- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mohd. Sabir v. Aziz Hoteliers Pvt. Ltd.
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Companies Act — Sections 397/398 et seq.)
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioners filed a company petition under Sections 397 and 398 read with Sections 402, 403 and 406 of the Companies Act, 1956 alleging acts of oppression and mismanagement by Respondent No.1 (the Company) and other respondents. The Company was incorporated on 29/09/1987 as a family company formed by the petitioners and Respondent No.2. The petitioners allege that equal family parity in shareholding was intended, that they and Respondent No.2 contributed funds to acquire Plot No. 244, Habib Ganj, Bhopal and built a commercial building, and that thereafter disputes arose (around 2000 onwards) including alleged clandestine appointment of directors, removal of the petitioners as directors, unlawful transfers of shares and diversion/non-accounting of company income for 2010–2012.
Procedurally, the petitioners had earlier filed Civil Suit No. 22-A/2003 in the District Court, Bhopal to challenge the sale of company property and later sought amendments in that suit to challenge their removal as directors. That civil suit was dismissed under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC and an appeal (F.A. No. 162 of 2004) is pending before the High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Jabalpur. The company petition was filed before this Bench in 2013. Respondents raised preliminary objections as to affidavit/non-compliance with CLB Regulations, delay and laches, and availability of alternate remedy.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petition is maintainable given alleged non-compliance with affidavit requirements under the CLB Regulations (i.e., whether the affidavit defect warrants rejection of the petition).
- Whether the petition is barred by delay and laches, given that the impugned acts (appointments and removals) occurred between 2000–2002 and the petition was filed much later.
- Whether the petition is maintainable when the petitioners have availed an alternate remedy (Civil Suit No. 22-A/2003) involving substantially similar reliefs.
- On the merits, whether (a) appointments of Respondent Nos. 3–5 as directors were clandestine/void, (b) the petitioners were wrongfully removed as directors in breach of Section 284 and the Articles, (c) shares were illegally transferred (including alleged joint "any one or survivor" holdings), and (d) company funds were siphoned/diverted (mismanagement) as alleged for 2010–2012.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The petitioners alleged acts of oppression and mismanagement including clandestine appointment of new directors by Respondent No.2 without notice or resolution, wrongful removal of the petitioners as directors without valid notice and in contravention of Section 284, illegal transfer of shares (including jointly held/share survivor basis) by Respondent No.2 to Respondent Nos. 3–5, and diversion/non-accounting of company income for 2010–2012 indicating siphoning of funds.
- They contended that parity in family shareholding was intended and that they invested personal capital for acquiring property and constructing the building.
- On affidavit defects, petitioners filed fresh affidavits after defects were pointed out and relied on Associated Journals Ltd. v. Mysore Paper Mills Ltd. (Supreme Court) for the proposition that procedural irregularities should not be used to defeat substantive justice.
- On delay, petitioners argued the alleged acts of oppression/mismanagement were continuing (e.g., irregular meetings, non-payment of dividends), and thus the petition remained within time.
- On share transfers, petitioners relied on case law (Smt. Claude-Lila Parulekar v. Sakal Papers Pvt. Ltd.) to argue that transfers of jointly held shares without consent are illegal and liable to be set aside.
Respondents' Arguments
- Respondents denied the allegations of oppression and mismanagement and raised preliminary objections: (a) petition not supported by proper affidavit under CLB Regulations (relying on Mulchand Wahi v. National Paints Pvt. Ltd.); (b) the petition suffers from inordinate unexplained delay and laches (relying on A.P. Jain v. Faridabad Metal Udyog Pvt. Ltd.); and (c) petition is not maintainable because petitioners had availed the alternate remedy of a civil suit (relying on Dr. Mrs. Mrunalini Devi Puar and Pradip Kumar Sengupta decisions).
- On appointments of directors, respondents produced minutes (Annexure R-10, R-11) showing meetings and appointments, statutory forms filed with the ROC and argued appointments and share transfers were made in accordance with the Articles and law (including reference to Section 169 procedure where applicable).
- On removal of petitioners as directors, respondents produced notice (Annexure R-19), acknowledgements (Annexure R-20), postal receipts (Annexure R-21) and the Annual Return filed with ROC (Annexure R-22) showing cessation; they contended proper procedure was followed.
- On share transfers, respondents alleged forgery by the petitioners in the share certificates (adding "any one or survivor") and pointed to company records and a company secretary's report (Annexure Q / Ms. Kavita Bansal) showing no reference to joint holdings.
