Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ashok Brothers v. Bank Of India

Debts Recovery Tribunal
Jan 13, 2006
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent Bank issued a notice dated 24.9.2004 under Section 13(2) of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (SRFAESI Act), demanding payment of outstanding dues amounting to Rs. 47,53,353.87 from the applicants/appellants, related to Cash Credit Hypothecation of Stock & Book Debts. Upon non-payment, the Bank took symbolic possession of the property identified as Plot No. 37, Mathuranagar Co-operative Housing Society Ltd., Khardi Road, Chandan Nagar, Pune, via a notice dated 27.10.2005. The applicants challenged this possession and the underlying notice on various grounds, leading to the present application and hearing.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the notice under Section 13(2) of the SRFAESI Act was valid and properly issued to the applicants/appellants.
  2. Whether the Bank complied with the mandatory requirement under Section 13(3-A) of the SRFAESI Act to consider and respond to the applicants' representation dated 7.10.2004.
  3. Whether the possession notice was valid in light of the alleged discrepancies in the outstanding amount and the failure to publish the possession notice as required under Rule 8(2) of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002.
  4. Whether the symbolic possession taken by the Bank was legally sustainable given the above contentions.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicants/Appellants' Arguments

  • The notice under Section 13(2) of the SRFAESI Act was flawed as it did not mention the account number and incorrectly stated the date of N.P.A. as 1.3.2004 instead of 1.4.2004.
  • The notice was addressed improperly, being sent to appellant No. 1 with only a copy to appellant No. 2, the mortgagor.
  • The outstanding amount mentioned in the notice was excessive and calculated with an exorbitant rate of interest, not reflecting the actual dues after accounting for Rs. 26.24 lacs received from an Insurance Company.
  • The Bank did not consider or respond to their representation dated 7.10.2004 requesting abeyance of further action under the SRFAESI Act, which is mandatory under Section 13(3-A) of the Act.
  • The possession notice was not published as required by Rule 8(2) of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002, rendering the action invalid.
  • The Bank's allowing the account to be operated after the representation implied withdrawal of the securitisation notice.

Respondent Bank's Arguments

  • The account became a Non-Performing Asset (N.P.A.) effective 1.4.2004.
  • The Bank allowed operation of the account as a compromise measure, with the applicant permitted to operate the account only to the extent of amounts deposited.
  • The receipt of Rs. 26.24 lacs from the Insurance Company is admitted.
  • The Bank refuted the applicants' contentions and sought dismissal of the application on these grounds.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the validity of the notice under Section 13(2) of the SRFAESI Act and found that minor deficiencies such as non-mention of account number, incorrect date of N.P.A., and addressing errors were not sufficient to invalidate the notice as the mortgagor did receive notice. However, the court found merit in the significant discrepancy between the amount stated in the notice (Rs. 47,53,353.87) and the actual dues shown in the statement of account (Rs. 42,27,126.87), considering this difference substantial.

The court emphasized the mandatory requirement under Section 13(3-A) of the SRFAESI Act that the Bank must consider and respond to the representation made by the applicants on 7.10.2004. The Bank's failure to do so was held fatal and undermined the legality of the action. The continuous operation of the account after the representation supported the applicants' claim that the Bank had effectively withdrawn the securitisation notice.

Further, the court noted that the possession notice was not published as required by Rule 8(2) of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002. The use of the word "shall" in the rule indicated that publication is mandatory and not a mere formality. The omission to publish the notice rendered the possession action invalid.

While the court acknowledged that the possession notice's mention of the amount was not a mere technicality since it served to alert interested parties of the charge, the cumulative procedural lapses led to the conclusion that the Bank's action was unsustainable.

Holding and Implications

The application of applicant No. 2 is allowed with costs. The notice dated 24.9.2004 under Section 13(2) of the SRFAESI Act is quashed, and all actions pursuant thereto are set aside.

The respondent Bank is directed to deliver symbolic possession of the property located at Plot No. 37, Mathuranagar Co-operative Housing Society Ltd., Khardi Road, Chandan Nagar, Pune-411 014, within 15 days.

This decision directly affects the parties by invalidating the Bank's possession and related notices but does not establish any new legal precedent beyond the facts and statutory interpretation in this case.

Show all summary ...

