Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M. Lakshmi Narayanan v. Rasi Nidhi Ltd. And Others

Company Law Board
Jun 1, 2004
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition was filed under section 614(1) of the Companies Act, 1956, by the petitioner seeking directions against M/s. Rasi Nidhi Ltd. and its directors to file Form No. 32 with the Registrar of Companies, notifying the cessation of the petitioner’s directorship effective March 30, 2002. The petitioner contended that he resigned by submitting a resignation letter dated March 7, 2002, acknowledged by the then managing director, late C.S. Prakash. Despite repeated demands and legal notices, the company and its directors failed to file the required Form No. 32. The company denied receipt of the resignation letter and alleged misappropriation of funds by the petitioner. The matter involved disputes over the validity and effect of the resignation, complicated by the death of the managing director who had acknowledged the resignation.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the company and its directors are obligated to file Form No. 32 with the Registrar of Companies notifying the petitioner’s resignation as director effective March 30, 2002.
  2. Whether the petitioner’s resignation letter dated March 7, 2002, was valid and effective despite the company’s denial and absence of explicit provisions in the articles of association regarding resignation.
  3. Whether the Company Law Board (CLB) can adjudicate the dispute regarding the resignation letter in a summary proceeding or if the remedy lies before a civil court.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The petitioner resigned as director by submitting a letter dated March 7, 2002, which was acknowledged by the then managing director, late C.S. Prakash.
  • The resignation was intended to take effect from March 30, 2002, as clearly stated in the resignation letter.
  • In absence of any provision in the Companies Act or the articles of association regarding resignation, the common law principle applies that resignation takes effect upon unequivocal expression of intention.
  • Despite repeated demands and legal notices, the company failed to file Form No. 32 as required under section 303 of the Companies Act, 1956.
  • Reliance on judicial precedents to establish that resignation is a unilateral act effective upon communication to the board, and acceptance by the company is not required.

Company’s Arguments

  • The company denied receipt of the petitioner’s resignation letter dated March 7, 2002.
  • The petitioner was alleged to have misappropriated company funds causing losses and complaints against the company and its directors.
  • The company contended that there was no record of the resignation letter and thus no obligation to file Form No. 32.
  • The company argued that the resignation letter’s existence and validity were disputed and could not be adjudicated in a summary proceeding before the CLB.
  • The company also stated that the managing director’s suicide and related allegations complicated the matter, and the board decided not to entertain the petitioner’s resignation.

Sixth Respondent’s Argument

  • The sixth respondent stated he ceased to be director from March 11, 2002, and had a pending petition for directions under section 614.
  • He claimed no knowledge of the petitioner’s resignation and sought dismissal of the petition as against him.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
S.S. Lakshmana Pillai v. Registrar of Companies, [1977] 47 Comp Cas 652 (Mad) In absence of provisions in the Companies Act or company’s articles, resignation by a director takes effect from the date of submission when intention is unequivocally expressed. The court applied this principle to hold that the petitioner’s resignation was effective from the date communicated, as no contradictory provisions existed.
T. Murari v. State, [1976] 46 Comp Cas 613 (Mad) A resignation once made takes effect immediately when the intention to resign is clear, absent any articles’ provision to the contrary. Supported the finding that the petitioner’s resignation was effective upon communication to the company.
Mother Care (India) Ltd. v. Prof. Ramaswamy P. Aiyar, [2004] 51 SCL 243 (Karn) Resignation is a unilateral act relinquishing office; acceptance by the company is not required; filing of Form No. 32 is consequential and not a condition for validity. The court relied on this precedent to conclude that the resignation was valid upon communication and the company’s failure to file Form No. 32 was a statutory default.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the petitioner’s resignation letter dated March 7, 2002, and the company’s acknowledgment by late C.S. Prakash. It noted the company did not produce any articles of association provisions governing resignation, thus common law principles apply. The court referred to precedents which establish that resignation is a unilateral act effective upon communication of clear intention, and acceptance by the company is not a prerequisite. The company’s contradictory statements—acknowledging the resignation letter in one communication but denying it in another—were noted as unexplained inconsistencies.

