- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Shail Bala v. Union Bank Of India & Ors.
Factual and Procedural Background
This opinion arises from an appeal filed under Section 18 of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (SRFAESI Act). The appellant challenged a notice under Section 13(2) of the SRFAESI Act which stated that the borrower owed Rs. 43,04,804/-. The appellant, an elderly widow and not the borrower or guarantor, contended that the property in question had already been auctioned for Rs. 1,41,21,000/- and that the amount was held by the respondent Bank. She argued that the property was agricultural land that could not have been mortgaged, and that the mortgage was improperly executed with the Bank. The appellant sought relief from depositing further amounts under Section 18 of the SRFAESI Act. The Court was tasked with deciding the admission of the appeal and the waiver application for pre-deposit under Section 18.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the appeal under Section 18 of the SRFAESI Act can be admitted without the appellant making the mandatory pre-deposit of at least 25% (or 50%) of the debt amount as stipulated by the Act.
- Whether the appellant, who is neither the borrower nor guarantor, can be exempted from the pre-deposit requirement based on the auction sale proceeds already held by the Bank.
- Whether the property in question qualifies as agricultural land exempt from mortgage under the Act.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The property has already been auctioned for Rs. 1,41,21,000/- and the Bank holds this amount.
- The appellant is an old widow, not in sound financial condition, and neither the borrower nor guarantor of the loan.
- The property is agricultural land and thus could not have been mortgaged.
- The mortgage was not properly executed with the Bank but with another Bank.
- The appellant should not be required to deposit any further amount under Section 18 given the auction proceeds held by the Bank.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Commissioner of Wealth Tax, Andhra Pradesh v. Court of Wards, AIR 1977 SC 113 | Determination of the nature of land (agricultural or otherwise) for mortgage purposes. | The Court referred to this authority prima facie to conclude that the land may not be agricultural for the purposes claimed by the appellant. |
| Gujala Exim (P) Ltd. v. Authorised Officer, Andhra Bank, 2009 (1) Bank CLR 611 (AP) | Similar view regarding the nature of property and mortgage validity. | Supported the Court's prima facie view on the property’s nature and mortgage validity. |
| Star Textils and Industries Ltd. v. Union of India, 2009 (1) Bank CLR 401 (Cal) | Validity and mandatory nature of pre-deposit under Section 18 of the SRFAESI Act. | The Court relied on this precedent to uphold the mandatory nature of the pre-deposit condition and reject claims that it is onerous or unreasonable. |
| Maikaal Fibres Ltd. v. H.D.F.C Bank Ltd., 2009 (1) Bank CLR 618 (Cal) | Similar affirmation of the mandatory pre-deposit requirement. | Reinforced the Court’s position on the pre-deposit requirement. |
| Jamshed M. Pandey v. Indian Renewable Energy Dev., AG 2007 (1) bankers Journal 653 | Non-waiver of statutory pre-deposit requirements absent proof of inability to pay. | Used to emphasize that inability to pay must be proven with evidence, and mere assertions do not suffice to waive pre-deposit. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the appellant’s contradictory arguments—seeking to prevent confirmation of sale while simultaneously asserting that the auction sale proceeds held by the Bank should exempt her from the mandatory pre-deposit. The Court underscored the mandatory statutory requirement under Section 18 of the SRFAESI Act that no appeal shall be entertained unless the borrower deposits 50% of the debt amount, or a minimum of 25% as reduced by the Appellate Tribunal for reasons recorded in writing. The Court found no convincing evidence to establish the appellant’s financial incapacity, noting that widowhood alone does not prove inability to comply with the pre-deposit. It referred to binding precedents confirming the mandatory and reasonable nature of the pre-deposit provision, rejecting the appellant’s arguments as incongruous and unsupported by documentary evidence. The Court also expressed a prima facie view that the land may not be agricultural as alleged, citing authoritative case law. Consequently, the Court ordered the appellant to deposit 50% of the amount claimed by the Bank within four weeks, to be held in a fixed deposit receipt (FDR) by the Registrar, pending further proceedings.
Holding and Implications
The Court held that the appeal cannot be admitted without the appellant making the mandatory pre-deposit of 50% of the debt amount as stated in the notice under Section 13(2) of the SRFAESI Act.
The appellant’s waiver application for the pre-deposit was rejected due to lack of credible evidence of financial incapacity and contradictory submissions. The direct consequence is that the appellant must deposit the specified amount within four weeks, failing which the appeal will not be entertained. No broader precedent was established beyond affirming the mandatory nature of the pre-deposit requirement and the necessity of credible proof for any waiver.