- On allegations of siphoning/diversion of funds and non-accounting for 2010–2012, respondents denied siphoning, explained the appointment of S.D. Enterprises as a temporary agent (July–Dec 2013) due to medical problems of key persons, produced accounts and said rent collection thereafter resumed by the company; respondents denied transfers to S.D. Enterprises and denied unlawful loans/withdrawals as alleged.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Mulchand Wahi v. National Paints Pvt. Ltd. (Company Cases Vol. 60, p.198) | That an affidavit not in consonance with CLB regulations and lacking proper annexures can be ignored/rejected. | The respondents relied on this authority to urge dismissal for affidavit defects. The Court considered it but, noting that fresh affidavits were filed and invoking the principle that procedure should not defeat justice, declined to dismiss the petition purely on that technical ground. |
| Associated Journals Ltd. v. Mysore Paper Mills Ltd. [2006] AIR SC 2695 | Procedural rules are meant to advance justice and cannot be used to circumvent justice. | The petitioners relied on this Supreme Court decision to counter the affidavit objection. The Court accepted that the rules should not be used to thwart justice and therefore rejected the preliminary objection of dismissal on the technical affidavit point. |
| A.P. Jain v. Faridabad Metal Udyog Pvt. Ltd. [1976] 95 Company Cases 84 | Authority cited in relation to delay/laches as a ground to decline relief under company oppression/mismanagement petitions. | The respondents relied on this case to contend the petition was barred by delay. The Court, after reviewing facts and chronology (events in 2000–2003 and petition filed in 2013), held that the petition suffered unexplained delay and laches and dismissed the petition on that ground. |
| Dr. Mrs. Mrunalini Devi Puar v. Gaekwad Investment Corporation Pvt. Ltd. (Company Cases (1995) Vol. 982, p.899) | Where petitioners have availed alternate remedy, proceedings under Sections 397/398 should not be entertained. | The Court accepted the principle and, having examined the plaint and amendments in Civil Suit No. 22-A/2003, held that the reliefs seeking to challenge removal and seek re-induction as directors could not be considered in the present company petition. |
| Pradip Kumar Sengupta v. Titan Engineering Co. Pvt. Ltd. (Company Cases (1998) Vol. 94, p.825) | Same principle as above regarding availability of alternate remedy barring CLB jurisdiction to entertain the petition. | The Court relied on this line of authority together with Dr. Puar (supra) to decline to consider certain reliefs (removal/re-induction) in the company petition because those matters were being litigated in the civil suit/appeal. |
| Smt. Claude-Lila Parulekar v. Sakal Papers Pvt. Ltd. [2005] Vol. 107 (2) Bom. L.R 818 (SC) | Authority on illegality of transfer of jointly held shares without consent of the joint holder (as relied upon by petitioners). | Petitioners relied on this decision to challenge transfers said to be jointly held. The Court examined documentary evidence and the company secretary's report, found force in respondents' allegation of forgery and the absence of proof of joint holding, and rejected petitioners' claim in relation to the share transfers. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded in a structured manner: it first addressed the preliminary objections and then—despite holding parts of the petition not maintainable—considered merits in view of the parties' full arguments.
Affidavit/Procedural Defect: Respondents argued the petition was not supported by a proper affidavit under CLB Regulations (relying on Mulchand Wahi). The petitioners filed fresh affidavits after defects were pointed out and relied on Associated Journals (procedural rules should not defeat justice). The Court observed the fresh affidavits, acknowledged they were not strictly proper but held that dismissal on that technical ground alone was not appropriate. The preliminary objection on this ground was rejected.
Delay and Laches: The Court noted that the alleged appointments took place in 2000, removals in 2002, and the petition was filed in 2013. The petitioners had knowledge of their removal and had earlier filed a civil suit in 2003 and amended it to challenge removals. The Court reiterated the established proposition that while limitations law does not strictly apply to Section 397/398 petitions, delay and laches are important in maintainability. Concluding that the petition had an unexplained and inordinate delay and no cogent explanation for the delay, the Court held that the petition suffered from delay and laches and deserved dismissal on this ground.
Alternate Remedy / Res Sub Judice: The respondents relied on authorities holding that where an alternate remedy has been availed, CLB should not entertain a petition under Sections 397/398. The Court examined the plaint and amendments of Civil Suit No. 22-A/2003 and found that the civil suit (and its appeal) covered the reliefs challenging removal and seeking re-induction as directors. On that basis, the Court held that those reliefs could not be considered in the present company petition.
Merits — Appointments of Respondent Nos.3–5: Petitioners alleged clandestine appointments and false Form 32 filings. Respondents produced minutes (Annexures R-10 & R-11) showing extraordinary general meeting and AGM appointment/confirmation of directors and noted filing of statutory forms with ROC. The Court observed that while respondents did not produce notice dispatch proof, records filed with ROC and the long delay in challenging the appointments (11 years) made it difficult to accept petitioners' challenge. Considering companies are required to preserve records only for eight years, and that statutory forms had been filed, the Court rejected the challenge to the appointments as an act of oppression.
Merits — Removal of Petitioners as Directors: The petitioners challenged removal as being without valid notice and in contravention of Section 284 and Articles. Respondents produced minutes (Annexure R-12), notices (Annexure R-19), acknowledgements/postal receipts (Annexures R-20/R-21) and the Annual Return filed with ROC (Annexure R-22) showing cessation. The Court noted that the issue was also subject matter of the civil suit dismissed under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC and an appeal is pending; therefore the Court refrained from rendering any finding on the validity of the removals (i.e., did not decide the core validity due to parallel proceeding and appeal).
Merits — Share Transfers: Petitioners alleged illegal transfers of jointly held shares (on "any one or survivor" basis) by Respondent No.2 to Respondent Nos.3–5. Respondents alleged forgery in share certificates and pointed to absence of any indication of joint holdings in company balance-sheets, income-tax correspondence, annual returns and a company secretary's report (Annexure Q). The petitioners filed no rejoinder addressing these assertions. The Court found sufficient force in respondents' case suggesting forgery and noted the long delay; it rejected the petitioners' claim regarding illegal share transfers.
Merits — Alleged Siphoning / Mismanagement (2010–2012): Petitioners alleged non-accounting of income and diversion of funds, loans advanced to directors without board approval, erosion of reserves and diversion to personal purchases, and a change directing rent cheques to S.D. Enterprises. Respondents denied siphoning, explained the appointment of S.D. Enterprises as a temporary agent (July–Dec 2013) due to medical infirmities, produced supporting material and said rent collection reverted to the company from January 2014. The Court found no convincing evidence of siphoning or mismanagement for personal benefit and noted absence of documentary support for petitioners' allegations. It also noted that petitioners had not included non-payment of dividends as a formal complaint in their petition (it arose during oral argument) and that respondents said steps were being taken to pay dividends given medical and death-related difficulties.
