- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
B.R. Ramabhadriah v. Principal Secretary
D. Surya Rao, Member (J):— The applicant herein is a retired Principal Chief Conservator of Forests of the Indian Forest Service in Andhra Pradesh having retired from service on 31.12.1984 He states that he had a very good record of service. There was not a single adverse entry in any of his C.Rs He had submitted his pension papers to the Accountant General (A&E), Andhra Pradesh (3rd respondent) for verification six months before the date of his retirement. Hie Accountant General in his turn sent a pension verification report dated 27.9.1984 showing the pensionary benefits due to the applicant. Thereafter the Government of Andhra Pradesh through its Principal Secretary to Govt. (1st respondent) issued orders under G.O.Rt No. 1553.Forests & Rural Development/For.II/Dept. dated 31.12.1984 retiring the applicant from service on superannuation from 31.12.1984 The 3rd respondent issued pension payment order dated 8.2.1965 Consequently the applicant has been drawing regular pension at Rs. 1,313/- per month from 1.1.1985 The applicant, however, complains that death-con retirement gratuity (DCRG) of Rs. 36,000/- authorised by the 3rd respondent and the commutation pension admissible under Regulation-7 of the All India Services (Commutation of Pension) Regulations, 1959 have not been paid to him. The applicant submitted several representations including the one addressed to the Chief Secretary to Government of A.P dated 19.3.1987 No action was taken thereon. Finally when the applicant made a representation dated 27.9.1987 to the 2nd respondent, a reply was received from him under a reference dated 12.11.1987 stating that the matter was still under consideration. Despite the same, gratuity and pension commutation amount have not been paid to the applicant. It is stated that the applicant's pension was revised to Rs. 1,500/- with effect from 1.1.1986 The applicant, therefore, prays for a direction to the respondents (1) to pay gratuity due to him with interest from 1.1.1985 and (2) to pay commuted value of pension with interest from 1.1.1985
2. On behalf of the respondents one and two a counter is filed stating, that while considering the sanction of pensionary benefits i.e, DCRG and commutation of pension in respect of the applicant, the Chief Conservator of Forests had in his letter dated 19.1.1985 reported to the Government that certain general allegations against Andhra Pradesh Forest Development Corporation Officials including the then Managing Director, the applicant herein, were brought to his notice concerning corruption, collusion and causing loss to the Government. A complaint was made to the Lok Ayukta alleging that the officials of the Andhra Pradesh Forest Development Corporation had connived with the Contractors in disposal of fuel wood.
3. The Lok Ayukta in its report came to the conclusion that there was huge floss of Rs. 22,50,874/- due to dereliction of duty on the part of certain officers concerned i.e the Regional Manager, Divisional Manager and also the Managing Director who failed to supervise, check and guide the work of his subordinate officers. Consequently, the State Government decided to initiate disciplinary action against the applicant and other officers. As sanction of the Government of India was necessary under Rule 6 of the All India Services (DCRG) Rules, 1958, the Government of India had been addressed in the matter. The Government of India was, however, of the view that there was no grave misconduct involved justifying action against the applicant. As disciplinary action had been initiated against other officers responsible for the loss, the State Government came to the conclusion that the Government of India may be addressed again for approval to initiate disciplinary action against the applicant, if the inquiry report against the other officers reveals connivance and complicity of the applicant. It is stated that charge-sheets against other officers were issued and disciplinary action is yet to be finalised in regard to them. In these circumstances, it is stated that the relief sought for by the applicant does not deserve consideration.
4. We have heard the learned counsel for the applicant, Sri M.P Chandra Mouli, Special Counsel for State Government and Sri N. Bhaskar a Rao, Addl. Central Govt. Standing Counsel.