The court rejected the company’s contention that the dispute over the resignation letter could not be resolved in a summary proceeding, finding the matter was not too complicated and could be decided on the evidence presented. The petitioner’s resignation was held to have taken effect from March 30, 2002, as per his stated intention. The court emphasized that this decision did not absolve the petitioner of liabilities accrued prior to resignation.

Consequently, the company and its directors were found to be under a statutory obligation under section 303 of the Companies Act to file Form No. 32 notifying the change in directorship, which they had failed to do despite legal notices and complaints.

Holding and Implications

The petition is disposed of with directions to respondents Nos. 1 to 5 and 7 to file Form No. 32 with the Registrar of Companies within 21 days from receipt of the order, notifying the petitioner’s resignation effective March 30, 2002.

The direct effect of this decision is that the company and its directors must comply with their statutory duty to notify the cessation of the petitioner’s directorship. The court did not set any new precedent but reaffirmed established principles regarding director resignation and filing obligations under the Companies Act. The ruling clarifies that resignation is a unilateral act effective upon communication and that the company’s failure to file Form No. 32 constitutes a statutory default warranting judicial intervention.

Show all summary ...

K.K Balu, Member:— This is a petition filed under section 614(1) of 1 the Companies Act, 1956, (“the Act”), by the petitioner seeking directions of this Bench against M/s. Rasi Nidhi Ltd. (“the company”) and its directors, being respondents Nos. 2 to 7 to file Form No. 32 with the Registrar of Companies, the eighth respondent herein, intimating the cessation of directorship of the petitioner as director with effect from March 30, 2002.

2. According to the petitioner, as reiterated by Shri S. Eshwar, the learned authorised representative, in the course of his arguments, the petitioner was one of the directors of the company who had resigned from the office of director on personal grounds and accordingly submitted to the company his letter of resignation dated March 7, 2002, which was duly acknowledged by late C.S Prakash who was then at the helm of affairs of the company.

3. Shri Eshwar referring to the letter of resignation dated March 30, 2002 pointed out that the intention of the petitioner was clear that he had resigned with effect from March 30, 2002. Shri Eshwar, while dealing with the proposition as to when a resignation takes effect relied on the following decisions:

S.S Lakshmana Pillai v. Registrar of Companies, [1977] 47 Comp Cas 652 (Mad)—to show (headnote): “in the absence of any provision either in the Companies Act, 1956, or in the memorandum or articles of association of the company regarding resignation by a director, the ordinary rule of common law must be applied and a director who had submitted his resignation would be deemed to have resigned from his office from the date of the submission of his resignation, when his intention is unequivocally expressed either orally or by a letter”.

T. Murari v. State, [1976] 46 Comp Cas 613 (Mad)—to show that “a resignation once made takes effect immediately when the intention to resign is made clear, in the absence of any provision relating to resignation in the articles of association of the company”.

Mother Care (India) Ltd. v. Prof. Ramaswamy P. Aiyar, [2004] 51 SCL 243 (Karn)—to show that “resignation means the spontaneous relinquishment of one's own right and in relation to an office, it connotes the act of giving up or relinquishing the office”.

4. In the present case, the resignation took effect from March 30, 2002, as clearly indicated by the petitioner in his letter of resignation dated March 7, 2002. Moreover, the company has not produced the articles of association showing any provision in respect of resignation of directors. Therefore, the petitioner ceased to hold office since March 30, 2002. By virtue of the provisions of section 303 of the Act, the company and its directors are bound to file at the office of the eighth respondent, Form No. 32 duly notifying the change in the composition of the board of directors of the company. In spite of repeated demands, the complaint made to the eighth respondent and the legal notice dated May 26, 2003, sent to the company and its directors calling upon them to file Form No. 32, they failed to discharge their statutory duty. In this connection, Shri Eshwar, learned authorised representative referred to the letter of resignation and the correspondence exchanged in connection with the filing of Form No. 32 (annexures A2 to A8) produced before this Bench and sought for appropriate directions against the company and its directors.