Overall Analytical Conclusion: On preliminaries the petition was partly held not maintainable (insofar as reliefs covered by the civil suit), and on delay/laches the petition was found to suffer unexplained delay. On merits the Court rejected the appointments challenge, refrained on removal due to parallel pending proceedings, rejected the share-transfer complaint due to evidence of possible forgery and delay, and found no convincing evidence of siphoning/mismanagement. The cumulative outcome was dismissal of the company petition.
Holding and Implications
The Company Petition is DISMISSED.
Implications (direct consequences on the parties, as stated in the opinion):
- The Company Petition (C.P.) is dismissed.
- Any ad-interim order, if existing, is vacated; any pending interim applications (C.A.) are disposed of.
- No order as to costs was made.
- Copy of the order shall be issued to the parties.
- The Court specifically held that reliefs challenging the petitioners' removal as directors and seeking re-induction could not be entertained in the present petition because those issues were raised in Civil Suit No. 22-A/2003 and its appeal; the Court refrained from deciding on the validity of the removals for that reason.
The opinion does not state that it is laying down any new legal precedent; the decision applies existing authorities and the facts of the case to dismiss the petition.
1. Being aggrieved by the alleged acts of oppression and mismanagement complained of in the Petition, the Petitioners have filed the present petition invoking the jurisdiction of this Bench conferred upon it by virtue of Sections 397, 398 read with Sections 402, 403 and 406 of the Indian Companies Act, 1956 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act” in short). The Petitioners have sought various reliefs as contained in the petition.
2. The brief facts leading to file the present petition as set out in the petition are as follows:—
2.1 That the Respondent No. 1 Company (hereinafter referred to as “the Company” in short), which carries on business of acquiring, constructing, erecting, managing, promoting or in other way and in all aspects carry on business of deal in hotel, motel, lodging, boarding houses, restaurants, case and other allied activities, was incorporated on 29/09/1987, with the Registrar of Companies, Madhya Pradesh, Gwalior. The Company is a family company which has been incorporated by the Petitioners and Respondent No. 2 for the benefit of the Petitioners and the Respondent No. 2 and other family members.
2.2 It is the case of the Petitioners that at the time of incorporation, all the four Promoter Directors of the Company were having equal shareholding of 1 Share of Rs. 1000/- each out of 2500 equity shares of Rs. 1000/- each and 500 preferential shares of Rs. 1000/- each. It was the intention of all the promoter directors of the Company that parity in the family shall be maintained with equal shareholding of each in the company, and that the company shall be for the equal benefit of all the four branches of family.
2.3 It is further case of the Petitioners that the main intention of Incorporation of the Company was to purchase a property, being vacant Plot No. 244, Scheme Major Shopping Centre Zone-1, Habib Ganj, Bhopal, admeasuring 8000 sq. ft. (743.2 sq. meters), on behalf of the Company. Further, it was the intention of the Petitioners and Respondent No. 2 that the rent from the said property shall be enjoyed by the Petitioners and Respondent No. 2, being the Promoter Directors of the Company, The said property was purchased by all the Petitioners on behalf of the Company by putting their own personal capital, as described in paragraph 17 of the Petition.
2.4 According to the case of the Petitioners, after purchase of the said vacant plot, a commercial building was constructed thereon with the funds brought by the Petitioners to the extent of more than Rs. 15 lakhs. It is further alleged by the Petitioners, for construction of the said building the Company availed a loan of Rs. 18.75 lakhs for which the Petitioner and Respondent No. 2 stood as Personal Guarantors.
2.5 It is further stated that looking into the investments made by the Petitioners and Respondent No. 2 the Company had allotted following shares with joint shareholding with the other directors.
(i) Mohd. Sabir (Petitioner No. 1) : 320½ (ii) Mohd. Anis [Petitioner No. 2) : 487 (iii) Mohd. Ayaz (Petitioner No. 3) : 487 (iv) Mohd. Aziz (Respondent No. 2) : 710½
2.6 It appears that in or around November, 2000 the dispute arose between the Petitioners on one side and the Respondent No. 2 on the other side. As a result thereof, the Petitioners were removed as directors of the Company and the Respondent Nos. 3 to 5 were inducted as directors of the Company. The genesis of the dispute leading to filing various litigation arose when the Respondent No. 2 sold the company's property for the alleged consideration of Rs. 13 lakhs, which according to the Petitioners, valued more than Rs. 20 lakhs at that point of time. Feeling aggrieved thereby the Petitioners approached the District Court, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh and filed a suit challenging the said sale in favour of one Mehamooda Bai and for cancellation of Sale Deed, in which suit the Petitioners also challenged various other acts committed by the Respondents in the conduct of affairs of the Company. The suit is still pending before the Hon'ble High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Jabalpur, However, the Petitioners, being aggrieved by certain acts of oppression and mismanagement, has also approached this Board by way of filing the present petition. The main grievances raised in the petition by the Petitioners against the Respondents are us follows:
a. Firstly, the Respondent No. 2 has clandestinely and without intimating and adopting due process of law to the Petitioners, appointed the Respondent Nos. 3 to 5 as Directors and uploaded a false Form 32 on the Website of the ROC.
b. Secondly, the Respondents have wrongfully and illegally removed the Petitioners as the Directors of the Company, According to the Petitioners, they were not given any valid notice and the Respondents have acted in contravention of the provisions contained in Section 284 of the Act.
c. Thirdly, the shares were illegally transferred by the Respondent No. 2 to the Respondent Nos. 3 to 5 which were jointly held by the Petitioners and the Respondent No. 2, and he had no authority to transfer the said shares to the Respondent Nos. 3 to 4 as the said shares were jointly held by them and Respondent No. 2.
d. Lastly, the income earned by the Company in the years 2010, 2011 and 2012 have not been accounted for appropriately in the balance sheet of the Company and the Respondents have diverted huge funds of the Company to their personal benefits.
