- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Secretary, Ministry Of Commerce, Govt. Of India v. Vinod
Factual and Procedural Background
The Respondent, a registered exporter, applied for REP licences for exports totalling Rs. 6,16,116 for the period 1988–1993 and claimed a premium of 20% (Rs. 1,23,223). The scheme for issuance of REP licences was discontinued and the premium was not paid. The Respondent was initially informed that its application was under consideration. An order dated 3.9.1991 by the Additional Chief Controller of Imports and Exports kept the grant of premium in abeyance for a specified period which was extended; a debarment circular dated 9.9.1991 was thereafter issued by the Director General of Foreign Trade (DGFT), New Delhi.
The Respondent appealed to the Appellate Committee, Ministry of Commerce; the appeal was accepted on 5.8.1996 and the debarment circular was withdrawn by circular dated 2.9.1996. After withdrawal, the Respondent repeatedly requested grant and release of the premium (with interest) but received no substantive response. Officials later informed the Respondent that the premium scheme had been closed and that its case file was not traceable. By letter dated 15.11.2001 the DGFT informed the Respondent that the premium could not be refunded because the premium scheme had been closed long back.
The Respondent filed a complaint before the District Forum. The Petitioners did not appear despite service and the proceedings were ordered ex parte. The District Forum accepted the complaint and directed the Petitioners to pay Rs. 1,23,223 to the Respondent, along with Rs. 5,000 as compensation for mental agony and harassment and Rs. 1,000 towards litigation expenses, to be paid within three months, failing which interest at 9% per annum would run until payment. The Petitioners appealed to the State Commission, which dismissed their appeal (the impugned order). The Petitioners then filed the present revision petition.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the subsequent withdrawal or discontinuance of the REP licence/premium scheme operated retrospectively and thereby disentitled the Respondent from benefits that had accrued under the scheme at the relevant time.
- Whether the Petitioners are liable to pay the claimed premium amount (Rs. 1,23,223) and the additional sums awarded by the District Forum (compensation and litigation expenses).
- Whether the District Forum's ex-parte allowance of the complaint (in view of the Petitioners' non-appearance and failure to produce or seek admission of documents) can be disturbed on revision.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The Petitioners contended that they were not liable to pay the premium amount because the REP/premium scheme was subsequently withdrawn (i.e., the scheme had been discontinued).
Respondent's Arguments
- The Respondent maintained that it was entitled to REP licences and the corresponding premium of 20% on exports made during the relevant period, that the premium had not been paid, and that administrative actions (abeyance/debarment) had been set aside on appeal, after which it sought payment of the due premium with interest.
- The Respondent relied on the complaint facts and evidence before the District Forum; those facts and evidence went unrebutted because the Petitioners did not appear.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court agreed with the State Commission's conclusion that the withdrawal of the premium/REP scheme operated prospectively and could not retrospectively deprive the Respondent of benefits that had already accrued under the scheme for the relevant period. The court explained that a benefit which had accrued under a scheme while it was in force cannot be withdrawn merely because the scheme was later discontinued for the future.
Separately, the court relied on the procedural posture before the District Forum: the Petitioners failed to appear despite service and were proceeded against ex parte. Consequently, the facts pleaded in the complaint and the evidence adduced by the Respondent remained unrebutted before the District Forum. The Petitioners had not produced these facts/evidence at the District Forum, nor had they filed any application seeking permission to place additional documents on record before that forum. The court held that, in the absence of such permission, documents not produced before the District Forum could not be taken into account at the revision stage. These procedural and substantive determinations led the court to conclude there was no merit in the Petitioners' challenge.
Holding and Implications
DISMISSED — The revision petition was dismissed with no order as to costs.
Implications: By dismissing the revision petition and agreeing with the State Commission, the court upheld the view that the Respondent could not be deprived of benefits that had accrued under the REP/premium scheme prior to its withdrawal. The District Forum's allowance of the complaint and its monetary directions (payment of Rs. 1,23,223; Rs. 5,000 as compensation; Rs. 1,000 towards litigation expenses; and interest provisions) were sustained insofar as they were the subject of the challenged proceedings. No costs were imposed on any party.