5. Rule 6 of the All India services (DCRG) Rules, provides for recovery from pension of the whole orpart of any pecuniary loss caused to the Central Government or a State Government, if the pensioner is found in a (departmental or judicial proceedings to have been guilty of grave misconduct or to have caused pecuniary loss to the Central Government or a State Government by misconduct or negligence. The proviso to the said rule lays down that departmental proceedings for such a recovery shall not be instituted save with the sanction of the Central Government and shall be in respect of an event which took place not more than four years before the institution of such proceedings. In the instant case recovery could not be ordered as there is no sanction of the Central Government. Further admittedly, no disciplinary proceedings have been initiated against the applicant under Rule 6 of the said rules. The applicant has retired from service with effect from 31.12.1984 i.e, four years have since elapsed from the date of his retirement. There is, therefore, no scope for the Departmentto initiate disciplinary proceedings against the applicant. The question of recovery from the gratuity or other pensioner, amount due to the applicant would not, therefore, arise. The applicant is, therefore, entitled to payment of gratuity forthwith and also the commuted value of the pension.
6. The next question for consideration is as to the rate of interest to be paid to the applicant consequent upon delayed payment of gratuity. The further question is as to what is the interest payable to the applicant on the commutation value of his pension. In the case of delayed payment of gratuity, Rule 19(a) of the All India Services (D.C.R.G) Rules provides that if the delay was attributable to an administrative lapse, interest at 5% p.a, on the amount of gratuity in respect of the period beyond three months will be paid. Mr. M.P Chandra Mouli, Special Counsel for the State Government seeks to contend that the delay cannot be attributed to the State Government since the Lok Ayukta of the State found that the applicant cannot be absolved of the responsibility for negligence. No doubt the Government of India by letter dated 24.10.1986 refused sanction on the ground that the acts of the applicant did not constitute grave misconduct. But it is sought to be contended that till 24.10.1986 it cannot be said that the State Government is responsible for the delay. It is further contended that even thereafter the Government of India's decision does not preclude the State Government from asking the Government of India to review its decision and that the State Government was awaiting the result of a disciplinary inquiry against the other officers of the State Government. He argues that as long as there is a possibility that this inquiry would have thrown further light on the aspect of negligence of the applicant, the State Government would be entitled to ask the Government of India to review its decision and start proceedings against the applicant for recovery from gratuity. We are unable to accept these contentions. Gratuity cannot be withheld on hypothetical considerations viz; that the inquiry against certain other officers is likely to result in culpability of the applicant. It is for the State Government on the material on record to satisfy itself and make out a valid case that the applicant was guilty of grave misconduct. It is only then action can be taken under Rule 19 of the AIS (DCRG) Rules for withholding pension. Since the State Government were not able to make out any such prima facie case against the applicant to the satisfaction of the Government of India, there can be no doubt that the delay in payment of gratuity is attributable only to the State Government. The applicant is, therefore, entitled to interest on the gratuity due.
7. In regard to the rate of interest to be paid to the applicant for delayed payment of gratuity, Sri Desai, counsel for the applicant contends that the applicant is entitled to 12% interest p.a, on the basis of decisions reported in ATR 1987 (1) CAT 578 (M.R Chaudhary v. Union of India) and ATR 1987 (2) CAT 200 (Smt. Savitri Devi v. Union of India): In both these cases, 10% interest was granted. These were the cases disposed of under CGS (Pension) Rules wherein a specific provision for payment of interest at 10% is made. This was as a result of an amendment made in 1984. Sri Desai contends that a similar amendment would have been issued in the case of members of the All India Services and, therefore, the applicant would be entitled to 10% interest per annum. No such amendment, however, has been brought to our notice. We accordingly direct that the applicant would be entitled to such interest as is admissible under Rule 19-A of the AIS (DCRG) Rules for the delayed payment of gratuity i.e from the date of retirement till the date of its payment. If the rate of interest has been enhanced from 5% to 10% per annum, the applicant would be entitled to 10% interest per annum. If, however the AIS (DCRG) Rules have not been amended and Rule 19-A of the said Rules stands as it is and provides for payment of interest only at 5% per annum the applicant will be entitled to only 5% interest on the gratuity amount due to him from the date of retirement to the date of its payment.
8. In sofar as payment of commuted value of the pension is concerned, the applicant will be paid the commuted value of pension as is due to him under the rules with effect from 1.1.1985 He would be entitled also to interest thereon at 12% per annum from the date of retirement to the date of its payment. The Government would, however, be entitled to recover the excess pension paid to the applicant i.e, the difference between full pension and the commuted value of the pension paid to him during all these years.
9. With these directions, the application is disposed of. There will be no order as to costs.
10. Orders accordingly.
Alert