3. Based on the above complaints, the Petitioners have sought the following reliefs in the petition:—
a) To pass appropriate orders and directions u/s. 397, 393 r/w Sections 402, 403 & 406 of the Act as this Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper;
b) To pass an order removing the Respondent Nos. 2 to 5 as Directors of the Respondent No. 1 Company and to grant permanent order of injunction restraining the Respondent Nos. 2 to 5 from directly or indirectly, or in any manner whatsoever acting as and/or holding himself/herself out and/or representing himself/herself to be a Director of the Respondent No. 1 company and/or from in any manner exercising any of the rights, powers, authorities and/or privileges of Director of the Respondent No. 1 Company;
c) To a how the Petitioners to be inducted as Directors on the Board of the Respondent Company;
d) To de-bar the Respondent Nos. 2 to 5 from active management in the Respondent Company;
e) To re-arrange the shareholding of the Respondent No. 1 Company as per its the original share certificate;
f) For direction to the Respondents to produce the complete accounts with respect to the income of the Respondent Company accrued from the rent and other sources of past 15 years etc.
4. In reply, the Respondents have denied all the charges relating to the alleged acts of oppression and mismanagement levelled against them by the Petitioners. They have also raised preliminary objections challenging the maintainability of the Petition and seeking its dismissal at the threshold stage without entering into the merits of the case.
5. I have heard the Ld. Counsels appearing on behalf of both the Parties and perused the record. I would first like to deal with the preliminary objections raised on behalf of the Respondents. Dealing with the first preliminary objection, it was argued that the petition is not supported with a proper affidavit as required under the CLB Regulations. Placing reliance on the decision of the Hon'ble Punjab & Haryana High Court in the case of Mulchand Wahi v. National Paints Pvt. Ltd. Company Cases Vol. 60, page 198, the Ld. Counsel appearing for the Respondents submitted that an Affidavit, which is not in consonance with the CLB regulations and does not have proper annexures, is liable to be ignored/rejected, and hence, the petition deserves to be dismissed on this ground alone.
6. In reply, on behalf of the Petitioners, it was argued that pursuant to order dated 20/02/2014 passed by the CLB, fresh Affidavits have been filed by the Petitioners, wherein they have stated that whatever information given is true to their personal knowledge and belief. Placing reliance on the decisions rendered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Associated Journals Ltd. v. Mysore Paper Mills Ltd.. [2006] AIR SC 2695, whereby it was held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court that rules of procedure are meant to advance the cause of justice and thus rules of procedure cannot be a tool to circumvent justice. The said preliminary objection is liable to be rejected being untenable.
7. I have considered the rival submissions. It may be mentioned that after the defects were pointed out to the Petitioners, a fresh affidavit was filed on their behalf. Although, it is correct to say that the fresh affidavit too is not strictly proper, however, in my opinion, merely on this technical ground, it does not seem proper to reject the Company Petition.
8. The next preliminary objection contended on behalf of the Respondents is that the Petition suffers from acute unexplained delay and laches and hence, the same is liable to be dismissed for the said reason. Taking me through the petition, the Ld. Counsel, appearing on behalf of the Respondents, submitted that admittedly the Respondent Nos. 3 and 4 were inducted as the directors in the year 2000 and the Respondent No. 5 was inducted as a Director in the year 2004. Further, the Petitioners were removed as the Directors of the Company in the year 2002, However, they did not prefer to file a petition under Section 397/398 of the Act, raising the said grievances despite having knowledge of the said facts for more than 11 years. Further, according to the Ld. Counsel, no explanation has been offered on behalf of the Petitioners for the said delay and hence, the Petition suffers from acute delay and laches and is thus liable to be dismissed on this ground also. To support this contention, the Ld. Counsel, appearing on behalf of the Respondents, has placed reliance on the decision in the case of A.P Jain v. Faridabad Metal Udyog Pvt. Ltd. [1976] 95 Company Cases 84.
9. On the other side, the Ld. Counsel, appearing on behalf of the Petitioners, has argued that the act of oppression and mismanagement is continuous one. Taking me through the averments made in the petition, the Ld. Counsel for the Petitioners pointed out that the Company is not holding regular meetings, and that the dividends of the shareholders are not being paid till date. The Ld. Counsel contended that the said acts of oppression are still persisting, and therefore, the petition is well within time. According to the Ld. Counsel, there is no delay as such on the part of the Petitioners to approach this Bench, and hence, the preliminary objection with regard to delay and laches raised on behalf of the Respondents is without substance and is liable to be rejected.
10. I have considered the aforesaid preliminary objection raised by the Respondents. It is an undisputed fact that the grievances made by the Petitioners against the Respondents relating to alleged illegal appointment of the Respondent Nos. 3 to 5 as Directors and the illegal removal of the Petitioners as the Directors of the Company had happened in the year 2000 and 2002, respectively. It is not the case of the Petitioners that they did not have knowledge of their removal as the Directors of the Company prior to filing of the present petition. Despite having such knowledge, they did not choose to approach the Company Law Board by way of filing a petition under Section 397, 398 of the Act until 2013. Instead, they chose to file a civil suit in the year 2003 challenging the sale of the Company's Assets and later on also challenged their removal by way of seeking amendments in their Civil Suit. Thus, it is clear that not only the Petition is filed at a highly belated stage, but the Petitioners have also failed to give any cogent and reliable explanation for the delay in filing the instant petition before the CLB. It is an established proposition of law that though the provisions of Law of Limitation do not apply in the proceedings under Section 397/398 of the Act, yet the delay and laches play an important and vital role in determining the maintainability of the Petition. I, therefore, hold that the petition surfers from unexplained delay and laches and therefore, the Petition deserve to be dismissed on this ground also.
