- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Bharati Sahkari Bank Ltd. v. The South Indian Bank Ltd. & Ors
Factual and Procedural Background
The South Indian Bank Ltd. (respondent No. 1) filed Original Application No. 238/2003 before the Debts Recovery Tribunal (DRT), Pune, seeking recovery of Rs. 12,05,164/- from Rajendra Kumar Kalicharan Verma (respondent No. 2), Ramdhar Suku Vishwakarma (respondent No. 3), and Bharati Sahakari Bank Ltd. (appellant/original defendant No. 3). The loan of Rs. 10 lacs was granted to respondent No. 2 for payment towards a flat purchased from M/s. Shraddha Associates. The respondent No. 1 alleged that the appellant Bank negligently allowed respondent No. 2 to open an account in the name of the builders and that respondent No. 2 fraudulently encashed a banker’s cheque issued by respondent No. 1 through the appellant Bank. The appellant Bank challenged the maintainability of the claim and the jurisdiction of the DRT on the ground of non-compliance with mandatory notice provisions under Section 115 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002, and Section 164 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960. The DRT rejected the appellant Bank's application, holding that it had jurisdiction. The appellant Bank filed this Miscellaneous Appeal against that order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Debts Recovery Tribunal had jurisdiction to entertain and decide the claim against the appellant Bank, a Multi State Co-operative Society, in the absence of mandatory notice to the Central Registrar as required under Section 115 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002?
- Whether the notice dated 18.8.2003 given by the respondent No. 1 Bank’s advocate, which was addressed to the appellant Bank and copied to certain state authorities, constituted valid compliance of the statutory notice provisions under Section 115 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002?
- Whether failure to comply with the statutory notice requirements under Section 115 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002, and Section 164 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960, renders the suit/original application barred and non-maintainable?
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The appellant Bank, governed by the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002, contended that a mandatory notice had to be given to the Central Registrar before instituting a suit as per Section 115 of the Act.
- The notice dated 18.8.2003, although addressed to the appellant Bank and copied to certain state cooperative authorities, did not satisfy the statutory requirement of being delivered or left at the office of the Central Registrar.
- The appellant Bank argued that mere labeling of the notice as being under Section 115 cannot substitute actual compliance with the statutory provisions.
- Non-compliance with Section 115 is fatal and bars the institution of the suit against a Multi State Co-operative Society.
Respondent's Arguments
- The respondent No. 1 Bank contended that the purpose of the notice was to inform the appellant Bank of the suit, and this purpose was achieved by the notice dated 18.8.2003.
- The notice was addressed to the appellant Bank, and copies were sent to the Commissioner for Co-operation, Registrar for Co-operative Societies, Maharashtra State, and the Divisional Joint Registrar of Cooperative Societies, Pune Division.
- The respondent argued that the notice should be treated as valid under Section 115 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002, as stated in the notice itself.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Mohan Meakins Ltd. v. The Pravara Sahakari Sakhar Karkhana Ltd., 1987 Mah. L.J 503 | Necessity of notice under Section 164 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 before instituting suit against a cooperative society. | The court applied this precedent to establish that notice under the relevant statutory provision is a mandatory prerequisite for maintainability of the suit. |
| Shetkari Shakari Sakhar Karkhana Limited v. Narahari Balkarishana Tulpule, Maharashtra Law Journal 210 | Requirement of notice under Section 164 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 before filing suit touching management or business of a society. | The court used this case by analogy to affirm that the notice requirement under Section 115 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002 is similarly mandatory. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the provisions of Section 115 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002, which mandates that no suit shall be instituted against a Multi State Co-operative Society until 90 days after a written notice has been delivered or left at the office of the Central Registrar, specifying the cause of action, plaintiff's details, and relief claimed. The plaint must also contain a statement confirming such notice.
The Court compared this with Section 164 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960, which contains similar notice requirements for suits against societies registered under that Act.
The Court found that the notice dated 18.8.2003 was addressed to the appellant Bank and copied to certain state cooperative authorities but was not delivered to the Central Registrar as required by Section 115. The Court rejected the respondent's argument that the notice could be treated as valid merely because it was labeled as a Section 115 notice.