5. Shri H. Karthik Seshadri, learned counsel, while opposing the company petition denied that the petitioner had submitted a letter of resignation on March 7, 2002 to the then managing director of the company. The petitioner along with C.S Prakash, since deceased was managing the affairs of the company, when the latter had committed suicide on March 3, 2003. The petitioner, while carrying on the business of the company had misappropriated huge amounts of money causing losses to the company. The company defaulted in repayment of matured deposits resulting in a large number of complaints lodged by the depositors before the Consumer Forum and other authorities against the company and its directors in their personal capacity. The petitioner, with a view to escape from the charges of misappropriation, has come out with the present petition. According to the company, there is no record establishing the alleged resignation of the petitioner and therefore the company is not under obligation to file Form No. 32 with the eighth respondent. In this connection, Shri Seshadri, learned counsel pointed out that the company has been constantly contending before the eighth respondent as early as on July 9, 2003, and when a legal notice was issued to the company on June 9, 2003, that there was no record for the proof of the alleged resignation letter said to have been delivered to late C.S Prakash. The letter of resignation is under dispute. In the absence of any concrete evidence for having tendered the resignation letter by the petitioner as claimed by him, his resignation letter cannot take effect. This dispute in regard to the resignation letter cannot be contested in a summary proceeding basing reliance on the affidavit and counter affidavit filed by the parties. Therefore, the CLB cannot adjudicate this contentious issues and the remedy of the petitioner lies before the civil court for enforcement of his right.

6. Shri R.S Mangala Kumar, counsel appearing for the seventh respond-ent adopted the arguments made on behalf of respondents Nos. 1 to 5.

7. According to the sixth respondent, he had already ceased to be director of the company with effect from March 11, 2002 and filed C.P 1208 of 2002 before this Bench for appropriate directions under section 614, which is pending. Moreover, this respondent has no knowledge about the petitioner's resignation from the board of directors of the company. Therefore, this respondent sought for dismissal of the company petition as against him.

8. After considering the pleadings and arguments, the issue that arises for my consideration is whether the company and its directors must be directed to file Form No. 32 with the eighth respondent notifying the resignation of the petitioner from the post of director in the facts and circumstances of the case.

9. While according to the petitioner, he had tendered his resignation letter dated March 7, 2002, to the then managing director, the same is vehemently denied by the company. This contentious issue becomes further compounded on account of the fact that C.S Prakash, the then managing director is no more alive to testify the stand taken by either of the parties. At this juncture, the complaint dated January 22, 2003 (annexure A3), of the petitioner made to the eighth respondent and the communication dated July 9, 2003, of the company sent to the eighth respondent (annexure A5) pursuant to the complaint dated January 22, 2003, of the petitioner assume utmost relevance. The relevant portion of the complaint (annexure A3) reads as under:

“I was holding the office of the director of the captioned company, since November 2, 1991.1 attained the age of 70 during the year 2002. I felt that with my advancing age, I cannot be taking on responsibilities as a director. Therefore, I submitted my resignation from the office of the director of the captioned company, by my letter of resignation dated March 7, 2002.1 enclose a copy of the said letter of resignation. The said letter has been acknowledged by the company, signed for and on its behalf by Mr. Prakash, one of the directors of the company. A copy of the said acknowledgment letter is also enclosed.”

10. The reply of the company (annexure A5) is as follows:

“In the case of Sri M. Lakshminarayanan, Form No. 32 has not been filed. This is so because, one C.S Prakash, a full time director of our company had committed suicide on March 3, 2003, leaving behind a letter addressed to honourable Commissioner of Police, Coimbatore stating that the said Sri M. Lakshminarayanan managing director of M/s. Rasi Nidhi Ltd., together with his son L. Chan-drasekar, had misappropriated Rs. 50,00,000 (Rupees fifty lakhs only) out of the company's funds, with a promise that such sums will be reimbursed to the company with interest and in full the principal amount. As per the above cited promises by the managing director Sri M. Lakshminarayanan, he had not acted upon his promises, resulting in heavy losses incurred by the company, which fact leads to the level of suicide committed by the then full time director Sri C.S Prakash.