11. In addition to the above, I have also considered another contention raised by the Respondents that since the Petitioners have availed the alternate remedy by way of Filing civil suit being No. 22-A/2003 in the Court of Hon'ble District Judge, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, for the same reliefs, a copy of Plaint of the said Civil Suit is filed as Annexure-“M” to the petition, therefore, the petition under Section 397/398 is not maintainable as held in the cases of Dr. Mrs. Mrunalini Devi Puar v. Gaekwad Investment Corporation Pvt. Ltd. Company Cases (1995) Vol. 982, Page 899 and Pradip Kumar Sengupta v. Titan Engineering Co. Pvt. Ltd. Company Cases (1998) Vol. 94, Page 825. In the aforesaid decisions, it has been held that where the Petitioners have availed alternate remedy, in that case the proceedings under Section 397/398 of the Act before the CLB should not be entertained.
12. I have examined copy of the plaint pertaining to the said civil suit available on record. From perusal of copy of the plaint, it is clear that the Petitioners herein/Plaintiffs in the said Suit have challenged the sale of Company's property in favour of one Ms. Mehmoodabai (Defendant No. 1 in the Suit). It is matter of record that the Petitioners/Plaintiffs, during the pendency of their Appeal being F.A No. 162 of 2004, moved an application for amendment whereby the Petitioners/Plaintiffs have also challenged their illegal removal as the Directors of the Respondent No. 1 Company. It is to be noted that by way of amendment they have sought to plead that the alleged resolution passed by the Defendant No. 3.Respondent No. 2 herein (now deceased) alone in the name of the Board of Directors on 31/07/2002 thereby removing the Petitioners/Plaintiffs from the directorship of the Respondent No. 1 Company is illegal and void in view of Clause 24 of Articles of Association of the Company which provides that the Directors named in Clause 23 shall not be liable to retirement by rotation, provided that if any of them resigns his office or dies, the remaining Director(s) may appoint such other person(s) as they may think fit as Director(s). It is further sought to be added in the suit that since the Plaintiffs are one of the four Directors named in Clause 23 of the Articles of Association and therefore, they could not be removed from the directorship in view of the specific embargo created by Clause 24 of the Articles dissociation.
13. Further, the Petitioners/Plaintiffs by way of amendment sought to challenge the induction of Amna Bi, Khurshid Bano, Khurshid Jahan (Respondent No. 2) and Zamrund Imtiyaz (Respondent No. 3) as Directors of the Company stating that the sole resolution passed by the Defendant No. 3.Respondent No. 2 herein (now deceased) is illegal and void, and therefore, the sale deed under challenge purportedly executed by the Defendant No. 3.Respondent No. 2 herein (now deceased) in favour of the Defendant No. 1 in the said Suit Ms. Mehmoodabai is illegal and, unauthorized and does not create any right, title or interest in her favour.
14. In addition to the above, in the prayer clause of the Suit also the Petitioners/Plaintiffs have proposed to add a new relief thereby seeking an order to declare the resolution passed by the Defendant No. 3.Respondent No. 2 herein (now deceased) dated 31/07/2002 as null and void and ineffective and also that the Petitioners/Plaintiffs are entitled to continue to remain as Directors of the Respondent No. 1 Company, without any break in their tenure as Directors, it seems that the Application for amendment was allowed Vide an order dated 23/07/2003 and the said pleadings are now thus the subject matter of the said suit.
15. In view of the above, I am not Inclined to accept the contention of the Petitioners' Counsel that the subject matter of the dispute as contained in the aforesaid Civil Suit No. 22-A/2003 decided by the IX Additional District Judge, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, and the First Appeal No. 162 of 2004 which is filed and pending in the High Court of Madhya Pradesh Jabalpur against the dismissal order dated 6/11/2003 passed by the IX Additional District Judge in the said suit and the subject matter of the present petition are not the same. It is further incorrect to say that the reliefs sought for in the present petition do not form the subject matter of the proceedings of the said Civil Suit/Appeal and hence both the decisions referred to above do not apply to the facts and circumstances of the present case. The said contention raised on behalf of the Respondents is, liable to be accepted. Therefore, In so far as the reliefs sought for by the Petitioners challenging their removal as the Directors of the Company and seeking their re-induction as Directors of the Company, in my opinion, cannot be considered by this Board in the present Company Petition filed under Section 397/398 of the Act, as held in the cases of Dr. Mrs. Mrunalini Devi Puar (Supra) and Pradip Kumar Sengupta (Supra).
16. Although, I have held that the Petition is not maintainable as stated herein above, nevertheless, taking in to consideration that the Petition was argued on merits also, I proceed to consider the petition on the merits.
17. The first charge levelled by the Petitioners against the Respondents is that the Respondents have, with malafide intention to acquire the Respondent No. 1 Company, wrongfully and illegally appointed the Respondent Nos. 3 to 5 as the Directors of the Company, in this connection it is argued by the Ld. Counsel, appearing for the Petitioners, that on 27/11/2000, the Respondent No. 2 clandestinely and without intimating the Petitioners, who were at the relevant time Directors of the Company, uploaded a false Form No. 32 on the website of the ROC reflecting therein the appointment of the Respondent Nos. 3 and 4 as Additional Directors of the Company. It is further contended that the Petitioners were not given any notice of the meeting of agenda of the meeting. Further, these was no Resolution passed for appointment of these Respondents as Additional Directors of the Company. It is further contended by the Ld. Counsel that the said appointment was in contravention of Section 289 of the Companies Act, and Articles 26, 32, 33, 35 and 36 of the Articles of Association of the Company. Therefore, the Ld. Counsel submitted that the appointment of these Respondents is void ab initio and therefore, deserves to be set aside.