The Court emphasized the mandatory nature of the statutory notice requirement and held that non-compliance bars the institution of the suit. The Court applied precedents underscoring the necessity of such notice before filing suit against cooperative societies.
Accordingly, the Court concluded that the Debts Recovery Tribunal lacked jurisdiction to entertain the claim against the appellant Bank due to the absence of valid statutory notice.
Holding and Implications
The appeal is allowed.
The impugned order dated 19.7.2004 passed by the Presiding Officer of the Debts Recovery Tribunal, Pune, rejecting the appellant Bank’s application challenging jurisdiction, is set aside.
The Original Application No. 238/2003 is dismissed as against the appellant Bank (original defendant No. 3) only.
Miscellaneous Application No. 666/04 is disposed of accordingly as it does not survive.
The direct effect of this decision is that the claim against the appellant Bank cannot proceed due to non-compliance with mandatory statutory notice requirements. No new legal precedent beyond the application of existing statutory provisions and case law was established.
Justice Dr. Pratibha Upasani, Chairperson:— This Misc. Appeal is filed by the appellant/original defendant No. 3 Bharati Sahakri Bank Ltd. being aggrieved by the order dated 19.7.2004 passed by the learned Presiding Officer of Debts Recovery Tribunal, Pune on Exhibit No. 1 Original Application No. 238 of 2003. By the impugned order, the learned Presiding Officer rejected the application made by appellant Bank and held that the Debts Recovery Tribunal had jurisdiction to entertain and decide the claim against the appellant Bank. It is this order which is challenged by the appellant Bank by way of filing this appeal before the Appellate forum.
2. I have heard Mr. Khurjekar for the appellant Bank and Mr. Kaushik for the respondent No. 1 Bank. I have also gone through the proceedings and the relevant provisions of the law with respect to giving of a notice, before filing of the suit, under Section 115 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002, so also under Section 164 of the. Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 and in my view, the learned Presiding Officer was not correct in coming to the conclusion that though there was no compliance of the provisions of Section 115 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002, still the Tribunal had jurisdiction to entertain and decide the claim against the appellant Bank.
3. Few facts which are required to be stated are follows:
The respondent No. 1 The South Indian Bank Ltd. had filed claim application before the Debts Recovery Tribunal, Pune being Original Application No. 238/2003 against the respondent No. 2 Rajendra Kumar Kalicharan Verma, the respondent No. 3 Ramdhar Suku Vishwakarma, so also the present appellant Bank namely Bharati Sahakari Bank Ltd., for recovery of Rs. 12,05,164/-. The said application was filed mainly against the respondent Nos. 2 and 3 to whom the respondent No. 1 Bank had financed loan of Rs. 10 lacs repayable in 180 equal monthly instalments of Rs. 12,000.each. The said loan was granted for making balance payment of the purchase of a flat booked with a builder “M/s. Shraddha Associates”, Promoters and Builders of Pune, a registered partnership. It was the contention of the respondent No. 1 Bank that it paid the loan amount of Rs. 10 lacs to the respondent No. 2 by a Bankers cheque bearing No. 620918 dated 7th August, 2002 drawn in favour of the builders M/s. Shraddha Associates. The said loan was secured by way of mortgage of the flat purchased by the respondent No. 2. Further case of the respondent No. 1 Bank was that it had got knowledge of the fact that the respondent No. 2 had tried to defraud the Punjab National Bank, Khadki, Fune and the respondent No. 2 was arrested. Therefore, the respondent No. 1 Bank made inquiries with the appellant Bank. The respondent No. 2 had deposited the Bankers cheque issued by the respondent No. 1 in an account opened, by the respondent No. 2 with the appellant Bank in the name of M/s. Shraddha Associates.
It was the contention of the respondent No. 1 Bank before the Debts Recovery Tribunal that the appellant Bank acted negligently in allowing the respondent No. 2 to open an account with it and that because of the negligence and casual approach of the appellant Bank, the respondent No. 2 could fraudulently encash the Bankers cheque issued by the respondent No. 1 and, therefore, the appellant Bank was liable to refund the amount of the cheque together with interest. On this background, the respondent No. 1 Bank joined the appellant Bank as party defendant No. 3 in the claim application before the Debt Recovery Tribunal.