J.M Malik, Chairperson:— This is an appeal under Section 18 of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (for short ‘SRFAESI Act’). This order shall decide the question of admission of the appeal and the waiver application moved by the appellant under Section 18 of the Act.
2. The notice under Section 13(2) of the SRFAESI Act mentioned that the borrower is liable to pay an amount of Rs. 43,04,804/- only. The Counsel for the appellant argued that the property in question has already been auctioned for a sum of Rs. 1,41,21,000/- and the said amount is lying with the respondent-Bank. The appellant is said to be an old lady and widow of the mortgagor late Mr. R.P Goel and is not in a sound financial position. According to the Counsel, the appellant is neither the borrower nor the guarantor of the loan in question. Her husband Mr. R.P Goel had executed a Will in favour of the appellant. The case of the appellant is very strong on merits. The property in question is an agricultural land and the same could not have been mortgaged. He, however, conceded that there are boundaries all over the land in question and a building in the name and style of M/s. Aggarwal Rice and General Mills, Jagadri is built thereon. Counsel also submitted that the property in question was not mortgaged properly with the Bank. This was mortgaged with other Bank. He lastly submitted that the property of the appellant has already been sold for an amount of Rs. 1,41,21,000/- and the Bank has received this amount from the auction purchaser and, therefore, the appellant may not be directed to deposit more money.
3. The arguments put forward by the Counsel for the appellant lack conviction. On the one hand his prayer is that the sale should not be permitted to be confirmed and on the other he argues that the sale consideration of the property in question is with the Bank and, therefore, the appellant may be exempted from depositing any money under section 18 of the srfaesi act. Both these arguments are incongruous.
4. Section 18 of the SRFAESI Act clearly mentions that no appeal shall be entertained unless the borrower has deposited with the Appellate Tribunal 50%-of the amount of debt due from him as claimed by the secured creditor or determined by the DRT, whichever is less. It further lays down that the Appellate Tribunal may, for the reasons to be recorded in writing, reduce the amount to not less than 25% of the debt. Consequently, the above said provision of pre-deposit is mandatory.
5. Prima facie it does not appear that the land in question is meant for agricultural purposes. The lower Court has cited an authority reported in AIR 1977 SC 113, Commissioner of Wealth Tax, Andhra Pradesh v. Court of Wards Piagh. Similar view was taken in a recent decision by the Hon'ble Apex Court in Gujala Exim (P) Ltd. v. Authorised Officer, Andhra Bank, 2009 (1) Bank CLR 611(AP). Moreover, the appellant has failed to prove that the appellant's financial position is not sound. The mere fact that she is a widow is not sufficient to prove that she is facing financial stringency. No documentary proof saw the light of the day to show that the appellant is unable to comply with the pre-condition of section 18 of the srfaesi act. In the case of Star Textils and Industries Ltd. v. Union of India, (2009 (1) Bank CLR 401 (Cal)), the Hon'ble Calcutta High Court held that the above said condition is not so onerous or oppressive or arbitrary or unreasonable that legislative wisdom has to be put in judicial scanner by entertaining instant writ petition. The writ petition was dismissed. A similar view was taken by the Hon'ble Calcutta High Court in another case, Maikaal Fibres Ltd. v. H.D.F.C Bank Ltd., 2009 (1) Bank CLR 618 (Cal). In an order passed under Section 21 of the Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act reported in AG 2007 (1) bankers Journal 653, Jamshed M. Pandey v. Indian Renewable Energy Dev., the Division Bench headed by His Lordship the then Chief Justice Hon'ble HMJ Mr. Markenday Katju was pleased to hold as under:
“Learned Counsel for the petitioner then submitted that the petitioner has no means to pay the amount mentioned in Section 21 and hence the same may be waived. The same plea has been taken before DRAT as is evident from a perusal of the impugned order. The DRAT has after detailed consideration of the case held that nothing had been placed before it by the petitioners to show that it could not comply with the conditions of Section 21. This is a finding of fact and we cannot interfere with the same in the writ jurisdiction. Thus, there is no force in this petition and it is dismissed.”
6. Keeping in view all these facts and circumstances, I hereby order the appellant to deposit with the Registrar of this Court 50% of the amount mentioned in the notice issued by the Bank under Section 13(2) of the SRFAESI Act, minus the future and pendente lite interest or costs of the case, within four weeks from today, without prejudice to the rights of the parties. The Registrar of this Court, in turn, will deposit the said amount with the same Bank in the shape of FDR renewable after every six months.
7. In the meantime, the respondent is directed to submit counter-affidavit within four week. The case to come up on 27.11.2009 for showing the compliance and for filing counter affidavit. The record from the lower Court be requisitioned if not already requisitioned.
8. Ordered accordingly.
Alert