18. Responding to the said charge, it was submitted on behalf of the Respondents that the Respondent No. 3 is the second wife of the Respondent No. 2 and she was appointed as an additional Director of the Company on 27/11/2000 as shown in the Form No. 32 filed as Annexure-“J” with the Petition. In addition to above, one share from Mohd. Aziz (Respondent No. 2) was transferred to her on 28/8/2000. The Ld. Counsel further submitted that the appointment of the Respondent No. 3 as a Director of the Company was made in accordance with its Articles of Association. To support his arguments, the Ld. Counsel invited my attention to Annexure “R-10, which is the copy of the Minutes of the Meeting held on 10/3/2001, to show that the Respondent No. 3 was appointed as a Director w.e.f 10/05/2001, upto the next Annual General Meeting. From the perusal of Annexure R-11, copy of the Minutes of the Annual General Meeting held on 28/9/2001, it is revealed that the Respondent No. 2 was made a permanent Director. Similarly, the Respondent No. 4 was appointed as a Director or the Company in accordance with law, and the transfer of shares have also been properly made, as apparent from the said Minutes. The Ld. Counsel further submits that the Respondent No. 5 is the maternal-grandson of the Respondent No. 2, who was appointed as a Director on 1/5/2004 and 809 shares from the Respondent No. 2 were transferred to him on 30/4/2007 in accordance with the Articles of Association. The Ld. Counsel, therefore, submits that the challenge made by the Petitioners as to the appointment of the Respondent Nos. 3 to 5 as the Directors of the Company is without any basis and therefore, the said charge deserves to be rejected.
19. I have considered the rival submissions and examined the documents carefully. Perusal of Minutes of the Extra Ordinary General Meeting held on 10/3/2001 at 1.00 P.M, a copy of which is filed as Annexure ‘R-10’ to the Reply of the Respondents, reveal that the Notice convening the Meeting was duly sent to the Directors on 27/12/2000 by the major shareholder Mohd. Aziz, Respondent No. 2 herein (since deceased). The said minutes state that when after passing 45 days, no meeting was convened, the Respondent No. 2 convened this meeting as per the provisions of Section 169 of the Companies Act, 1956. The said Minutes further goes to show that in the said Meeting, Smt. Khurshid Bano and Smt. Zamrud Imtiyaz (the Respondent Nos. 3 and 4, respectively, herein) were appointed as the Directors, in addition to Smt. Amna Bai and Smt. Khurshid Jahan, with effect from 10/5/2001 until the next Annual General Meeting. It is further noted that in the next AGM held on 28/9/2001 these Directors were made permanent, which is corroborated from the Minutes dated 28/9/2001, a copy of which is filed as Annexure ‘R-11’ to the Reply by the Respondents.
20. This is true that the Respondents have failed to produce the copy of the Notices along with the proof of dispatch of such notices to prove that the Notices were sent to the Petitioners. However, it is to be kept in mind that the Petitioners have challenged these appointments after a period of 11 years. A company is supposed to maintain its record for a period of 8 years only, as contemplated in the Companies (Preservation and Disposal of Records) Rules 1966. Therefore, non production of a copy of the Notice and the postal receipts as proof of dispatch thereof, in my opinion, cannot be held fatal to the case of the Respondents taking into consideration the inordinate delay in challenging the said act by the Petitioners. It is also to be kept in mind that the statutory forms pertaining to the appointments of the said Directors were filed by the Company with the ROC immediately after appointments of the said Directors. It is, therefore, difficult to believe that in the fast 11 years, the Petitioners did not come to know about induction of the Respondent Nos. 3 to 5 as the Directors on the Board of Directors of the Company, particularly when their relations with the Respondent No. 2 were not cordial and various litigations between them were going on with respect to the affairs of the company. For the said reasons, in my opinion, this alleged act of oppression, cannot be accepted, and the same deserves to be rejected. It is rejected accordingly.
21. Now, I proceed to consider the next complaint made by the Petitioners regarding their illegal removal as the Directors of the Company by the Respondents. With respect to this complaint, it was submitted on behalf of the Petitioners that the Petitioners were not given any valid notice under Section 284 of the Act. Further, the Petitioners were never served with any Special Notice for passing resolution for their removal as the Directors of the Company, Moreover, they were not given an opportunity to be heard at the meeting in accordance with the provisions contained in sub-Section (3) of Section 284 of the Act. Inviting my attention to the Annexure ‘R-12’, relied by the Respondents to show by the Minutes of the Meeting dated 31/7/2002 that a valid resolution was passed for removal of the Petitioners as the Directors of the Company, the Ld. Counsel for the Petitioners submitted that the said minutes do not show the presence of the Petitioners in the meeting, wherein their removal was considered and the Resolution was passed in that regard. It was further submitted that the Respondents have, thus, acted in contravention of the provisions contained in Section 284(2) & (3) of the Act. Further, the Articles of Association of the Company specifically provide that there shall be no removal of Directors by way of rotation. It was further submitted that there is nothing on record to show that the Petitioners have ever tendered their resignations to the company. It was, therefore, argued that the removal of the Petitioners from the office of Directors of the Company is wrongful and illegal.