The appellant Bank appeared in the matter as per the notice of the Tribunal and also filed the written statement. In the said written statement, the appellant Bank had raised issue of maintainability of the claim against it and had questioned jurisdiction of the Tribunal on the ground of non-compliance of the provisions of Section 115 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002 and or non-compliance of provisions of Section 164 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960. The appellant Bank also filed an application dated 20.2.2004 at Exhibit No. 11 raising the point of maintainability of the claim application and jurisdiction to be heard, as preliminary point. The respondent No. 1 Bank filed its reply and resisted the said application made by the appellant Bank. The learned Presiding Officer after hearing both the sides, rejected the application made by the appellant Bank holding that the original application was maintainable and the Debts Recovery Tribunal had jurisdiction to entertain and decide the claim against the present appellant Bank also. Being aggrieved, the present misc. appeal is filed by the appellant Bank.
4. Mr. Khurjekar, the learned Advocate appearing for the appellant Bank, vehemently argued that the appellant Bank was governed by the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002 and therefore notice was required to be given to the Central Registrar before initiating the original application.
Mr. Khurjekar further argued that the notice dated 18.8.2003 given by the Advocate Sriniwasan & Co. for the respondent No. 1 Bank, which was addressed to the appellant Bank and the copy of which was given to the Commissioner for Co-operation and Registrar for Co-operative Societies, Maharashtra State and to the Divisional Joint Registrar of Cooperative Societies, could not be construed as compliance of the provisions of Section 115 of the the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002.
Mr. Khurjekar argued that what was contemplated by Section 115 of the Multi State Co operative Societies Act, 2002, was that the notice had to be mandatorily given to the Central Registrar, stating the cause of action, the name, description and place of residence of the plaintiff and the relief which he claimed, and the plaint should contain a statement that such notice had been so delivered or left at the office of the Central Registrar. He drew my attention to the provisions of Section 115 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002, which can be reproduced below:
“115. Notice necessary in suits.—No suit shall be instituted against a Multi State Cooperative Society or any of its officers in respect of any act touching the constitution, management of the business of the society until the expiration of ninety days next after notice in writing has been delivered to the Central Registrar or left at his office, stating the cause of action, the name, description and place of residence of the plaintiff and the relief which he claims and the plaint shall contain a statement that such notice has been so delivered or left.”
5. Mr. Khurjekar, thus, argued that no suit could have been instituted against the appellant Bank which was the Multi State Co-operative Bank registered under the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002 unless the notice to the Central Registrar as required by Section 115 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002 was delivered or left at his office. Also by pointing out the letter/notice dated 18.8.2003 given by the respondent No. 1 Bank's Advocate, Mr. Khurjekar pointed out that such notice could not be construed to have been given under Section 115 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002 just because it said so, in fact when there was no compliance of Section 115 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002.
6. Mr. Kaushik, on the other hand, supported the order passed by the learned Presiding Officer and submitted that the only intention of giving notice was to make the other party aware of the filing of the suit. He also argued that this object was achieved by the notice dated 18.8.2003, which was given by the respondent No. 1 Bank's Advocate. He further argued th??? the copy of the said notice was sent to the Commissioner for Co-operation and the Registrar for Co-operative Societies, Maharashtra State and to the Divisional Joint Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Pune Division, though it was addressed to the appellant Bank. He also drew my attention to the last sentence of said notice which stated that the notice was to be treated as a notice under Section 115 of the Multi-State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002.
7. I have heard both the sides at length. I have also considered the provisions of Section 115 of the Multi-State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002, the provisions of Section 164 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 and the relevant case law cited at the bar.
8. In the case of Mohan Meakins Ltd. v. The Pravara Sahakari Sakhar Karkhana Ltd., 1987 Mah. L.J 503, the Division Bench of the Bombay High Court has categorically held that in a suit for injunction against the Co-operative Society prohibiting it from manufacturing alcoholic products, notice under Section 164 was necessary and the suit filed without such notice was not maintainable.
9. In the above mentioned case, the notice given was under Section 164 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960, but the provisions of Section 164 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 and provisions of Section 115 of the Multi-State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002 are para materia. By way of comparison, Section 164 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 can be reproduced below:
“164. Notice necessary in suits.—No suit shall be instituted against a society or any of its officers, in respect of any act touching the business of the society, until the expiration of two months next after notice in writing has been delivered to the Registrar or left at his office, stating the cause of action, the name, description and place of residence of the plaintiff and the relief which he claims, and the plaint shall contain a statement that such notice has been so delivered or left.”