Ashok Bhan, President:— Petitioners were the Opposite Parties before the District Forum.
Complainant/Respondent (hereinafter to be referred as “Respondent”) being a registered Exporter was entitled to REP licences against the exports made by it under the scheme prepared by the Petitioners for the relevant period 1988–1993. Respondent applied for REP licences against the export of Rs. 6,16,116/- during the above period for which they were entitled to a premium of 20% of the amount of exports under the scheme. As scheme for issue of REP licences was dis-continued, the premium of Rs. 1,23,223/- was not paid. Respondent was informed by the Petitioners that the application filed by it was under consideration and action will follow in due course. Subsequently, Respondent received intimation that the Additional Chief Controller of Imports and Exports had passed an order on 3.09.91 keeping the grant of premium to the Respondent in abeyance from 3.2.88 to 31.3.92 which period was further extended to 31.3.93 Later on, debarment circular dated 9.9.91 was issued by the Director General of Foreign Trade, New Delhi.
Respondent, being aggrieved, filed the appeal before the Appellate Committee, Ministry of Commerce which accepted the appeal on 5.8.96 and the debarment circular dated 9.9.91 was withdrawn by circular dated 2.9.96 After withdrawal of the debarment circular, Respondent made several representations to the Petitioners for grant and release of the premium amount of Rs. 1,23,223/- with interest thereon but there was no response from the Petitioners. After several visits, Respondent was informed by the concerned officials that the scheme for issue of REP licenses had been done away with and it's case file was not traceable. Respondent was asked to give details of relevant files in respect of its claim which were supplied by the Respondent. Vide letter No. 01/92/180/406.Misc./PC-II/1029 dated 15.11.01, Respondent was informed by the Director General of Foreign Trade, Government of India that the premium scheme had been closed long back and its request for refund of premium of Rs. 1,23,223/- against the issue of REP Licence @ 20% on export of Rs. 6,16,116/- could not be granted. Aggrieved by the aforesaid letter of the Petitioners, Respondent filed the complaint before the District Forum.
Despite notice, Petitioner did not appear and ordered to be proceeded ex-parte.
Taking the facts stated in the complaint to be correct, District Forum allowed the complaint and directed the Petitioners to pay the sum of Rs. 1,23,223/- to the Respondent along with compensation of Rs. 5,000/- for mental agony and harassment and Rs. 1,000/- towards litigation expenses. Petitioners were directed to pay the amount within three months from the date of passing of the order failing which the amount shall carry interest @ 9% p.a till the date of payment.
Petitioners, being aggrieved, filed the appeal before the State Commission which has been dismissed by the impugned order.
Plea taken by the Petitioners that they were not liable to pay the premium amount as the scheme was subsequently withdrawn was not accepted by the State Commission. It was held that the subsequent withdrawal of the scheme could not dis-entitle the Respondent from reaping the benefits of the scheme prevalent at the relevant time. That withdrawal of the scheme would operate prospectively and not retrospectively.
Petitioners, being aggrieved, have filed the present revision Petition.
We agree with the view taken by the State Commission. Withdrawal of the scheme could not deprive the Respondent of the benefits which had already accrued to it under the scheme. The withdrawal of the scheme was prospective in nature and not retrospective. A benefit accrued under the scheme could not be withdrawn only because the scheme had been dis-continued for future.
This apart, Petitioners were proceeded ex-parte before the District Forum as they did not appear in spite of service. The facts stated in the complaint and the evidence led by the Respondent remained unrebutted. Under the circumstances, District Forum rightly allowed the complaint taking the facts stated in the complaint to be correct. The facts now convinced before us were not produced before the District Forum. Petitioners did not file any application seeking permission to take additional documents on record. In the absence of any permission, documents which were not produced in evidence before the District Forum cannot be now taken into consideration at the time of arguments.
For the reasons stated above, we do not find any merit in the Revision Petition and dismiss the same with no order as to costs.
Alert