No. 528/2012 expeditiously (if possible within three months from the date a copy of this order is placed before it), noting the S.A. was pending since 24th September, 2012.
  • No new judicial precedent was stated to be laid down by the Court; the decision resolves the appeal on the particular facts and statutory application described in the opinion.

Administrative directions: A copy of the order was to be furnished to the parties as per law and sent to the concerned D.R.T.

Show all summary ...

S.N.H Zaidi, Chairperson:— This appeal impugns the order dated 27th September, 2012 of D.R.T-III, Delhi passed in S.A No. 528/2012 titled as Kumar Enterprises v. Asset Reconstruction Company (India) Ltd., whereby the interim relief sought in the S.A has been rejected.

2. The circumstances of the case indicate that respondent No. 2 Bank had sanctioned an overdraft facility of Rs. 19 lacs to the appellants which was renewed for Rs. 10 lacs as overdraft and Rs. 9 lacs as demand loan. The facility was later enhanced and renewed as Cash Credit (Hypothecation) for Rs. 44 lacs in October, 2000 on mortgage of property bearing No. 1/641, Loni Road, Shahdara, Delhi by deposit of its original sale deed. As the loan account became out of order, the respondent No. 2 Bank classified it as Non-Performing Asset (N.P.A) on 31st March, 2002 and filed O.A No. 198/2002 before the D.R.T-III for the recovery of Rs. 54,54,604.48 along with pendente lite and future interest. The D.R.T directed the applicant Bank to maintain the status quo of the mortgaged property by order dated 25th April, 2013 and allowed to continue the order with the condition that the defendants would also not transfer or part with the possession of that property in any manner whatsoever, by order dated 30th May, 2003.

3. During the pendency of the O.A the Bank also issued demand notice dated 31st January, 2003 under Section 13(2) of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (for short, the SARFAESI Act) to the borrower/appellants claiming an amount of Rs. 57,51,365.48 within 60 days but the borrowers failed to pay the claimed amount. The Bank assigned the debt in question to respondent No. 1 Company, namely the Asset Reconstruction Company India Ltd. (A.R.C.I.L), vide assignment deed dated 23rd June, 2008 A.R.C.I.L approached the C.M.M Delhi under section 14 of the sarfaesi act for obtaining the possession of the mortgaged property and the A.C.M.M, Delhi, vide order, dated 14th September, 2012, appointed a Court Receiver for taking the physical possession of that property. The borrower/appellants thereafter filed S.A No. 528/2012 before the Tribunal below challenging the actions of A.R.C.I.L and also sought interim relief qua the possession intended to be taken by the Receiver. The Tribunal below, however, declined to grant the interim relief by the order impugned dated 27th September, 2012. The respondent No. 1 took over physical possession of the property in question through the Court Receiver. Feeling aggrieved with the order of the Tribunal below, the appellants have filed the instant appeal claiming the restoration of possession of the property in question as interim as well as final relief.

4. Mr. M. Dutta, the learned Counsel appearing for the appellants, has mainly urged that the account of the appellants could not have been classified as N.P.A, in view of the then prevailing prudential norms/guidelines issued by the Reserve Bank of India (R.B.I) qua the asset classification and all the measures taken by it pursuant to that classification is bad in law. According to him proper classification of the account as N.P.A is the very basis for the invocation of the provisions of SARFAESI Act as no demand notice under Section 13(2) of the Act can be issued unless the account is classified as N.P.A and unless the demand notice is issued, the secured creditor cannot take any measure for the enforcement of its security interest under Section 13(4) of the Act. He has submitted that, as per the R.B.I guidelines for the Year 2001-2012, the account in respect of the overdraft/cash credit facility could be classified as N.P.A only if it had remained ‘out of order’ for a period of 180 days or more and the definition of ‘out of order’ provides that an account would be treated as ‘out of order’ if the balance remains continuously in excess of the sanctioned limit/drawing power. He has further contended that the statement of account (Annexure A-4) would show that the account was within the sanctioned limit of Rs. 44 lacs up to 21 st September, 2001 and since on 3rd October, 2001 the Bank had sanctioned a temporary overdraft limit (ad hoc limit) of 10% of the sanctioned limit of Rs. 44 lacs, i.e, Rs. 4.4 lacs, for a period of 90 days to the appellant firm, the overall sanctioned limit had enhanced to Rs. 48.4 lacs which was to expire on 1st January, 2002, as such the account could not have been declared as N.P.A on 31 st March, 2002 as the required 180 days had not expired oh that date. Mr. Dutta has also submitted that the said statement of account would also show that the balance in the account had remained within the limit of Rs. 48.4 lacs up to 31st December, 2001 and thereafter it had exceeded the sanctioned limit.

5. Ms. Rungta, however, opposing the above contentions has submitted that the account in question was rightly classified as N.P.A on 31st March, 2002, as it had remained out of order for more than 180 days on that date. She has further stressed that the Bank had never sanctioned any ad hoc limit of Rs. 4.4 lacs on 3rd October, 2001 as alleged by the appellants and this fact has specifically been denied in para. 5.9 (at page 199) of the reply to the appeal. She has also contended that after 22nd September, 2001, the balance in the account had always remained in excess of the sanctioned limit of Rs. 44 lacs and if on any day it had come down to less than Rs. 44 lacs due to deposits of amounts, it has again exceeded the limit on the very day on account of the withdrawal of amounts.