As per the directions of the board, a criminal complaint has been lodged with Coimbatore Crime Branch and the suicide case is registered under FIR No. Cr. No. 48 of 2002 under section 174, Criminal Procedure Code and later taken under section 306, Indian Penal Code. Action by Police Department is being awaited. Unless otherwise court verdict is received, the company and its board cannot entertain the resignation of said managing director Sri M. Lakshminarayanan, and a decision to this effect has been taken at the board meeting. Moreover, the said managing director Sri M. Lakshminarayanan is not attending his duties by his continuous absence and also not co-operated with the company's affairs/board activities. Further more the said managing director Sri. M. Lakshminarayanan boasts himself by saying that, since he had continuously not attended for consecutive three board meetings, his post as ‘managing director’ gets dissolved automatically. Hence board has taken decision that even after the continuous absence of the said managing director Sri M. Lakshminarayanan, he is deemed to be director for all practical purposes. This decision is binding on all the absentee directors also.”

11. It is apparent from the above correspondence, that the petitioner categorically reported that he had submitted his resignation from the post of director by a letter of resignation dated March 7, 2003 and that the said letter was acknowledged by C.S Prakash since deceased on behalf of the company. It is further clear from the above communication of the company that the company did not entertain the resignation of the petitioner for the reasons stated therein. The company neither denied submission of the resignation letter of the petitioner nor the acknowledgment signed for and on its behalf by C.S Prakash. Moreover, the company has not established any requirement of acceptance of the request to relinquish the office of director. In this connection, reference is invited to Mother Care (India) Ltd. v. Prof. Ramaswamy P. Aiyar, [2004] 51 SCL 243, 249 (Karn) to show that “As the appointment of a director is not of a bilateral character, the question of acceptance of the request to relinquish the office would not arise. Filing of Form No. 32 in terms of section 303(2) is only a consequential act to be performed by the company in obedience of the statutory provision. If such a form is filed with the Registrar of Companies it is a proof of a director ceasing to be a director. But, it is not an act to be complied with in order to make a resignation valid. Therefore, as the resignation by a director relinquishing his office as such director is of an unilateral character it comes into effect when the act of such resignation to relinquish the office is communicated to the board. In law, the board to whom the act of relinquishment is communicated is not required to take any action by way of accepting resignation and, therefore, the relinquishment takes effect from the date of such communication where the resignation is intended to operate in praesenti… Therefore, once a resignation letter is submitted to the board, the date on which the intention to relinquish is communicated to the board, that is the date from which the director ceases to be a director of the company.” The denial of the company in the legal notice dated June 9, 2003, (annexure A7) sent in reply to the legal notice dated May 26, 2003, of the petitioner (annexure A6) in regard to the letter of resignation is not in consonance with its own communication dated July 9, 2003 (annexure A5). This contradiction remains unexplained. The claim of the company that this contentious issue cannot be adjudicated in a summary proceeding is not convincing. There are decisions to show that the company court should not hesitate to exercise its jurisdiction where the matters are not too complicated and can be sorted out on the basis of evidence produced by the parties. With the documents produced before me, I am convinced that the letter of resignation dated March 7, 2003, was before the board of directors which clearly shows the intention of the petitioner that the resignation was to take effect from March 30, 2002. Therefore, the petitioner, in my view, applying the principles enunciated by the decisions cited on behalf of the petitioner (supra), ceased to hold office since March 30, 2002. This, however, is without prejudice to his liabilities and obligations which had occurred up to that date and which he cannot evade by severing his connection with the company. Therefore, the claim of the company must fail. By virtue of section 303, the company and its directors are bound to file Form No. 32 with the eighth respondent notifying the resignation of the petitioner with effect from March 30, 2002. They have not so far made good the default by filing Form No. 32. This Bench, by an order dated May 29, 2004 held that the sixth respondent ceased to be the director of the company since March 11, 2002. I, therefore, in exercise of the power vested in section 614, hereby direct respondents Nos. 1 to 5 and 7 to file Form No. 32 with the eighth respondent as claimed in the petition within 21 days from the date of receipt of this order. With these directions, the petition stands disposed of.