Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M/S. Enjoy Chemistry With Yash (S) v. Commissioner Of Central Excise & S.T., Surat (S).

CESTAT
Dec 26, 2014

H.K. Thakur:— This appeal has been filed by the appellant with respect to OIA No. SUR-EXCUS-001-APP-529-13-14 dated 25.11.2013. The issue involved in the present appeal is payment of service tax on Commercial Training and Coaching services imparted by the appellant during the period 2006–07.

2. Shri R. Subramanya (Advocate) appearing on behalf of the appellant argued that the entire service tax along with interest was paid before the issue of show cause notice and the 25% of Section 78 penalty imposed was also deposited by the appellant within one month from the date of adjudication order. It was his case that once 25% penalty is also paid within one month from the date of issue of order-in-original, therefore no other penalty is imposable, in view of the decision of the Hon'ble Gujarat High Court in the case of Commissioner of Service Tax v. Manan Motors Pvt. Limited, [2013 (31) STR 535 (Guj.)].

3. Shri Gobind Jha (AR) appearing on behalf of the Revenue argued that even if Section 78 penalty to the extent of 25% has been paid by the appellant still penalty under Section 76 of the Finance Act, 1994 is payable prior to amendment of Section 78 with effect from 16.5.2008. He relied upon the following case laws:—

(a) Bajaj Travels Limited v. Commissioner of Service Tax, [2012 (25) STR 417 (Del.)]

(b) Anand Decorators & Hirers v. Commissioner of Service Tax, Ahmedabad, [2013 (30) STR 86 (Tri. Ahmd.)]

4. Heard both sides and perused the case records. Appellant is not agitating the issue on merits but has claimed non-imposition of penalty under Section 76 of the Finance Act, 1994. The entire amount of service tax along with interest was paid before the issue of show cause notice dated 27.7.2011. 25% of the Section 78 penalty was also paid by the appellant on 25.2.2013, within one month from the date of order-in-original (29.01.2013). The issue therefore left in these proceedings is whether Section 76 penalty required to be imposed upon the appellant when Section 78 penalty to the extent of 25% is paid within one month from the date of order-in-original. Learned AR relies upon the judgment of this bench in the case of Anand Decorators & Hirers v. Commissioner of Service Tax, Ahmedabad (supra) and argues that penalty under Section 76 is imposable. It is observed from the above case law that the same was passed on the basis of judgment of Hon'ble Delhi High Court in the case of Bajaj Travels Limited v. Commissioner of Service Tax (supra). At the same time, it is also observed that the judgment of jurisdictional Gujarat High Court in the case of Commissioner of Service Tax v. Manan Motors Pvt. Limited (supra) was not brought to the notice of the bench. On the same issue the Hon'ble High Court in this case has held as follows:—

‘6.?We are in agreement with the view taken by the Tribunal, though Mr. Darshan M. Parikh, learned counsel for the appellant has vehemently urged that under Section 73 read with sub-section (1A) of the Finance Act, once show cause notice has been issued then the assessee is required to make payment of penalty. He has further argued that even before the issuance of show cause notice if the Service Tax and interest has been deposited by the assessee, still he would require to deposit the penalty as he would have known as to what penalty would be levied on the assessee, therefore, atleast he should have deposited the 25% of the penalty amount within thirty days. We do not agree with the argument of learned counsel for the appellant as the Boards Circular dated 3-10-2007 in paragraph No. 3.1 has considered the proviso to Section 73 that where a person has paid service tax in full together with interest and penalty under sub-section (1A), the proceedings in respect of such person to whom notices are served under sub-section (1) shall be deemed to be concluded. In the instant case was not contesting the Service Tax liability and had deposited the entire service tax and interest much before the issuance of show cause notice and discharged 25% of the amount of service tax liability, and at that time, neither any penalty was levied by the appellant nor any quantum of penalty was fixed. Therefore, the assessee has not committed any illegality in not depositing any penalty amount.

7.?For the aforesaid reasons, the penalty levied against the assessee in excess of 25% under Sections 76 and 78 of the Finance Act, 1994, has rightly been set aside by the Tribunal. We do not find any illegality in the order of the Tribunal. The question raised by the assessee in our opinion does not raise any substantial question of law. We do not find any merit in this Tax Appeal. This Tax Appeal is accordingly dismissed.’

5. In view of the above law laid down by the jurisdictional High Court, it has to be held that penalty in excess to 25% can not be imposed upon the appellant. Accordingly, appeal filed by the appellant is allowed to the extent that penalty in excess to 25% of the Section 78 penalty is not imposable.