Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Homi Rajvansh v. Union Of India

Central Administrative Tribunal
Feb 11, 2011

L.K Joshi, Vice Chairman (A):— We are dealing with both the OAs in this common judgement as the Applicant is the same in both Applications and common question of law is involved.

2. Challenge in both the OAs is to the two separate Memoranda of Charge, both dated 22.12.2006, but based on different allegations. The Applicant belongs to Indian Revenue Service and is presently working as Commissioner of Income Tax. The aforesaid Memoranda of Charge have been challenged on the sole ground that these have not been approved by the disciplinary authority, that is, the Union Finance Minister. The learned counsel for the Applicant would contend that the issue is squarely covered by the judgement of this Tribunal in OA number 800/2008 decided on 05.02.2009, B.V Gopinath v. Union of India, which was upheld by the Honourable Delhi High Court in Writ Petition (C) 10452/2009 decided on 28.07.2009 The ratio that the Memorandum of Charge in disciplinary proceeding is not maintainable unless it is approved by the disciplinary authority has been followed by the Tribunal in OA number 1434/2008, S.K Srivastava… v. Union Of India & Others…S, decided on 18.12.2008 and in OA number 2680/2008 and ten other connected OAs, Ashok Kumar Agarwal v. Union of India et cetera decided on 24.02.2010 It could not be disputed by the learned counsel for the Respondents that the issue in the OAs in hand is covered by the aforementioned judgements.

3. In view of the above the Applications are allowed and the impugned Memoranda of Charge dated 22.12.2006 and any consequent proceedings resulting from these are quashed and set aside. However, the Respondents will have the liberty to proceed afresh against the Applicant by issuing fresh Memoranda of Charge in accordance with law. No costs.