22. Refuting the aforesaid contentions, the Ld. Counsel, appearing on behalf of the Respondents, submitted that having come to know the various misconducts committed by the Petitioners as the Directors of the Company, which according to the Respondents were detrimental to the interest of the Company, the Petitioners were removed after following proper procedure prescribed under the law. To substantiate the said version, the Ld. Counsel drew my attention to the Annexure ‘R-12’ i.e the Minutes of the AGM dated 31/7/2002, wherein the Resolutions for removal of Mr. Mohd. Sabir, Mr. Mohd. Anis and Mr. Mohd. Ayaz, the Petitioners herein, were passed. Thereafter, the Ld. Counsel invited my attention to the Annexure ‘R-19’, copy of the Notice dated 25/6/2002 Informing the members for holding AGM on 31/7/2002 at 11 A.M, in which the Resolutions for removal of the Petitioners were proposed. Vide Annexure ‘R-20’, the Respondents have filed the duly signed Acknowledgement Dues, which have been relied on by the Respondents, to show that the said notices were delivered to the Petitioners, Annexure ‘R-21’ is the photocopy of the postal receipts/Speed Post receipts to prove that these notices were dispatched to the Petitioners on 2/7/2002. Thereafter, the Ld. Counsel for the Respondents, drew my attention to the Annexure ‘R-22’ i.e the photocopy of the Annual Return dated 31/7/2002 filed with the ROC on 27/2/2003, whereby the Petitioners have been shown as ceased to be the Directors of the Company and by the same filing the appointment of the Respondent Nos. 3 and 4 as Directors has been shown.
23. From a close scrutiny of the aforesaid documents, in fight of the rival submissions, It is clear that the appropriate forms were filed by the Company with the ROC in the year 2003. The Petitioners, admittedly, did not raise this issue nor made any complaint since 2003 until 2013. In my opinion, raising this grievance after such a huge unexplained delay cannot be accepted. Further, as pointed out, this issue is the subject matter of the Civil Suit No. No. 22-A/2003 filed by the Petitioners herein against the Respondents before the Ld. District Judge, Bhopal. In the said Civil Suit, the Petitioners have sought reliefs to set aside resolution by which they were removed as the Directors. The said suit has been dismissed under Section 7 Rule 11 C.P.C However, an Appeal filed by the Petitioners is pending in the Hon'ble High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Jabalpur. Therefore, keeping in view the aforesaid facts, I would like to refrain myself from rendering any finding as to the validity of the removal of the Petitioners as the Directors.
24. The next grievance ventilated by the Petitioners against the Respondents is that the Respondent No. 2 (since deceased), who was the father of the Petitioners, in his lifetime, illegally transferred the shares of the Petitioners to the Respondent Nos. 3 to 5. Drawing my attention to the Share Certificates filed along with the Petition, the Ld. Counsel appearing on behalf of the Petitioners submitted that from the bare perusal of the said certificates, it may be noted that the Petitioners were the owners of the shares allotted to them. Furthermore, the shares held by the Petitioners with the Respondent No. 2 were joint and “any one or survivor” basis. It was submitted that since the Petitioners and the Respondent No. 2 were alive when the said shares were purportedly transferred to the Respondent Nos. 3 to 5, the said transfer could have been done only jointly by the Petitioners and the Respondent No. 2, According to the Ld. Counsel, in the instant case, the Respondent No. 2 took undue advantage of his relationship with the Petitioners of being their father and grandfather of the Respondent Nos. 3 to 5 and has not only wrongfully transferred the said shares of the Petitioner and the Respondent No. 2 held jointly by them to the Respondent Nos. 3 to 5, but also illegally transferred the shares which were solely held by the Petitioners to the Respondent Nos. 3 to 5. Placing reliance on the decision in the Case of Smt. Claude-Lila Parulekar v. Sakal Papers Pvt. Ltd. [2005] Vol. 107 (2) Bom. L.R 818 (SC), the Ld. Counsel submitted that the illegal transfer of the shares jointly held by the Petitioners and the Respondent No. 2, by the Respondent No. 2 in favour of the Respondent Nos. 3 to 5 without the consent and knowledge of the Petitioners, is illegal and liable to be set aside.
25. Responding to the said allegation, it was argued on behalf of the Respondents that the Petitioners have committed forgery in the share certificates. According to the Ld. Counsel for the Respondents, the original certificates were in their possession and they have added words “any one or Survivor” in the said certificates.
26. Further, according to the Ld. Counsel for the Respondents, from perusal of the balance-sheets from 1987 onwards, it may be noted that in none of the balance-sheets, the shares of the Respondent No. 2 (Since deceased) have been shown to be joint holdings. Furthermore, in the tetter dated 10/1/1996 field as Annexure R-2 with the Reply sent by the Respondent No. 2 (since deceased) to the Assistant Commissioner of Income tax, there is no reference to any of the joint holding of the shares. In question with the Petitioners. The Ld. Counsel further pointed out that in the Annual Return upto 27/05/1992 there is no reference of joint holdings. Similarly, right from the very beginning in the statutory returns submitted before the ROC, there is no reference of joint holding of the shares of the Respondent No. 2. In addition to the above, the Petitioners themselves have filed one report of Ms. Kavita Bansal, Company Secretary, filed as Annexure-Q, and even in this report, there is no reference of any joint holding of shares. It was, therefore, contended that this report itself supports the case of the Respondents that the Petitioners have made forgery in the share certificates by adding the words “joint” and “anyone or survivor”. It was, therefore, argued that the Petitioners have forged the said share certificates and added therein words “any one or survivor” in the said share certificates. They were never joint holders of the impugned share certificates. The Respondent No. 2 was the only legal owner and tide holder of the share certificate, which he validly transferred to Respondent Nos. 3 and 5, and hence, any contention contrary to the above, is liable to be rejected being devoid of merits, 27. I have considered the rival submissions and carefully examined the documents referred to by the Respondents in support of their defence. It is pertinent to mention here that the Petitioners have not filed rejoinder in rebuttal of the facts stated by the Respondents referred to herein above. There is no answer to the question as to why Ms. Kavita Bansal, Company Secretary, in her own report has not given any reference of joint holding of the shares. Therefore, I find enough force in the case of the Respondents that the Petitioners have committed forgery in the share certificates as alleged by the Respondents. Once again, I would like to reiterate here that these shares were transferred long back i.e in or about 2002. The Petitioners kept silent for all these 11 years. Therefore, at this belated stage, their aforesaid complaint appears to me as an afterthought. It therefore, deserves to be rejected. It is rejected accordingly.