The above section can be read in juxtaposition with Section 115 of the Multi State Co operative Societies Act, 2002, which can be reproduced once again for the ready reference:
“115. Notice necessary in suits.—No suit shall be instituted against a Multi-State Cooperative Society or any of its officers in respect of any act touching the constitution, management or the business of the society until the expiration of ninety days next after notice in writing has been delivered to the Central Registrar or left at his office, stating the cause of action, the name, description and place of residence of the plaintiff and the relief which he claims, and the plaint shall contain a statement that such notice has been delivered or left.”
Thus, it is quite clear that the filing of the suit is barred under both the sections namely under Section 164 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 and under Section 115 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002.
10. In the present case at hand, since there is no notice given as per provisions of Section 115 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002, the suit/original application filed by the respondent No. 1 Bank against the appellant Bank which is registered under the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002, is clearly barred. I find no substance in the submission of Mr. Kaushik appearing for the respondent No. 1 Bank that the notice dated 18.8.2003 has to be treated as notice given under Section 115 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002, because there is no compliance of the provisions of Section 115 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002. Giving notice as per the provisions of Section 115 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002 is a mandatory and statutory requirement. Adherence to the statutory requirement has to be in toto and when there is no such adherence, the suit must fail.
11. Useful reference can be made to the case of the Shetkari Shakari Sakhar Karkhana Limited v. Narahari Balkarishana Tulpule, reported in Maharashtra Law Journal 210 wherein the Bombay High Court has held that before filing of the suit with respect to the matter touching the management and/or business of the society, notice under Section 164 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 was necessary and that the suit without such notice was barred.
12. In the present case at hand, the same analogy has to be applied. The original application was filed against the present appellant Bank alleging that it was negligent in allowing the respondent No. 2 to open an account with it and that by such casual approach of the appellant Bank, the respondent No. 2 could fraudulently encash the Bankers cheque issued by the respondent No. 1 Bank and the appellant Bank was liable to refund the amount of the cheque together with the interest. From these allegations it is clear that this is something which touches the business of the appellant Bank. Opening of an account and encashing the cheque are certainly things touching the business of the Bank. When the appellant Bank is alleged to be responsible for these deeds notice under Section 115 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002 was mandatory. The notice dated 18.8.2003 was addressed to the appellant Bank itself and the copy of the same was sent to some authorities like the Commissioner for Co-operation and Registrar for Co-operative Societies, Maharashtra State and to the Divisional Joint Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Pune Division, working in Maharshtra State. However, requirement of Section 115 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002 is that the notice has to be sent to the Central Registrar. The Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002 is a Central Act, which extends to whole of India. This Act has designated the Central Registrar as the authority to whom the notice under Section 115 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002, has to be addressed. The alleged notice dated 18.8.2003 is devoid of this requirement. Firstly it was addressed to the appellant Bank itself, while it had to be addressed to the Central Registrar.
It is meekly stated by Mr. Kaushik that copy of the said notice was given to the Commissioner for Co-operation and Registrar for Co-operative Societies, Maharashtra State and to the Divisional Joint Registrar of Co-operative Societies. However, those are not the authorities, who are concerned with the notice, which is to be given under Section 115 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002.
Mr. Kaushik also argued that in the last para of the said notice, it is mentioned that the notice was to be treated as the notice under Section 115 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002. This submission of Mr. Kaushik has to be rejected. When there is no compliance of Section 115 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002, just by making a statement in the notice that the notice was given under Section 115 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002, will not serve the purpose. I, therefore, reject this contention of Mr. Kaushik. The appeal therefore succeeds. Hence, following order is passed:
Misc. Appeal No. 301/2004 is hereby allowed and the impugned order dated 19.7.2004 passed by the learned Presiding Officer of DRT, Pune below Exhibit-1 in Original Application No. 238/2003 is hereby set aside.
Original Application No. 238/2003 is dismissed as against the original defendant No. 3 only.
In view of above, Misc. Application No. 666/04 does not survive and is disposed of accordingly.
Appeal allowed.Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002,
Alert