6. I have given my considered thoughts to the submissions of the parties' Counsel qua the question of the classification of account as N.P.A and perused the recorded. In my view mere averment of the appellants that on 3rd October, 2001 the respondent Bank had sanctioned an ad hoc limit of Rs. 4.4 fees is not sufficient to accept that fact, as respondent No. 1 has very categorically denied it in its reply and the appellants have not filed any sanction letter of adhoc limit in support of this contention. A perusal of the statement of account (Annexure A-4) shows that on 3rd October, 2001 an amount of Rs. 8 lacs was deposited in the account, due to which the debit balance had come down to Rs. 37,68,418.48 from Rs. 45,68,418.48 as it stood on 1 st October, 2001 but since on that very day the aforesaid amount of Rs. 8 lacs was withdrawn in three parts, therefore, at the closing on 3rd October, 2001 the debit balance had again gone up to Rs. 45,68,418.48. The contention of the appellants in para 5.9 of the rejoinder does not appear to have any force that if no ad hoc facility was sanctioned, then it was beyond any explanation as to why and how the balance had exceeded the sanctioned limit, because in an overdraft/cash credit facility the balance in the account often exceeds the sanctioned limit but if it continues to remains in excess of the said limit for more than the permitted period, then the account can be classified as N.P.A The next contention of the appellants has also no legs to stand that since up to 31st December, 2001 the balance had remained within Rs. 48.40 lacs, as was enhanced with the sanction of the ad hoc limit, therefore, this circumstance establishes the grant/sanctioning of ad hoc limit, as the statement of account (Annexure A-4) shows that the balance had often exceeded Rs. 48.40 lacs limit during the period between 3rd October, 2001 and 1st January, 2002. I am, therefore, of the considered view that the fact qua the alleged sanctioning of ad hoc limit is not established from the record.

7. In view of above, it is to be seen now whether or not the balance in the account had remained out of order or in excess of the sanctioned limit of Rs. 44 lacs within 180 days prior to 31st March, 2002 the date of N.P.A A perusal of the statement of account (Annexure A-4) shows that the balance had remained in excess of the said limit since 22nd September, 2001 up to the date of N.P.A and if on any day the balance had come down to less than Rs. 44 lacs, it had again exceeded the said limit at the close of that day The account in question is, therefore, held to have been duly classified as N.P.A, in accordance with the then prevailing guidelines of the R.B.I, and the order impugned is not liable to be interfered with on this count.

8. Though the appellants Counsel has not argued qua this ground yet since it has been contended in the appeal that the appellants had sent a response dated 7th April, 2003 to the demand notice dated 31st January, 2003 issued under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act but the respondent Bank, despite its receipt, did not Send any communication about its non-acceptance in compliance of the mandatory requirement of section 13(3a) of the sarfaesi act and had acted in contravention of the said provision, it is being taken up for consideration. A perusal of paras 5.22 and 5.23 of the appeal memo would, however, show that the appellants had only demanded certain documents/information in their response dated 7th April, 2003 and had not made any representation or raised any objection qua the claim of the Bank. In this regard I am in full agreement with the view of the learned Tribunal below that since Sub-section (3A) was inserted in Section 13 of the SARFAESI Act by Act No. 30 of 2004, which came into force with effect from 11th November, 2004, i.e, more than a year after sending the response on 7th April, 2003, therefore, it was not obligatory for the secured creditor under the then law to communicate to the borrower the reasons for the non-acceptance of the representation/objection as the application of the said provisions was prospective and not retrospective. Thus, if the respondent Bank had not given any reply to the response dated 7th April, 2003 of the appellants or failed to furnish the required document/information, it cannot be said to have acted against the provisions of law.

9. In view of the discussion made above, I am of the view that the appellants have failed to show any prima facie case for the interim relief as sought by them and the Tribunal below has committed no error in refusing to grant the same, because it is not in dispute that the appellants had defaulted in repayment of the loan amount and owed a huge sum of more than Rs. 57 lacs to respondent No. 1 as such the secured creditor could not have been restrained from proceeding against the secured asset in accordance with law. Since the physical possession of the property in question has already been taken over by respondent No. 1, the same cannot be allowed to be restored to the appellants during the pendency of the S.A

10. Consequently, this appeal fails and is accordingly dismissed without any order as to cost. It is, however, clarified that the Tribunal below shall not be influenced while disposing of the S.A by any opinion expressed by this Tribunal in this order, which has been made only for the purposes of disposal of this appeal. As the S.A is pending since 24th September, 2012 the Tribunal below is directed to make endeavour for its expeditious disposal, if possible, within three months from the date a copy this order is placed before it.

11. Copy of this order be furnished to the parties as per law and be also sent to the D.R.T concerned.

12. Appeal dismissed.