K.J Paratwar, Presiding Officer:— The respondent Bank's taking symbolic possession, vide notice dated 27.10.2005 of Bangalore over Plot No. 37, Mathuranagar Co-operative Housing Society Ltd., Khardi Road, Chandan Nagar, Pune-411 014 has aggrieved the applicants/appellants

2. The respondent vide notice dated 24.9.2004 under Section 13(2) of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (SRFAESI Act) called upon the applicants/appellants to pay outstandings of Rs. 47,53,353.87 (being dues under Cash Credit Hypothecation of Stock & Book Debts) failing which the further steps under SRFAESI Act were threatened to be taken. The respondent ultimately took symbolic possession as noted above.

3. The grounds are that the applicants had replied the notice vide letter dated 7.10.2004 inter alia requesting for keeping the action under SRFAESI Act in abeyance. The Bank thereupon allowed the account to be operated on understanding that securitisation notice stands withdrawal. As such, the account was continuously operated. The respondent Bank also received on 13.6.2005 Rs. 26.24 lacs from Insurance Company (in respect of the fire broke on 8.3.2003) against claim of Rs. 38.76 lacs. The outstandings on the date of possession, therefore, was much less than the sum mentioned under Section 13(2) of SRFAESI Act. The claim is said to have been calculated by levying exorbitant rate of interest. Thus, the action is said to be bad in law.

4. Vide reply in the nature of affidavit of Mr. Gautam Prasad Bose (Exh. 10) the respondent Bank has refuted the applicants' contentions. The account is said to have become N.P.A w.e.f 1.4.2004; the applicant/appellant No. 1 allowed to operate the account since the applicants approached for compromise/settlement with rider that the account would be operated with extent of the amount deposited. The receipt of the amount of Insurance Company is admitted. The dismissal of the application is sought for on aforesaid grounds.

5. I have heard arguments of learned Counsel representing the rival parties. I have gone through the copies of the relevant record including the statement of account.

6. The notice under Section 13(2) of SRFAESI Act is said to be bad because it does not mention account number and the date of N.P.A is wrongly mentioned as 1.3.2004 as against correct date 1.4.2004 stated elsewhere. It is addressed to appellant No. 1 and copy is given to appellant No. 2 rather than addressing it to appellant No. 2. The same is also said to be bad because the amount mentioned therein is more by about Rs. 5 lacs than the amount in the statement of account. In my view, except last point, there is not much merit in the other contentions. Non-mentioning of the account number and the wrong date of N.P.A as also addressal of the notice to appellant No. 1 (copy being given to appellant No. 2) are not the crucial facts to invalidate the notice. It cannot be said that the mortgagor (appellant No. 2) did not get notice. There is however some substance in the discrepancy of the amounts. The notice mentions amount of Rs. 47,53,353.87 while the statement of account shows dues on the date of notice to be Rs. 42,27,126.87. The difference is not marginal.

7. There is also merit in other point raised that the action under SRFAESI Act is unsustainable since the respondent Bank did not consider representation dated 7.10.2004 made by the applicants and did not give any reply. Section 13(3-A) of SRFAESI Act makes it mandatory. The omission is fatal and goes to the root of the matter. In fact, the omission on the part of the respondent lends credence to the applicants further contention that the Bank had withdrawn the notice and allowed the account to be operated. If that were not to be so, there would not have been several credit and debit entries in the account since after 7.10.2004 The bare perusal of the statement of account shows that the account was operated practically, as it was operated earlier.

8. There is one more aspect to the matter which is that the outstandings on the date of possession notice were admittedly much less than the amount mentioned in notice under Section 13(2) of SRFAESI Act since the Bank had received inter alia Rs. 26.24 lacs as said earlier from Insurance Company. In the possession notice the wrong mentioning of the amount is not a technical aspect since by such notice, everyone is put on the guard that the property is subject to charge of aforesaid amount.

9. It is also to be seen that the possession notice has not been published as required by Rule 8(2) of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002. The publication of the notice is not formality as is evident from the user of the word ‘shall’ in said sub-section. The action under SRFAESI Act is bad also on this count.

10. The application of applicant No. 2 is liable to be allowed on aforesaid grounds. Hence, following order:

(A) The Securitisation Application of applicant No. 2 is allowed with cost. The notice dated 24.9.2004 under Section 13(2) of SRFAESI Act is quashed and action pursuant thereto is hereby set aside.

(B) The respondent shall deliver, within 15 days, symbolic possession of the property being Bangalore over Plot No. 37, Mathuranagar Co-operative Housing Society Ltd., Khardi Road, Chandan Nagar, Pune-411 014.

Application allowed.