28. The next allegation made by the Petitioners, which is according to them, is an act of oppression and mismanagement purportedly committed by the Respondents in the conduct of the affairs of the Company, is siphoning of its funds for their personal benefits. In this connection, it was submitted that the Respondents have been engaged in siphoning of funds, which is reflected by the fact that the income earned by the Company in the years 2010, 2011 and 2012 has not been accounted for appropriately in the Balance Sheets of the Company. It was further pointed that the loans to the extent of Rs. 1,26,754/- and Rs. 3,98,000/- have been advanced to the Directors of the Company without any approval of the Board of Directors of the Company. In addition to the above, the cash in hand of Rs. 13,50,437/- show in the Balance Sheet of the year 2010-2011 and the same should have been utilized for the repayment of Secured Loans in order to save interest and penalties. Further, according to the Petitioners, the Surplus and Reserves of the Company have reduced over the years and inspite of erosion of surpluses and reserves, the Respondents have acquired expensive cars and incurred other expenses at the cost and to the detriment of the Company and the Petitioners, being its shareholders. The Ld. Counsel further submitted that after filing of the present petition, the Company has issued a notice to all the lessees/licensees/tenants which states that henceforth all the rent cheques should be drawn in the name of S.D Enterprises, and that all the security deposit being held in the name of the Company will stand transferred to the name of S.D Enterprises. On behalf of the Petitioners, it was contended that the aforesaid change was being caused without informing the shareholders and for the purpose of causing loss to the Company and the Petitioners. The Ld. Counsel, therefore, submitted that by these acts of the Respondents, it is apparent that the Respondents are trying to divert the funds of the Company to their own use. It is further submitted that the Company has not paid any dividends to the Petitioners, which fact was also admitted at the time of oral submissions on behalf of the Respondents while answering the query made by the Bench.
29. On behalf of the Respondents, it is denied that the Respondents have reduced the Reserves and Surpluses from Rs. 26 lakhs to Rs. 16 lakhs and thus sum of Rs. 10 lakhs has been siphoned away. It is contended that this is a bald statement made by the Petitioners without any basis or supporting documents. The Respondents have further denied that any loan of Rs. 48 lakhs has been availed as alleged by the Petitioners. According to the Ld. Counsel, in fact a loan of only Rs. 30 lakhs was availed by the Company for making payment of property tax etc. The Respondents have further denied having availed any other loan. According to the Respondents, the security deposit that was being received from the tenants and which is refundable to them, was kept in Fixed Deposit for the benefit of the Company.
30. The Respondents' Counsel also denied the allegation that the Respondents are in process of changing the name of the Company. According to the Respondents, they have not transferred any amount of the Company to S.D Enterprises. The Ld. Counsel appearing for the Respondents tried to demonstrate from the documents available on record that the rent is being collected by cheques only in the name of the Respondent No. 1 Company.
31. On behalf of the Respondents, it was further argued that the Respondent No. 2 (Since deceased) was suffering from various ailments and other directors also suffered medical problems, therefore, the Respondents appointed an Agent for the time being in the month of July 2013 for the purpose of collection of rent from the 40 tenants and they were to be regularly approached and reminders had to be given to them. Apart from this, regular maintenance of the building including the electricity maintenance, water supply, security and cleaning of the building was also required to be attended and looking to these problems, for a limited period the said Agent S.D Enterprises was appointed to collect the rent from July, 2013 till December 2013. According to the Ld. Counsel, the said Agent had submitted the accounts to the Respondent No. 1. In fact, the said Agent during the said period also paid the property tax to the Municipal Corporation Bhopal. According to the Ld. Counsel, in December, 2013 the said agency has been terminated. Inviting my attention to various documents, it was argued that from January, 2014 the entire rent is being collected by the Respondent No. 1 directly. It was, therefore, contended that the allegations of siphoning of funds are bald, vague and not supported with any documentary evidence and hence, these allegations are liable to be rejected being devoid of substance.
32. Having given my serious thoughts to the rival submissions and upon a critical examination of the documents, I do not find any convincing evidence to the effect that the Respondents are mismanaging the affairs of the Company for their personal benefits. From the medical certificates filed by the Respondents, it appears that the Respondent No. 2 was seriously sick and the Respondent No. 3 was also suffering from cancer, and in these Circumstances, if the Respondents had to appoint S.D Enterprises as a agent for collection of rent from the tenants, that cannot be said as an act of mismanagement. There is no material available on record which may lead to conclusion that the Respondents have siphoned off the funds of the Company for their own use, 33. It is to be noted here that the Petitioners have not made any complaint in their petition with respect to non payment of dividends to them. In the course of arguments, the CLB had raised a query to the Respondents' Counsel as to why the dividends are not being paid to the Petitioners who are admittedly being the shareholders of the company, to which the Ld. Counsel replied that on account of the illness of the Respondent Nos. 2 and 3, and thereafter, due to the death of the Respondent No. 2, the Petitioners' dividends could not be paid, however, the company is taking steps to make payment of dividends to the Petitioners.
34. Based on the above discussions, I have come to the conclusion that the Petitioners have failed to make out any case for the alleged act of oppression and mismanagement in the affairs of the Company as defined under Section 397/398 of the Act. The petition has no merits. The same is, therefore, liable to be dismissed. Order is thus:—
a. The C.P is dismissed.
b. The ad-interim order, if any, stands vacated. Pending C.A, if any stand disposed off.
c. No order to costs.
d. Let copy of order be issued to the Parties.
Alert